First, let me say that I clearly see why there are mixed reviews of this café here on Yelp, as I have mixed feelings about our dinning experience as well. Our first impression of this café was the trash that was piled up outside the front door. I just assumed that it was part of the morning cleaning routine until I overheard a regular customer comment that it had been there since the day before. Upon entering, it was apparent that cleanliness was not their highest priority. It certainly wasn't "filthy," but it could stand a good cleaning. That being said, everything else was very good. The food was delicious, the coffee was hot and very good, and no complaints about the service at all even though there was only one young man running the dining room. The prices were very reasonable as well. Unfortunately, they let slip the cleanliness aspect of their establishment. No complaints otherwise. read more

See all

Tasty Cafe is a very nice quaint restaurant. Excellent breakfast and lunch and dinner menu! Friendly staff and servants. A solid dining experience! read more

We ordered takeout and they seemed extremely busy when we picked it up. The food wasn't the best, however, we said maybe it would be better if we ate inside next time, especially for breakfast foods, not their fault! It looks like a very cute cafe and we have heard great things about it! Hoping to try it out again with a dine-in experience next time. read more

We typically like to eat at a locally run restaurant versus the usual chain. We stopped in on a Sunday afternoon on our way back from Springfield. The first red flag as others have noted was the cleanliness was not their top priority. It was not filthy but could have used a good cleaning. The overwhelming scent from the plug in air freshener also had me wondering what smells they were trying to cover up. The dining area was being run by a younger person but it wasn't busy so we had no concerns there. When I went to the rest room to wash my hands I noticed that the faucet did not have hot water, another strike. I ordered a club sandwich with the soup of the day, my wife ordered chicken stir fry. The soup came out right away and was good, no complaints there. It took a bit to get our meal but it finally came out. The sandwich was "okay" nothing that couldn't be made at home but it tasted off. The wife's chicken stir fry didn't look like any stir fry I had seen. It was soupy and greasy looking. I asked her if it was okay and she just replied she was picking out the chicken. While both of us had these concerns the server never came back to check on us. Finally he noticed we were finished and gave us a ticket. The price for slightly disappointing food was reasonable, unfortunately the person at the cash register could not make change and we waited even longer while two people figured out our change. I get this is a dinner not a steakhouse but regardless you should have a clean restaurant, second your staff should know how to greet, check up on and give exact change from their patrons and last, while the food was not horrible, something made both of us sick. I'm sorry but I would not recommend this establishment. read more

My family eats here a few times a month. I have NEVER had a meal that wasn't good. Service is good and prices are very reasonable. One of the things I like the most is their varied menu. Breakfast choices are wonderful and I especially like their coffee. My granddaughters are all about the burgers and chicken strips. So glad to have a great dinner in Sherman!! read more

Wonderful owners! Food is good and their recommendations are always good! Right in the area of Lincoln's Home.

1st time under this name at this location. During ordering the waitress was unfamiliar with the menu and we had to point out what we were ordering. Ordered potatoes and bacon crispy. Potatoes were barely brown. Bacon was barely crisp. GFs order for fruit pancakes came as crepes. Waitress asked if we needed more coffee and answered yes, then walked past our table 3 times wandering before we got coffee. Food taste was mediocre at best. read more

Service was great. I liked the staff a lot, and our server was friendly. They suggested the buffet, which was fine because it was quick and well priced. Food was just okay. If you love meat, though, it would be great. I do think the fried chicken would be good with waffles as it was kind of sweet. read more

Food is nasty asf but good customer service 10/10 food is a good -1/10 slap some seasoning on it so if you come here bring your own seasoning and the apple pie was cold asf never been to a diner that doesn't have warm apple pie like throw that boy in the microwave read more

Tasty Cafe - Walleye French Fries and apple pie - Cafes Near Me - Sherman, Illinois

Just stopped for lunch while traveling on I55 and found this to be delightful. I was so surprised that there were so many menu items, daily specials, senior specials, kiss's menu. Staff were friendly, facility clean, food quite good. What more can one hope for? Oh, I forgot to mention that the prices were reasonable too. I'd go back! read more

Tasty Cafe is one of our breakfast group's regular haunts. They have a wonderfully charming waitstaff whom take thoughtful care of their regulars and new patrons alike. The breakfast selections are diverse and from all reports universally delicious. The coffee flows and the food arrives hot and fast. It is a top notch breakfast spot for anyone in the area. We visit at least once a month as a group of four to six and always walk away satisfied and happy with our decision. read more

The food was good! Fast friendly service. Clean restaurant! And the prices were very reasonable! Great experience!

