I needed some NJ bagels while visiting and checked out a few places on Yelp. I called up All Star and placed an order for a couple sandwiches and let them know I'd pick out some out of the case to take with me. I arrived and there was only one person ahead of me so I was in and out in no time. I took an assortment of six bagels to get us through the week on top of the hot sandwiches. We both got Pork Roll, egg, and cheese for obvious reasons and I got mine on a jalapeno cheddar bagel. This was the perfect choice and if I were to order another I would get it exactly the same way. The bagels we had at the house were gone in the next few days and I'm glad I got some of the cinnamon raisin because they were so good when I slathered them in butter. Obviously you have plenty of choices for bagels in this area, but I would absolutely recommend checking out All Star. read more

See all

Was going here every weekend. BUT, today not feeling well had someone get my breakfast. Order was wrong twice!! Had to bring it back, was very upset said what I needed to say. They gave me my money back and Extremely " Said Hope You Never Come Back, From the Female Worker !! read more

All Star Bagels - Sandwiches Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

Pretty good breakfast sandwich got a pork roll egg and cheese on a plain bagel, can't complain read more

All Star Bagels - Pork Roll, Egg and Cheese Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Very great service, very welcoming all our bagels were perfect and really good. He gave us two free bagels very nice welcoming place. Highly recommend!!!! read more

Great little bagel joint that had soft, fresh bagels that weren't too chewy. The service was quick and everything was reasonably priced. All fresh tasting ingredients in my sandwich! Coffee was great and is self served so you can add how much of whatever you want. Definitely stop here if you are in your way to the beach! read more

All Star Bagels - Egg everything Bacon, Egg and Cheese Sandwich and a coffee - Sandwiches Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

This place has decent bagels but service is terrible. I order light butter and it come covered read more

Came here after reading all the Yelp reviews and I'm so glad I did! The pork roll egg and cheese bagel is life changing...no seriously! Don't order anything else. I recommend calling in your order if you don't want to wait around -- this place gets really busy! read more

Friendly efficient service, great variety, very fresh and generous portions. Very friendly atmosphere

Obviously don't care for customer. I'm here before noon. No plain, egg in fact no bagels unless you want blueberry or a multi colored one. The bagel I tried seemed stale and tasted of ....garlic l? I'm new to area but this is no All Star next stop I was recommended NY water bagel hopefully it's better and more concerned with actually providing Bagels at 11.30 in the morning. Is there a 1/2 star? read more

This particular Location was pretty bad the day I came. They only had 4 different types of bagels and arrived around 11ish So decided to go with Salt bagel with PEC and Jalapeño toasted with butter. Pretty simple right? Well the bagel wasn't toasted and they put so much butter that I had to scrape more than half what they gave...now if the bagel was toasted then it would have melted into the bagel.... Sadly was not the case. The other locations in Jackson was always a pleasure to go to. Maybe because this was closer to Manchester....who knows but was pretty disappointed at this location. read more

Little Shocked!! Been here many times. By far Best bagel around and I'm from NY. Service has always been above and beyond but..... I'll never go here again!!!! Wife went in and ordered me my usual... scrambled soft cheese on a lightly toasted roll. Took one bite. Roll didn't look or taste fresh. Roll was all cracked up and a little burnt. Brought it back in. Told them I don't think roll is fresh. they told me they get them fresh everyday( my mistake for saying not fresh) and then the owner ( Joe?) came over to counter " threw the box at me" and said " you pick out a roll" I said I don't wanna argue. that's okay I'll keep it but then I said to myself " F You". and walked out telling them @ keep it". Doesn't matter if roll was fresh or not fresh. You don't throw a box of rolls at a customer I never raised my voice and you don't serve a egg sandwich which is usually great all " cracked up and a little burnt. All that nice service and great bagels and egg sandwich just went out the window. Perhaps Joe should attend a Anger management class. He certainly was disrespectful. I was quite shocked. He has lost our business forever. Doesnt he know the customers always right. The nerve of him!!! Nice guy? Shocked by his behavior. Never expected that from this establishment read more

Overpriced take advantage of seniors. Will never go there again. There food not that great

I'm from Indiana and I come to Tom's River NJ to visit my girlfriend and I come here EVERY SINGLE TIME!!! My goto is the pork roll egg and cheese! Food is great and the people are super nice there HIGHLY recommend it. read more

If I can I'd give you zero star's! The young man who took my order was very professional! But the owner,cook no responsibility for a 40min wait that I ordered that I placed 9:20am! 6 customer's who ordered at counter got served before me! 40min wait RIDICULOUS! read more

Excellent food & service. Owner is so friendly and welcoming. Would highly recommend. A+++

