Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

Taliercio's builds you a sandwich the old school way. Piled high with only the best ingredients…read more One sandwich could make two meals in most cases. Today, wife had pork roll and cheese on hard roll, ate only half because it was so big, having about 6 or more slices of pork roll. I had a classic Ruben with the exception of the rye bread, I had a gluten free (Celiac disease sufferer) sub roll. It was so big, it may make 3 meals for me. Absolutely huge and absolutely one of the best I have had. The staff are an amazing group that bring the old school deli feeling out, which is rare these days.

I went in blind -- no idea about prices, wait times, or what to expect. Just an ad online that…read morelooked too good to ignore. So I drove 45 minutes to Red Bank, NJ. The line at the door was bananas. But after a 45-minute drive, I wasn't turning around. Pre-surgery gluttonous me was getting this sandwich. I stood in line for another 45 minutes -- plenty of time to decide on the signature cheesesteak. When I got to the register, they gave me the heads-up: $45 for the cheesesteak. At that point the only thing that could ruin it was if it wasn't good. I also grabbed a few extras -- the prosciutto balls (if you know, you know) and some Italian vanilla wafer cookies that are outstanding. Decision time: eat it in the parking lot, or drive 45 minutes home first? I chose to wait. The smell in the car the whole ride back was borderline sinful. Got home, washed up, unwrapped it -- and this thing was enormous, clearly not just chopped-up steak thrown on bread. First bite in, I knew I wasn't in Kansas anymore. It'll probably take me a few weeks to finish (it's that big), but I'm already planning my return trip. Bonus points: while we waited, they kept coming out with fresh hot cheese tortellini and handing out free samples to everyone in line. When I paid, they threw in a whole separate container of it too. For context -- I'm a Philly guy. I'll drive an hour and a half for a cheesesteak without blinking. This place is 45 minutes away and it's still worth it. That says everything. The space itself is bright, clean, and stacked with an incredible variety of Italian fare. Bring patience, bring an appetite, and run -- don't walk. You will not regret it. 5/5 stars. 544 NJ-35, Red Bank, NJ 07701 talierciosdeli.com IG/FB: @taliercios

The line was put the door.

See all

Johnny Drinks

Almost Home General

4.2(184 reviews)

2.1 mi

This review is specifically for the Westwood location, and it's a 10/10, no notes…read more The breakfast biscuit sandwich is insane. My husband and I genuinely could not get over how good the biscuit was.....perfectly flaky, buttery. They also have an option covered in an espresso glaze, and it's just ridiculously good. I'm still thinking about it. Coffee was really solid (always matters), and the space itself is super cute and cozy. They also made Mickey Mouse pancakes for my daughter, and she was absolutely obsessed -- such a sweet touch and totally made her day. Westwood is a must. We'll absolutely be back.

Loved this adorable little spot. Wish i got a coffee. The OG chicken sandwich was pretty good. The…read morechicken had a few ick bites but I was a bit bummed out the bottom bun was totally soggy (we ate it there) My bfs chorizo egg burrito was a special I think and it came with those sauce that was actually addicting. so delish i still think about it. I picked up a blonde shallot chicken salad which was good too! They didn't have a price tag on the juices which were veryyyy pricey and I think it's someone else like selling their juices from their store and we got 2. $28.50 for 2 juices felt kinda like steep just put a sign plsss

The OG Chicken Sandwich

See all

House Cold Brew (16oz), butterfly lemonade

Joyce's Subs & Pizza

4.1(29 reviews)

0.1 mi

This place is a local favorite If your going for lunch I…read moresuggest calling in the order Great subs, my favorite is the Italian with everything Pizza is great too, big slices

Was traveling on business and was hoping to find a nice breakfast place nearby. The food is great…read moreand service is amazing. It's a little place that you want to keep coming back to. I'm ordering sausage gumbo to go because she gave me a little taste for free. Love it here.

Breakfast pizza

Eggplant parmesan sub

See all

Meatball Parmesan very good

Elsies Sub Shop

4.3(93 reviews)

3.0 mi

My new favorite sandwich spot in NJ! The subs are fantastic and whether you get them on their bread…read moreor a pickle, you'll be satisfied! I've now had lunch here two days in a row. Can't wait to come back and try more!

Starving after trip to sandy hook with my dog so I searched for a sandwich shop & picked this one -…read moreit was surprisingly good - lucky to find a 15 min parking spot available near the shop - only down side no public restroom, they said I could go across the street to use another businesses

Macaroni Salad

See all

A Turkey and Provelone half sub

Filoncino Bakery Cafe

4.2(42 reviews)

2.6 mi

If my husband says "I'll come back for lunch or dinner", you know the cafe is a winner!…read moreSecond time here; we just had egg sandwiches. Quality ingredients l, and home baked rustic roll elevated the sandwich even more!

