All Star Bagels

In town visiting family and wanted to grab some lunch. Found Gustosa's was right around the corner…read moreso decided to check it out. Cute little Italian market, deli and pastry shop. We chatted with several of the employees and thought everyone was friendly and fun to talk to. We ordered a couple of sandwiches which were stuffed with meat. No skimping here. I ordered a roast beef and hubby ordered prosciutto. Choice of toppings and cheese, so you get exactly what you want. They were delicious! The hot entrees looked delicious too. We did order some pastries and cookies, but haven't tried those yet. May stop by again before we leave town.

Wish I could give 0 stars! Charge my 86 yr old mother $19.95 for a 8 inch sub! Sour cole slaw! If…read moreyou want to get RIPPED OFF! & get Italian sub with nothing but ham no cheese! This is the deli for you!

Just bad sad disappointed

See all

Wheres the sauce. Wheres the ricotta water lasagne really

Sub Doctors

4.2(75 reviews)

Best subs I have ever eaten, reasobable prices, have hot and cold subs, plus regular deli…read moresandwiches, salads, side items, breakfast and a drive thru window. What more could you ask for. Great service too.

Great tasty sandwiches tuna delicious turkey Swiss definitely delicious try this sub doctorsread more

Front area

See all

Front door

Fat Patty's Bar & Grill

4.0(45 reviews)

1.5 mi

First time here, great experience Maddie our server was…read moregreat. The Jammin Patty was good. Cape May on tap = home run. Can't wait to come back.

We went to Fat Patty's for the 2nd time this summer. Glad to see plenty of parking and a small…read morecrowd for a Friday night. Sat at the bar and received great friendly conversation and service. Conversed with the bartenders and nearby patrons. We had the lil burgers. The burgers were juicy and tasty and the accompanying onion rings & sweet potato fries were crisp on the outside and tender in the center. Tons of TV's all around to watch the Yankee game with pleasant noise levels. You can easily have a conversation. Ask for a toasted roll for your burger it will not become a gooey mess of mushy bread because the burgers are so juicy. Also very reasonable pricing.

Our lovely view at the bar of all the service napkins.

See all

The Miracle Pub

3.5(235 reviews)

TOMS RIVER: Miracle Pub is a local favorite with great food, great vibes, and they are dog…read morefriendly! Leashed and friendly pups are welcome both on the beautifully decorated outdoor tiki patio and inside the restaurant. With an American‑style menu in a fun sports bar setting, this spot is perfect for game days, casual hangs, and year‑round good times. The fried green beans are a must‑order, and the mango margarita brings the perfect spicy kick. Huge shoutout to Kevin (manager) and Nicole (our server) for the amazing service and great conversation! If you are looking for a place to watch sports, enjoy delicious food, and bring your pup along, this is it. They also have a front store with package goods, which is super convenient. Thanks to our follower Wendy (Mom to pups Kylie & Kevin) for the awesome recommendation!

I've heard a lot of talk about this place throughout the years and finally had a chance to dine…read morehere. This place is actually bigger than it looks. We walked in the front door and immediately you see a liquor store and in the back is a huge restaurant. It was so crowded that we ate outside, which I believe was actually better both since the weather was nice and not as crowded. The price of food here is really reasonable. This watering hole is a real plus to the locals. Elise was our server. Very friendly. Excellent food, large menu for every type of diner. I believe they even serve late breakfast because they open up at 10 AM. Check it out. Not the easiest place to find when you're on the highway 37 E.

