Perfect sushi for a COVID takeout Friday night. Sushi was fresh and flavorful. Pickup was easy and safe. Finding Nemo, Sexy Roll and Yummy yummy were DELICIOUS. We found the simple rolls to be over priced but the specialty rolls under priced. Really great sushi tonight and we were all happy! read more

Sushi Ya - two plates of sushi on a kitchen counter - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

Im a regular here! :) A local and fresh sushi place that never disappoints! Every time i order here, my food is always delicious and fresh. The staff is nice which adds to the overall great experience. read more

New owners and I'm so sorry to report that the food is no longer wonderful! Big issues with the not fresh food. Smallish issues with egg shells in fried rice. Just not good! We would never go back! read more

Sushi Ya was recommended to me by my uncle and I've been hooked ever since. I always order out and so the staff always has my order prepped and ready. The restaurant offers up a nice cozy place to have lunch with co-workers during the day. You can never go wrong with the lunch special... The sushi rolls are amazing... Always fresh. I recommend the kani salad as it is always a nice way to start off the meal. I also love and recommend the JB roll and may roll... I recommend this to everyone in the area. read more

Good food and good service. This is my go to when I need my sushi fix. My summer go to on hot days

Eh, not my favorite... I had worked a tad late and got home around 7:45/8:00. My boyfriend and I intended to go to Press, but there was a wait and we were both really hungry for dinner (after trying to park, it was almost 9:00). We saw Sushi Ya and thought we'd try it out. We love sushi, so we were excited! It didn't look like there was much of a wait, so we thought it'd be perfect! Maybe because we love sushi so much and have been to quite a few restaurants, we were disappointed. The furniture looked a little dated, my booth seat had a big square of black tape to close up a big hole. Their selection was ok, nothing fantastic compared to where we've been before, and the prices for what they offered was high in my personal opinion. I even suggested we leave and go elsewhere before placing our order. We will say they had some interesting appetizers that set them apart from other sushi spots we've been to before. We tried the sushi tartar - yummy! Then the dim, colored lighting started bothering my boyfriends eyes and he was having a really tough time focusing. We ate our rolls and left shortly after. All in all it was a nice meal in an ok little spot, but I'm not sure we'll be back anytime soon. read more

Sushi Ya - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Don't recommend, pretty sad roll with no care for presentation whatsoever. Server was nice but the food quality is not up to par. read more

Sushi Ya - Spicy Salmon (roll) - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Fresh and delicious food! Very quick delivery & even delicious as left overs! I had the chicken teriyaki over rice, gyoza and a miso soup! Portion was big enough for two people!! 10/10 highly recommend read more

My boyfriend and I' s favorite sushi place. Literally ordering right now as I speak. It has a nice scenery on the inside. The customer service is amazing. It doesn't take too long to get your food either. The food is always fresh in the restaurant and even when you order it from an online delivery service such as DoorDash or Uber eats. Definitely would recommend the food is good! read more

Since Fhoo closed I had to find a new sushi place decided to try Sushi Ya and I'm glad I did we ordered the baby octopus, sashimi tuna, king crab, scallop and ikura, Aloha roll and the February roll all exceptional! My only complaint is the delivery guy didn't come upstairs to make the delivery there was plenty of parking. I've never ordered delivery and had to go get it downstairs that just sucks and is a total inconvenience for me. If I wanted to go outside I would've just gone to the restaurant I have no problem ordering again but if they can't make the delivery to my door I'll pass read more

Came here with my family for a late dinner and unfortunately we had an overall unpleasant experience. The food itself wasn't great, but to add to that we spent a good part of the night waving away gnats that were circling our table. In addition the staff decided to start cleaning while we were in the middle of our meal and mopped all around where we sat which wasn't cool, but to add to that, the smell of the cleaning agent was super strong and the place smelled of a very intense Lysol. When we let the staff know instead of offering a discount we were offered a bottle of wine. We ended up requesting that our food get packed up to go. Had no desire to sit there any longer. read more

Mmmmm... The sushi was fresh and tasty. I have no real complaints except for our waitress she was very inattentive, so when we asked for extra things she would forget and once we reminded her of anything she kind of placed it on the table aggressively. But the hostess came over a few times to ask if we was enjoying the food (she was very pleasant) I would still return or order take out from here. read more

