If you're dying of starvation on your way to the mountains, The Bagelry is your cure. I showed up hangry AF on a Saturday at around 1:30pm before closing and was greeted by the friendliest lady at the register. She might have been one of the owners, but how friendly and inviting she was really elevated my mood and overall experience. She was super helpful and ran me through what was left of the available bagel options. The rosemary, thyme and sea salt bagel really caught my eye, especially given there were only 3 of them left. I pulled the trigger on it and got it with the lean supreme (turkey sausage, provolone, and egg whites with scallions) which only costed me shy of $11. I'm confident to say that was hands down one of the best bagels I've ever had. The scallions were an amazing touch on the egg whites, the provolone melted in your mouth, and the turkey sausage didn't even taste like I was eating sausage's skinny legend cousin. Four days later and I'm still dreaming of the bagel I had. Counting down the days till I head out west again to reunite with her... read more

The Bagelry - Lean supreme with rosemary thyme sea salt bagel - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

A fun spot to hit up while passing through evergreen! I had a wheat bagel with garlic herb cream cheese but the sandwiches looked great, and I heard the coffee is very good! A lovely local spot that sells out fast! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

See all

Cute little bagel place in Evergreen. I enjoy getting a rosemary bagel with lox and cream cheese. A lot of fun flavors and sandwich options. Freshly baked bagels. (Don't be upset if they run out - they may be making more. And this should only reassure you that everything is baked fresh! Just roll with it and try something new!) Really friendly staff, very kind and they create a fun and homey vibe. Cute and eclectic interior but still very clean!! Would recommend. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

I've only been once so far, and everything was on par for what I expected from a bagel sandwich joint. I had the lox and cream cheese on an onion bagel. I hope to give it a few more tries, and if the consistency is there then I'll bump it up another star. Edit: After seeing the business manger's response to my review I've decided to change my review to 1 star. I had read his unprofessional responses to previous 1 star reviews before writing my initial 3 star review and decided not to let it influence my review. But after seeing his sarcastic response to my honest review of my mediocre experience at his restaurant, they don't deserve 3 stars. No manager should be responding in such a manner to honest reviews from long-time Yelpers. I'm a local, but I will not be giving you any more business - I'm sure you're heartbroken about this. As the 1 stars continue to pile up, your business will no doubt decline, and you may begin to regret your unprofessional behavior. It cost nothing to be polite; you should either give it a try or get out of the hospitality industry. And for crying out loud go wipe down those sticky tables. I left that out of my initial review in an effort to be polite to a local restaurant. read more

The Bagelry - Yikes, I wonder what 2025 will bring. It just gets lower and lower each year. - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

What a great space! The bagels were delicious and fresh. I got a breakfast sandwich and a cup of coffee and hung out in one of the little roomie spaces to either side of the counter. Definitely worth checking it out if you haven't been. read more

This is the spot if you want amazing bagels! Been coming for years and it's time I share this friendly place!! You'll never walk in without seeing a smile on the employee's faces!! read more

Such an awesome family owned business! Delicious bagels and great service. Love the Grateful Dead motif inside.

Best place to grab a fresh bagel or breakfast bagel on the way up to skiing. The great help gets you in and out with a smile with the freshest bagels you can find anywhere. Love the Dead Head vibe...any other bagel after having one of theirs just tastes 2nd rate. read more

My veggie egg bagel sandwich really hit the spot the other day. Needed a hearty, but not too heavy or greasy, breakfast before a big day of hiking. Thrilled I found this bagel shop. The guys taking orders were very friendly & efficient. Cafe was clean with easy parking. Bagel was fresh & soft and so tasty. I liked my non dairy latte as well. Reasonable price for the size of the sandwich. Zero complaints here! read more

See all

The new owners have turned the Bagelry back to a morning must!!! Wonderful menu and friendly staff! We love the Bagelry read more

This place is a local gem! Being from the north east, its hard to find a comparable bagel anywhere else, but the Bagelry nailed it. Their bagel selection is on point and the breakfast sandwiches are out of this world. I also love all the grateful dead art and how kind the staff is. Definitley check it out if you're craving some carbs! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