Deviled eggs

See all

New York Deli

3.0(2 reviews)

1.2 mi

I'm New Yorker at heart. When I see a New York Deli I get excited. When I see Pastrami on the menu…read moremy 26 cardiac stents start to close my heart labored and I breakout into a cold sweat. It doesn't matter what else is on the menu. My mind is made up already. So it was the pastrami sandwich on rye with mustard. Everyone know the look on a kids face when he gets this really cool balloon he really wants and 2 seconds later it goes BOOM. This was my BOOM MOMENT. the pastrami was salty and pressed together like one big lump. I don't know what they did it was dry with some liquid pouring from it. The rye bread was on the edge of being stale. I have to say the staff was very nice and friendly. They don't accept credit cards. A sight is written on a post it note at the register buried behind a faux plant. I was $.22 short and offered to go to the cash machine across the hall but the owner declined. The service it relatively fast so if your taste buds don't mind and you are tired of fast food chains this could be a respectful alternative. You never know they have eggs ya can't screw them up too bad. Or can they?

To be honest I didn't like my sandwich too much. It made me sick. This however was my fault for…read morechoosing a sandwich with both mayo and cream cheese. The sandwich selection here is very good, as there are a lot of options to choose from. The service is also exceptional. They treat you like a friend at this deli and that kind of service is always a good sign.

Dariusz Polish Deli and Grocery

5.0(10 reviews)

0.6 mi

OMG! I love this place!! The shop is full of cool snacks, cookies, pickles, bakery goods, and other…read moreimported Polish products. There is a small refridgerator section with cheeses and pierogies. Also, they have plenty of amazing deli meats, hams, head cheese, and more! I got a "cheesecake" made from farmers cheese and golden raisins which was great! Not very sweet. I couldn't resist and bought the homemade kielbasa sandwich with mustard and saurkraut on rye bread. Woooo this is soooo good! The sandwich is huge and the sausage is piled on generously. Why don't I live in Toms River again?!

Authentic polish food, delicious ready to go salads and desserts! Service with a smile, everyone…read moreis so nice. Love this deli/store

Deli counter and register. Menu on back wall.

Kielbasy on Rye - Amazing!

See all

Meats and Cheeses

Wawa

4.3(9 reviews)

0.3 mi

I'm particularly partial to Wawa ...whenever I'm in NJ I try to stop . I love their coffee and…read moresince I keep a particular diet during the day Thor salads are perfect. I walked into this one grabbed a small coffee hot you prepare yourself...so I say ...perfection light and sweet the way I enjoy. My significant other and myself need a quick lunch 2 snack chicken wraps for him At frat price of 2.49 and my salad no chicken for 7.99 plus add one of extra dressing and a hard boiled egg. 9.49 for my stuff. They called my number when they did my wraps were ready not my salad since their was a line pretty long because their was only one cashier open I didn't go right bc away to my surprise only the snack wraps were ready so I waited a few minutes grabbed my salad and into the car Bless my soul I opened my salad as we were almost out of the parking lot and my sunflower seeds and eggs were missing turned around . I entered Wawa where to the counter that's prepared our food showed the young lady my items were missing and told her my order number . At first she was kinda nonchalant said that there were sunflowers but she'd give me more...I think she totally didn't here me about the egg I said look I don't eat protein like the chicken I'm sorry the egg is my protein....she gave me two containers with extra of both apologized.... That made it better;) we are human we need to be understanding... I will note I ordered only spinach; what I got was spring and son ache mix something was off; still love Wawa the clientela and location was perfect in Tome River. I'll go back maybe sine day to that one.

They have great employees go to Tom river Wawa it the best It even has a gas station the gas is…read moregood as well and don't forget the tips :)

See all

Schiano's Pizzeria

3.4(117 reviews)

Excellent food I have ordered from here 7 times last 2 months…read more Delivery person are always extremely punctual and very polite

What the ...?? For the most part I never really had anything bad from here . . Till now . The worst…read morethin crust pizza (well done) I have ever had . Also ordered was chicken (Boneless) now that was over cooked . I ended calling back and asking if this was a THIN CRUST WELL DONE ..I was told *THATS WHAT YOU ORDERED * I EXPLAINED the pizza pie appears not thin crystal not well done .. I was told sorry about that . Duh.. not once was I asked to make the order better . . I was told sorry.. oh well. Ugh unexpected answer just sorry ..nit sure I will ever go back . Too bad .oh well live and learn .

