I've been to the main restaurant and thought it was ok so I decided to try the new location yesterday because they have a drive thru.
I ordered the #2 Hatch Valley combo plate and it wasn't what I was expecting. It came with a cheese enchilada (I had it with green chile), a taquito, a ground beef taco, chile con carne, rice, and beans. The enchilada was on the smaller side and didn't have a lot of cheese. It was also drowning in the green chile sauce. The beef in the taco was really soggy and might have been undercooked. It didn't taste bad, but the meat was still pinkish-grey. On the other hand, the meat in the taquito was charred and overcooked. The chile con carne was alright. It was a lot of food but the $16 price was a bit much for the quality I received. The staff didn't include any utensils so I had to use my own at home.
I also got a chile relleno burrito for later and it was really disappointing. It was a hefty burrito but when I cut into it, I found out that it was mostly beans and cheese with two small chile. The stringy stems were still attached to the chile which was annoying because I had to cut them off. I wouldn't order this again, especially for the $9 price.
My order came with a handful of tortilla chips (literally - there wasn't a lot), green and red salsa, some mashed up beans, and cream sauce. I'm not certain, but I think the staff gave my order to some other customer by mistake. I was waiting at the drive thru window when I saw someone carrying a big plastic to-go bag enter through a side door into the restaurant. The contents of the bag had a packaged plate, packaged bowl, and two paper bags. The guy at the drive thru window stepped away for a moment and then handed me an identical bag with identical contents to what I just saw the other person bring into the restaurant.
A lot of people rave about Si Senor, but I don't think their food is anything extraordinary. This location opened relatively recently and I might come back again if they improve.
Also - I don't know what the issue is, but you can't order online from this location despite the website and posted notices at the restaurant saying you can. Every time I tried, the online service platform (Clover) says "Si Senor Sonoma is not accepting online orders right now." It doesn't matter the time of day or day of the week. read more