Cancel

Open app

Search

Bake Me A Cake Etc

4.6 (8 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Bake Me A Cake Etc Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Bake Me A Cake Etc

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Cake

Our cake looked amazing exactly what I wanted! She was very friendly and personable. Was always able to reach and stay in contact with her.

The beautiful rose like cupcakes/works of art Erinn created.
Aronne M.

Erinn at Bake Me a Cake was recommended to me while I was looking for someone to make cupcakes and a custom cake for a friend's baby shower. First of all, she's just really pleasant and likable. I will put up with arrogant jackasses when they're really talented if I have to, but Erinn comes across as that type of affable friendly that makes her seem like the kind of person you'd want to be stuck in an elevator with while you're having a panic attack. Or the stranger you'd trust to watch your belongings while you chased down your runaway pet. And then there is the actual product. I asked her for what I thought would be a semi-difficult layered cake (Erinn scoffed at the difficulty level) and cupcakes all with buttercream frosting. It's hard to go wrong with buttercream, it's basically the kind of deliciousness that you could take a bath in, but it's also a bit fragile in it's susceptibility to heat. No worries with Erinn's work. It held up like cathedral constructions. Even during my former Marine boyfriend's breakneck 'transpo,' which would send even seasoned combat veterans into white-knuckled alarm. Additionally, although I hadn't thought to give her particular instruction on decoration for the cupcakes, she turned them into beautiful rose-like works of art. The layered cake I thought would be so difficult, Erinn executed with perfection, even though I again had not given her much in the way of aesthetic specifics. I had asked Erinn to color the layers inside the cake to correspond with the colors of the flag of the country in which my friend and her husband were born. It was a little surprise for them and one of the things I am most happy I did for the shower. The colors were bright and beautiful and stood out so perfectly next to that delicious white buttercream. I couldn't have been happier and, most importantly, neither could the mom and dad to be. Bake Me a Cake is an excellent choice for your next event, big or small.

Absolutely LOVE the house warming cake that our coworker purchased for us when we moved into our new home!

See all

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Cake arrived as scheduled. Was packed carefully and securely. Cake was fresh and tasty.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Aronne M.
65
13
14

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Ordered a red velvet cake for my husband's birthday--it was wonderful. Can't recommend enough. Very reasonably priced and delicious!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Bake Me A Cake Etc

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Custom Cakes 106 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Sugar and Spice Bakery - Pumpkin bread, jasmine citrus tea latte

Sugar and Spice Bakery

3.0(23 reviews)
7.3 mi
•$

This is the IU bakery and coffee shop located in the Memorial Union building. Their baked goods can…read morealso be found at other campus cafes. The baked goods are awesome! The cookies and muffins and cinnamon roll just seem to melt in your mouth (I'm sure lots of butter is involved). They even have a very good vegan coffee cake! The drinks are not great and consistency is not the name of the game. Maybe the coffee is better than the tea, but the chai tastes more of sugar and cinnamon than tea, and the matcha was very murky, but maybe that's because I got the strawberry matcha and that affected the colour. It didn't taste bad but just didn't taste like quality matcha. They have decent teabags, but the brand and selection varies and is not what's listed on the menu board. They can do a tea latte but don't always have teas that work well with milk. I like the iced tea they make during the summer better than the hot tea. They sometimes have bubble tea, which is made with a machine and is decent (as far as artificially flavoured tea goes) but very sweet. It's a complete gamble as to whether or not the bubble tea machine will actually be on at any given time. I tried to get it in the evening once but was told they usually power it down around 6, so came back around 4:30 next time, but it was off again. I finally did manage to get bubble tea a few times around lunch time and in the morning, but there have also been days where they don't turn it on at all despite displaying the posters for it. Tapioca pearls are on the menu but they seemingly never have them, only the popping pearls. The baristas are students and are sometimes friendly, sometimes not. I would guess there's a combination of high turnover and poor training because some of them just seem very confused. They usually do okay at keeping the line moving though. I come for the baked goods, and just get a drink while I'm at it because I don't want to wait in another line at Starbucks even though I actually think Starbucks makes slightly better drinks.