Great spot for sandwiches. Their house made bread is fantastic. We came back the very next day for…read morebreakfast but it was a miss. The egg bowl left a lot to be desired. Not much flavor. The porchetta and eggs dish was also a miss. They threw some spices on top and it was overly salty--almost inedible. Surprised that the platter didn't come with home fries or some sort of potatoes. I'd come back only for their lunch sandwiches. We also got their chocolate bread to go which was fantastic. Their pistachio bar was also delicious and very heavy on the almond extract which I enjoy.

Dining area

See all

Pat's Market "The Neighborhood Butcher Shop"

3.8(45 reviews)

0.1 mi

I think the quality of most of the food, sandwiches, chop meat, steak is very good. I think the…read morereviews that are shown are older than the new owners of the store. There is a good variety of choices. A large variety of Italian "dishes". Good bread and a variety of bread choices for sandwishes. I have bought the Belle & /Evan's chicken there recently and it was up to the Belle & Evan's quality. That is why I think some of the reviews are from before it "changed hands". Go Get a sandwich. Very generous and very good.

Cheese steak was terrific. My wife liked her steak sandwich as well. Will return…read more We will also try the butcher section.

Pat's Market "The Neighborhood Butcher Shop"

Italian sub (with a few changes)

See all

Brennan's Delicatessen of Middletown

4.1(25 reviews)

3.0 mi

Delicious sandwiches! Everything was so fresh. Large portions and adorable shop with extra snacks…read moreto buy. Highly recommend.

This location has beef open for a while now but I've never been here. I know Brennan's in Rumson is…read morea fine establishment so I had no doubt this would be anything less than excellent. It's Saint Patrick's Day weekend and I was craving corned beef and where else would you go but Brennan's. The hand carved corned beef sandwich was the special today and it's terrific. The place is nice, lots of food choices and a busy staff that's second to none. I highly recommend this place.

The food here looks amazing

Saint Paddy's day corned beef special

See all

The corned beef special on pumpernickel

Aleo Italian Specialties

3.8(50 reviews)

0.0 mi

Purchased a sandwich, # 25. It was delicious. Just a note...I would have liked to see more coldcuts…read morein the sandwich. They were paper thin. It seemed like a veggie sandwich with a whisper of cold cuts. This store has a lot of delicious foods to offer. The cashier was friendly.

Large selection of Italian foods already cooked, fresh bread & rolls. Home made mozzarella &…read moreroasted peppers! Great cookies ! Sandwiches! Catering!

Arancini ball

See all

Eggplant pa sandwich

Dom's Cherry St Deli

4.4(40 reviews)

2.4 mi

Dom's Deli consistently delivers, providing high quality food with friendly customer service…read more Dom's passion is evident, and the food is delicious. The smoked meat specials (across the board) are hands my favorite.

Best sandwich with fresh arugula, soft roll, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, prosciutto and…read morechicken cutlet to die for! I dream about this baby! Who says you can't go home! Thanks Procopio family for fast service and an authentic Italian sandwich!

Lunch menu

Chicken Cutlet BLT

See all

Lunch menu

Angelo's Italian Market

4.9(44 reviews)

4.3 mi

Angelos is the best of the best. Fresh and delicious every single time. It's our go to when having…read morecompany and everyone always loves it!

We had 47 people for a barbecue and Angelos knocked it out of the park. Despite the power outage…read morethey worked extra hard and delivered excellent ribs, chicken, corn, burgers, etc. Will definitely use them again!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mason H.

11 months ago

as soon as i walked in the ladies in the front acknowledged me and helped me. they were unbelievably kind and very hospitable. they kept a conversation going not making it awkward just standing there waiting. i would 1000% recommend. the atlantic sandwich is a great choice! read more

Karen B.

7 years ago

I cannot thank ABC- Lincroft enough for their generosity! My daughter was a part of a iDance4aCURE dance-a-thon for childhood cancer research and they donated bagels for this great cause! Thank you again!!!! read more

Ross D.

8 years ago

Three months ago we opened our doors and we can't believe the response from the Lincroft community. Atlantic Bagel would like to wish all a happy and healthy New year. read more

Tom M.

7 years ago

Great ET bagel sandwich with roast beef and provolone lettuce and tomato. Great service and fast. Sorry no picture too good to put it down.

