Conveniently located next to Rook so you can grab a coffee next door and come here for a bagel. Also this is part of a plaza of stores so there's plenty of parking. I got a sausage, egg, and cheese on plain bagel and it was sooo good. The meat and egg was cooked perfectly, and the bagel had the perfect amount of slight crisp without being overly toasted. The service was quick and friendly, and the size of this bagel is no joke! I was full for hours after. Tip: I grabbed some ketchup packets to dip the bagel in, chef's kiss. read more

The Bagel Store - Sausage egg and cheese on plain - Bagels Near Me - Colts Neck, New Jersey

See all

Consistently good bagel spot, and very nice staff. Doesn't have as many options and frills as some other bagel spots, but haven't ever been disappointed with my breakfast sandwiches and bagels. read more

We were in town for a short time and were in a bit of a time crunch and I'm glad I checked this place out as it was close to where we needed to be at. They've got a nice variety of bagels and cream cheeses. It was busy on a Saturday morning which I'd expect, the bagels were super soft I got a salt bagel one of my favorites my husband got a plain bagel with egg and cheese, and we both enjoyed our bagels. They have coffee here and plenty of options for creamer so if you like oat or almond milk creamer they have those, they also have regular cream too. Worth checking out if you are in the area. read more

In a plaza in Colts Neck, you will find a bagel store with potential. Brand: 9/10 I do appreciate the cartoon bagel characters with the old-fashioned 1930s animation eyes painted on the glass walls. The interior has a standard appearance typical of bagel shops with glass storage containing bagels and delicacies. The entrance definitely has a presentable impact, for you will find stone tables on a platformed plaza cluttered with stone. The Bagel Store has been known to donate to the local community, though it is not really known for any kind of events. However, I do not know how long the establishment will have the name "The Bagel Store," since many businesses exist that have such a standard type of name. Ambiance: 8/10 The environment inside had a standard quality to it, though with some elements sticking out. The television did play in the background a bit intrusively and a fly roamed around the inside. It can get noisy as a tightly insulated space, but nothing too chaotic. As a small space, the Bagel Store accommodates as much as it can with the tables and chairs vaguely separated apart. There are also stone tables and seats outside in case you cannot find room inside. Service: 10/10 I did like the self-directed check-out with an option to pay cash or credit, and giving you the choice between have the receipt or not. The owner described the leadership of this establishment as a place where every employee is a leader within their own station. I can see how this plays out in the workplace, since the staff makes many menu items readily available while others are just getting prepared shortly before the near-noon rush. Wait Time: 10/10 We did not experience any interruptions for the wait time. Food: 8/10 I chose the Black Russian bagel packed with cream cheese, with orange juice. It was already prepared, since it was already behind the glass case. The bagel held its form with none of the cream cheese pouring out. It had an earthy smell, which fits. This bagel flavor is a new taste for me. I will say that the hardiness complements the cream cheese perfectly, as the contrast befits this meal. The aftertaste disappeared quickly. Worth The Money?: 8/10 The food represents the brand well, since its well-preserved nature ensures that you get a simple yet fulfilling meal. While the Black Russian bagel satisfied me, the noisy environment did outweigh it. I can see how the brand will evolve over time beyond just an ordinary bagel shop. The family-friendly ambiance does reflect the cartoon characters of the glass walls, and the cartoons playing on the television. The business works within its own inflationary constraints, only requiring extra workers when it really needs them however rare. I admire how small businesses always know how to grapple with what little they have. Perhaps, applying the Pareto Principle to the business would help by investing first on the most vital parts of the businesses, investing second in everything else, and letting good luck fill in the rest--at least that's my personal business philosophy. I can see how this applied to updating the technology at the check-out area, just as it can apply to other areas. The owner expressed interest in situating the Bagel Store as the center of an event. Local eateries contribute more to the community than chain eateries through the local multiplier effect. Local eatery employees play a huge role, since they typically spend their income within the community itself. If the employees are leaders within their own station, then surely they could have enough voting leverage to suggest events to sponsor or create. I will say that the overall price is worth it. Rating: 5/5 Stars Given the choice between four or five stars, I will give it five stars due to the hope and potential that I see within the Bagel Store. Recommend To... Anyone and their family in the Colts Neck area looking for a bagel store. read more

The Bagel Store - Black Russian Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Colts Neck, New Jersey

This place is okay. With NJ having a ton of bagel shops I think there is a better place you can go and grab a bagel. The bagels are big but a bit flavorless in my opinion. If you are in a hurry and this is nearby I'd say go and grab a bagel but I definitely have had much better plus I paid about $7 for this which is pretty pricey. read more

The Bagel Store - Egg everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Colts Neck, New Jersey

The best around! Service is fast, great vibes, breakfast and lunch here is amazing! Fresh Hot Coffee and friendly staff!

