I was so disappointed when I received my sub. At the Henderson, Ky location it looked liked slop…read moreon a platter. When you eat a sandwich you don't want it to get all over you. There was more lettuce, mayo and hot relish that the bread became soggy before I even got to eat it I've eaten at other locations and I really enjoyed their subs. But I honestly probably won't return I was so disappointed. I should have taken it back but I was headed out and didn't have the time. So I basically forced myself to eat this nasty sandwich because I was so hungry and wasn't about to spend another $12 on lunch. I hope they do better.

I've had two experiences here since its opening. Both great experiences. I ordered my food ahead on…read moreapp and picked up in store. My sandwiches have been prepared accurately, tasted great, and ready for pick up in a timely manner. I haven't had any interactions with staff yet. The store has been clean each time I enter. Will definitely continue to return and recommend to others.

Soooooo good! I wish I'd taken photos, but I was hangry (just ask my husband LoL!), and by the time…read moreI thought about it, our meals were nearly gone. My husband ordered the Cuban sandwich, and it was even better than the ones we order at a Cuban restaurant we frequent in Florida. I had the chicken breast platter, and oh my goodness, so delicious! With the platter you get to choose 2 different sauces. Upon the owner's (?) recommendation, I got the Jalapeno/Cilantro and Chimichuri. Yum! I couldn't decide which one was better! My 2 sides were also delicious. Everything was fresh and hot. My only complaint was the building needs a little TLC, especially the bathroom. It was clean, but the sink and door are in need of servicing. Also, the ventilation needs improvement. It got a bit smoky in the dining room. They have a nice outdoor area that I'm looking forward to taking advantage of when the weather is warmer. Small price to pay for the yummy food though, so it still gets 5 stars! Not sure if this is a franchise, but with better marketing/advertising, this restaurant would flourish!

Tried for the first time. The decor caught me first thing. Love the large Elvis statue as you…read morecome in. The place is very clean. Was greeted right off. Love the natural wood tables. Service was very fast. Would definitely recommend and added to our list of restaurants in Evansville.

So glad we stopped in. Such a small town feel with a great taste. The fried pickles were on point…read moresome of the best Ive ever had.

Total enjoyment. That describes my experience at the oldest continuous running tavern in Kentucky…read more The folks that work, there are extremely pleasant and capable. The tavern has an ambience that you expect for one of that age. This place is the real thing. A neighborhood spot that people of all ages can drop in and have some really good food at a decent price. They have a window that you can order ahead and pick up. I thoroughly enjoyed my cold beer and pork tenderloin sandwich. The slaw was delicious and different. My friend had the Coney dog. She absolutely loved it and said she dreamed about it the next week. Do yourself a favor and check this place out.

This was my first trip to Siciliano Subs. I was not familiar with the menu but the staff was very…read morehelpful in explaining each sandwich and helping me create something I would enjoy. All the food was fresh and very good! They load the sandwiches up so you definitely get your money's worth. I will be going back and recommending to everyone I know.

Everything we tried was amazing. It is a small place and you can tell a lot of people grab and go…read more No prices anywhere when we came in. But tbh they may have been changing things over. I believe all the prices were online. And I think they do a lot of online order then pickup. Two women behind counter never stopped cooking or cleaning. The entire time we were there. Very clean and welcoming even though it's small. If you get a chance try it. I heard they used Boars head meats. I think they do because it was good

I have celiacs and periodically travel to Evansville. THIS Jersey Mike's is my go to! The staff is…read moreknowledgeable, they have clean (gluten free) counters to prep gf sandwiches, and they even remember to change their gloves! It is rare a restaurant is this proactive so I hope they get recognized. I appreciate you all more than you know!!

This place caught me off guard. Assuming it's just another 'sub' chain, I was pleasantly wrong. The…read moreslice the meats when you order and the veggies seem incredibly fresh. Having it Mikes way is the only way. I greatly enjoy this place!

It is good but if I bought meat and bread it would be cheaper than just buying a sandwich.read more

Johnny has great quality meats at reasonable prices. He is accommodating when it comes to special…read moreorders and it's always spotless. He takes pride in his business. His sandwiches are generously portioned and still affordable! The slab bacon is the best cab in in town.

Something fishy going on here in a whale of a good way. They have a great seafood chowder, a bit…read morehigh bit so so so good. They have Mahi tacos, wings and a wide menu selection. Sunday the tall draft beers are just three dollars and the glass is extra cold. Summer offers up outside eating spots and a concert venue, summer fun spot. Inside is clean and welcoming with friendly service. Loved this fishy spot.

Fantastic wings with Korean bbq sauce, big and crispy. Sauce is sweat and tangy, I think it has a…read moreteriyaki base, don't brush off the chives they are add flavor. Greek salad is huge, fresh and delicious. My take out order was less than 10 minutes. Fun warms spot, staff is friendly.

We stop at Pips on road trips. I got The Danny Double burger (Two 2 oz. Mustard Seared…read moreHand-Smashed Beef Patties, Grilled Onions, Pickles, Two Slices American Cheese, Danny's 1000 Island Sauce on a Toasted Bun.). It was a nice burger. The burgers were seared well and the toppings gave it a big flavor. The fries have a brown sugar seasoning that sounds odd, but it's not overpowering and the fries are cooked well and not greasy. The staff are always great and the restaurant is clean and has a fun diner vibe. We'll be back!

Stopped on the way through for a work trip. Service was quick. Food was good. We must have hit an…read moreoff time as it was pretty quiet. Looks like they have a decent bourbon selection too! Everyone at our table enjoyed the meal!

Looking for unique off the beaten path lace, this is the place for coffee, muffins, breakfast or…read morelunch. Charming vintage house, surrounded by cornfields, with outdoor seating, offered us a peaceful setting to enjoy our special coffee, breakfast casserole and bubble waffles. The service makes you feel very welcomed. We would recommend and will stop again.

Lunch here was pretty good. We got box lunches. The club sandwich was massive. It also came with…read morechips and a cookie and the cookie was also massive but good. The potato soup was seasoned well even though it had gotten cold. Also I don't think it was stirred up well because I had huge chunks of cream cheese which were not edible. The pasta salad was cooked well but a little sweet for my taste. In general probably pasta salad or soup in a box lunches but don't need both.

Stopped in for a coffee & baked treat while doing a walking-tour of the town. Cookies, chocolate…read moredipped pretzels, bars and other treats filled the bakery case -- we split a berry bar, which was delicious. Sandwiches & other "full meal" options available if you're interested! Staff was friendly, indoor seating is was closed off, staff were behind a partition/ masked & hand sanitizer was provided.

Stopped in for a brunchy treat with my sister and niece. We ordered the maple pecan French toast…read more$5, an apple pastry $4 and a rosemary biscuit $2.25. While I thought the price was a little much, the food was delicious. I will definitely be back