Stopped by for the first time and was not disappointed.Pizza had great thin crust and service was excellent.Restaurant has a great variety of pizzas many options not usually available will definitely return to try other pizzas many! read more

Just arrived into Sandwich for two week stay. We needed to order out. Two large pizzas, one small gluten free, two greek salads...$95. All of the items were wrong, absolute bs. We waited an 1.5 hrs. They asked for our name 5 times. Clearly don't let teenagers run your business. Now they won't pick up phone. Stay away! read more

Pizza was YUMMY! Came here solo and they are one of the few open later LOL. Service was great. The people working seem super nice. Pizza is made to order so takes around 15 minutes but you can order. Tomatoes are so yummy on the pizza. They had 80s music playing on the tv. Great vibes!!! read more

See all

Do yourself a favor and drive by -Food is gross. I've eaten pizza in gas stations, airports, school cafeterias, and tiny hole-in-the-wall shops--and somehow this was the worst pizza experience of my life. From the first bite, it was clear that quality and customer service are not priorities here. The pizza was disappointing, the order was handled poorly, and the staff's response made an already bad experience even worse. Instead of trying to make things right, they acted as though customer satisfaction didn't matter. It's rare for a restaurant to make me say I'd never come back, but this one accomplished that with ease. Save yourself the money, the frustration, and the wasted meal. There are far too many excellent pizza places to settle for one that leaves you regretting every dollar you spent. One star is generous only because zero isn't an option. read more

Delicious pie here on the Cape! Good thin crust. Big slices for our big family. :) Sauce is very good. The cheese pizza has some chopped sweet tomatoes which I am going to speculate works well with the name. :)) We picked ours up, so I can't speak to the ambiance. The service was on point. Good times here on the Cape! You can trust me, we are big eaters wherever we are. ;D read more

What a horrible business owner. Never set foot in this establishment. Flag upside down 4th of July week. RETARD commie!

I've been getting Sweet Tomatoes pizza for a couple of years now and my family and I have really loved them. Today, however, was just the opposite. The pizza was terrible. We ordered the meat lovers pizza and it seemed to only have pepperoni and a little bit of sausage. Other parts of the pizza seemed to only be dough. Terrible. Parts of the Hawaiian pizza only seemed to be dough as well. My son in law picked up the pizzas and he said he only saw one person working and another person came out of the restroom to help right when he was leaving. Now I won't hesitate to try other pizza restaurants in the area. It's sad because I always raved about Sweet Tomatoes pizza. read more

See all

So disappointed.. Just picked up a large margarita pizza and it was awful my family has been getting that for years and it always had fresh slices of tomatoes and mozzarella , today nothing but dry over cooked diced tomatoes , no fresh cheese , and the manger told me they always made it like that one i got today ..if that was the case I wouldn't have gone there for the last 5 years . Also the manager refused to give her name .. Looking for a new pizza place in Sandwich.. read more

You know how to do Pizza! Loved your pepperoni pizza! Crispy, thin crust and sauce not overwhelming either! Great spot in Sandwich MA to grab a slice or whole pizza to serve your crew. Call ahead to pick up and eat at home is my favorite way to enjoy this pizza! read more

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

See all

I was working in the area and after work i decided to stop and eat something before heading back home to springfield ma. Im glad i did stop here at this place, i order a large pepperoni pie and the lady started making it. The pizza was thin the slices were big, the cheese and the sauce was delicious with a few tomatoes chunks. I took a few slices back home and later that night my wife pre heated them and she even made a comment of how good the pizza was. The only thing i would have change was the pizza had no crust but thats not a deal breaker for me here since the pizza was that good. If you in the area and looking for a good pie try this place. Next time im back there i will deff hit this place again and maybe buy an extra pie to take home ( the pizza here in Springfield Ma is trash i lost hope out here) read more

See all

Should be called garlicky tomatoes. The most flavorful and sweet garlic pizza sauce. Delicious thin crust. Very good cheese. Can't complain at all, it's great pizza. read more

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza - Half cheese Half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

Stopped in with friends from the area per their recommendation for dinner while we were visiting. We were not let down. Complete NY/NJ pizzeria vibe with casual dining at high tables. We purchased two specialty pizzas and two large salads (caesar and garden). All was delicious and made with fresh ingredients. Restaurant was clean, organized, and staff were all busy. Pizza crust is the thin style but nice and chewy rather than brittle. Service was counter- based and prompt. Easy on and off road with ample parking. Solid value for money. Highly recommend for a casual dinner or take out while on the cape. read more

Thin crust is delicious. Could have been cooked a little longer for a crispier under carriage. We had a cheese and a veggie with zucchini's. Both were flavorful and the sauce was not acidic. We ordered by phone do not dine in. But have dined before and it's a simple ambiance with no bells and whistles. Our order was ready at the time as told on the phone. read more

Damn good pizza. Excellent crust and delectable toppings. If you are a fan of thin and crispy, look no further. read more

Discovered this place during the start of the pandemic. We have tried many pizza places and can't believe we had not tried this place earlier. If you like nice thin crust with some crisp to it this is the place. We got the light cheese extra mushrooms and a Margarita. Such good flavor !!! The Drive through was a huge plus too. read more

See all

Sweet Tomatoes is the best pizza this end of the Cape. The pizza is consistently great and we love the thinner crust. Lots of interesting combo pizzas to choose from on their menu and different toppings. Whenever asked we always recommend Sweet Tomatoes! read more

Large delicious pizzas with fresh toppings and sweet tomato sauce! Grab one to take to Treehouse brewing ;)