My only disappointment was myself not taking a pic of my delicious breakfast bagel. I ordered a breast bagel ( everything) with egg, bacon and avocado. They were kind enough to make what I asked. Their bagel was SO fresh and just hit all the satiating taste buds. Their salt bagel was EXTREMELY salty so be aware. If you're running those long runs, get that bagel to replenish your sodium levels. I am already dreaming about the next time I can get to this place... keep up the great work Bagelry! read more

My mom and I stopped here on our way up to Echo mountain for tubing! The workers greeted us when we came in and helped us in making a decision on what to order! We both got a bagel sandwich and a coffee. I love that you can choose the flavor of bagel for your sandwich!! The shop has a punk/rock vibe with decor, but is not too loud. There are lots of spaces to sit and eat or chat (tables, couches, etc). You can tell it's nestled in a small town because as we say and are the workers knew many of the customers by name read more

See all

Ordered a steak and egg bagel for $11. Got a roast beef and egg bagel. Call it what it is, but it's not steak. I'd like to support local businesses without feeling like I'm getting suckered by them too. read more

The Bagelry - Roast beef and egg sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

Wow. The most unfriendly staff I've encountered ever. I've received better counter service at Burger King. For the three employees I saw in the restaurant there was almost zero eye contact, nothing but scowls, and no effort to be anything other than robotic. If I didn't know better, I'd say that everyone was high and just trying to get through the day. It really doesn't take any effort to smile once in a while, or ask people how they're doing or at least pretend like you're not an inconvenience being a consumer. The coffee was unremarkable, and my bagel was very doughy and undercooked. read more

Delicious bagels, friendly staff, and a cool/relaxing environment! I got a regular breakfast sandwich on a garlic bagel and it hit the spot.

Such a groovy vibe in The Bagelry! All sorts of flavors of bagels and spreads, and lots of different breakfast sandwiches, too. Super nice staff. Pulled off the highway by chance, but will certainly be back. This New Jersey couple highly recommends. read more

I ordered the blueberry with walnut raisin cream cheese. The service was great! I loved the vibe of the location. Thanks!

Some of the best bagels I have ever had! I love their cinnamon raisin bagel with honey walnut raisin cream cheese. Also has a very groovy atmosphere. read more

I think this place is slightly underrated, it is close to 4 stars in my book. The bagels have a nice chewy texture and I like the option to add scallions to the eggs. The espresso machine was broken so I can't comment on any of their fancy coffee drinks. read more

Great bagels and tons of sandwich options, large selection of cold beverages in the fridge as well as coffee/espresso. Certainly a Grateful Dead theme to the place, and comfy chairs to hang out in read more

I'm guessing they are under new ownership or management as the service and bagels are vastly improved. We stop in fairly often and it's always great. read more

It was a crisp summer morning and I had a craving for bagel with a perfectly symmetrical hole. I had been up late the previous night making TikToks with two grown men I met on Grindr and had worked up quite the appetite. As I walked into the Bagelry I announced my pronouns and made eye contact with a splendid young gentleman at the front counter. He was quick and efficient but something may have been off. Perhaps he was celebrating Trippy Tuesday as well. As I placed my order, I was delighted to have the tip screen default to 69%. A small price to pay for such excellent service. On my way out, I opened my bagel bag to find a hand written note: "Love in every hole". What a coincidence I thought, as the night before I had experienced just that. read more

First time in and the bagels were amazing. Fresh bagels! And their sandwiches are delicious. Must try for anyone living or visiting the area. read more

The Bagelry - California Turkey with Bacon - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

The bagels were delicious, staff was friendly and attentive. Perfect place to grab a bite and go! read more

The Bagelry - Bagel supreme- egg with fresh scallions, pork sausage and cheddar cheese - Bagels Near Me - Evergreen, Colorado

The food is always great and the staff is even better. My only complaint is that the line moves slow but that's what you get for wanting great food. read more

