This is a good place for a light lunch. Sandwiches come with chips, no fries. (I personally prefer…read morefries!) I ended up with the quiche and salad. That was plenty for me. I added a refreshing strawberry lemonade though I preferred his choice of mango. I looked on the label and it said the lemonades were made in New Jersey. I enjoyed the names of the items on the menu. The bathrooms are located upstairs. Unfortunately, I don't believe it's accessible for anyone who can't make it up the stairs.

Solid lunch spot when you're in this remote town of Bennington. Good variety of sandwiches…read more Traveled for work and needed lunch. Co-workers recommended Belly's Deli. Small town, so make sure you have time... bc it gets busy during lunch. If you're ordering takeaway - call ahead. If you're eating in - give yourself 1.5hrs to enjoy the meal. They have an upstairs where you have a nice view of the public stage (guessing when they have performances). The staff are very nice people, it's very homely... like the rest of the town. I got myself the Commander-In-Chief (pastrami & coleslaw + pickles), it was delish. Got a ginger ale - it's a Foxon brand! I love that CT brand soda. One happy diner. Coworker had their egg salad special and she enjoyed it very much. I went back the next day to pick up the same sandwich for on the road in the Amtrak home.

Worst experience in Bennington! Do not patron if you enjoy…read moreany level of hospitality & actual value. I came in cheerful & this guy ruined the day... I ended up leaving angry and literally cried.... Their online ordering has a Reuben with an option for $2 extra meat & a note box so I cld have written there asking for the extra portion on the side. EASY. Yet, I went in person to see what the specials were hoping for a great lunch, because Im here for medical procedures at the hospital and had fasted since the day before. Id never been to The Elm Street Market before, but it was close to the hospital, & love Vermont markets for all the years I have lived here. But THIS place :: T E R R I B L E mistake! The employee at the counter was as fake & uncaring as it gets, & shld definitely not be the customer guy. He would not just let the added side be $2 , but wanted to weigh it out & charge me for a deli style $6 sliced side in a package as an addition to the $14 sandwich. ($20 Reuben?!) I said I didn't need or expect a package of sliced cold meat, that I was just adding the side portion to share with my pups. For Lunch. He just becomes patronizing, dense, & fully lacking capacity or willingness to help and says he "can't bc it just doesn't work that way" unless I get it on the sandwich. I cld order it online but not with him at register. And for some reason he cant figure out a $2 portion of meat. Surreal Incompetence. The next level of downhill not-so-fun is seeing the tiny soup. A cup of soup for $8. A latte "special" that I cld not even taste the smoked maple flavor and was only 3/4 full. It's actually shocking- what happened to actually CARING about just helping ppl have a good experience if you are working in the restaurant business as a small local independent market? Hey Elm Street Market Fella, you cld do the simplest things like not try ripping ppl off & being kind! His patronizing attitude & lack of capacity really took it over the top- how am I supposed to enjoy this $36 ordeal? Supposedly he is refunding the meat, bc I explained I didn't order a package of meat. He took it out of bag & literally said "take your sandwich & drink & go". I was upset~ I said this is truly unacceptable ~ try some Kindness & Authenticity! And left. The other young lady who was working that day & witnessed this whole debacle seemed to feel bad making 'Im So Sorry' faces. She at least offered me a dollop of maple syrup & noted the drink was not filled~ but also was being oppressed by his attitude. I cld tell he was being an overbearing tyrant. Wtf - this is NOT Vermont as it should be DUDE. All it took was putting a few slices on the side for $2 & filling up a drink. Ridiculous.

Awesome service even better food. They have a nice porch to eat on and picnic tables in the back…read more Def recommend !

Great store for sandwiches, preserves, deli, etc. Staff were courteous. Locals favorite place to…read moreshop for essentials.

This is a hidden gem. My family comes here all the time and I finally went with them and it's the…read moreperfect place for a sandwich or just to shop around the market. The build your own sandwich is the best deal going. Like $9 and it's perfect. Highly recommend giving it a shot if you've never been because I'll be going back.