Ughhh this pizza is not pizza for anyone not from Massachusetts perhaps. We ordered from here for pickup on July 4th, and while I appreciate that they were open on a holiday serving up the pies, the pizza was pretty awful. It isn't sauced instead there are just chunks of tomatoes under the very thin layer of cheese. read more

Pizza was ok/almost good. We ordered 6 pies en route to a Cape League baseball game and the time given on the phone was fairly ambiguous. My mother in law and I walk in after a bit and were told in a pretty bitchy tone we were 20 mins early, when we were there probably 5 mins after the approximated time given on the phone. Amaris next time. read more

I am so glad I found this place. I found 2 other pizza places in Sandwich that do not compare, but if you want really good pizza, please come here. We got the margarita pizza to go, which is to die for!!! Reasonable prices and fast service. The only thing is that we had a little trouble finding it. read more

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza - a pepperoni and spinach pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

A+ pizza!!! Amazing crust, fresh ingredients, lots of flavor. I am always looking for GOOD pizza and thiz hit the spot. Would definitely recommend read more

Love Sweet tomatoes cheese pizza! Crust is thin and crispy and tomato sauce chunky and fresh. Definitely my favorite local pizza spot!

Very expensive, great dough, maybe the best on the Cape, but the pizza had very little sauce or cheese. Could be a great pizza with a little more product on top. read more

SO glad i gave this place try. it is truly delicious. I went with a friend. We shared a chicken bacon ranch. i am addicted to this pizza. it is very unique. really enjoyed it. read more

Excellent taste beautiful with chunks of tomato's and wonderful spiced. Thin crust I just wish a little crispier, I like a stiff crust. I hate a limp crust. read more

See all

My dad loves this place I'm in town from New Hampshire called up and asked for a delay on the making of the pizza because we were a bit away and what do you know! Devin did a great job. When we got there the pizza was piping HOT, we even were able to get a couple of beers right at the drive up window and go sit down by the water, enjoy a hot pizza and a cold beer. What a place! read more

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza - Hot and Gooey when we arrived!! Thanks Deven - Pizza Near Me - Sandwich, Massachusetts

See all

Pizza was amazing. You won't be disappointed. Now just getting to 85 so it will post.

I am so happy I discovered Sweet Tomatoes. I thought it was a sister restaurant to Tomatoes. It's almost the best pizza I've ever had. I particularly like the Truffle Pizza. The service is excellent. Keep up the good work!!! read more

Our favorite pizza on the Cape!! Everything is fresh and delicious, it's thin crust and perfectly wood-fired. Only request would be that they add more salads/side options but I wouldn't drop a star over it. The staff is also friendly and it's nice they have a drive-through pizza window - makes it so easy to pick up with a packed car of kiddos! Highly recommend. read more

Delicious!! Great thin pizza with the perfect crust and sauce. One of the best pizzas around!

We love, sweet tomatoes. Especially that you can get slices at lunch. I love the thin crust.

Grabbed a pizza for me and the family today, Nothing to special when it comes to this pizza we found it rather bland. Told us to pick it up in 30 mins and we arrived 35 mins later to find we had to wait in the parking lot for a extra 15 mins.I'd not really recommend it although drive through is cool read more

They have Drive Through in Sandwich! Perfect during this time. I got the White Greek, but I had them add red sauce. So yummy, one of the best pizza I have had. I love the crunchy thin crust. I had it about a week ago and thinking of going back. Very friendly, ready as promised. Please support this quality establishment. read more

Great pizza and food. Not so good as to warrant price. 70 dollars for two pizzas and a chaser salad. Those are primium prime rib restaurant prices read more

The pizza is always good. Great sizes and plenty of toppings. It is unfortunate to have to wait 45 minutes for a pizza that was luke warm.

We ordered a large pepperoni and the folks ended up making an odd oblong pizza so it ended up in two boxes. The sauce they use isn't so heavily stewed that the acid is crazy high. I have to be careful with red sauces because of gerd. This place was great. read more

Lonnnnnnnnnnng wait for take out and RUDE phone manners. Worst of all was the pizza that appeared to have been physically abused by a level 3 pizza offender. I called in my order and when I was done the young woman just hung up without reviewing the order, asking my name or telling me how much it would be. I immediately called back and asked her why she just hung up and that I didn't know what to do with that. No apology. She repeated my order as though I was a nuisance for calling back to be sure we were on the same page. Apparently they don't know how to be polite or thank their customers. The pizza looked like a recent abortion. Look at the pictures and you be the judge. I just wish I had looked at it prior to leaving. My mistake. Don't let it be yours. read more

See all

Recently bought a house in Sandwich and decided to give Sweet Tomatoes a try. I've been back like 10 times in the past couple of months! This place has the most amazing thin crust pizza! So tasty. I do prefer the pizzas here with fewer toppings as they tend to not get "soggy", not a bad soggy but I like my slices a bit firmer with no flop. So pizzas with more items taste great, but pizzas with a couple of toppings are superb! Anyway, highly highly recommended!!! read more

Best pizza I've had in Massachusetts. Thin-crust New York style. Not greasy and full of flavor. The kind of pizza you'd expect to get in Little Italy. Skip the chains and other small pizza restaurants around this area. Especially that disgusting place Graziella's. Go here instead. read more

I am from Queens N.Y. if you want New York style Crust brick oven pizza fresh seasoning, no grease like you get on Greek Pizza, this is only place on the Cape, excellent place. Only place in Sandwich.... The Sandwich Gourmet should visit this place. Great flop, thin, brick Oven excellently seasoned. You get what you pay for, and you get it at Sweet Tomatoes, my only go to pizzeria. The other places don't sell real Italian Style Pizza. Danny read more