Sushi Ya - Dumplings - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

First time here. Came for lunch about 3pm on a Monday. I was the only patron when I arrived. I ordered the lunch special (ends at 3:30-cool!) chicken teriyaki. It was tasty and a good proportion also. I have no complaints considering I had the staff to myself so service was no problem Had a plum wine and lunch for only $14. I'll be back but likely under different conditions (time). That's when I'll know how they do from a service perspective. Also I didn't have sushi so that'll be another rating. read more

Let me paint the picture for you. Friday night, moderately full restaurant. (We had to wait maybe 5 minutes for a table) so definitely busy but not crazy. We get seated and as soon as we sat down, we noticed the table next to us very perturbed. At first we thought, maybe they just having a bad day but the more we sit here, I start to hear one of them say, "should we just leave?" And then I see it, they haven't been served water, they haven't taken their order and they have been sitting there for a good 15 minutes at least and no waiter has come over to them. This should have clued me in to our experience. They just got up and walked out. We should have followed suit, but we ultimately opted to stay. 15 minutes go by and they reseat all the tables around us. Another 10 minutes and still nothing, the waiter continues to walk by us and not stopping. Then finally the table that sat down after us gets their order taken. I was flabbergasted. He literally walked by us at least 4 times and nothing. Finally, I guess the manager sees how annoyed we are and takes our order. As I sit here literally still waiting for our food over 60 minutes after we walked in, I am still annoyed. If it had not been for the fact that I have a pregnant wife,a hungry toddler. I would have left. But it's Rockville center on a Friday night. All the other places are packed and I am not waiting another hour to be seated. Not sure if this is just and off night for them or what. But I will definitely not eat here again! read more

Sushi Ya - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

Always a great experience at Sushi Ya. I've been coming for the past 3 years and have never had a bad meal. Tonight my friend and I came, we shared 3 specialty rolls, a seaweed salad and a lobster ball. Everything was delicious and the fish was so fresh. The service was quick and employees were very friendly. read more

Sushi Ya - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

I've had my share of sushi in Long Beach, Rockville Centre, and Lynbrook... sushi ya has been consistently delicious and fresh EVERY time I order from them. For the food quality, the price point is cheap. Definitely a casual place. Service and decor is okay. Eating there is FAST, even with a group you can be in and out in under an hour. Salads, soups, appetizers come out instantly. They make your sushi in minutes. I typically feel rushed, even when you order slowly, eat slowly. 4 stars for sushi quality. read more

I came here with my significant other on a date and we had a good experience. I ordered the plum wine and that wine was so strong. It was only 5 bucks and gave me a strong buzz. Then we ordered the miso soups with a bento box of chicken teriyaki. The food was so good. The decor was nice but the booths need to be replaced. They had holes in it fixed with black tape which was tacky. Also some tiles were broken and they fixed with tape. They need to put some money in the place and not be cheap. However, the service was good and the food was so tasty. I also enjoyed the fried green tea ice cream! It was so tasty and a nice treat to end the date. Prices were decent and I would recommend. However, the owner needs to put to money into the restaurant for renovations! read more

Competition is a plenty with numerous other sushi restaurants in Rockville Centre but this one has stood the test of time. From it's inception on Merrick Rd (current location of La Bottega) to now in the heart of Park Avenue (across from the movie theater) this restaurant delivers on taste and quality. Here you will not find a modern decorated restaurant with a beat and cocktail menu longer than the special roll list (just beer and wine served). Instead, this no frills traditional decorated sushi bar with wood accents and authentic art scattered throughout puts food quality and customer satisfaction at the top of the list. Sushi Ya has maintained substantial portions and fresh fish throughout plenty of adversity over the years. The oldest sushi restaurant in Rockville Centre stays current with a big list of special rolls featuring numerous dragon rolls and a roll for named for every month of the year. Owned by a small family trying to make ends meet they are always very appreciative of my business and I am happy to support them. Great for take-out as well if you can navigate the parking situation (lot and entrance in the back). Sushi Ya has been my top choice for sushi in the area for many years. read more

