Tasty bagels, good quality selection of bagel spreads, generous schmears-about all you need in a local bagel shop. Plenty of parking.

I occasionally come here on Sunday mornings to grab a bagel. It can get pretty busy, and you may have to wait a bit for your order. However, the staff is friendly, and the bagels are good. If you're looking for a lunch item, my favorite sandwich is The Atlantic, which is chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and pesto mayo on your choice of bread. The sandwich is warm, juicy, and seasoned well. It's a solid bagel spot if you're around Lincroft. read more

Atlantic Bagel Lincroft - The Atlantic Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

See all

Ordered last two times no toast and below pictures of breakfast delivered we ordered before this and enjoyed just last two times came like this will not order again read more

Atlantic Bagel Lincroft - Bagels Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

See all

It was my second time going to the store and the bagles were amazing. I was greeted by a girl from the south and she was absolutely wonderful to speak with and very nice to all customers. I will be going back for the quality and service! read more

The first time the workers there were super cool. Everything seems fresh and the price was fine The second time the one lady was a total dick and then had the nerve to aggressively spin the clover tip screen towards me and request a tip I actually gave the bitch a tip . I should have spit on the tip screen . Ill never go there again . read more

Good bagels; they give you 15 when you order a dozen. Spreads and things are very fresh. Staff not so friendly though.

This place is great- the food is wonderful and the staff is courteous and friendly. Try the Wrangler- and if you're lucky you just might hear the staff break out in song! Keep up the great work, guys! read more

Atlantic Bagel Lincroft - Amazing food and great service! - Bagels Near Me - Lincroft, New Jersey

Best bagels in the area. They need the soft white butter. They use the yellow hard butter that's like the equilivent of stick butter so one side has it and the other doesn't. read more

the coffee might be the worst in the whole area, they don't pick up their phones... ever, & better show up before 1 if you want food because they close their kitchen 2 hours early. no wonder why it is a failed resturant. read more

The food is good. But if you call in an order and you're asked to "please hold", don't bother staying on the phone, as they never pick the phone back. They've done it to me so many times I can't even count. read more

Store was slow when i went in, asked for a pork roll egg and cheese specifically asked for NO KETCHUP. Order was ready quickly but was SLATHERED in ketchup. It's not like they were busy and had a lot going on, the store was slow, theres no excuse. read more

Delicious bagels and great service ! Struggled to find a good bagel since moving from NY and these hit the spot .

Waited 45 minutes for a bacon egg and cheese the guys behind the counter have no social skills wouldn't give me an update. Told them what I wanted 6 times I then repeated it to them in Spanish they still didn't understand. Wouldn't recommend bagel was ok but jeez. read more

I ordered a egg bagel and a pork roll and cheese.. I called in my order and still had to wait 20 additional minutes to what i was told. My pork roll was dry and three very very thin slices. This place used to have meaty sandwiches quality has sure gone down. read more

The worst service I have ever seen. Ordered 2 bagels took 25 minutes with no update on when the food would come out. Joke of a bagel shop. Do not recommend ever going here. Pick somewhere else. read more

Delicious bagels, friendly staff! Love this spot for morning bagels for the family :)

Bagels are decent. They have become cheap on the meet for an egg sandwich (bacon). I think they need to END the demand for a tip when paying with card. You insert card and they flip the screen for you to pick a tip %. I mean they gave me a bagel, not even coffee I had to get that myself. Do they tip at McDonald's? I really don't see any difference. read more

I've stopped in twice now, and both times the bacon and egg on an everything bagel was very good, the staff was friendly, and the price was reasonable... 5 Stars ! read more

This place is amazing. Love the people, love the food. Deserves 6 stars. The Smokey is a great sandwich and their bagels are always fresh

Great bagels, friendly staff. Has quickly become our go to place on the weekend. Can't say enough about how friendly the staff is. It feels like it will be a cornerstone of the community for a long time. read more

Told the staff I have a dairy allergy. I ordered a bagel with egg and bacon. Received my bagel and it said "no butter" but had cheese on it. Make it make sense. read more