Food is good. But -2 stars for inability to follow simple instructions on a breakfast order delivery. I usually drive here and order/pickup so I can check to make sure order is correct. I ordered for delivery for 1 sandwich, & 2 different bagels with 2 different cream cheeses- (correctly spelled in English). Order arrived very quickly...Got ready to eat ... BF sandwich was great... kid opened bagels and cream cheeses were mismatched. I will still order food from here because it is very good. but maybe next time I'll order everything on the side so no confusion. Mistakes do happen - and hopefully this doesn't happen often. read more

Their bagels are delicious with many different kinds. They open at 6:00am therefore, I can purchase them warm and serve them for breakfast. There are two stores on Route 37 east & west close to my home. They offer takeout breakfast orders, hot coffee, other beverages and bagel condiments. Excellent service too. read more

This used to be my go to spot for years. But when they sold last August is went down in quality and service faster then the titanic!!! New owners are rude and no clue what they are doing. And to top that off last Sunday they had no bagels at 11am and told me they where done making them for the day. read more

Porkroll egg cheese spk everything bagel best in the area coffee is excellent counter people are extremely nice and friendly will definitely be back read more

There's nothing like a good fresh delicious bagel in the morning! And this is the only place around here that I would buy them from! Especially the EVERYTHING Bagels! Lightly toasted with veggie cream cheese.... Dang! Now I'm hungry for one! it's just too bad that they don't deliver to my house otherwise I'd probably look like a bagel now lol read more

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!!!!! This place is phenomenal! I've eaten here almost everyday for three years straight and never had a bad meal! To top it off, the staff and owners here are extremely friendly and polite. They even sell CBD products now. Stop by if you are in the area you won't be disappointed! read more

Toms River, NJ is a classic New Jersey town. Strip malls galore and every 500ft there's a new pizza place. Who knew everything you could ever need would be in some strip mall off a random state route. Toms River encapsulates the classic New Jersey experience and this bagel store is no exception. Right next to an at&t that looks deserted, this bagel store makes its presence known with its delicious bagels. Delicious choices of bagels, drinks, and even chips! I get my favorite order here and it does not disappoint. Bacon egg and cheese on a toasted everything bagel with hot sauce if you're interested. Overall-- great local place that will teach outsiders just how amazing a New Jersey bagel is. read more

See all

The best I've had has been the French toast one. I love all there bagels. So fresh and delicious. And the French toast bagel is my favorite one now. We just got a dozen 2 days ago. I'm about to eat 1 now...get there early. You don't want to miss out. read more

I am a customer at All Star Bagels, I'm not sure what has changed there. I got a bagel there today and it was hard as a rock. I'm not a bagel baker so I'm not sure if it was burnt or what. It was terrible!! Lately that location has been terrible during the week but fine on the weekends. I don't know if the baker changed or what's going on there. All I know is if it continues they are going to lose my business. read more

I have been going to All-Star for about 1-1/2 years now. Their bagels have always been just OK, nothing spectacular. Recently I have been experiencing bagels that have not been fully cooked. I returned to the store with my non-cooked bagel in hand and explained and showed the staff my mushy bagel. The employee got very defensive and told me that the bagel is just very fresh. I was taken back by the attitude and reply. All I wanted was just an exchange of the bagels. After some attitude from the employee, she gave me my replacements. I understand that from time to time bagels get under or over cooked but don't try to defend the problem when the problem is right in front of you. Also, in the same order, my cinnamon raisin bagel didn't look like a cinnamon raisin bagel. There was hardly and cinnamon or raisins in it. I don't know what's going on at the store but its not good. Especially with the attitudes going on. I hate to leave because the store is convenient, but I think I will be taking my business else where. Mike read more

All Star Bagels - bagel not cooked - Sandwiches Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Being new to the area I try different places for different things. I ask for insight from friends in the area, but mostly I find places by driving by. This was the case with All Star Bagel. The quality, service and cleanliness I rate 5 stars. The bagel was warm with a nice crisp bite to it. The only negative was a smear of cream cheese was a little too much for my taste. But overall it was an outstanding bagel, the best I have experienced in my three months in the area. read more

Wishing I honestly could leave 0 stars...just starting off. They took my order wrong, the food was wrong by a long shot 2 things were wrong on the bagel then I didn't get my order of hash browns. So I said alright fine I'll just give 'em a call and let 'em try again... nope not today... I ordered BACON**AND**CHEESE SALT&PEPPER on an EGG BAGEL I get my order back the second time what do I get..oh I get the bagel but huh what's this 1 hash brown god forbid... I got charged 11something$ for a meat EGG and cheese with 2 hash browns so I'll leave it to you. read more

Great bagels to have not to big not to small. They are tasty and never stale. These bagels are one of the best in ocean county

Fresh bagels. Excellent lox. Great alternative to a burger for lunch. Plenty of choices of bagels.

