I have eaten at a lot of sushi restaurants over the years and this one is definitely one of the best! I have never had a bad meal. The sushi is fresh and served in nice sized pieces. They offer creative yummy new sushi rolls as specials. The presentation on sushi boats is always nice with a fresh flower and other decorative touches. Staff is friendly and accommodating. BYOB. read more

sushi is pretty much, eh, they were great when they opened, now not so much I have had increasingly less and less quality everytime i get food here, used to be 5 stars japanese restaurant in lancaster, in my book, now... it's good if you want japanese from carryoutcourier. read more

Went to this place for the first time tonight. Overall, my husband and I decided to give it 3 stars (A-OK!). Our reasons why: PROS: -Bruce Roll is amazing! -Shrimp Tempura was unreal -TNT roll was superb -Yum Yum was fantastic! -Aaron's roll was very tasty -Seated promptly (due to being the only people in there) -Portions are very generous -First experience with BYOB was fun...needed a cab home (OOPS!) -Good prices -Presentation was pleasing to the eye CONS: -Felt like a teeny bopper listening to the Backstreet Boys CD throughout the whole meal -Waitress questioned my husband on whether or not he really could eat the 5 rolls he ordered (C'mon lady, he's 6'5 230...need I say more?) -My water got kidnapped...I was asked if I needed more and it was taken away from me for a good ten minutes (I was thirsty!) -Waitress was answering phone while waiting on tables (very unprofessional, IMO) In conclusion, we would recommend this place. The sushi is delicious and the price is fair. Just bring your ear plugs to avoid horrible music, and get ready to be questioned on your eating abilities. read more

Mediocre at best. This place used to be better 5yrs ago but is now a place to avoid. The sushi went from an ok quality to that of which one would purchase from a supermarket. My friend and I both have a headache after our meals. The flavor and freshness are questionable. Save your money and eat elsewhere read more

It's an attractive restaurant and the food is good. But on the occasion that we were there, the service was not so great. There were three of us in the middle of the afternoon and we were the only party. Slow service when you're the only party is not a good sign. Our appetizers came at quite different times and there was no cutlery on the table. A minute is a long time when your food is hot and in front of you and you have nothing to eat it with. The late appetizer was followed almost immediately by the main course, which sat cooling as the guest finished his appetizer. read more

The staff is rude, the service is slow, and you will likely go home with food poisoning, seriously.

The owner is rude and the staff is the same way we have decided to take our business elsewhere. It is a shame because the food is actually quite good but the service casts a black cloud on anything that is good in this place. My suggestion is find a better sushi place unless you want plates dropped in front of you, nasty stares and attitudes like you wouldn't believe!! I can't believe a place a place could run like this!!! read more

You used to have the best sushi rolls in Lancaster but you have gone down hill. Your rolls are smaller and sloppy and the freshness of the ingredients has declined. I have gotten crab shell in two of the last three fresh crab California rolls and the amount of crab you put in them now is minuscule. Your Thai dishes are over filled with cheap water chestnuts and your curry is from a can that is weakened down with watery coconut milk. read more

It was a quite Sunday early evening went here as a date for the AYCE sushi for $27.99 and was disappointed. First, the staffed never came by for any refills or aked if we needed anything. The sushi was crap...there was so much rice compared to filling that all you were eating was rice. Also, sushi is supposed to be one bit type food and the hand rolled sushi was so big! Lastly what turned me off was the price...for $27.99 you got no standard soup or anything, sushi wasn't good, and the fish wasn't the greatest...I've had better. Sorry probably won't ever return. read more

What a great time this was. Despite some early trepidations over dining room size and so-called reputation of some of our members (Central PA Sushi Meetup), the staff at SushiOne really stepped up their game tonight. The staff was eager to please and the sushi was delivered in a reasonable amount of time considering our group size (17). One of the popular items on the menu that night was a customizable sushi platter where you picked the sushi you wanted on the platter and was only $30. This is the first I've ever seen it done like that compared to how most places have their "Love Boat" where you need to guess what you're trying. I was also surprised when Liu (SushiOne's host) let me know that they were going to give us free dessert of fried bananas (with lots of whip cream) ON THE HOUSE. It was agreed that even though SushiOne is small in stature and simple in decor that we WOULD be coming back here in the future. It is a great value for your dollar. Also, as with many sushi places, this place is BYOB. read more

Honestly disappointed...had the salad with ginger dressing. Dressing was watered down and no flavor. Was disappointed by the sushi roll too. Likely not returning. read more