Front Counter

Soft pizza not well done

See all

Dessert and Drink Fridge

Favorites

2.0(3 reviews)

1.3 mi

This place was good when it was open. Quick easy food. Sad to see it gone. My husband ate there…read morewhen he was tiny now is sad he cant go back. Good luck favorites

Assistant manager FRANK is rude, unprofessional, and just plain mean!! I was unaware of the…read morespecific rules the facility had for Covid19 and instead of taking me aside to simply explain them, he got within 2 feet of me and started yelling at me like a child. I was completely embarrassed and appalled by his behavior. I have never been treated with such disrespect in my life. I dont know how someone of this character is able to be an employee let alone in management. I have read other reviews which have similar complaints. Upper management needs to do something about him!! He completely runs the experience of what is supposed to be a fun environment. I will absolutely not be recommending this place to friends in the future unless you want to be yelled at and called out like a child. I guess he's unaware of how to politely speak to someone when there is an issue. His behavior was uncalled for and he has repeatedly treated customers the same way. Frank needs to go!

See all

Cluck U Chicken

3.2(67 reviews)

Left only 1 Star because they are gone. 5 Stars for their…read morewings - been eating them for at least 35 years. OUT OF BUSINESS. No one has been there for weeks. No one answers phone. No one replies to email. I'm wondering if the whole CLUCK-U chain has gone under, as I've tried contacting headquarters to see if Toms River will reopen, but they don't respond either

Took exactly an hour to get to me when it is 10 minutes down the road…read more My food was cold The only thing good were the fries Absolutely worst ranch I've ever tasted and the Buffalo wings weren't even spicy If it wasn't cold and if it was actually spicy it wouldn't be so bad but considering the fact that it took an hour to get here with a 5$ fee is just absolutely ridiculous since it wasn't even that good. Very disappointed.

Store hours

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Oh My K.

3 years ago

I've seen a lot of these peoples review and I can guarantee they have no idea how stressful it is to run a business they can't please everyone but writing reviews on a bagel shop running out of bagels at noon when they close in an hour in my opinion is going to happen if you want the bagel you are in the mood for simply get there earlier every time I go in the owners and staff are awesome and I haven't gotten a bad sandwich read more

Michael D.

9 years ago

Good bagul. Would buy more. Closes at 2 though and shelby doesn't wake up till 5. Hard to get bagul early when sloth sleeps in. Best bagul on the Jersee Shore read more

Jack B.

Elite 21

240

115

8 years ago

I like to get the bagels, go home and toast them... Then they are to my liking. Place is good overall.

All Star Bagels - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

People who viewed All Star Bagels also viewed

Delicious Bagels

3.1

(57 reviews)

My husband is from the area and loves this place. I ordered an everything bagel with cheese and…read moreegg. I received an egg bagel with cheese. When I took it back, they were confused. There was no egg, I'm not sure what the confusion was. I did end up getting the right bagel. I'd give it another chance but it would just be helpful if they made what the customer ordered.

good product.. rude staff. Won't be back! Baron owner is rude too... don't go there either…read more. William and I will go to Manhattan bagel

Round Dough With A Hole

4.1

(175 reviews)

Love. Bagels so good. Fluffy on inside with nice crisp crust. All homemade cream cheese. The bagel…read moresandwiches looked really good too. Also so did the cookies. Total deli vibe. Take Apple Pay and cash

If i cant get to Joes this is a good not so quick hit. They are much better since they sold/changed…read morestaff a few years back. Original people were horrible. Lines can get crazy just have to hit them at the right time. Nice open place and coffee is decent.

Jt's Bagel Hut

4.2

(174 reviews)

It's amazing what they can do with bagels, outstanding, service, polite, and prompt & and wonderful…read morepeople that work there are extremely polite and courteous. Semper Fi! God bless the United States Marine Corps

Such a small portion of pork roll and one slice of cheese on my bagel! It's so dry I can barely eat…read moreit. Compared to other bagel places and the quantity you get on a breakfast sandwich, I would not come back. It's a shame because they used to be really good. The place is always clean & friendly staff- no problem there!

