I can only speak for the cupcakes in my ratings, and I must admit they are very disappointing. They're dense, dry and just lacking anything worth paying almost $3 each. I will never purchase cupcakes from here again simply because I make them better and have purchased far superior tasting cupcakes for the same purchase amount from other bakeries. I find it extremely hard to believe that some people on yelp rates these as 5 stars. Have they never eaten a gourmet cupcake before? Judging by their glowing reviews, I would guess no chance.... Just skip the cupcakes, get froyo or stop at the grocery store and buy a cake mix... read more

I want to preface my review and say that we used to love Sweet Mutiny, but since the move- the changes made have left us disappointed. The froyo flavors are still great although when I went recently, the flavor I wanted wasn't really coming out. I asked the gal who was working there if it was gone or just not working.... her response was something like "eh it's just been doing that". So, fix it? Or help me? Or put a sign on it? Then we went over to the very limited and much smaller topping selection. My favorites weren't there- Oreos, Captain Crunch, or fresh fruit. Zero fresh fruit. Now, I understand that the fresh fruit probably expensive for your margins.... but instead of getting rid of it all together, you could sell it in cups for an extra 25 cents or so? That's my favorite part about froyo. They were also missing my husbands favorites- cookie dough and brownie bites. Last, we were disappointed that it's a flat fee now. I never fill my cup all the way, it's way too much for me. My husband gets much more than me but his cup when weighed never cost more than $5! I'm sure families refrain from going now that they have a flat fee of over $5 per person. Needless to say, we will probably go out for dessert elsewhere from now on. read more

I have taking my family to Sweet Mutiny for a least a year. I like seeing the same friendly college students that were employees of Sweet Mutiny. I guess there are new owners and my sweet college students are no longer employed at Sweet Mutiny. I went there yesterday, the place was dirty and the candy seemed really stale. The employee {I did not get her name} seemed really unhappy. I am unhappy that there is only one froyo in Pullman. read more

I have to say that I was more then disappointed when I went for the first time. I had heard that the cupcakes were fabulous.... what a disappointment.... the cupcakes were dry, the bottom was hard and crisp. They were over priced. I will not be going back and I will never recommend the place. read more

Promised my two year old a cupcake for her birthday. Planned the entire day (errands, naptime, etc), around being there when they opened at noon. Drive all the way from Moscow just to be told that they do not have cupcakes today. I even checked their FB page, and it didn't say anything. What's the point of a cupcake place that doesn't have cupcakes? Very disappointed. Probably won't make the effort to try and go again. read more

I decided to stop and pick up cupcakes for a friend's birthday. I picked up chocolate, lemon and red velvet cupcakes. I was ok with paying around $3 a cupcake, since they were beautifully decorated and I couldn't wait to share. Plus, I looked at their Facebook page for the word of the day to get a discount on my order. However, as soon I bit into my red velvet cupcake, I didn't get the flavor I was expecting. I also was disappointed that the cupcake was dense. I have always thought cupcakes should be light. I'm not sure I would spend that much money on cupcakes again. However, I would eventually like to try the frozen yogurt. read more

Not a bad place for fro-yo, but why can't they just put simple labels on their toppings? Too often I ended up with something unexpected. Prices are a little high. read more

Sweet Mutiny has some of the best cupcakes I've ever had! I brought some home to the family after a road trip - S'mores, Irish cream, and an apple pie cupcake for myself and no complaints from anyone. They were so moist and yummy. The frosting was not overly sweet. I can't wait til August when I get to have another! Maybe we'll try the fro-yo then, too. read more

Was out with my five year old daughter, saw this shop and had to stop. We didn't try the cupcakes as we were both full off of the froyo and toppings :) I had never been in a place like that before and was amazed by their topping choices. However was disappointed by their froyo flavors-more variety would have been nice. Also they had three choices for cupcakes and none of them sounded all that awesome to me, I may have grabbed one for the road if they had something that appealed to me. All in all it is a super cute place, the gals working there were really nice and I will definitely go back next time I am in town. read more

The froyo is the only reason I go here. They have different flavors that they rotate through. The cupcakes aren't anything really worth going out of your way for. (Small, pricey, not terribly good.) I'd say most of the time, the customer service is great. Have had a couple of times where there is an older woman working who you have to work hard to get her attention to come out from the back and ring you up. They have an outdoors-y sitting area that's nice in the summer. read more

We have had: Lemon Scurvy- Good! The frosting and curd were very yummy. Coffee- Ok. The coffee flavor seems to be in the chocolate covered coffee bean and overall we didn't really notice coffee flavor. Vanilla- Good! A nice true vanilla flavor. It doesn't seem perfumy flavored. Very simple but very yummy. Overall the cupcakes have all been moist. Our main complaint is that the flavors are not posted anywhere consistently. We have inquired and been told that the "flavor of the day" on their website is inaccurate and to check their Facebook, yet that is also not updated daily. While I very much appreciate that they only make enough cupcakes to ensure freshness and reduce waste it would be nice to know what my options were before heading over. As a follower on Facebook I do like when they announce promotions and overall support for the community. The shop itself is nice, clean, and looks like a few people enjoy lounging with their treat. As we are not "froyo" people we can not review that. read more