This place has went down a notch for me. It is still good but the sushi chef seems sick the last 3 times I have been there and it is a huge turnoff. read more

We both did the AYCE...because we were starved. Probably worth it but be careful if you don't finish your last rolls - they charge a buck a piece if you leave it or take away. Will say that it's pretty good though, had four specialty rolls each which are likely around $9 each these days. read more

We have been regulars at Sushi One since they have opened. Previously we would have rated them much higher however recently they have reduced the size of their rice serving considerably with their Nigiri sushi to the point that it is easily noticed. Other than that, we enjoy the quaintness and especially our waitress Lisa - she is a pleasure to talk with. Bring you own sake or beer. Other review shown says that the staff if rude - I doubt that any rudeness was intended by these people - they are good people. D&Y read more

I found this place by chance today after leaving Tokyo Diner really upset. (really horrible experience which I've already posted on their Yelp). The price at Sushi One was perfect, the sushi was exceptionally fresh, the service was amazing, and the time it took to get our order back to the table was very quick. I will definitely be returning after such a great experience. And for anyone reading, DO NOT GO TO TOKYO DINER which is just 2 minutes away! You'll regret it and Sushi One is a million times better :) read more

Fish was not fresh. Spicy tuna was awful. Salmon was chewy. The rest of the rolls were meh. Won't be going back.

The sushi is fresh and delicious. There are also options for people who don't like sushi or sashimi as well. Ambiance is nice, comfortable, and clean. Would be better if they served alcohol, but you can bring your own. read more

My favorite sushi place - I eat here once a week and I always look forward to it. Excellent fish quality, always fresh, a great place to bring your own bottle of wine. Best miso soup ever. Great selection of special rolls - my favorites: Tokyo roll and Summer roll. read more

We were kind of new to Sashima and Sushi when we encountered Sushi One on Fruitville Pike in Manheim Township, PA. It is now our favorite restaurant of any kind. Once every two weeks, we grab a bottle of dry Reisling and head over. The Clipper Magazine usually has coupons for $5 off, but we would be eating there regardless. Our favorites are the Jersey Roll, and anything which includes shrimp tempura. Our friends who still do not indulge in Sushi spoke highly of the Chinese style entrees. The service is quick and non intrusive unless they are very crowded, then, of course, everything slows down. Don't miss the best Sushi in Lancaster County, PA. read more

This place, #SUSHIONE is a hidden treasure! I saw the "open sign" flashing & my stomach said yes please however here is the kicker. It was 10:30 PM and they close at 10:00 PM. I thought someone forgot to turn off the light but just in case I'm going to call. I'm so glad I did. They do close at 10:00 (11:00 AM-10:00 PM Sunday-Thursday & 11:00 am-10:30PM Friday-Saturday) however customers had a party tonight and since some of the guest were still there they stayed open for other customers (like me, lol). Most places close the doors at said closing time and start the closing clean up while working around patrons. Not them, they stay open. After he took my order, I turned around & drove back to pick up my order. If you like sushi and have not been here yet, you do not know what you've been missing out on! The owners & employees are really nice & genuine! Make sure you come try this place out & pass this hidden gem on to family & friends they will thank you for it. Walk in or reservations. B.Y.O.B. Great sushi, great environment & great employees can't ask for more than that! If you chose to you have a party at Sushi One give them a call to make reservations. (Parties get 10% off the total of your bill). They chose to remain open and it got my attention. They stayed open, got more business have gained a new customer! Shout out to my 2 Italians guys that walked me to the door, thank you. Also for letting 1 of the owners know I was your cousin so he'd give me a discount, every penny saved counts! They told me "5 years living here and I haven't ate sushi at any other place & I never will!" Lancaster county has a lot of places to jump around & eat at. 2 guys eating at the same place for 5 years... I think that speaks magnitudes about SUSHI ONE! The food, atmosphere & employees! Next time I will be sure to show up before closing and I'll be dining in with my hubby! *** I referred to it as a hidden gem because It is kinda hard to see from the road (Fruitville Pike). I've never noticed it before & I am sure there are others as well. It's across the street from Kmart in the little strip shopping mall. (Little Ceasers Pizza, used book store are what I can remember seeing). read more

My fiance took me here as part of a weekend getaway for our anniversary, and hands down it was the best sushi I have ever had!!! All you can eat sushi was the perfect way to spend our first night of vacation together. read more