I have been going here since I was a kid! Their cream cheese spreads are incredible, and their bagels are unmatchable! A staple spot for my family and a favorite spot for breakfast sandwiches. Highly recommend! My favorite order for a while has been plain and simple, but hits the spot EVERY time! read more

Simple breakfast sandwich - made well. Everything bagel was fresh and tasty. Staff was quick and respectful. read more

Terry's Not Just Bagels - Pork roll egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I went in for a bagel with cream cheese after church (and before the Jets game I had 30 mins before it started) My first time there. I asked are the bagels fresh the server said no they're stale. A gentleman down the way said we make them everyday. Then I ordered my bagel it was $4 I gave her my ATM/visa she said $5 you must buy 2 bagels. I said I'm sorry I have no cash on me she said I guess you're just gonna have to buy 2 bagels. I said no thank you. Her words "don't ever come back" Don't worry I won't.... read more

$10.66 for a plain bagel toasted with butter!! I guess they charge for using the toaster, their electricity!!! What a joke! Never coming back. read more

Great sandwich!! A must try. At $8.50 pricey but best around. 3 porkroll, 2 eggs, 2 cheese and bagel was good. Enjoy, I did. read more

Terry's Not Just Bagels - Everything bagel, 3 porkroll, 2 egg and cheese. Very good and it's big! Pricey at $8.50 but better than anywhere else in Manchester NJ area. - Bagels Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

there must of been a change of management the people working there are not inviting. i asked for a mmultigrain bagel w/ cream cheese they were none upfront said they had in back they gave me a un cooked broken bagel they tried to make it better by putting a pound of cream cheese not going back read more

We have been going to Terrys bagels for years when we visit my moms house in Manchester. This weekend was no different but we haven't been here in a while. We were so excited to get bagels and the best chicken salad we ever ate. However when we got home with our order. The bagels were raw and the chicken salad looks like prison food from a movie set. Please see attached picture. This cost me almost $40. As the owner was very nice, the food was absolutely disgusting and we will never return. We miss the old owners! RIP Terrys Bagels! read more

Terry's Not Just Bagels - Chicken salad - Bagels Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Bad service, bagels are just eh, not a lot to the sandwiches. Broadway Bagels around the corner is much better

Love the food, all the people are very friendly, and been clean every time I have been in

This place has gone downhill and they probably should close up! I ordered a ham and cheese omelette. It was extremely burnt with hardly any cheese, and they just threw these huge pieces of ham in the middle. Gross. I gave them another chance and ordered a pork roll with cheese on a bagel. Not only is this the thinnest pork roll ever, but there's was only 3 slices and it cost over $10! Absolutely ridiculous. I will NOT be back read more

I absolutely LOVE Terry's Not Just Bagels!!!!! The bagels are delicious! The store itself is so clean and the staff is so friendly! Antoinette and her family have changed Terry's for the better! read more

Always stop at Terry's! On Sunday morning, Awesome bagels! Always friendly service. Always one free bagel

Very bad experience with the new ownership. Had a gift card that was hand written from the past owners. When I went to use it, I was told by who I think is the owner that she did not write it and that I could have just gone and made it myself. I was shocked, I knew that she didn't write it and I tried to tell her that it was from the old owners but she kept questioning me and making me feel as if I was trying to use a fake gift card. If they were no longer excepting gift cards I would have understood, but there was no need to accuse a customer of trying to use a fake one and questioning them about the authenticity of the card. Great way to keep old customers coming. read more

I came here twice not the same as the old owners.I waited 20 mins for a no meat sandwich.never again.they will be out of business soon

Entirely to expensive. I got one breakfast sandwich (without a meat) and it came out to 11$ !!! Thats insane

Another classic New Jersey strip mall with a bagel shop. Terry's was a great place. The sandwich was delicious although the bagel itself was not 5 stars. The owner was friendly and kind and you can tell she works very hard to make this bagel store successful. Clean and plenty of drink options. Manchester sucks so if you find yourself in the area either leave immediately or stop and get some classic New Jersey food. read more

Terry's Not Just Bagels - a person holding a can of peace tea - Bagels Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

this place is amazin! I came in very welcoming and respectful workers. I got a bacon, egg and cheese. It was absolutely amazing and very affordable. I do recommend this place!! read more

Great food and even friendlier staff. Highly recommend to anyone who want a great breakfast sandwich and/or bagels.