Kid friendly place with couches to hang out at. Good selection of fro-yo and even better selection of toppings. Good cupcakes with chocolate, red velvet and lemon cheesecake being our faves ( tried them all) . Love the uber cute logo too read more

I'll start the the good. Very friendly and inviting atmosphere. The smores & carrots cupcakes were DEVINE Decent yogurt and toppings selection. Lots of space and friendly staff. The not-so-good 1. I think they should have prepared more for an opening weekend which happened to be U of I's Mom's Weekend 2. We went 2 nights in a row and each night they had ran out of almost every flavor cupcake. I understand this will get better, but you should always prepare for the worst. 3. No vanilla froyo! (I dont remember seeing chocolate either) That is hands down the safest and most popular flavor that goes well with any mix-ins. When I asked, I was told that Original Tart and Cake Batter are very similar to vanilla - definitely not true. Original Tart is gross, and I'm personally not a cake batter fan. I'd prefer to drive to Jamms in Moscow where they without a doubt have standard flavors like vanilla and chocolate. 4. They ran out of all but 2 froyo favors the second night and there were no signs so the line took 3 times longer because each person tried a non-working flavor. Again this is something I think could have been better prepared for. 5. The line is very confusing. Do you have to wait behind everyone getting froyo if you only want a cupcake? The staff should be offering to ring people up if all they want is a cupcake. I'm sure once the place has had a while to be opened and they have standard yogurt flavors, we'll be back. But for now, we'll stick with Jamms for Froyo. read more

Not sure what all the bad reviews are over. This place is good and should be given a chance. I didn't try their cupcakes but their frozen yogurt is delicious! I do like fruit in my froyo, and their fruit didn't look the best, which is why they earned a 4 out of 5 starts. read more

Can't get yogurt out of the machines, the employee is empathetic at best. The excuse is that they are cleaning the machines tonight... Worst froyo experience ever. read more

I take my kids here often for a sweet treat that's healthy too. Wonderful selection of frozen yogurt flavors and toppings. Haven't tried their cupcakes or baked desserts but I've heard good things. read more

Going into Sweet Mutiny always, without fail, makes my day. From a warm and inviting staff, to a clean environment and great place to sit and have conversation, this is seriously one place you NEED to stop. Their fro-yo bar is amazing and their toppings are endless (and to die for...brownie bites anyone!?). Their cupcakes are always absolutely beautiful. If you go in around a holiday or a big game day, they will be decorated with amazing patterns and have fun flavors. They do a wonderful job on special orders, and if you think their cupcakes are beautiful, you should see their cakes. Just go get one, or 12 (cheaper that way). You will NOT regret it. read more

I purchased two rather small cupcakes....approximately $2.50 per treat. They were stale and dry. I could have bought a Duncan Hines cake mix and frosting for what I paid for 2 cupcakes and it would have tasted much better! I won't be back. read more

Horrible customer service. The girls working here are hiding behind the yogurt in the back and just keep peeking out like they're checking on shoplifters. Extremely rude, bought a few yogurts and I wasn't offered a bag or anything. The yogurt doesn't taste good and we were just desperate for some dessert while visiting Pullman. Save your money. read more

Other than the assistant manager Beth badmouthing me and my daughter's party guests to an employee when they thought I was out of earshot it was great. Maybe you shouldn't have children's parties if you don't want kids "making a mess".It was a cupcake decorating party, I'm sorry the group of 11-12 year Olds aren't Martha Stewart. I'm sorry we waited for the stragglers to arrive before starting so we messed up your schedule though we were well within the 2 hour block we'd reserved the room for.. So incredibly rude. Never again. read more

Nothing special. Small selection, dry cupcakes, free water cups are the size for infants.

I personally think the employees are nice, but their food is lacking. both the cupcakes and the frozen yogurt are bland. Plus their toppings are not kept clean. I would suggest going somewhere else for dessert. read more

This place is my dream come true. One of my favorite places in Pullman. Not only does it have delicious froyo, but cupcakes and cake pops. That's all you really need. read more

Sweet Mutiny was GREAT in helping this VERY VERY long distance mom (Hong Kong) send a surprise (large) order to my daughter's house. From the immediate response of the pastry chef to the young man who answered the phone when I called (to ask about the order which was handled perfectly on time and as promised)...the whole thing went off without a hitch! THANK YOU!!! read more

Sweet Mutiny has some of the best frozen yogurt and cupcakes I have ever had. The ingredients for the frozen yogurt are always fresh and there is so much selection. After going to Sweet Mutiny I went to Menchies which I used to love and was disgusted at the quality compared to Sweet Mutiny. The cupcakes are amazing, all very fresh and so many different creations. I have nothing bad to say about this establishment. It is also incredibly reasonably priced and has a very cute atmosphere. read more

I really like the froyo here! The variety of flavors and toppings are great. I like the cheese cake and kiwis the best :)