Atlantic Bagel Lincroft - bagels - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Restaurants near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Breakfast near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Coffee near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Parking near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Things to Do near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Pizza near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Cocktail Bars near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Desserts near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Shopping near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

BEST of Lincroft, New Jersey Thrift Stores near Atlantic Bagel Lincroft

Best of Lincroft

Things to do in Lincroft

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Atlantic Bagel Lincroft also viewed

Bagel Station

3.4

(89 reviews)

Service was friendly from everyone and my bagel came out way sooner than expected. I got a bagel…read morewith cream cheese and lox, along with tomato's, onions and capers. They have an additional fee if you use a credit card. So it came out to around $15.50.

Very kind and efficient staff and pretty good bagels. I wasn't particularly impressed with the…read morebagels or the egg sandwiches but the location and space are very convenient. Its very nice that the menu includes a variety of breakfast blatters in addition to what you would expect from a bagel spot. There's also 6ish small tables that fit 2-4 each, and a TV usually playing the morning news. Great that it's located right across from the train station, and very close to Red Bank staples like Two River Theater and Red Bank Antique Center.

The Bagel Store

3.8

(52 reviews)

In a plaza in Colts Neck, you will find a bagel store with potential…read more Brand: 9/10 I do appreciate the cartoon bagel characters with the old-fashioned 1930s animation eyes painted on the glass walls. The interior has a standard appearance typical of bagel shops with glass storage containing bagels and delicacies. The entrance definitely has a presentable impact, for you will find stone tables on a platformed plaza cluttered with stone. The Bagel Store has been known to donate to the local community, though it is not really known for any kind of events. However, I do not know how long the establishment will have the name "The Bagel Store," since many businesses exist that have such a standard type of name. Ambiance: 8/10 The environment inside had a standard quality to it, though with some elements sticking out. The television did play in the background a bit intrusively and a fly roamed around the inside. It can get noisy as a tightly insulated space, but nothing too chaotic. As a small space, the Bagel Store accommodates as much as it can with the tables and chairs vaguely separated apart. There are also stone tables and seats outside in case you cannot find room inside. Service: 10/10 I did like the self-directed check-out with an option to pay cash or credit, and giving you the choice between have the receipt or not. The owner described the leadership of this establishment as a place where every employee is a leader within their own station. I can see how this plays out in the workplace, since the staff makes many menu items readily available while others are just getting prepared shortly before the near-noon rush. Wait Time: 10/10 We did not experience any interruptions for the wait time. Food: 8/10 I chose the Black Russian bagel packed with cream cheese, with orange juice. It was already prepared, since it was already behind the glass case. The bagel held its form with none of the cream cheese pouring out. It had an earthy smell, which fits. This bagel flavor is a new taste for me. I will say that the hardiness complements the cream cheese perfectly, as the contrast befits this meal. The aftertaste disappeared quickly. Worth The Money?: 8/10 The food represents the brand well, since its well-preserved nature ensures that you get a simple yet fulfilling meal. While the Black Russian bagel satisfied me, the noisy environment did outweigh it. I can see how the brand will evolve over time beyond just an ordinary bagel shop. The family-friendly ambiance does reflect the cartoon characters of the glass walls, and the cartoons playing on the television. The business works within its own inflationary constraints, only requiring extra workers when it really needs them however rare. I admire how small businesses always know how to grapple with what little they have. Perhaps, applying the Pareto Principle to the business would help by investing first on the most vital parts of the businesses, investing second in everything else, and letting good luck fill in the rest--at least that's my personal business philosophy. I can see how this applied to updating the technology at the check-out area, just as it can apply to other areas. The owner expressed interest in situating the Bagel Store as the center of an event. Local eateries contribute more to the community than chain eateries through the local multiplier effect. Local eatery employees play a huge role, since they typically spend their income within the community itself. If the employees are leaders within their own station, then surely they could have enough voting leverage to suggest events to sponsor or create. I will say that the overall price is worth it. Rating: 5/5 Stars Given the choice between four or five stars, I will give it five stars due to the hope and potential that I see within the Bagel Store. Recommend To... Anyone and their family in the Colts Neck area looking for a bagel store.

Conveniently located next to Rook so you can grab a coffee next door and come here for a bagel…read more Also this is part of a plaza of stores so there's plenty of parking. I got a sausage, egg, and cheese on plain bagel and it was sooo good. The meat and egg was cooked perfectly, and the bagel had the perfect amount of slight crisp without being overly toasted. The service was quick and friendly, and the size of this bagel is no joke! I was full for hours after. Tip: I grabbed some ketchup packets to dip the bagel in, chef's kiss.

