Very disappointed! Went with my husband and two boys. We all had the all you can eat. I ordered once and then I got full, My husband ordered twice and finished everything, and then my sons ordered a second time, ate almost everything but 1 1/2 roll and was charged $20.00 extra for not eating all of our food! It states nowhere on there menu that if you don't eat everything you will be charged additionally. We will not be back. read more

Came here with a friend and it wasn't that great. Fish didn't taste fresh. We each ordered a few rolls and every roll had too much rice. They try to get you full off of rice I guess. Also, not much variety. Every roll had very similar if not the same ingredients but different names... Also the service was not friendly and they only came by our table 2 times as if they did not want us to order anything else. I do have to lower my expectations for sushi in Utah but I would probably not go here again. read more

Not a fan. Good variety, but the service isn't great, the rolls had a weird temperature and the rules on the menu? "No sharing. No wasting." etc. Seriously? If I want to share a roll with my friends, I'll share a freakin' roll. read more

We got all you can eat and my son didn't like two of the rolls. They told him they'd charge us for unfinished rolls! Doesn't say that anywhere... My poor son looked at me like he had to finish these gross rolls! read more

I would give this place ZERO stars! I've never been to a place with "buffet" rules. Lunch $15.00 dinner $20 per person. 1. No sharing 2. No wasting food or you will be charged. 3. Limit 3 rolls per customer. I ordered the volcano, shrimp tempura, crispy California tempura roll on my first round( 3 rolls). The tempura roll was deep fried and GREASY with a lot of rice and a tiny bit of avocado, imitation crab, etc. I was literally picking off the rice! The volcano roll was OK. I ate about almost 2 hand rolls and left most of the rice on my plate. I am ready to order more. Well, our waitress informed me I was WASTING food and I NEED to FINISH BEFORE ORDERING my 2nd order. EXCUSE ME?! I brushed it off and started to pick apart my greasy ass sushi... Finally, she brought me my 2nd order, 2pcs salmon nigiri and 8pcs of cucumber rolls. The salmon was fishy as hell. Again, A LOT of RICE on the cucumber rolls! I didn't want to get charged for " WASTING" so I ate what I could.... Lots of rice left over... Finally, we asked for our ticket. Waitress said, " next time, you will be charged for wasting food!" This lady was treating me like a child... I am 30 years old and let's keep in mind who is the paying customer. If I want to waste food it's my decision. Not yours to charge me! All the quality ingredients in the sushi sucked! All rolls were loose packed! Too much rice. (I even like rice!) salmon was not fresh. Vegetables were stale. I was so PISSED off on how I was treated, I will never return or recommend anyone to this place! Save your money and go else where. read more

The following review was written for Orem, but applies to Draper as well: I've had sushi all over the Salt Lake and Utah valleys--from stuff that tasted like canned cat food mixed with wet toilet paper, to fish so good that it must have been blessed by Poseidon himself--and I'd developed a firm belief that good AYCE sushi just didn't exist. A belief I held proudly, that is, until my friend convinced me to try this place in 2010. I reluctantly broke bread with him here (but not real bread--it's a sushi place, you know) and on that fateful day, history was made. We've eaten here probably 20 times since. The three things this restaurant does best are value, flavor, and consistency. VALUE: My pal and I will work up a good case of the hungries by raking leaves or navigating the raging Provo River, and then we'll head on over to the Sushi Ya. Each of us will get 4-5 rolls from the AYCE dinner menu (usually the Playboy, Mama, Rocky Mountain, Spicy Crunch, and perhaps one wildcard) and the dozen mussels. That's a large and delicious meal for about $25 dollars per person after tax and tip. FLAVOR: Go eat those rolls and mussels and tell me that's not one of the tastiest meals you've had this year. And I'm saying this in November; that means you've got almost 11 whole months of meals to compare with this one! I'm not worried. I know what I said. CONSISTENCY: What surprised me about this AYCE sushi, beyond its value and taste, was its consistency. The rolls and mussels look and taste exactly the same (if not a little better) every time we go in. Every. Single. Time. And on top of that, I've been to their new Draper location twice this year, and was shocked to find that the food there is a carbon copy of the original Orem location. How do they do it? Must be magic. Good luck explaining this one, Neil DeGrasse Tyson. Now is the time in my review where I will mention what I'd like to see change or improve at the Sushi Ya. 1. This first one is easy--be open on Sundays. I'd probably feast at the Draper location every other Sunday, were it open. But I understand that business would probably be too light to make it a profitable day. Still, a man can dream. 2. The only real con that I feel when I eat at these stores is that they suffer a little bit from what I like to call "Cafe Rio Syndrome." I just made that up, right now, and you can use it if you want, but remember who came up with it. Me, that's who. By "Cafe Rio Syndrome," I mean that the food is delicious, but the best rolls on the AYCE are basically the same 5 or 6 ingredients, just arranged in different ways. It would be nice to have more variety there. I am now realizing that Jim Gaffigan said something similar about Mexican food in general--the same 5 things just put together different ways. Does that make my invention of the term "Cafe Rio Syndrome" less awesome? No it does not. But let's get back to reviewing the Sushi Ya. Seriously, do yourself a favor and try out the dinner AYCE--it's excellent all around. I've always been treated well here, and am always happy when I walk into and out of the restaurant. I hope they continue to perform awesomely, and that they're around for a very long time. tl;dr Sushi Ya rocks the casbah read more