Service was great! I got my food in around 5 minutes. The lady in the front was so kind. I love Terrys! def recommend.

My husband and I LOVE Terry's! It has become our Saturday morning spot. Their breakfast sandwiches are packed! Great bang for your buck here! read more

Best bagels we found in the area so far. I liked the egg meat and cheese deal that they have. It comes with a hot drink, but hot chocolate machine doesn't always work when I'm there. Hoping to try out some other sandwiches soon. read more

got 2 pork roll sandwiches and it was 17.00 my menu from about 2 year ago says 4.50. I understand prices go up but 4.00. there was hardly any meat on it. when I questioned it the girl got nasty with me. not sure if new owners but not going there again just because the girl was nasty read more

I've been coming here for years. Not the prettiest place but I could always count on a good bagel. I walked in a month ago and it had a different feeling. Nothing had to be said that it was a new owner. It was 7:15 am (they open at 7) and there were 2 people ahead of me. It took 10 minutes just to get to the register and place my order (a toasted bagel w cream cheese). I placed my order and the woman who I assume is the new owner took my order then shouted to the back "do we have any plain bagels?" This cracked me up since it was now almost 7:30 and there was not a bagel on display. I was told I had to wait another 5 minutes. Ok...I waited patiently and considered leaving but I already paid. Another 5 turned into 15!!! Now the line is growing, everyone behind the counter acted like they didn't want to be there, and service was incredibly rude. At one point, the woman was talking down to a younger guy working there. A gentleman finally got his order and said something of the slow service and she told him he didn't have to come back if he didn't like it. When she FINALLY called me, there was no acknowledgment of having been kept waiting, no apology, and acted like she was doing me a favor by making me a bagel. Which was TERRIBLE! The taste was not great, the texture was off, and she squished it so flat that it looked like it was sat on. Very disappointed! I went back 1 more time a month later just to give it a 2nd try. It was worse! 1 other person in the shop and it still took a while to be acknowledged and get the the same thing. The woman thanked me for my patience by saying "thanks for waiting bud" I felt that was unprofessional and condescending. Bagel still was not good so I will not be going back. read more

Worst bagels and customer service I have ever seen. Bacon egg and cheese on a bagel - HOW ABOUT MELTING THE CHEESE...... Wanna talk about DIRTY - Lets Not..... Place is filthy I've had better frozen bagels than this. First and last time in this place read more

Love the new owners! They're so sweet, especially the woman who usually takes my order. Even when they're slammed I notice that she makes it a point to have genuine conversations with the customers and doesn't just brush them off after taking their order. I haven't noticed any huge differences in the bagels or my usual orders, so maybe they stuck with the original recipes or just make things similarly. I've been coming here for about 2 years and will continue to! read more

NEW OWNERSHIP IS RUDE and quality has gone down. I've been here a half a dozen times or so and won't go back. Here is why.... After getting 1 of my 3 sandwiches wrong rather than re-making it fresh, they took the egg and meat and repurposed it to the new roll. How cheap can you be??? Then the female owner told me "if I wasn't happy I don't need to come back". Oh don't worry rude lady I won't. And I'll tell anyone who will listen not to go back either. You are selling bagels, not rare artifacts. I'll go to one of the 20 other places within a mile that do the exact same thing. Hopefully if they make a mistake like YOU did, they might take a shred of accountability and apologize and make it right. Can't wait for the new ownership a year from now when you have to sell at a loss because of your complete lack of customer service. read more

Food is always good here it's unfortunate I won't be returning, the owner is beyond rude. My mom asked him a question while he was cooking and he couldn't be bothered to turn around and acknowledge her. She asked him if he heard her and only then does he reply with an attitude "I heard you" and runs away like a child to the back and has his wife complete our order. Then he continues to huff and puff behind the counter. I've been in the store plenty of times and he's always like this, go be miserable somewhere else, you change the whole attitude of your staff when you act like that. If you don't care that the staff treats you like it's a major inconvenience to be at their business and just want your food then this is the place for you. There's plenty of other bagel shops in the area. I don't have to give my money to this man-child who can't control his emotions. read more

Great family owned business and great service. Breakfast sandwiches are top notch and would recommend to anyone looking for a quality Jersey breakfast sandwich. read more

