My family has been going to Teddy's for years, starting with my Grandfather who always used to disappear once a week on a Saturday afternoon. We found out later that he was sneaking Fried Liver and Onions dinners.
I've been to Teddy's nearly 20 times in the last 7 years, going over 15 times between 2012 and 2013.
Teddy's menu is very strong in 2 areas and it really forms the foundation of what their restaurant is built on. As the name suggests, the first area is deli. I've tried the smoked meat sandwich, the roast beef, and the turkey, and each one is great. The meat quality is really good as I do believe they do their own in house smoking and roasting. The second area they are strong in is traditional western style family dinners. Roast Beef, Turkey, Meat Loaf, Salisbury Steak, and all the trimmings that come along with it are all 4-5 star worthy in their respected class of food.
The soups are also good and from what I understand, homemade (the soups change daily).
Items I have also tried frequently are the fillet of sole (sub par), The Garden of Eden Salad (awesome, although I do have have an issue that the House Dressing although homemade and delicious does contain MSG), The weekend special Salmon dinner with Spinach (a decent attempt but out of the element of what Teddy's is good at), Caesar salad (hard to get wrong, good), The liver and onions (great!), and the burgers (decent). The desserts are also great and homemade although limited in selection.
The portions of everything are quite sizable and are definitely great value. The speed of service is top of its class and is something to be recognized for. The waitresses are good at what they do and must serve multiple dozens of customers each day, the restaurant functions like a well tuned operation when you go during a rush. On a Friday or Saturday dinner, The wait is usually about 15 to 30 minutes, and frequently comes out the front door.
Teddy's does not serve alcohol and tries to maintain a family oriented atmosphere. Being friends with 2 of the waitresses before they started working there, I have come to understand that the majority of customers are loyalists and are usually 40-50+.
I want to reiterate. Teddy's is nothing fancy, and nothing innovative, nor should it be. It is just good old home cooked style food like grandma used to make, and the fact that they stick to that and do it so well is what makes them a great place to dine at. read more