Aboutstily brutal WTF asked for 4 toasted bagels NOTHING!!!! On top of that was short one bagel!!!! Shit service STAY AWAY FROM THIS DUMP

I love the wide variety of bagels! They have everything ranging from French toast, honey, banana, blueberry, etc. to the classics such as everything, plain, pumpernickel. I especially loved the mini everything bagel. The flavor of the dough is on the sweet side. They are flat and lacking an airy texture. There are plenty of tables to sit at while eating your breakfast. read more

I have no idea how a place with such a terrible bagel can survive in New Jersey bagels are dry and tough and have this overpowering malt flavor read more

Today I stopped by here again on the way back from the doctor's office. I was in a hurry and wanted to grab lunch really quick before getting back to work. Although I was previously rather impressed with the place, today I left irritated. I'll tell you why. 1. NOT ENOUGH TOPPINGS FOR BAGELS: I asked for avocado and alfalfa sprouts on my bagel. They do not have it. The only thing they have is lettuce, tomato, and onion. After some negotiation I was able to get red pepper. At a bagel shop where they prepare you bagels with cream cheese, there should just be a larger assortment of toppings available. 2. NO SIDE SALADS at all. There is no macaroni salad, no cole slaw, nothing. The only thing they have is potato chips. I ended up having to go to Wawa after the bagel shop, which really annoyed me because I was in a hurry. I knew this would be my lunch, and one bagel with no topping was just not going to be enough. I should have been able to pick up a bagel with avocado and some cole slaw. Is that unreasonable? No, it is not. They'd make more money, too, if they offered it. 3. BAD PASTRIES: The cookies are processed, long shelf life ones. They do not have fresh cookies or donuts, or anything else available. Everything is in a sealed bag and looks totally unappetizing. So, unless you want to have to pick up a bagel here and then go to Wawa in addition, you might as well just stop once at Wawa and be done with it. read more

Super supportive and went above and beyond. As someone who can only have gluten free they were so accomodating and helpful, really went above and beyond. Will continue coming back :) read more

Stopped in on the way home. Roomy bagel spot, with a good amount of seating. The menu was pretty good, some loaded specialty sandwiches and flavored cream cheeses. I opted for a simple pork roll, egg & cheese. You can take the boy out of Jersey, but not the Jersey out of the boy. I ordered pretty quickly, but was in for a wait. Looked like a couple people in front of me ordered for the office. It's ok, I got my coffee at the do it yourself area and watched tv. They also have a wall decorated with sports stuff, get it All-Star? I was able to just look at everything. Unfortunately, I had to eat on the go. The sandwich itself was pretty good. Thin sliced pork roll and a delicious egg with a good amount of cheese. The bagel was a bit soft for my liking. I'm more of a crusty bread guy. I know, get it toasted....no, I'd rather a nice baked crispness. I will say though, it was a good spot and being rather close to my girl's place, I'll head there again. read more

First off, as another post mentioned...the bagels aren't your typical NJ/NY style bagel. They are softer but I have to say they are the freshest and tastiest bagels I've had..period! They're is a wide variety to choose from and they also have a huge Bagel sandwich menu to boot. Fresh made cream cheese varieties as well! Price is right for baker half dozens or dozens. Our regular Sunday morning breakfast now!! read more

Bagels are always really good here ! Im obsessed. Their pumpkin cream cheese is to die for!!! And the pumpkin spice bagels are so good. Best bagel place in the south toms river area :) read more

Place started out to be good but they messed up 3 orders of mine and foolish me went back a 4th time and messed up another order, every order that was wrong I paid for something that I didn't receive. If you go there make sure you check order before you leave, as for me I will never go back there again. read more

The person taking the order on the phone was completely inept. We were placing a large order for our entire office and planned on picking this order up before they closed. Upon arrival, BEFORE CLOSING TIME, I pulled my car up in front of the store front and the lights were off, the closed sign was facing out, the door was locked, etc. I knocked to no avail. As I was driving back to the office, I get a call from a coworker stating that they are waiting for us and to come up and knock on the door even though they are closed!! I already did this !!!! And had already driven back 10 of the 15 minutes back to work. Why are they closing before they told me they would be!! Waste of time. read more

Spent all summer living in Toms River and of course I needed a kick-butt bagel place! All Star Bagels has been my saving grace. Incredible bagels, good coffee, perfect portions on their sandwiches, and everyone is so sweet and friendly! Thank you All Star Bagel! read more