My go to bagel shop when I'm in the area. I stopped in here 4 times on my 3 day trip to the Manchester area. I love the pimento cream cheese and the bagels are amazing! read more

I am actually a little weirded out by the low ratings but to each is own. These bagels are the best I have had in Toms River. I mean it to I show no favoritism or know anything about these people other then every-time I go in there the young girls treat me great and so does the two owner? (I could be wrong just the vibe I get.) their sandwiches aren't that skimp wawa sizzly quality it's an actual filling breakfast sandwich. Their cream cheeses are always great especially the veggie. They have awesome bagel flavors I suggest trying them all and if I'm not in the mood for a bagel I get it on a kaiser roll. Their younger girls working in there wearing sweatpants... I don't see how that affects the quality of their food but that's a little unfair. I will continue to eat here... they can wear basketball shorts and open toes Sandals whatever ... also bagels aren't something you can just "make more of" at the drop of a hat but that's enough ... read more

See all

I've only ever gotten bagels here, but man are they good! Definitely the best in the area. Highly recommended for a delicious, high quality NJ bagel experience! read more

Everyone says the food is 5 stars but gives this place low scores as far as "customer service" goes. The reality is that you come to this place for a great bagel. If I wanted great customer service and mediocre bagels I'd go to any other place in this area. Plain and simple. If you have a sweet tooth and like dessert for breakfast, a not-toasted frenchtoast bagel is where it's at. It's sweet with a crispy exterior and a soft yeasty interior. Getting it toasted caramelizes the sugars and you're left with melty cream cheese, which is good but you may need to lick your hands clean afterwards - you wouldn't want to wipe the goodness away with napkins, would you? Every place also features cinnamon raisin but I feel like they really miss out on cinnamon flavors and this place doesn't. There's also the onion bagels and everything bagels, which I haven't tried but I believe there's a lot of flavor there since I've avoided kissing my boyfriend after he ate. If you don't prefer processed cheese then I would skip it. I'm just picky in that area when it comes to different cheeses and like a good melting consistency in a breakfast sandwich - think of the difference between fresh mozzarella sticks and one that's been sitting for 10 minutes. Very weird, I know. This place is you get what you get. It's good bagels without the "bubblegum" customer service. I've never heard of people turning away a simple bagel because someone didn't greet them with a smile to take their order. Ps. They have a sign inside of their cost for a bagel and small coffee versus other places prices. You can't beat the cravings of it. I've spent $3 for a large coffee and a bagel with no cream cheese. read more

When I see the person behind the counter sneeze multiple times into their hands and don't wash it, it's plain disgusting. Not to mention they still attempted to ring my order up with their nasty germ infested hands. I'm not a germaphobe my any means but the total disregard for the sanitary is was shocking. Never going to eat there again. If they act that way in front of customers how do they act behind closed doors? read more

Nothing special - bagels were not very doughy and there was way too much salt.

Great Bagels. I love that they have so many different varieties of everything bagels (rye, egg, whole wheat, multi-grain, and my favorite pumpernickel everything). I stop here every time I am in the area and bring bagels home to freeze. They don't skimp on the seeds, the bagels are so fresh, and if you get there early enough you'll get a warm bagel. The staff has always been really nice and service is quick. One of my favorite bagel places. read more

The bagels are always on the smaller side and hard, pretty poor quality very similar to bagels from a grocery store. I bought half a dozen and the bagels are so small I immediately regret going here. Will not be back. read more

Stopped by on the way from the airport after flying all night to visit family. This place is in need of a good cleaning. The staff seem like the don't want to be working. The bagel I got was good... the cream cheese was great.. read more

Terry's bagels do not disappoint! They're right up there with New York bagels with flavor & texture. The variety offered is so good that it's hard to decide what to have first! read more

Since my wife started going to Terry's I was kind of forced into getting my bagel sandwich there, instead of the big chain bagel store. I could not have been more surprised or pleased and Terry's is now my 'go to' place. The bagels are bigger and they don't skimp on the bacon. The people who work there are ALWAYS friendly and courteous even when they are extremely busy. Couldn't be happier! read more

The bagels here are pretty good, but the service is a different story. The people behind the counter always seem to be angry and rude to the customers. Don't think I would go back anytime soon. read more