I was a very loyal customer I'm talking about years loyal but a few times when it was extremely busy I was totally ignored There was one time I waited close to 45 minutes just to be entertained to get my order I was fuming mad but composed myself to a point that I just chose not to say anything because I was not coming back to this place after that I now go to a different place close by I almost went to therapy for emotional distress and abuse The service was absolutely ridiculous I'm much happier now with their competition better food too Stay away from this place! REALLY! read more

This is my "Go To" place for sushi in the area. Always fresh, always tasty and lots of variety. My wife and I have been going here from it's earlier Merrick Rd. location. It's a family owned establishment and they take great pride in putting out a great product. We really like the Kellman roll, Rainbow roll,RVC roll, The tuna platter appetizer. They always have something special on "The Board". If you're a sushi lover this is THE PLACE!! If not they have good non- fish dishes as well. We were there for Valentines Day and the chief made us each 2 pieces of heart shaped sushi!!! Of course it was wonderful. read more

Sushi Ya - From the Sushi Chief on Valentines Day!! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

The absolute worst sushi I have ever had. Ate one piece and gagged. Couldn't even eat it. And they are overly priced for the low grade quality food that they are selling. Better off just ordering from Kashi for a few extra bucks read more

If you want an HONEST REVIEW read this one! Normally i wouldn't bother writing a review for a restaurant out of the city or the areas that frequent, but I felt like I had to write a review for Sushi Ya to do it justice because I was appalled at some of these suspect reviews... First of all, by chatting with the owner who was not only friendly but so sweet and attentive, I found that there are 4 other sushi restaurants in the area which makes for pretty stiff competition. No wonder I see some negative reviews from totally unreliable Yelpers. Also, the owner informed us that he only owns ONE restaurant which is this one in Rockville Center. The other Sushi Ya's are not affiliated. To address the worm review... in the 22 years of eating fish has he EVER seen a sushi chef cut and filet the fish? There is no way a worm could've gotten in between his fish unless the worm bore into it in which the cutter would've seen the damage in the flesh that the worm caused. Sure, you can say the worm was that tiny but really? How is it that his ONE piece of fish had a worm it in? And it also coincidentally perfectly fit into his ONE piece of fish. I find that pretty hard to believe that he seemed to have missed the worm also with his one perfect bite... ummmmm what? Seems pretty suspect to me. Oh, and he has only 2 reviews and both were on the same day? Definitely suspect. Just sayin' Anyway on to the food... 4 stars for the food and 5 stars for the fish. We ordered a bunch of appetizers including the beef negimaki, fried chicken, edamame and seaweed salad. The beef negimaki and chicken were great and prepared well. Seaweed salad and edamame are pretty standard but they were good as well. Miso soup was strong and not watered down, the waitress is really Japanease and speaks fluent Japanese. She's totally sweet and our tea and water never went empty. For mains my bf and I ordered a sashimi deluxe and 2 rolls, the Susan roll and the Sushi Ya #3, sister had the sushi sashimi combo and OMG!! It was some of the best cuts of fish I've had, even better that many places in the city. Buttery cuts of fish that I swear was just plucked from the sea and for $20 a platter it was soooooo worth it. I also had a piece of uni (sea urchin) which is a huuuge sign of how fresh the fish is and it was amazing, better than that pale yellow stuff I always get in the city. This uni was great quality and bursting with the sea. I hope you guys give Sushi Ya a try, I hate it when people give BS reviews, it really hurts a business especially a neighborhood joint. I'm not from the hood but I rely on Yelpers to be honest and I hope my fellow Yelpers feel the same. :) read more

This is going to be a short & brief review.....I did not enjoy this place at all. Starting from the service to the ambiance to the food....1 star. I'm very picky when it comes to sushi, and I make it my point to order sushi (not rolls) when I go to Japanese sushi restaurants for the first time to determine whether it'll be worth a second visit. The sushi here is horrible....thick chewy slices of fish that you can barely eat in one bite. They were not fresh at all, with a bit of foul fishy smell. My BF saw the expression on my face after my first bite, and he told me to stop eating because he can tell I hated it! I really felt bad about that, but their sushi was unedible to me. Will NEVER go back. read more