Ordered two gingerbread cookies, and this is what we got. Pathetic. We will be looking elsewhere…read moreshould we want gingerbread cookies in the future.

Photos
Sugar and Spice Bakery
Sugar and Spice Bakery - Cream and crimson (strawberry) milk tea w/ strawberry popping boba

Cream and crimson (strawberry) milk tea w/ strawberry popping boba

Sugar and Spice Bakery - Pumpkin sugar cookie, modern earl grey tea

See all

Pumpkin sugar cookie, modern earl grey tea

Rainbow Bakery - Pistachio matcha muffin, chai

Rainbow Bakery

4.5(158 reviews)
7.0 mi
•$

Really liked it. I believe it's mostly, if not all, vegan. I know they were experimenting with some…read moreitems with dairy a while ago but I did not notice any non-vegan items while I was there, so not sure if that's still a thing. Anyway, it is a little out of the way. It's walkable from downtown but not really in the downtown core. Pretty quiet when I was there, but the atmosphere felt approachable. Some of the chairs were like school desk chairs (adult-sized, of course) that I haven't seen since I was in primary school which was kind of funny. The guy at the counter was cheerful and friendly. They looked like they had run out of some of the hot savory items by Saturday mid-afternoon, but there was still a wide variety of sweets. I believe the current owners are Indian, and you see some of those flavours featured. I got: Samosa handpie: Good, not mind-blowing, but good. Nice flavours. If you like a flaky crust, this is not it, but I liked the rustic pastry crust. Pistachio cardamom donut: Loved it. Before I moved to Bloomington, there were a few bakeries that offered vegan-GF cake donuts that I loved, and this was the first thing I've gotten here that reminded me of that. Pleasant texture and strong cardamom flavour, not too sweet. I think these are baked donuts, so they're a little different from regular fried donuts, but in a good way IMO. Rose dream latte: Milk with rose syrup topped with coconut whip and nuts, no espresso. Tasted great, but more of a dessert drink than I was expecting. The coconut whip was quite thick. The concept could probably use some refinement, because the whip was too thick and rigid to drink without a straw, but the nut pieces were too big to go through a straw, and so I couldn't figure out the best way to drink it. From what I understand, there are some longtime fans of this place who feel like the quality has dropped since the most recent change in ownership, but as someone who had never been here before, I really had a good experience. I get why people would be upset when something changes, but if you are considering trying this place for the first time, I wouldn't be too put off by the negativity around the change in ownership. There's no other place specialized in vegan baking in Bloomington, so I think it's good to support what they are continuing to do here, and even though I am partial to vegan food I wouldn't say that if it wasn't also GOOD. They also had some refreshingly unique options for baked goods.

Rainbow Bakery sits off of 4th street west of the IU campus. It's all vegan, and we had a chance to…read morestop by and get two donuts and a cookie. The inside is cute and whimsical. The owners, a Sikh family, gave us their cardamom donut for free. The samosa hand pies were out. I would rate it 4/5. The decor was nice, and the owners were friendly. We were told that the staff is limited, and the owners themselves are thinking of selling this location and hoping to restart it in Greenwood, where they currently live and actually drive down to Bloomington every day. The matcha latte was fine. Everything was fine but not great. The vegan chocolate chip cookie was good, but could've used more chocolate chips.

Photos
Rainbow Bakery
Rainbow Bakery - Samosa handpie, pistachio cardamom donut, rose dream latte

Samosa handpie, pistachio cardamom donut, rose dream latte

Rainbow Bakery - Custom order of gluten-free donuts... beet, chocolate sprinkles, and the Homer (my favorite)

See all

Custom order of gluten-free donuts... beet, chocolate sprinkles, and the Homer (my favorite)

Bake Me A Cake Etc - customcakes - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...