Stopped here with my husband while we were traveling in Lititz and was blown away with how many delicious treats they have. The store was beautifully decorated for the fall season, clean, and inviting. We loved all the treats they had to offer. There were teas, honey, a large selection of maple syrups(the sparkle syrup was very cool), fresh pastries, hot cocoa bombs, and more. We purchased their mystery box and other treats. The mystery box was fun because it had treats my whole family loved. It was packed with licorice, cashew butter, chocolate, and chocolate covered espresso beans. We will definitely come back the next time we're in town and try their cookies and cakes. Thank you for such wonderful service! read more

Sweet Legacy Gourmet - $15 mystery bag! - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

This place is absolutely delicious!! We stopped in to grab some sweet treats while passing through Lititz. We were immediately greeted with very friendly and helpful staff who pointed us in the right direction with our choices. Our favorite treat was the coconut macaron. DELICIOUS and perfectly sweet from the flaky coconut. I also had a caramel covered marshmallow which was great (but extremely sweet!). The cookies were tasty (blueberry white chocolate). Prices were reasonable. Definitely check this Lititz gem out!! read more

Just fabulous! The pecan pie brownie is my new favorite treat and I'm already looking for excuses to drive back to Lititz to get more. The caramel covered marshmallow was also amazing and that is coming from someone who isn't a big fan of marshmallows. The buckeyes and peppermint patties were just okay, but still really good. Definitely a place that needs to be added to your stop in list. read more

See all

Hand made fudge tastes very good, discounts for health care workers, ethically sourced bottled water, buy one get one deals, friendly workers. I would recommend a stop if u r in lititz read more

Yum. Lots of choices. We had fudge too and chocolate covered pretzels . Nice couple. Average pricing for specialty chocolates. Very clean read more

Sweet Legacy Gourmet - a box of chocolates - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

I put in a cookie order via phone answering machine on a Saturday to be picked up the following Friday. The answering machine said they would call back in 24 hours. They are closed Sunday and Monday. I called Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday still reached an answering machine. I showed up at the shop on Thursday afternoon and spoke to Chella the owner and she claims she left a message on the answering machine at my home. Nothing was left on my machine. She said she would not have the cookies I ordered on Friday because she had a wedding cake on order. Can you imagine? I ordered the cookies six days ahead of time. I was not happy at all. Mrs. "A". read more

The Sweet Legacy Gourmet is a bakery that has been around for more than 25 years and is family-owned. Their stand inside the Bird in Hand Farmer's Market (located literally diagonally from the entrance) has a nicely-displayed spread of cookies, fudge,hand-dipped marshmallow, caramel apples, and recipe-in-a-jar. I tried some of their fudge, the Apple Harvest, which seemed to contain bits of apple (but had a golden raisin-like texture to it) - I personally thought it was overly sweet and grainy. They sell it by the large slices, rather than like the other confectioneries that tailor to the amount you want per lb. Service was nice, but a little intrusive, as we wanted some more time to look at each of their offerings; felt a little too pressured to purchase something! +grainy fudge +family-owned read more

See all

Cute little shop with all kinds of goodies. I picked up some cookies for my kiddos which they devoured. The woman working was so sweet (no pun intended) and was helpful. Prices were great and loved the quality. Recommend for a pick me up. read more

Love the charming nostalgic look of this sweet shop in downtown Lititz. Their signage, paper sacks, front display window & interior displays are all just perfect. I wish I could give them 5 stars, but the chocolate brownie I got recently was stale & flavorless! Everything looks & smells wonderful, but this item was poor quality & simply not fresh! I am a brownie lover & only ate a few bites before throwing it away. It is a real shame after paying $6.00 for it. read more

cupcakes are so good! Great service-friendly. vegan and gluten free also available...delicious! read more

TRY THE BACON BRITTLE That's right I said bacon brittle it was great so were the caramel and chocolate dipped marshmallows read more

Sweet Legacy Gourmet - BACON BRITTLE IT WAS INCREDIBLE - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

AMAZING treats. Delicious sea salt caramels and chocolate covered pretzels. I can only imagine how delicious all the other treats are. My husband said it was the best chocolate covered pretzel he's ever had. The gentleman working there was very helpful, nice and polite! It was also beautiful inside and spotlessly clean. Can't wait to go back and try more! read more

I'm so sorry it took me this long to do a review. I live an hour away and treat myself to a shopping trip to Lititz twice a year. Once in July and on Black Friday. I literally have been shopping here for years and finally decided that one day I'm gonna stop in this shop for the first time. I'm sorry I missed it all these years! When you walk in their store you are greeted by the amazing smell of chocolate. They have everything from popcorn to peanut brittle to salted caramel's, nuts, brownies and cookies, All made by them! Nothing I can put here will do this place justice. You just need to stop by. It's a small shop with a world of flavor and choices. read more

