Great food, great prices and family owned! Support local businesses. Try their Burger special. 1/2 the price of the others and bigger. read more

Solid little neighborhood spot. It's very dated and nostalgic inside. The cheese steaks hit the spot. read more

Sugar Bowl - diners waiting for customers - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Must Go! This place has everything! Severely overpriced and undersized wings? (they even keep the feathers on a few for a nice surprise treat) CHECK! Pizza crust that doesn't make the cut at Little Caesars? CHECK! And all for the low price of a midrange SUV! 10 wings and a large cheese pie for $41? How can you beat that! Overall I would rate this place 5 out of 100 Did I eat it? Couldn't afford not to:( read more

The Sugar Bowl was your basic American food type restaurant. It's good. I've only had a few things off their menu. I like their fries a lot! Their fried chicken wings are really good too; a little salty though. The people that work there are pretty friendly too. It is close to campus and they deliver which is great! Definitely helped when I was tired of campus food. Overall, a decent place. read more

I've always loved by the phrase "Even bad pizza is good pizza". I no longer use that phrase after having pizza from here. This place has aggressively awful pizza. I feel like they actively sabotage their pizza making somewhere in the chain. Greasy cheese? Check. Sauce that's been poured out of an old boot? Check. It smells like pizza. It looks like pizza. But by God, it's not pizza. Don't be fooled. read more

Don't waste your money--because you will waste it. I tried to complain about how my order was messed up and that dude couldn't care less. He said "I don't know what to tell you." The pizza was total garbage. read more

Delicious! Yesterday was our first time ordering and you never know what you're going to get, but we were pleasantly surprised. Really tasty pizza- cheesy, medium crust, cooked perfectly with a little cheesy caramelization on the crust. Salad was fresh, mixed greens (not old sad after thought iceberg). Delivery was fast for a Friday, overall very pleased and would definitely order again! read more

Nothing offensive. Nothing extraordinary. I went for the cheesesteak. Fine steak, fine amount, decent roll. Place is clean and service is nice (first time I've ever had a tip refused!). Again, nothing amazing. Looks like they're really trying to pull in the college crowd with all the fandm photos and sweaters on the walls. On a Saturday afternoon, it was me and a couple other old hats. I am glad it's located on this block. Every block needs a bit of grease, right? read more

See all

I recently ordered Sugar Bowl through a delivery app. This turned out to be a huge mistake and led to some absurd difficulties with the driver, and, to shorten a longer story, I had to drive down to grab my food. The guys in the restaurant, caught in the middle of this weird situation, were doing everything they could to ensure that I, the customer, had a good experience. The food was great (although I had to reheat it because of the previously alluded to problem) and their service was everything that it should have been. read more

Best cheesesteak stromboli around!!! The rest of the food is pretty good too but I definitely suggest the steak boli. And come hungry because the small is pretty big so you can imagine what the large is. read more

I live on this block, so eating at Sugar Bowl is about as frequent as walking out the front door. I like SB because it's a small operation (albeit "franchised" since there are two locations), everything is made to order and for what you pay you definitely get your money's worth. Once you pop your head in twice in one week, you're part of the elite regulars-of-Sugar Bowl society and are frequently treated to a free drink here or a 10% discount there. The owners know how to run a business and please their customers, so even if it's not a 5-star fine-dining establishment, it seems to manage a pretty regular customer base who repeatedly leave delighted and full. read more

I went here a lot when I dated a girl that went to Millersville. It was like the local eatery of choice for many students. The fries were good, the burgers not so much. Average pizza. We only went multiple times because we could walk from the dorm. read more

Pizza wasn't fresh looked like it was from 2 days ago with cheese and toppings put over it and burnt to a crisp to disguise it's oldness yuck never again read more

Ok, this place used to be famous pizza, now its a sugar bowl franchise. Im not that impressed really. I was going to hype it up for having veggie burgers, but the pizza tasted like grocery store frozen pizza. Credit cards are accepted, but they charge extra for orders of less than 10$. Street parking only, good luck finding a space. read more

Pretty awful pizza. Tastes like crappy frozen pizza. I've had better pizza at one of those pizza buffets.