Came in around 7:15pm on a Friday night to grab a quick bite. They told us it would be a few minutes wait which is no big deal. Once we get seated we asked for a booster seat or high chair for our toddler. They said ok and never returned. After several minutes of watching them walk back and forth we went to get our own seat from our car. Two girls sat next to us talking amongst themselves and kept looking for a waiter to place their order. After maybe another 10-15 minutes the two girls get up and walk out. That's when the cashier comes over and asks us what we want to drink. They have nothing for toddlers so my husband had to go back out to get a drink for her. They bring our drinks and walk off. Another 10-15 minutes and the waiter decides to ask the table behind who came in after us what they would like to drink. They immediately started placing their order. We were there at least 30 minutes waiting already and still nothing...... If it wasn't for the 2 sodas on our table we would have left. The waiter kept walking AROUND us as if we weren't even seated there. FINALLY the cashier comes back and takes our order. I don't even want to say how long we had to wait for our food. I never knew making 4 rolls would take 30 minutes. The food wasn't even worth the wait. I asked for a check and that took another 15 minutes. All in all we spent almost 2 hours in there and I could not be more unsatisfied with the service and food. Next time I'm just going to go to Karusaki who have better food and waiters who actually care whether or not you would come back............ read more

Sushiya is alright, but their prices are what really make me go there. Everything is on the cheaper side in comparison to other local joints. Their RVC Roll, Black Dragon Roll, and Gyoza are my staples. As far as service goes, I guess you get what you pay for... when ordering the same rolls every visit you know exactly what should be in each. Lately, i've been getting random inserts of pineapple and avocado amongst other unknowns. One time i ordered for take out and while i was waiting for my order to be completed, the wife/owner had given my roll away to a women who had already paid for and received her order in completion and had ordered the same thing after the fact. The wife/owner just smiled and told me to wait for MY ROLL?! Upon bringing this up to the husband/owner on my next take out visit he just laughed. The next and final time i ordered from them he told me 20 minutes and when i got there 30 minutes later he laughed and told me he had forgotten to put the order in. I haven't been back since If you would like to visit this place, i would highly suggest sitting down at a table and not getting take out. read more

Easily the best sushi I have ever had (and I eat a LOT of sushi). FRESH and TASTY sushi every single time. Everything on the menu is delicious, filling and reasonably priced. The servers are always friendly and attentive to their customers. Just beware - once you come here, sushi will never be the same for you again. read more

This is the best sushi place in RVC, period. Have been eating in Sushiya for 15 years (they used to have a smaller place in Merrick Road). The quality never change during these years. I just love the special rolls. Environment: 5 Star Sure, this is not a fancy club. no disco ball. But if you are looking for a comfortable place to spend time with your friend and family, this will be a perfect place. Service: 5 Star The waitress are nice and attentive. This is a family restaurant. Tony (the owner) does care about how customers getting treat. If he doesn't work behind the sushi bar, he always stop by and say hi to the regulars like me. Food: 5 star At the end of the day, it is the food matters most. I just LOVE those special rolls they have. My all time favorite is Kelman Roll. It has spicy tuna, crab mixed with avocado. It is covered with fresh sal. On the top, Tony put crunchy, eel sauce and special mayo.It is just so beautiful and tasty. My other recommendation includes Fancy Dragon roll and January Roll. If you are a pure sushi eater, this is the place for you. You can sit on the sushi bar and ask the chef to make you the most fresh sushi or sashimi. You don't eat raw fish like my mom. Don't need to worry about it. Sushiya has a large selection of kitchen food as well. My mom and my sister love the beef teriyaki and Seafood combo teriyaki. Price: 5 Star Among all the sushi place in the Area, Sushiya is one of most family friendly place with reasonable place. You will get every dollar worth of food. The fish is super fresh. Conclusion: As a long time RVC resident, I can tell you Sushiya is a great place to eat and spend time with family and friend. It has never disappointed me for the past 15 years. read more