Atlantic Bagel Company

4.2

(13 reviews)

Amazing bagels!!! Great service too. Really nice people who work there super convenient spot for…read moregrabbing bagels on the way to the beach

I love this place as a new regular, clean bagel shop, great staff and fast service. The food orders…read moreare made fresh. I absolutely enjoy the blueberry muffins and the egg bagels. Thank you for exciting here.

All Star Bagel & Grill of Forked River

3.7

(6 reviews)

From the moment I walked in I was welcomed! I arrived very late morning so my bagel options were…read morelimited but that's on me. There is a credit card surcharge so bring cash. There's some limited seating but feel free to enjoy your meal dining in. I ordered ham & provolone with mayo on a pumpernickel bagel and it came with lettuce & tomato. It was a decent bagel and yummy! The sandwich was almost $10 and included a bottle of water or can of soda. I thought it was quite pricey and I didn't need a drink so I'd prefer to pay $7-$8 and not have the drink. The drink should be an added option not automatically included. Overall, good sandwich!

Bagels are not bad, the pork roll egg & cheese was mediocre at best. A little expensive for the…read morequality.

Hole In One Bagel-Deli

4.0

(111 reviews)

This starts off dark but it ends with bagels and joy, trust me!…read more We had been at Jersey Shore Med Center all week as our mother transitioned, finally, at 4am on Christmas Eve. When hospice staff finally ushers us out of her room at 6:20 we are left to collect our hearts and heads and move forward. Mom loved the beach and the sun will be rising soon. But we are short on sleep and need comfort in this time. What says comfort at 6:30 in the morning better than the staff and bagels at Hole in One? We piled in the car to grab our favs and then ate breakfast peacefully on the beach in Ocean Grove as the sun rose. We reflected on life and death and family... And the joy of a soft, toasty bagel. I also had a Red Bull which may or may not seem insane lol If it was any other bagel shop we may not have gone there that morning (there are closer shops to the beach than this one!). I mean who goes straight for bereavement bagels at dawn after 3 hours of sleep? Well the staff at Hole in One are always so great and friendly. And the bagels are possibly the best you can get between Red Bank and Neptune. And their sandwiches? Delicious. That little danish/turnover type of pastry thing that was kind of warm when they gave it to me? SO TASTY. Please stop by when you get the chance!

I stopped in for the first time today & was disappointed by the customer service. The gentleman…read moreassisting me seemed impatient when I had trouble hearing him. As a first-time customer, I didn't feel particularly welcomed. Thankfully, the woman behind the counter was friendly & pleasant. But with so many bagel options in the area, I will not be returning to Hole in One.

Broadway Giant Bagels

3.0

(3 reviews)

Very disappointed. Bacon is way overcooked and crumbles. The bagels taste like the ones you get…read morelike Thomas's. They definitely are not crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and they are way overpriced.

I had high hopes when they opened on Mule Road. My first two experiences were positive. The staff…read morewas great, and I enjoyed the bagels. Then, rather abruptly things deteriorated. My last two visits resulted in smaller bagels that were flat out raw in the middle. And on visit #4, I picked up a take out order at 6:30 in the morning that was not my order. They had two orders on their table. Come on, really? My search continues for a good bagel place sadly.

Manhattan Bagel

3.3

(27 reviews)

Very good food and service breakfast is very good. They put plenty on the sandwiches.read more

Absolutely 5-star customer service from beginning to end. I was greeted right away and clearly…read moreinformed that he'd be with me shortly to take my order. He was very pleasant and attentive, making sure I had everything I needed. He even double-checked my order before I left to ensure it was correct. My bagel was neatly placed in a bag with napkins included. small details that truly make a difference. Not every place takes the time to do these things, and it really stood out. Keep up the great work.

Cathy's Bagel Shoppe

4.1

(7 reviews)