Great bagels and sandwiches! I grew up in Lincroft and was always used to driving to red bank or holmdel to get my bagels but now this is my "go-to" spot. The bagels and pork roll egg & cheese are as good as anywhere in the area. I was surprised to see so many bad reviews and honestly they don't do this place justice so I felt the need to give a review. I think a lot of those bad reviews could be chalked up to the servers having a hard time keeping up with the flood of people after they first opened but that seems to have changed now because they have different help behind the counter and many more hands. read more

Service is really attentive.. friendly and family atmosphere! Bagels are cream cheeses are delicious. I ordered the sausage egg and cheese and was totally satiated! read more

Disorganized behind the counter. Horrible customer service. I told the owner my order was wrong and he asked if i could just fix it at home. The same owner that Ive seen just sit there reading the paper while the line backs up out the door, not bc its that busy , but bc they are that slow. And then he has the nerve to yell to someone he knows to make sure they take care of his daughters behind the counter with tips bc they're only home for college for a week. Ive had the girl behind the counter BSing on the phone while shes trying to take my order. Its probably a 50/50 bet your order will be off in some way. The good food doesn't make up for the horrible customer service, and the arrogance of the ownership. I will be taking my business elsewhere moving forward. You should do the same. Looks like more than just a few reviews with the same experiences, so it must not just be my bad luck. read more

Love my local bagel shop! The standard bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on a bagel is my go-to, and it's made with two eggs, and plenty of bacon, all of which balances well with the bagel, whereas other bagel shops on shrewsbury who will remain nameless skimp on the egg and bacon and overwhelm you with bagel. Only reason I gave four stars is because of the service, which is occasionally all over the place. Super nice people always, but not as organized as a busy spot should be. Will continue to go on a weekly basis as always! read more

This place needs to put a major emphasis on sanitation. I was there recently to pick up bagels during coronavirus (had a mask on). The employee used the SAME glove to select my bagels, run my credit card, and press the credit card pad. I was so disgusted that I was speechless. I had to throw away my bagels when I got home in fear of cross contamination. Will not go here ever again. You would think that during this time they would take sanitation more seriously but that is not the case. read more

Was shocked at the bad reviews online, but tried anyway. Showed up on a Sunday at 11:24, not rush hour per se, 4 people talking behind the counter ignoring me. Had to ask if they were open since standing there in an empty line. Bad attitude. I fault ownership as that stuff trickles down. Too many other bagel options in the area. Worth the extra 5 minute drive. read more

Okay I really tried to give this place a chance since it is so close to me, but it is absolutely terrible. I do not understand how anyone can think these are bagels. The bagels are always hard to the point where they actually hurt your mouth. They have ZERO flavor, honestly they taste like something you would get at Dunkin, if not worse. This doesn't just apply for bagels, as I also ordered a pork roll, egg and cheese. Looked pretty good until I discovered AN ENTIRE EGG SHELL in my sandwich. I'm not talking a piece of shell, this was almost and ENTIRE EGG!! Completely disgusting!!!!! Go to Sheepshead Baygel in Holmdel, if you want to experience a REAL bagel. read more

First and last time. Asked for Taylor Ham to be crispy. Got to work, under cooked, what more can I say, waste of money, waste of time, I was forced to give one star, it does not deserve that read more

Pork roll egg and cheese..2 razor thin slices of pork roll ..not going back..step it up !..this is New Jersey!

3rd and last time at the Lincroft ABC Bagel. I must be a glutton for frustration. I ordered 3 bagels, 1 plain w/plain cc, 1 sesame with veggie cc, 1 plain with butter. No one wrote anything down. I paid $10.50. Got home and I had 4 bagels, not 3 like I ordered and 2 of the "4" I got were wrong....AGAIN! read more

Prompt service, small little place. Came here from out of town after going to a vet in the area. Bagel was good and they offered us a sample of their homemade chili. I would come again when in the area. read more

I would love to give this place 5 stars because it's the best bagel place in Lincroft now, BUT expect your order to be wrong 85% of the time. Not exaggerating either. Good food but not worth the frustration of getting home and not having the food you ordered. read more

The bagels are good but at times have a tendency to be over cooked. Unfortunately, with the exception of the older lady working behind the counter, service is horrible! The girls move terribly slow despite the number of customers that are in the store. Additionally, the kitchen routinely messes up orders. It's unfortunate because this could be a very good bagel store read more

amazing!! they really have the friendliest staff i've ever seen, the two girls in the front and were specifically so sweet. the bagel is delicious as well :) read more