I got their large three topping pizza and cheese fries for carry out. Three toppings I chose were black olives, spinach, and bacon. It was freaking good and my coworkers enjoyed the presentation of the pizza. Cheese fries were awesome as well. Fast service, and great food. read more

Had lunch with some colleagues today, and was pleasantly surprised at the good food and great service! Basic lunch menu, but nice quiet place and very friendly staff. read more

Perfectly fine little pizzeria near the college. A good cheesesteak does not exist in Lancaster but the ones here satisfy the craving. The rolls are pretty good and the meat is thinly sliced. Just your average lunch spot, nothing too special. Though they do have baklava at the counter which I appreciate. Service is always fast and friendly. Nice to have this place in the neighborhood. read more

Sugar Bowl is the schizzlebang. The pizza oh the pizza is so damn good. Light and fluffy crust and a nice light sweet sauce. I order the bacon and pineapple which has been deemed "Thee Lancastarian" by my roommate and I. The price is right and the apps are tasty treats. Even the grilled chicken caesar salada hits the spot. I highly recommend The Sugar Bowl on Lemon st. Staff is real cool too. read more

This is Sugar Bowl's second location, the original being in Millersville, PA near the university where I attended college. I have been a customer of Sugar Bowl for nearly 20 years. Anyone who knows will tell you their strombolis are fantastic, consistent between both locations, and sought after. Personally, I am partial to their cheesesteak/chicken cheesesteak strombolis which are flavorful and delicious. There is something unique about their dough and the way it crusts when it's baked that is highly appealing to me. The menu features mostly typical pizza shop items however being a Greek family run business they do offer some other items on their menu that are noteworthy including their baklava and chicken gyros. Service is always friendly and prompt. Prices are reasonable and they even feature daily specials which you can find on their website. Delivery is available to those within their service radius. The West Lemon Street location sits in a quiet neighborhood and always attracts locals. As I mentioned earlier, I have been a customer of Sugar Bowl for nearly 20 years and have never had a bad experience which speaks to their consistency and quality. read more

I love this place! It's my local pizza spot. They are always friendly! They have my order ready in 15minutes or less and they have never gotten an order wrong. The pizza is quite tasty and the prices are low. read more

The Strombolis are generous portions and delicious. I've never gotten better customer service at this little hole in the wall place on Nevin and Lemon. Fries are super crispy and they are pretty cheap so great for lunch. read more

best strombolis in lancaster, hands down. bolis are huge, amazing light crispy flakey outside, loads of cheese on the inside. pizza is average to slightly below average. read more

Sugar Bowl - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

I absolutely Love the Sugar Bowl on Lemon Street in Lancaster! The subs, pizza & wraps are "THE Best" !!! The Stromboli's are excellent & huge. They deliver Super-Fast, & the staff is sooo Friendly!! I order from here, on average, 6+ times/ month! Their food is addicting! Great coupons on menu & on online. A different daily special that is a great deal! read more

For strombolis and Phily cheese steaks, the Sugar Bowl is the place to go. The cheese steaks are better than the places that are higher rated. Probably because people haven't ever been to Sugar Bowl. Try the strombolis with sauce inside and request extra for putting it on top when you eat it. This is a great neighborhood place. read more

Great pies, great bolis. The owners are ultra-friendly, love what they do, and reward regulars.

The Sugar Bowl, in Lancaster, is run by the kind of people you wish you had in your family instead of the dysfunctional twits in your real family. It's a place I go when I don't want to go home. While eating their incredibly good cheeseburgers, cheeseburger subs and fries, I've studied, read, made decisions, and had long, meaningful conversations in the Sugar Bowl. I'd recommend it for everybody................C.G. Ferguson read more