With the demise of my fav Danny's Fish & Chips, was beyond thrilled to see the sign go up a few months back that a new fish & chips spot was opening minutes away from where I live. I only learned about their "unofficial" opening prior to their soft opening because of all of the reels I was seeing posted to IG of their Family Feast menu item. I say unofficial because I live close enough that it's on our way home and I could see, that they were not open yet and still setting up inside.
I stopped in during their soft opening , but it was very chaotic inside and people were being turned by other diners waiting for their food sharing that Big Catch was not accepting any new orders. Apparently the wait for takeout and dining in was already 90+ minutes. I stood at the front counter for 10 minutes with staff right in front of me but nobody looked up or acknowledge me, so we left. I get it, day 3 of the soft opening, it's busy, limited hours, but don't ignore your customers. This is a brand that has been in business for over 30 yrs, so I was not expecting this lack of service.
I did end up returning with my fam about a week later during the first week of July. Only one other table taken and it was not busy at all. We decided to grab a table and order.
This is what we ordered:
3 Can Dine Haddock & Fries: 3 pieces of haddock , fries and coleslaw. I was tempted to order the halibut, but wanted to first try the simplistic option of haddock to see how this would go. I was a bit disappointed over the batter. It was uneven in some spots, very thick in spots and also overcooked in some spots and when I cut into it with my knife, it crumbled apart which affected the texture of the fish - which fell apart. It was salted too much for my liking as I sometimes enjoy either ketchup or tartar sauce with my fish. The fries overall were over salted. Odd because the fries that came with the shrimp ordered below, were not. I have been to a lot of fish & chip spots and this was the saltiest for me.
Shrimp & chips: This was the winner for me! The batter was crispy and light, not oily and not too thick. The shrimps were pretty substantial in size. I would def order this again! Seasoning was light and just right.
Their poutine is def a must try! The gravy was insanely good!
Table service - well, we didn't really receive any except to take our orders and then bring our food. I would have preferred to just order, get my food and take a seat, but that is not an option. No plates taken away, no water refilled and nobody asked how our food was.
I will def give them another try and order the halibut. If the fish and fries end up being too salty again - not sure I will revisit again and likely stick to Stouffville (Joy's) for fish and chips.
***Seating and parking is limited. A little pricier than other local and well known GTA spots I have tried. read more