The rolls were amazing. You get a ridiculous amount of sushi for the all you can eat price. The service was phenomenal and everyone was very friendly. The atmosphere was perfect for sushi. If you can't finish they will charge you for what you ordered so if you don't have a big appetite it may not be the best value. I loved it. Great value and amazing food. read more

The sushi is pretty good, but it's a great place if you want a dude to see your weiner when you go pee-pee. The urinal is 2 ft from the door (and perpendicular to it), and you can't lock it. Door opens and boom - full display. Might be cool if you're into that kind of thing - viewee or viewer. Luckily there's a stall if you're not - like me. read more

If you like A LOT of sauce then you found the right place. Sauce sauce and MORE sauce. They have sweet chili sauce, soy sauce, eel sauce, spicy mayo sauce, ponzu sauce!!! Bring a spoon because you'll have to have one to eat all the sauce they serve for only $20!! There is some rice and fish underneath the sauce but let not your heat be discouraged, you can hardly taste it with all that wonderful sweet sauce flowing over your plate. This is by far the best sauce restaurant in the valley. Unfortunately I was looking for sushi. Guess I'll keep looking. read more

Decent sushi, not the best. Definitely good for the price, especially if you are doing the all you can eat and want to thrown down a couple rolls. Like $15 for a couple rolls is not bad. Ive definitely had better, but paid $50 for a few rolls at like Tsunami. I'd go back read more

We had to seat ourselves after not being acknowledged at a 1/4 full restaurant with 3 sushi chefs and two waitresses. We then sat down and the waitresses felt it was more important to fill other tables water and not give us a menu or giving us water. I have been there before, and the sushi was okay but the service was very slow on both occasions. read more

I love this place. Clean and nice, even upscale dining area. Friendly, informative waitress was willing to make any type of roll I was looking for, not just what was on the menu. The time of day probably a plus being there at 11:20. I sure wish we had one in Idaho Falls. The soup and salad was a nice extra with the lunch ayce. I got the raw tuna roll and the tuna was very fresh and buttery. Seriously, the only problem was I ate too much. What was nice was I was worried I was too glutinous and the waitress was encouraging me to get another roll. I ate at the one in Logan and they have both been great. read more

We had driven by this place daily and finally decided to go in. The all you can eat sushi for $20 is a good deal. The service was good and the roles came out fast. The sushi tasted ok, but I have definitely eaten at way better sushi places in Utah. My Boyfriend felt sick the rest of the night after eating here so it's not a place we will be going again. read more

When we want to celebrate and indulge in sushi, we make the trip to get their all you can eat sushi. It's always amazing, in a clean, friendly environment. I only gave them 4 stars due to price. (I tend to be the one picky up the tab for everyone.) read more

Orange Julius and the Vegas are AMAZING! I love this place, it's right near my house. My only issue is the amount of rice they lack into their rolls. Where's the fish?! read more

The food there is amazing. But the service is.. not. This is my 4th time eating there and the same waitress has been a complete jerk each time. She also works the register. Tonight, she walked away in the middle of us ordering and assumed we were done? I dont know how you could assume as we were literally in the middle of our sentence.. I'm literally amazed how she still works there. I've never had someone just walk away in the middle of an order. I recommend getting your food to go if you go there. No wonder the place is completely empty, no one wants to dine in with these assholes. read more

ok people good attitude no quality .... its more quantity the sushi rolls are stuffed with rice huge rice ball no fish ! not coming back again ! read more

Food is great, but it makes you feel so heavy, sleepy and full. If you do all you can eat the first order is fast. However, if you plan to eat a second and third time it is very delayed. read more

Solid sushi for the price. The nigiri was excellent! The Arizona hand roll was so delicious I'm coming back for it hands down! Seared tuna was fantastic also! Service was excellent, and we had our food in about 10 minutes which was awesome. Do yourself a favor, stop in and experiment with the menu, at the price you can afford it! The only thing that makes this review 4 instead of 5 starts is that they were lacking in diversity, I really like spicy rolls and they didn't have many to choose from. Other than that I'm smitten with this place, way better than the other sushi ya locations. read more

Loved the sushi at the Draper location. I will be going again & again! The food tastes great and is a work of art!

The food quality depends on the day. It is good quality, but the rice can taste stale and the fish can taste not fresh. On a good day, it's delicious, but you just have to hope that it's the day they renew the ingredients. I feel like they toss out the food when it is officially inedible, rather than when it doesn't taste fresh anymore. It makes sense, they save a lot of money that way. Just hope you go here on a good day! read more

Not good, tons of rice in each roll. Rules state you have to eat all the rice which also is not good. The fish is old and it smelled that way. I am surprised that I did get sick. After ordering my last roll I noticed hair in the roll. I know this can happen anywhere but really after such a gross meal that was the last straw. Don't eat here. read more

Sushi Nah. Rice was very sticky, too much rice accompanied many rolls and the nigiri. Very strict rules, but the service was good, we were the only two in the restaurant. read more

We always enjoy our experience at Sushi Ya. We have never been disappointed with the Rolls and have many favorites. The Happy Roll is one of our favorites but they do a great Crystal Shrimp as well. Service is great and friendly. You won't leave disappointed that you tried this location. read more

We really love this place. The service is kinda meh, but the sushi is damn good every time we go.