Planet Bagel

3.2

(52 reviews)

Bagels are so good.. service is meh and they don't take orders correct but keep it simple, check…read moreyour order and you'll be fine there's plenty of parking and the breakfast sándwiches we're spot on... they also offer everything on pump which I've never seen.

The bagels and breakfast sandwiches are REALLY good. I hate that I can't put 5 stars. The service…read moreis always so bad a majority of the time I go in. It's gotten a lot better overtime but they have days where it's impossible to get them to answer the phone. I'll show up in person and it's empty customer wise. Never understood why they have this problem.

Atlantic Bagel

3.4

(53 reviews)

We were in the neighborhood and instantly gravitated towards this place. The storefront here gave…read moreauthentic Jersey vibes. The minute we entered we knew we'd like it because they make their own spreads in house. I ended up getting the scallion onion bagel and definitely did not regret it. Great service, great business and great quality food. I wish I lived closer to make this my go-to bagel spot.

There are a lot of bagel options in NJ and we wanted to give Atlantic Bagel a shot. I got an…read moreeverything bagel with egg, cheese and avocado (note, they don't have fresh avocado, it's just guacamole) and then a side of macaroni salad. The bagel was fresh and flavorful, but I could have done without the guac. The macaroni salad was also a bit over seasoned (seemed to have the "Everything but the bagel" seasoning" on it). Unfortunately, service wasn't the best, but the bagels were good!

Pops Bagels & Deli

3.2

(80 reviews)

Always great, fresh and delicious food…read more Either walking in or ordering delivery, I love this place Bagels and Egg salad as fresh and so good Go here ! It'll be worth it !!

Have been coming here since they opened. This most recent visit was the worst. Bagel barely cooked,…read morebarely any onion on the onion bagel. The sandwich on the hard roll was paper thin, pork roll burnt to a crisp. It was like eating a bread sandwich. Something has changed at this place and it's not for the better. $16 for two basic breakfast sandwiches that left us barely satiated?? Everyone has off days so I will assume this was the case. I'll give them another chance. If it's the same disappointment I'll never go back.

Everything Bagels And Cafe

4.3

(26 reviews)

I was craving a breakfast bagel and saw that this spot was the closest to me so I gave it a try. I…read moreordered a toasted everything bagel with lox cream cheese. It was delicious! Bagel was fresh and fluffy and the cream cheese spread was generous and tasty. The French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese was my second choice if I decided to go sweet, so maybe I'll try that next time now that I know this spot is yummy! *Located in a strip mall with lots of parking!

TLDR: inconsistent preparation of bagels makes for a bad experience... don't come for breakfast,…read morecome for their hot lunch sandwiches. Came here on a Sunday around 10AM and ordered 3 bagels with cream cheese and 1 hot bagel. The breakfast bagels themselves were all inconsistent. One of the bagels had a generous amount of cream cheese while the other two had barely any... are we sure that these are jersey bagels?? The sausage, egg and cheese with a hashbrown was almost $10.... Seems a bit absurd for how thin the bagel was. Service was quick, but probably to their own detriment as an inconsistent product is being sold.

Hole Lot Of Bagels

3.6

(52 reviews)

My favorite bagels in the world! Their team is always friendly and treats you like family. I…read moreconsistently have a great experience here.

Nice bagel store next to livottis Good bagels, on the small…read moreside Well cooked the way I like them Solid service at the counter Many folks ordering breakfast sandwiches $9 for a half dozen, on par with most bagel stores

The Bagel Nook

3.7

(33 reviews)

Great bagels and spreads! My fave are the egg and sesame bagels. I had the French toast and cannoli…read morebags which are very tasty as well. The only problem I have with the Bagel book is that they tend to run out of bagels and don't keep up with making more. I went there the other day at 12:00 and they barely had any left. If you're going to stay open until 3pm you should be able to provide bagels until then. Their olive spread is very good! I get it all the time .

I placed a to-go order, and they were incredibly fast getting everything ready. Even though I…read morearrived later than the suggested pickup time, my food was still warm when I got home -- which was a pleasant surprise! I ordered the blue raspberry lemonade, and it was the perfect combo -- not too sweet and not too tart. Such a delightful mix. Whenever I'm in town, I have to grab some kind of pork roll sandwich. This time I went with the Double Nooker on an everything bagel, toasted and scooped with SPK (salt, pepper, and ketchup). Yum, yum, yum. There's a lot of food packed in there, but having the bagel scooped made it the perfect amount -- super satisfying without feeling overly stuffed or risking a tummy ache. The spot itself is open concept and has tons of space if you want to sit and eat there, which makes it great whether you're grabbing something to go or staying to enjoy your meal.

Bagel Time & Deli

3.3

(104 reviews)