Janet was a pleasure to work with, quick at responding, and created a beautiful birthday cake for…read moremy fiancé that left tasted equally as amazing as it looked! Our friends and family all devoured the cake and couldn't stop talking about how delicious it was! I highly recommend this cake shop to anyone who needs a cake for a special occasion.

Just the perfect amount of sweetness!! Super tasty Janet…read moremakes the most amazing cakes

The service was great and prices are low and it's a cozy spot super friendly staff I will returnread more

Great friendly fast service shelling out the sweets. Love the convenience of the drive-thru and…read moreonly a short distance off hwy 37, a recommended detour from your road trip if you are looking for a classic sugar fix. Donuts sell out fast, but 30 min before close, we picked up a hot chocolate, hot carmel apple cider, a couple of ghost sugar cookies and a couple frosted brownies. The cute ghost shaped cookies were decent in size and only cost 60 cents each!! The brownies were on the small side but still only 75 cents and the soft chewy texture hit the spot.

i've been coming here for years and the baked goods are so good! love supporting a local shop, and…read morethe ambiance is nice too. the coffee is good as well, especially if you like it on the sweeter side (which i do!). only thing i haven't been a fan of is their bagel/egg sandwiches, which makes sense since they're the only thing to my knowledge that's not made in house. would recommend the brownies, muffins, quiches, and frappes for sure!

Chocolate chip cookies was undercooked, greasy, and had almost no chocolate in it. Really yucky…read more On the other hand, the cinnamon roll was classic pure goodness and great flavor. I really wanted to try the coffee cake cookie as I have never seen that cookie flavor, but one cookie was enough. They should list the prices on the items in their display case. The woman working at the counter was very nice - thank you for that. But if you can't make a decent chocolate chip cookie, stop offering them.

Around January of this year we met with Janie, planned our cake, and she seemed very nice so we…read moreleft a deposit and decided to go with her for our wedding cake. In April I emailed her to see when I could come by to give her decorations and her money for the cake; she never responded. So them about 3 weeks or so later I called her and left a voicemail, still no answer. A week or so later I decided to look up some reviews on her (I should of done this from the beginning I know), and most were negative. They said they had the same problems with her not returning their calls, and a couple people also said she messed up their cakes, and did not do at all the design they had discussed. Obviously, at this point we were very concerned. I gave her another week to return my phone call and email. She did not, so I left another message stating that we wanted our deposit back. Two weeks later when we were in her area (we live about an hour and a half away) I called her and she actually answered! When I explained that we wanted to go another route due to dependability, and I explained-very calmly and politely- all the times we tried to reach. She then got rude and snippy with me. She made bogus excuses, that anyone with a basic understanding of how voicemails work would of known were not true. She never once apologized, and just said the deposit was nonrefundable. I then explained why we felt it should be in this instance considering it was her fault why we were cancelling our order. She did agree to refund (very rudely) and said she would send it out on Monday, which would mean that we should receive it no later than Wednesday. It is now a week past when we should of received it, and no surprise, I've called twice and left a voicemail with no return. The reason we went to her in the first place was because she was on Spring Mill Inn's bender list, which we will be informing them of our problems as well. I have never seen a business owner act so unprofessionally. I would strongly advised to everyone that they save theirselves the headache and find someone else!

From the owner: I love creating cakes and cupcakes! I have been decorating cakes for family and friends for 34…read moreyears. With the love and support of my wonderful family and friends, I have a beautiful shop in my home. This allows me to have flexible hours for my customers. I love challenges so feel free to call or email me and we will see what we can create together

Their baked goods are the best! "Only 2 people in store at a…read moretime" policy is so strange to me though... slows the line so much... I asked them if it's a Covid thing, and they said it's because "it can get too loud," what?? I just want to take a minute to see what's available before I order, I won't make any noise!

If you enjoy waiting outside no matter the weather this is the bakery to visit, they only allow 2…read morecustomers in at a time which is ridiculous. The GF selection is average at best. And to cap it all of the parking situation is terrible.

I picked this provider because the reviews suggested that she was good and her pictures also showed…read morethat she has talent in unique cake designs at a very fair price. BUT Communication: I was having trouble getting information out of her and had to ask several questions to get an answer. Response time took forever and the responses were very short UNTIL I started to speak about payment then everything was fine. style: Don't get my wrong the cake was pretty close (the two stars) We had a Taco Bell themed party and the inspiration cake was fake Taco Bell packs and "sauce" which I assumed would be made out of JELLY. NO, she put actual taco bell packets (did tell me she had to use real ones) and actual Taco Bell sauce on our cake that dried and looked disgusting. The very front of the cake was messed up. I was going to try and fix it myself when I got home but I was afraid I would make it worse. The whole thing just felt sloppy. Taste: This cake was not good. The layers of actual cake was thick and dry and the "filling" was so thin. The icing was thick that almost everyone picked most of it off and there was so much left over. And don't get me started on the taco sauce and the taste of that . Overall, I was very disappointed and will be going somewhere else next time.

Very fast and great customer service!! The cake was amazing!! Very delicious and beautifully made…read more Definitely recommend

She and her staff do a great job with other things, cupcakes and cookies. Reasonably priced and…read moregreat service. The folks are very kind and professional dining room for about 15 people plenty of room to sit and talk and have a drink very kid friendly with toys in the dining room and the area is decorated very nicely. It is next to a coffee shop if you need coffee for your delicious muffin cookie or Roll.

Food is INCREDIBLE! The owner is so nice and service is always speedy, such a friendly atmosphere!read more

Ok, this one is a bit personal because I know the owner very well as she was a student of mine many…read moreyears ago. Having said that, she also knows I will be very honest in my review. So here we go.... This was my first time at The Mix. This is a fairly new establishment in Mitchell. It may have been opened for a year but not much longer. This place is going to be a smash hit! The building itself has been renovated and is very clean. The display is adequate to show off the baked goods made in the bakery. I got an oatmeal raisin cookie, a chocolate peanut butter cupcake, a cookie butter cupcake, a brownie, and a breakfast bar. I also got two lemonades but will take about them in a bit. I LOVE cupcakes. They are one of my weaknesses. The cupcakes were moist and scrumptious! The icing was sweet but not overbearing. Just the right amount of touch's of ingredients. The cookies were simply amazing! Large, soft, and chewy just like my great-grandma made. I have yet to eat the brownie. My wife says they are simply the best...and my wife loves brownies. The big surprise to my was my lemonade. I got a pineapple frozen lemonade. OMG...this was the bomb! Refreshing and just so good! The Mix will soon be a hot spot for tourists and visitors to the Mitchell area. If you are in the area stop by and say Hi to Sarah...Tell her Grissom sent you. You won't be disappointed in this place. Five stars and two thumbs up! I will be back with a follow up review on my next visit just to ensure things don't slip. But if I know Sarah like I think I do...this place will soar because it is her heart and soul in her products.

Holy amazing! Accidentally found this place on the way home from French Lick, and couldn't be…read morehappier! Delicious drinks and pastries, fantastic smoothie bowl, and some inclusive books for my 2 year old daughter to read! Loved it!