My mom told me about this company as I was looking to sell my 2022 BMW 330i M Sport that had 37,000…read moremiles on it. Kelly Blue Book value on it was about $31,200 for a private party sale and about $26,000 on the low end for the trade-in value. I expected this company to offer me something in between, but they offered me a low $25,000 for it. The vehicle was in in pristine condition...not a scratch on it. I took such good care of this car, only using premium top tier gasoline, ceramic coating the exterior, never running it through an automatic car wash, only using synthetic oil, applying heat blocking ceramic tint to protect the interior, etc. I told them all of this but they didn't care and were firm on their low $25,000 offer. I wound up selling the vehicle privately for $31,000 through a Facebook Marketplace ad...$6,000 more than what this company offered. They advertise as beating Carmax and Carvana...but that's blowing smoke up people's you know what.
A December 9, 2025 post to their Facebook account states that they will beat Carmax's offer and if they can't they'll pay you $100. I went to Carmax and they offered me $26,400 for the car. When I contacted GetYourVin about the $100 for not beating Carmax, the lady i spoke with played dumb and said she wasn't aware of the ad and then said she checked with management and no one responded to her. After some back and forth, the business denied the existence of the ad even though I provided screen shots.
I then went to the BBB to file a complaint and the business responded stating that there are terms and conditions to the ad on their website, which, to me weren't easy to find. Buried in their FAQ is the FAQ with all the hoops you have to jump through. You have to actually sell your car to Carmax to receive the $100. The Facebook post is super misleading and I won't ever do business with this company. You shouldn't either.