Great assortment of product and a very friendly owner on site. It's a must visit, best cookies in Lititz

This is a cute little shop with tasty treats that include chocolate candy, caramel corn, whoopee pies, and fudge. They also offer Square One coffee. It's a little more expensive compared to some places, like local farmers markets, but it's worth it thanks to the quality. Definitely worth stopping in if you're visiting the Main St area of Lititz! read more

My mom ordered a tray from Sweet Legacy for my baby shower. It was SO impressive! Different types of fudge, cookie sandwiches, caramels, chocolate covered pretzels... there was something for everyone and it was organized beautifully. A huge hit! My mom also raved about how great they were to work with - I know she really appreciated their service! read more

By far the best bakery in Lititz! I love their chocolate dipped shortbread with sea salt! You'll always leave there with a tasty treat and a smile! read more

If you like sweets. You can stop looking for a candy store. Lititz now has the best and it's worth every penny. I can't wait to go back. I'm in my 50's so it's been awhile since I longed for candy. I literally think about my next visit. I'm so hooked. Do yourself a favor and go there the next chance you get! read more

We spotted their stand inside the Lancaster Central Market last week. Their fudge was absolutely delicious! We got 3 kinds, coconut, chocolate, and white chocolate. Every bite of the 3 was absolutely gorgeous. Perfect texture and taste. Good find in a market that has quite a few solid gourmet options. read more

The best chocolate (malt balls, butter toffee, macaroons) I've ever had. I'm planning a return trip or mail order. I need more chocolate! Highly recommended!! read more

Best sweets around! The salted caramels are a must have!! Perfect place for gifts or if you're just in the mood for some tasty treats!

Very kind staff. Hot coffee delicious and robust. Espresso beans in a bag also very good

Absolutely heavenly! Had the pecan turtle - wonderful and the best cookie of my life, shortbread,chocolate with sea salt

Best ever!!!!!!!!!!!! Had woopie pies, caramel corn, pumpkin pecan fudge, and coconut and pecan brittle!!!!!!!! Had to drive back to Harrisburg and all we did was eat everything!!!!NUMBER1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

The fudge is stellar! Wayyyyyy better than boardwalk fudge. Their caramels are awesome as well.

Right when you walk in you smell the absolutely delectable scent of fudge and baked good. Super friendly staff that answer all questions with a smile! Not to mention the fudge is to die for!! I wish I lived closer so I can go more often. Highly recommend to anyone who loves sweets!! read more

See all

This candy store is a must! Their salted caramel covered marshmallows are the best ever! They come in many different ways...on a stick, in a square, many ways. So so good, and I have had a lot of caramels in my day. The owner was there when we visited. Very nice and accommodating. We travel back to the store, just for these caramels. And we live over an hour away. You must try his candies. He has a huge selection of hand made, home made items. You will love it. read more

I swear I gain 10 lbs just by walking into this place. They have the most amazing assortment of candy and baked goods that you cannot find anywhere else. My favorite candies are the peanut butter buckeyes, and cashew turtle clusters. In the fall I always pick up a caramel apple with peanuts to take home. Not sure what kind of apple they use but it is always so fresh and crisp. The baked goods are superb and the cookies specifically the toffee pecan chip are probably some of the best I have ever had. The gentleman (not sure if he is the owner) is always so nice and helpful. You can tell that he appreciates his customers. Truly a gem and must stop if you are in the area. read more

Friendly service but more importantly exquisite baked goods and popcorn. You don't want to miss this shop. Stop here first!

First time we stopped in to the Lititz location on Small Business Saturday. Owners were on behind the counter and finishing up their baked goods. The owners greeted us and were really friendly. We ended up getting two coffees and a Toffee Pecan cookie. Coffee was fresh and the cookie was still warm and tasted great. They had so much in cookies, candy, Caramel coated Large Marshmallows, pastries, and fudge. It was $5.25 for everything. Very fair price for a large cookie and coffees. Shop was super clean and customers were being taken care of quickly. We ended up going back later to grab a dozen cookies for friends. The one owner still remembered us from the morning. We would definitely go back again when in Lititz. read more

When you walk through the front door you are hit with the wonderful smells of all the amazing treats and sweets. The shop is so aesthetically appealing too! You can't leave without trying the handcrafted old fashion family recipe fudge in so many amazing flavors (try the dark chocolate, peanut butter, and salted caramel chocolate) the salted caramels are to die for, and the caramel popcorn beats Fishers by a long shot.! My children couldn't leave without taking a few cookies and chocolate covered marshmallows for later. You must try everything!!! read more