Sooooooo, visiting a friend in VT and while they were at work needed food....we are both from…read morePhilly and they suggested I try the cheesesteak. I protested because who can do cheesesteak better than Philly?!?! Well, this place was indeed good (not Philadelphia level) but for Vermont, it was excellent. The meat was not salty and seasoned well, the onions well done just like I like them. My only complaint would be that they did not toast the bread (so lacking that crunch) and it was not cheesy enough. But it was a good size and I still have half for lunch tomorrow. The mozzarella sticks were delicious!! Well done and crunchy and gooey. Loves them. Great service. The attendant was very nice and welcoming. It's pretty big inside with enough seating (had benches). Definitely worth the stop and will return.

It was an okay cheese steak.. Bun not toasted rolls were…read morevery soft and preservative laden. We had the one with provolone, cheese wiz, mushrooms, onions, and steak. I wouldn't call it Philly... I've had better at Greek owned New England pizza shops. It will fill the void if you need a gut bomb, probably more fresh and healthy than most of McDonald's menu

Another win for Me in Vermont!!! Yummy food! Sweet and…read moreefficient staff!! Easy atmosphere with familiar music is just what I needed on my grumpy ( not common) weekend! I had some really Yum burger with bacon, onions, on a gluten free bun!! I got the chips with a side of slaw, cause veggies!! All good! I'm working a gig with youth this semester so I'm abstaining from alcohol: The Athletic Mexican is delish! Check it out, you won't be disappointed!!

Wanted to enjoy this place. However left with amazement, disappointment and utter lack of…read moreprofessionalism. Start with the food it was ok. Nothing wow or great just ok. Flavor on the food was just lacking. Even the Vermont cheddar cheese was bland and only a whisper of sharpness. The home made chips good but lacked anything special. The true problem of this place is the ownership/management. We went there little after it opened. To see a table with a 5 gallon bucket of utensils and servers doing their side work on a table you have to walk past to get to anywhere in the seating area. Then we come to the management/owner. My biggest pet peeve is doing the books or daily paperwork in the guest area. You have an office or a place away from your guests. Not in full view and with in ear shot of your guests. And not in a place where sound carries. The BIGGEST complaint is the language. You are the leader of your staff. You set an example for the behavior and attitude of your staff. Dropping F-BOMBS and other vulgar language is not at anytime acceptable. Clearly the servers knew it and didn't thankfully follow your lead. This is NOT your buddies garage or basement. You are having people come in and hearing your language and seeing and clearly hearing your behavior I can not recommend going here. If it was based on food maybe. But clearly the ownership and leadership will keep me away from here. Such potential wasted by such poor work ethics.

This little store is a gem! We were staying at an Airbnb in the area and wanted to order dinner…read moreout but not just fast food style like pizza or burritos. We couldn't seem to find what we were looking and tried this market as a last resort. It was a great decision. They had many fresh, premade, heat and eat meals. We got shrimp scampi and a Greek salad. It was very filling and delicious. They also have a lot of fresh meat packages and other premade food. It was a great find. I wish we had something like it at home!

I live in western NY and travel for business to NE region regularly. I always stop at Henry's when…read moretraveling home if I'm in the area. The meat selection is great Vermont beef.. The staff is friendly. A wide selection of cheeses and meats. It's a small shop and usually has a small line for lunch subs and sandwiches for takeout. It's a small deli so don't expect a place to eat inside. Lot's of good food to select from.

This place was cute and lots of fun to visit. Filled with mostly local products. Had an excellent…read moreselection of coffee beans (and grinder available), wines, cheeses, and baked goods. Everything we tried from there was Vermont fresh! Wish we had something like this near home.

