We ate at Millie's twice this week while we were here. Once for lunch and once for dinner!…read more We will definitely go back when we come again. We sat out front at a picnic table and our servers both times were excellent! We were waited on professionally and our food was delivered promptly! I ordered the swordfish kebabs for lunch and they were delicious! We all enjoyed the guacamole and chips too. I had tuna crudo for dinner and it was fresh and tasty! Sitting outside in the front worked out well because we had two small grandchildren and they could play in the grass.

Arrived and were greeted by the hostess team. They were friendly and accommodating. Maddie was our…read moreserver which she was friendly as well and efficient! I had the New England clam chowder and the lobster roll Connecticut style. Both were flavorful and hardy. I was full after and relaxed. The view is homes and the ocean while sitting and listening to great tunes. I do have to share for the owners sake on training that one star missing is due to the restrooms being unkept with urine splattered on the floor, urine in the toilet and a dirty toilet. Had I gone in there first, I may have not stayed for a bite to eat. Perhaps assign on team member as a floater with the assignment of keeping the restroom spotless. Hope this helps.

Back Yard BBQ was one of our favorite meals on Nantucket! The lobster roll was absolutely…read moredelicious--fresh, flavorful, and generously filled. What really stood out was the value; while many lobster rolls on the island can cost $60 or more, theirs was in the $30 range and well worth it. The burger was equally impressive--juicy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. Service was quick and efficient, making it a great spot for a casual meal without a long wait. Great food, reasonable prices, and friendly service. We'll definitely be stopping by again on our next trip to Nantucket!

We fell into the door on the Fourth of July and were able to sit right away. The restaurant kept…read moretheir door open which made it on the warmer side. It was during the heat wave and I sure was hoping for some AC. The Benedict and tator tots were delicious! Everyone at the table enjoyed their food and had no complaints. There are TVs at the bar area ton if there is something you would like to watch too. Our waiter was friendly and had great suggestions. He is from Jamaica and we all were talking about the World Cup. I would go back again. It's off the path from the downtown area across from the stop and shop. Enjoy!

I had an amazing truffle, egg, and cheese sandwich from here today. My husband had a veggie panini…read moreand was super impressed! Tons of delicious sounding options and the desserts looked super yummy too! We also had immunity shots as well that we enjoyed. Service was great. Super cute place and one of our favorites we have been to in Nantucket so far!

Be prepared for a massive line. Got here around 10 and took about an hour. Worth the wait? No, way…read moreoverhyped. If you can avoid the long line then def worth a visit, but not for an hour long line. Bread was good. Got an ABC grilled cheese- it was solid. The waitstaff was great, but tik tok got me on this one.

Service was so attentive and engaging. The brok salad is amazing and will forever have a place in…read moremy heart. Funnel cake...elevated and fun. Roasted chicken was perfectly seasoned/cooked. An all around gem of a restaurant and a lock for a win. I've been going for several years and it really is a top notch spot!

3.5 overall. While the food is solid (4 stars), I found it to be overpriced, and that's taking in…read morethat Nantucket is expensive. The small plates were all $25+ and while the small plates were actually larger than one would think, nothing blew me away. The cocktails are also expensive, pricier than drinks I recently had at The Pearl & Straight Wharf. Pics were from a few years back, but I most recently dined this year (2026) and had the octopus, little gem salad, the clam dip and fried broccoli. While all good, I wouldn't say a dish stood out as fantastic. (Granted, we didn't order any of their more "main dishes". This is definitely a spot that seemingly is more fun with many mouths to feed and try bites of many things. With just my husband & I, we were limited to the same bites of a few dishes. The service was great and the vibes also. The bar is bustling and upstairs is so charming. Overall, a solid night out. I do find it to be more expensive than their neighbors and not quite sure the food lived up to those occasions, which is why the 3 stars, but regardless, a nice night out. Fun Fact: Back in the day, this spot was an Italian restaurant called DeMarco's and I used to be the hostess! (This was 30 years ago and now after writing that, I feel quite old).

This review is specific to the Caribbean takeout menu, not the normal menu for Nantucket Lobster…read moreTrap. While wondering around town, we went down a side road behind the Nantucket Lobster Trap and a wonderful aroma of curry reached us. The takeout window has a special menu off to the right side of Caribbean curries and other dishes. We came back that night and were rewarded with some of the best food we had on the island. The chicken was so tender it fill off the bone, sauces were rich and flavorful without being too spicy. We tried Festival, which is a bread that is a little sweet, and found it good for dipping in the sauces. Everything was excellent. Give it a try, it is like a hidden secret on Nantucket.

It has been one hour and 30 minutes since we have been seated Everyone around us has eaten and left…read morewhile we are here without an appetizer After sitting for at least one hour, we asked the bartender, because the server was nowhere to be found, to help us locate our food we were appalled to find out that the food has only been put in 10 minutes prior Everyone around us, including those who arrived later, have gotten their food paid and left I am very disappointed however, I hope the food is good. Will keep you posted Update: We have finally received our food, I am both relieved and thankful. It was pretty good however we are still very disappointed about the wait and the service. Update 2: We were told my the table next to us to talk worn the staff, so we did. We told them about what happend and how tables that were seated after us got their food before us and had already left before our food had even arrived. They gave us a 10% discount which I Believe does not suffice because we had plans and now we are late.