Honestly, I had high hopes for this establishment. The sushi was decent, but the fact that it took over an hour to get our food, pretty much killed any chance that I will return. If you're looking for all you can eat, stick with Simply Sushi. read more

I love Sushi Ya! I am not much of a sushi roll fan, I usually only order Sake Nigiri (raw salmon on top of rice.) I have also tried the miso soup and the Las Vegas roll and have loved both! The lunch all you can eat sushi is only 15$ and well worth it. Sometimes it takes a while to get my food, but I have never been in much of a hurry so I wasn't too bothered. My husband orders a variety of rolls from the menu and he has loved most of them. Overall one of my favorite sushi places for the price! The Sushi Ya in Orem is just as good. I've had multiple good experiences at both locations! read more

I love this place for sushi. They have inexpensive yummy sushi. This is actually my favorite sushi place for non tempura sushi. Their non tempura sushi has so much flavor, my favorite being Mountain. The tempura sushi is very good, but not the best. I never had to wait for a table. I highly recommend this place. read more

So I went in here half expecting it to be bad because of the reviews. But I was pleasantly surprised. I went in here after work alone for the all you can eat dinner. I think it came out to be 23 dollars and some change excluding the tip. Anyway I went in and sat in a booth, ordered my rolls and they were good. Nigiri was amazing and the rolls were well made. Good portions of fish in each roll and service was fast. Will be coming back, I think this my new sushi joint! read more

Horrible horrible ever the salmon tasted like frozen thawed fish. I will never go there!!!! I was sick the next morning!!! The hand roll was chewy and not crisp!!!! Go to Yi sushi bistro it's the best!!!!!!!! read more

I arrived and ordered in 15 minutes, still without receiving water. Eventually, after being seated for about 30 minutes, I received water. I also asked where my food was and the waitress didn't know. After being seated for approximately 45 minutes, which is 30 minutes after ordering, I walked out. read more

Very UNPROFESSIONAL! DONT EAT HERE! I went to an all you can eat restaurant to be told I couldn't order all that I wanted. I'm a relatively small guy 170lbs but I can eat a lot and I lift and it's gain season. I wanted to treat myself. While eating I heard the woman ringing me in at the counter talking to the chef about charging me for appetizers when it clearly states on their menu that it's included. He was rude and when I told him what I wanted he said that it was too much food. When they realized that they made me sushi that looked more like a wad of rice with a tiny piece of fish - the owner is nice but his lead chef is very rude. I've never seen very many people in there and I finally realize why. The meat was seemingly dangerous quality as well I'm not sure if the tuna he gave me was old but I got sick afterwards. I will never eat there again and had a horrible experience. This is my first yelp review it was that bad! If you have an all you can eat buffet then make it all you can eat, otherwise market yourself otherwise. DONT GO TO SUSHI Nah! read more

We are sushi snobs and we LOVE this place! We used to drive all the way to Orem to eat here. We are so excited now that there's one just minutes away from our house. We will become regulars. read more

do not come here during the weekend. they are understaffed and cant handle the crowd. waiting 45 min for a table. rediculous

We love going to all you can eat sushi places. Is this top of the line sushi? No! But, it is relatively good sushi for an all you can eat place? Yes! You order three roles or hand rolls at a time. Several reviewers indicated that the Tempura Veggie Roll was really good. Those reviewers were right. The Tempura Veggie was excellent. I ordered it twice and had different veggies for each one. We also really liked the Tempura Shrimp, Happy, and Summer rolls. Both of use were disappointed with the hand rolls and thought both were heavy on the rice. When we come back, we will skip the hand rolls. But, overall, for an all you can eat place, this is where we will be heading. read more

Finally decided to try this place. I was a little nervous because it's pretty unassuming, but it's my new favorite sushi place in the valley! I ordered the CK special and the eel nigiri, and both were 10 out of 10. The service was fine, and I don't think anything had more rice than other sushi joints. Actually the rice was what really set the place apart for me; it wasn't chilly or dry or tough like some other places. Will definitely be going back! read more

Worst service ever!!!! Our party of 8 had to wait about 10 minutes just to get our party size. Then we're basically told to find a table... then we had to wait another 10 minutes just to get water... we left and went to panda. I would recommend skipping the restaurant if you have a large party. They could not handle ours today... read more

Like other reviews, the raw fish tastes terrible! It's old and rubbery. The nigiri wasn't any good either. I have eaten at other all you can eat sushi places with good results. This is definitely the worst sushi I've eaten. Save yourselves the money! read more

Great food and great service! I went with a friend and they had us in and out with fully stomachs! Loved everything about it.