The Bagelry offers daily fresh baked bagels and day old bagels for sale. They have a full breakfast & lunch menu with bagel sandwiches, wraps, salads, etc - They also offer a full espresso menu, fresh Dazbog coffee & smoothies. Free WiFi - It does get busy so be patient, lot's of seating & friendly service.. read more

See all

I mean. It's bagels. The bagels are good. The two guys that work here are good. The lady who has "helped" me the past two times - is not so good. She's just a bit on the rude side. When I came in w my step mom who was holiday visiting and she was asking "too many" questions, the lady was short and a bit rude. Whatever. We he next time I went in by myself, I tried to order in the same order she'd insisted on before, she was again snappy and short. Whatever - if you're not a morning person don't work at a bagel shop. The two guys are very nice. Bagels are good. Lady just makes me hope she's not working when I come by. read more

I eat bagels several times a month. I was in the area and discovered this place. Bagel,coffee and staff were all fantastic. read more

We stopped here after a hike nearby and were delighted. The bagels were tasty and soft. I had the lox cream cheese on a garlic bagel with tomato and onion and it hit the spot! The spread could have had a little more lox, but it was still good nosh. Staff were friendly. read more

Delicious, chewy, fresh bagels. They offer discounted day-olds, but I have yet to encounter any leftovers in the basket- presumably because they're so good they don't stay in store. We love the sun dried tomato bagel with a schmear or the bagel breakfast sandwich. Drip coffee is serve yourself, so don't forget to grab a cup! read more

See all

What an awesome bagel place! The bagels and the yummy fillings - we had the Figgy and Pizza Bagel- were superb! Love the staff and decor. What a gem in the mountains! Best bagels going! read more

Good bagels and very nice people but they don't take Apple Pay. Two stars off for pretending that technology doesn't exist. Get it together guys. It's 2023. read more

This place is great!! The staff is always so happy and positive, and the bagels are always delicious! If you're looking for a quick bite in evergreen, go here and don't waste your time going anywhere else! read more

Lived here 20 years in Evergreen and I thought I'd try this place after driving by it for a long time. I am SO sorry I did. The food is microwaved and coffee not so good, and it is all so overpriced it isn't funny. However, that isn't why I am writing this review at all. It's bagels and coffee, I may have gone back if it was convenient to what I was doing... however, I am writing this because I cannot STAND the service/staff. I took three days to calm down and write this; yes, it was that bad. All young millennials working there, that won't give you the time of day. Just sit on their phones texting... I just didn't think I'd see such disrespect in such a small town where I know everybody. Another person came in right before me and ordered and then I ordered after him. He then went and sat down and was reading the paper while I was watching this disgusting place in action. (I need to mention the place if filthy...they staff couldn't be bothered with cleaning at all obviously!) After they were done microwaving his food, she looked at him, took his hot bagel and threw it on the counter, just shrugging her shoulders like it was his fault he wasn't there to take care of her every thought and whim. I finally walked over and told him what happened; he was aghast and just left...it was weird... The other three young people working there seemed to all just wanting a trophy for just being there I guess, and they wouldn't help anyone...just kept staring at their phones... I have the right to be disgusted with their attitude- even if they think that they were doing us all favors by just being there- and I will never come back to this worst place in Evergreen that I have been to. I will spend my money elsewhere - you can guarantee that. read more

Really great bagels. Love the mountain power breakfast bagel! Only complaint is the price is high but that's the cost of living in Evergreen. read more

Great bagel stop in the way to the mountains! Love the old school vibes, will definitely be stopping again!

Delicious food and the ambience is great here. The staff are friendly and lots of options for food that include many dietary needs.

Nice people, good food, not overly expensive. Nice to support a local business! Coffee is great too :)

Amazing experience! The sweet lady helped us choose the best bagels/sandwich combinations and everyone was so kind! Recommend: garlic bagel breakfast sandwich and rosemary salt bagel with chive cream cheese. Go support the bagelry!!! read more