Great place clean good food and very friendly Very good Menü have not had a bad experience yet and have been here many times read more

Their hours have changed 6 am - 9 pm. I have informed them they need to change on Yelp. Have a large menu. Broasted chicken is excellent 4 pieces w 2 sides for $9.99! Breakfast anytime! read more

Great food, great service, and even better prices!!! Friendly family atmosphere as well in a quiet area of Sherman.

Always greeted by friendly staff. Food has always been very good for us. I would recommend Tasty Café for anybody driving through Sherman.

I SAW NO WET FLOOR SIGN. The food was fine. I saw a hair but it maybe could've been mine .But it was a whole different color of my hair. Their service was awful considering we were like the only people there. Back to the no wet floor sign. I was walking, I didn't see that there was water on the ground. The workers just laughed it off. I had no severe injuries, but I still hurt. read more

The best fried chicken dinner I have ever had! Amazing homemade pie and a huge ice cream selection. Everyone is so friendly. The food was out quick and sooooo good! Very fairly priced. We bring a large group every Saturday morning and it is always a great time. I usually eat here more than once a week! read more

Tasty Cafe - Strawberry and Balsamic Salad with homemade dressing! - Cafes Near Me - Sherman, Illinois

When we first moved here about a year ago, we went here for breakfast and I wasn't impressed with the service or the food. Tried it again today to give it another chance and the customer service wasn't very good. It wasn't very busy and our waitress barely came to check up on us, the coffee was Luke warm, and then when she brought us our food it was cold to the touch, she was missing half the order and had to go back to the kitchen and have them make the food she forgot. Once again, I was very unimpressed. read more

Good food great people awesome service awesome prices try the Chicago style omelettes you can't go wrong

Well prepared comfort food with a very nice and competent staff it's a great place to bring a friend or family member living at Villa next door- they get a discount. read more

This was a delightful find! Food was great, toast so crispy and eggs and hash browns cooked like I wanted. The prices are super, as well as the staff. If we get back this we'll definitely eat here again. They also brew real ice tea! read more

Beware food could contain pieces of wire. After ordering broccoli and then taking the first bite there was something in the broccoli. After spitting it out on a napkin the was something unusual, it was a piece of wire about 1 inch long with an extremely small diameter. I waved the chef over and showed him, he seemed unconcerned. I showed the waiter and he seemed less concerned. I find this very disturbing. read more

We have eaten for breakfast and supper and both excellent! Highly recommend it!

This is a gem in Sherman. Nice breakfast with specials. Service was impeccable with staff and owner going table to table. My family enjoyed the breakfast show while I had the scrambled, sausage, and pancakes. read more

This is another of those "best kept secrets". My wife and I stopped in on Saturday evening for dinner and were very pleased with the entire event. Very good service. Clean surroundings. Full menu and just plain good food at a reasonable price. I ordered spaghetti with meat balls and a cup of beef noodle soup and wife had broiled chicken breast with two sides. I expected at least a 15 minute wait since they were fairly busy; at least a dozen other patrons were in the restaurant. But the soup was delivered in just a few minutes and the rest of our meal less than 10 minutes wait. We'll be back. read more

This place is so cute and quaint! The staff is amazing here very attentive and the food was really good. You can tell it's family owned and operated. Make sure to check this place out you won't be disappointed. read more

Wow what a great little place. The food was great, the server was polite and the place very clean and you can't beat the price. Sorry I've driven by it so many times on my way to someplace else. Will be back!!! Highly recommend. read more

We have ordered take out several times in the last month. We've tried different sandwhiches, burgers and salads. We've also had pie! Food is always ready quickly and packaged nicely. Their menu is big and everything we've had has been excellent! Best kept secret in Sherman! read more

Great breakfast, friendly service and excellent prices. Coffee cup never got close to empty until we were ready to leave. Highly recommend.

Was a great little place that we stopped for breakfast on our way down 55. Would stop again for good diner food and nice services. Not far off the highway but tucked back a bit. Don't worry your not going the wrong direction! I loved that we stopped here and found a good breakfast. read more

Perfect stop off I-55! Great food and great prices! Service was excellent! We had breakfast for 5, two kids meals and 3 adults for $32! Would recommend! read more

GREAT food. EXCELLENT service. Great and interactive staff and owner. Newly renovated and clean overall nice place for breakfast and lunch with lots of smiles read more