It was fine. You can get much better bagels around, like Tommy's bagels in Manalapan.

First time here and discovered this place next to Rook Colts Neck. Walked in about 10 minutes to 12 and they literally had 4 bagels left which lead me to believe I had to try their bagels. Opted for the one whole wheat left, toasted, with 2 egg white, turkey bacon, cheese, easy on the ketchup and pepper. 10 mins later - bliss. So glad I found another small NJ business that knows how to make an awesome bagel and a great sandwich! read more

The Bagel Store - Whole wheat bagel, lightly toasted, with a couple of eggs, turkey bacon, cheese, pepper, and ketchup. - Bagels Near Me - Colts Neck, New Jersey

Went in to try this place and give it a chance despite bad reviews. Was utterly disappointed with the service and food. There was no hospitality whatsoever. I'm sure the woman working the register means well but the ambiance of the entire place was just off. My total was $12.45 for a BEC on an everything bagel and a juice. I cannot justify paying that price for two pieces of bacon and one egg, not to mention the everything bagel had zero flavor. I always try to give a place a chance when they have some bad reviews but it seems like they accurately depict the situation in this establishment. Something needs to change! read more

I am so sorry to be doing this but these were the most disgusting bagels we have had in a long time. I ordered two bagels a sesame and and an egg bagel toasted with butter..............what I got were tasteless, doughy bread with whatever they call butter.......I would never go back there again, Shame on the owners for trying to pass their inferior product as bagels read more

Bagels literally had NO FLAVOR... (how does this happen??) Had to wait for them to make coffee, plus no lids for the coffee cups. Worst part was the staff, unfriendly (put your phones down) and seemed bothered when I requested for them to make more coffee. read more

The bagels are over cooked and have no flavor. The girl working in the front always has an attitude. You have to double check that you're not buying an expired milk, because they don't check the dates on the stuff in the fridge. Also, this is the third week they haven't had a working toaster. Not sure how you can run your business this way. read more

10/2/22- orders a whole wheat bagel with veg cream cheese and slice of tomato. The young girl behind the counter charges me $6 which I felt was very high for what I ordered. Website says $3.50. She tells he it hasn't been updated in years & manager just raised prices few weeks ago. Asked for price list- there is none. I proceeded with the order bc I was hungry yet when I got home & opened it up no tomato. So $6 for a bagel with veggie cream cheese? Called the store the girl forgot & will talk to owner Tuesday bc he's not in tomorrow. Usually don't leave reviews like this but this was honestly ridiculous. read more

The Bagel Store - Bagel no tomato not even sure if this is whole wheat... - Bagels Near Me - Colts Neck, New Jersey

This place is sure to satisfy your bagel crave. Can't go wrong with the pork roll, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel. You can easily call in on a Saturday morning and your order will be ready in very little time. Centrally located next to Rook coffee, down the street from Delicious Orchards and Source brewery. I will be a return customer for sure. read more

I visit my family nearby but never visited this bagel shop. First off the store is spotless and so you know they take pride in their look. They have a good selection of bagels and sandwich. I ordered an egg and cheese on a plain bagel and it was exactly what you expect to get from a bagel shop. The bagel was soft with a nice crust. The sandwich worked. I also ordered one with cream cheese and another with butter. All were consistently delicious. The other thing that stuck out to me was how busy they were but they still seemed to have quick service. They have a great team of people here and that serve some high level bagels. Check it out! read more

See all

I enjoy the homemade bagels and their ability to make any combo egg ham cheese bacon or sandwich you want. Great coffee. Stocked fridge. Place to sit. Lost a star. Bad news no bagels 1p. They close at 2p. See photo of empty bagel racks. read more

See all

Called our order ahead and in about 20 minutes it was ready! We got an everything bagel with jalapeño cheddar cream cheese as well as the Star Destroyer. Listen to me. Get the star destroyer. It has everything you could possibly want in a breakfast sandwich. 2 Eggs, Pork Roll, Bacon, Sausage, Cheese, Hashbrowns! All under $10! Come on now! Don't miss out and by the way another amazing feature is the bagel has the everything seasonings on both sides! Rare! Bagel is firm yet chewy. I will be back! Thank you read more

The Bagel Store - Star Destroyer - Bagels Near Me - Colts Neck, New Jersey

Average bagels. Fresh salads, tuna, chicken salad are good. Been here a few times for bagels and every time I'm underwhelmed. Just kind of flavorless but that's just me maybe. Egg bagels were good. Chocolate chip and blueberry not really, not enough flavor in either. Nice people, nice store, give them a try, your mileage may vary read more

I just paid $4.35 for a bagel with butter. Prices are ridiculous (and not posted anywhere) for an average bagel.