Once again, the kitchen is closed. I keep giving the market a chance but it continues to disappoint.read more

This is a pizza "parlor" serving scrumptious pizza on an airy, crispy crust along with salads,…read morepasta, calzones and bagel sandwiches. Counter service inside with takeout and deliver options. Visiting Bennington for the first time. While this isn't your standard NY style, I really enjoyed the crispy and airy crust. Sauce is a straightforward, basic tomato sauce, but toppings are of good quality and tasty. What we ordered: - small Greek salad w/ creamy Greek dressing: (4) Quite tasty. The feta made the salad. I wish the olives were pitted. I didn't realize they weren't until I bit into one. Oops. - 10" cheese: (4) pretty simple pizza. The misses liked it and she is a fan of simple cheese pizzas. - 10" the whole shebang (4.25): I am a fan of the crust and the toppings were perfect. Could have split this, but me and the misses like different pizzas. Some seating inside and a lot of outdoor seating when the weather cooperates. Ambiance gave us the pizza parlor vibe.

Our go-to pizza place in Bennington…read more... Huge fan of the calzones here - buffalo chicken is phenomenal, also love their sausage and pepperoni calzone! The pizza and wings are also great, and the bagels make for a nice breakfast. Sitting outside on the porch there is beautiful. Was happy to see that the inside seating was available again last year, too! Would love to be able to enjoy a nice cold beer while waiting for food, but they don't serve alcohol. The food is good enough, however, that we will sit at the pizza place (whose food is not as good...) across the street and have a beer while waiting for food from Benner's if we haven't ordered ahead. The wait times can be long (maybe an hour) on busy nights, like Friday, for pick-ups; but most places are (it's not fast food...). They are always pretty accurate with timing estimates when we call and order so we plan accordingly. I've rarely had to wait beyond the amount of time indicated when going to pick up the food. I've never had an issue with the food or how it was cooked (except when I've ordered a half-only-cheese, half-six-different-toppings pizza - there is literally no way to make sure that is cooked evenly, lesson learned). Typically have had good experiences with the staff. There have been a few interactions that were a little off-putting, but nothing that would deter me from coming back. I've seen myself on a bad day at work - it happens.

The service was fast and friendly. The sandwich was fantastic. Good quality meat and breadread more

Best subs in town. Nowhere else is even close. Owner and staff are great people. Call ahead to…read morecheck wait time if you are ordering late afternoon/evening during late spring, summer, early fall. No need to call ahead Monday-Wednesday unless it's a holiday. TIPS: Don't be confused by the name. The gas pumps were removed years ago. It's a convenience store/deli now, not a gas station. Lock all your vehicle doors and make sure all windows are rolled up. (This goes for anywhere in Bennington.) Don't be put off by this advice. Their food is awesome!

In Bennington randomly for a doctor's appointment with my son. Reached for Yelp to guide us for a…read morebrunch-time sandwich - this led us here. Outside looked like a furniture/nicknack store. Typical "I love VT" t shirts and stuffies in the window, $400 syrup, and artsy cards and candles etc. Making our way to the back was a small nook of seats and tables and a breakfast/sandwich/bagel menu. To say we were skeptical was an understatement. My son ordered a Southwestern steak and egg sandwich on a rainbow bagel. I had a dill pickle chicken salad sandwich on an everything bagel. Add in a coffee, a hot chocolate, two cans of Diet Coke (and a small cheesecake round for my son) and we were all set. Menu was way more reasonably priced than we expected. Average bagel sandwich (which they fill amply) was roughly $10. All of the fillings were very good. Well seasoned. Creative. Again, exceeded our initial expectations. Even the bagels were surprisingly good. Please note I grew up in NJ so a bagel is essentially unattainable to me north of the Tappanzee Bridge. I was expecting "airport quality," however, it was not half bad. Chewy and tasty for the area. Service left me with two very distinct feelings. 1) the people were AWESOME. Friendly, attentive, seemingly happy to be at work (a rarity). But... 2) there were 6 total customers in the store (some simply reading books) and yet it took 16 minutes for our coffee and hot chocolate and roughly 30 for the sandwiches. Was so weird to experience the quiet of the store - yet the ticket time and wait of a bustling morning at a deli. Oh well. Was a pleasant place to be. Will likely find a different place next week following our upcoming appointment. But was not mad at the experience.

Stopped here for breakfast to go. got the bagel with lox and caesar salad wrap both were good. the…read morebagel was chewy has decent amount of lox. The staff were nice. The place was big. Merchandise in front and the cafe in the back. I do recommend this place. Sorry i forgot to take pictures.