See all

This is actually my go-to sushi place whenever I'm in Rockville Centre. I've seen them improve over the years - I've been visiting this place for 2 years now. During my experiences here, the wait staff has always been friendly to me and my friends. We received warm towels to wipe our hands on before we ate, and the wait staff made sure we were attended to. The sushi has good presentation and is very well-made. It is not the absolute BEST quality but it is much better than other sushi places that I've tried. I suggest trying the JB roll and the Eel/Avocado roll - they're fantastic! The fried ice cream is okay, I've had better. Also, skip out on the miso soup. Overall, I love this place and I go here with friends pretty often. It's worth a visit. read more

Decent sushi, Decent prices. Their service really won me over. My friend and I decided on Japanese for dinner tonight. As soon as we walked in we were seated. The waitress was friendly and always made herself available. We were given complementary cups of green tea, which was perfect for the cold weather. I ordered one of the specialty rolls and my friend ordered a la carte. My specialty roll was good. The portions are big so I did not finish. And the waitress asked me if I wanted to take the rest home before I could even ask. She's so sweet! The prices were decent, dinner for 2 came out to be 30ish dollars. There are plenty of dessert shops next door and down the block for some after dinner treats:) read more

This place is a hidden gem. A lovely mom and pop establishment with great food and service. We frequent this place regular and are treated like royalty when we come in. Prices are extremely reasonable this day in age for sushi. read more

I ordered a meal this evening. It was overly priced and the food was terrible. I didn't order sushi, I ordered teriyaki chicken. I will never order or eat there again. read more

The space is very small and gets very busy so if you are looking for a quiet meal or to have a private or even just pleasant conversation, this isn't the place. We ordered the pork dumplings and they were amazing. Full of flavor and well cooked. Edamame was also good but how do you mess that up? The sushi was great - super fresh and delicious. Wine selection was laughable - red or wine with no description of what kind. They also did not have a sake menu which we thought was odd. They only have regular or hot. So if you want to eat here (because the food is good), order takeout because service was just ok and they don't offer the best experience. read more

My go-to Sushi spot !! They really hung in there during the shutdown, as their takeout orders lose NOTHING on the way home. I always go with the Sushi/Sashimi for two, and if it's cold -- the Miso soup ( which is spot on ) and if hot outside -- the ginger salad. I get a spicy tuna roll as well, and there is a LOT of tuna in there ( very little rice ). Last night I went with an octopus appetizer as well. Usually order once every 7-10 days on average, but miss my meals when away longer than that. If you do take out, you're better off parking in the back. Enjoy ! read more

The sushi here is delicious. You have to go on a night it's not busy though, it can really fill up! During the week for me is the best time to go. Their spider roll is amazing. I also love their chicken terriyaki and hibachi dinners. It's hard to compete with other sushi places that have "half off sushi" specials. However, I will be back because I really enjoyed their food! read more

Any time I bring someone new to Sushiya, I warn them it will ruin every other Sushi place for them. They never believe me until halfway through the meal when they admit it's the best they've ever had. Everyone I've introduced to this restaurant has become a return customer. If you're a seasoned sushi eater I highly recommend Omakase (chef special) when Toniko the owner is preparing. It will knock your socks off - a whole other level!!! read more

Sushi Ya - Omakase: chef special for three. It's always something new! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Rockville Centre, New York

See all

The place is a bit run down. However, the food and service are good. I've had better sushi in the five boroughs. Finding good sushi in Long Island is difficult. This wouldn't be my first choice but I'd come back here any day. read more

Here it is. I always sit at the sushi bar simply because i enjoy watching the SUSHI MASTERS work there magic. I ordered the SUSHI/SASHIMI COMBO. The quality of the fish was superb, The temperature was right on the money, The taste was excellent. I ordered the GYOZA (squid) grilled with ginger sauce instead of the teriyaki sauce and it was great. Tony is one of the owners working behind the sushi bar and if you can get him to prepare your sushi it's quite the experience he is a Master. Rockville centre Parking is horrible and the meter maids are out for blood. dont skimp on the Muni-Meter. $30 ticket. read more

Amazing sushi. I have been coming here for years. I always order the Niel Roll, my absolute favorite!

Really good food!!! Nice calm setting, the pricing isn't bad at all and I've never had any problems here.

highly recommend this place they have the the best sushi in town !! best Sushi