bar none the best bagel in nj. they have egg bagels. not bagels with eggs on them. egg. bagels. so good. read more

Always fresh and fast at this busy establishment. Primetime Sunday and I've waited much longer for a lesser bagel in the area. One of my top three bagels spots and part of my Sunday routine. read more

The food here is good. The issue I have is I asked for the 'Greek' with no bread and the employee informed me that I had to get bread bc the owner doesn't allow no bread. She said then it would be a platter. I have a gluten intolerance so the last thing I need is a bagel or even the temptation of one. I got the Greek on a bagel, took it off the bagel and threw the bagel out my car window. I did get a hash brown too. So the Greek sandwich, hashbrow, coffee and a Gatorade came to $12.00. I don't understand why I couldn't just get the meal with no bread. I didn't ask for extra eggs or a bigger portion. I suppose the owner doesn't believe in food allergies. If he does and forces his customers to get bread then he should have a gluten free option. I know it's a bagel store but still.... read more

Friendly service, weekends are really packed in the morning so better to place your order by calling in ahead of time. My go to is the Bagel Brunch with a whole wheat every bagel. read more

Stopped 9n for some bagel sandwiches. Had to wait as other orders behind me where processed. Asked for no ketchup multiple times. Sandwich had ketchup. Bacon was not crispy, kinda chewy. Major disappointment. read more

I went in at 1130 am and they were sold out of everything! No bagels, no rolls no nothing. How can you be called the bagel store and be sold out before noon? Unbelievable! read more

I really really don't like leaving bad reviews. We ordered two bagels, both orders were wrong and we were the only ones in there. I figured it was no worries mistakes happen I get it, so I just bit my tongue and went in and ordered another bagel since I'm more picky than my boyfriend. My bagel itself was flavorless, and there was a big black hair on my tomato. it wasn't cheap either. cream cheese was just philadelpha. colts neck needs a good bagel place and I guess this is not it :( read more

if you want to be extorted, this is definitely the place for you!! i got a sesame seed bagel with scallion cream cheese and bacon for a grand total of $10.35. for one bagel. i don't even know what to say next, this was beyond ridiculous. they didn't even put that much cream cheese, and the bacon was under cooked and fatty. the bagel itself? not bad. the overall product? just okay. definitely not worth 10.35. i will never go back here again. ever. i don't know what kind of world we are living in that a bagel could possibly cost this much money. read more

Working close by and looking for a quick bite. I ordered the deluxe bagel which was a bagel of choice (rye) cream cheese, lox, capers and red onion. Exactly what I was hoping for read more

Love this place. I don't get eyes rolled when I ask for a scooped bagel with egg and cheddar with salt pepper and ketchup. The food is prepared quickly too! read more

Best bagels in the area! The owner and staff are always super friendly and consistently make fantastic bagels!

This bagel store is hands down the best around, the owner chris always has a smile on his face along with the rest of the crew working there. They have tons of bagels and they are incredible, chris is a genius I purchased st Patrick's day bagels from the bagel store and they were the talk of the party! Keep up the great work you definitely deserve five stars! read more

I really want to like this place but the bagels just don't have any flavor and to top it off we've lived locally for over 3 years now and I'd say half the time the order is wrong. I will say that their cream cheese and the favors I've had are very good. read more

I drive from Howell to get bagels and sandwiches from here. Chris knows what he's doing and he has a friendly staff. Make sure to try the jalapeno bagel and the chicken salad read more

These bagels healed my broken heart. They have a soft doughy center with a nice freshly baked outter crust. The employees also are humble and kind lovely experience all around read more

Hands down, best bagels in the area! The bagels are handmade and always fresh. The friendly atmosphere and personable staff is just an added bonus. read more

Great place to grab a bagel or sandwich while heading down the shore. Bagels and sandwiches are good and the prices are very reasonable.

Fresh bagels, great variety of spreads, fresh baked goods, great breakfast sandwiches and... fast service! What's not to love about this place! read more

Been here a few times. Bagels are just ok. Not sure if they are made fresh daily. They have a small selection of creme cheese choices. What really got me this time was that after drinking my juice I needed to use the restroom. How disgusting. Looked like the bathroom hadn't been cleaned in months. Floor dirty and urine all over the toilet seat. Did not use the bathroom and left quickly to get home. Pretty grossed out and not sure if I will return. read more

Nice bagel shop, friendly staff. Can't beat the bacon or pork roll, egg and cheese on a plain/egg bagel.

Best bagels around!! They are so fresh and delicious. My only complaint, they run out of egg everything bagels too fast :) !! We won't get our bagels anywhere else! The sandwiches are delicious too!! We enjoy all of the bagels! go there try them!! read more