The clutch was slipping on my 2010 Honda Accord with about 84K on it. I was impressed by Suburban's web site, warranties, and comments from customers. I was given an estimate for clutch replacement and 5th gear repair of $2000. I was told he couldn't get a Luk clutch (his normal supplier) and had to get an OEM clutch from a dealer. I asked about the web site warranty discussion, and he said that only applied to automatic transmissions -- I guess I should have asked about manual transmission warranties specifically before the repair. Mike sounded extremely knowledgeable and, while it took longer than expected (my wife thinks it was about 2 weeks), I was happy enough. They're very busy.
Nine months and 12K miles later, the clutch is slipping again (just occasionally this time), and I bring it in on Tuesday. That afternoon, I get a call from one of someone in the office that my clutch is burned out and I need a replacement. I'm shocked a clutch, driven primarily by my wife who has driven a clutch for 30 years, would wear out so soon. The guy (not Mike) said he was sure they could cut me a deal on the labor -- maybe charging me either nothing or their cost of labor, about $200 -- but nothing was said about charging me for parts, which sounded like it was covered under warranty. When would it be done? He'd try for late Wednesday, maybe Thursday. On Wednesday, I get a call from Mike, telling me that everything in the clutch was operating perfectly and the wear was caused by driver error. I was upset. He asked for a copy of my original receipt, so he could see where he got the clutch from (I guess to try to get a replacement under warranty). I thought it was strange his shop didn't keep records of the parts used in his jobs, but he said his Quickbooks system didn't keep that information and they don't keep paper copies.
After I scrambled around to find our receipt (which didn't have any information about the parts or supplier) and faxing it to him, I waited. Later Thursday, he calls back and says he can order a new OEM pressure plate but it wouldn't be in until Monday, or get a new Luk clutch kit sooner. We agreed to use the Luk kit since he wasn't sure there might be something awry with the OEM product and that he rarely had any trouble with the Luk kit. He thought he could get one for about $350 or $400 (which he would pay himself) but I would be charged $400 for the labor -- about the full cost of labor. Could be ready Friday.
On Friday morning I call, and he says it will be done Monday. When I pick up the car on Monday, I see Mike but someone else shows me the old clutch plate and why they replaced it. He says they used the OEM parts (made in Japan) for the job, which surprised me. The new receipt says "Replace Clutch, Pressure Plate" with $400 under the labor column. Now I'm not sure what parts of the failed clutch system got replaced, since we had discussed a partial replacement of the OEM system vs. complete replacement with Luk. Did he get the replacement parts under warranty from his supplier (arguing that the parts were defective?), and did I end up paying the full cost (just labor) of the replacement? Based on our agreement to use the Luk system and then finding they had put in OEM parts again, that sounds plausible.
The clutch is much tighter than it was before, engaging more decisively, so I hope I won't have the same slipping problem we had before. It's clear that this installation is different than the original one.
If I had problems again, would I go back. No. Was I happy with their customer service? No -- Mike argued it was all driver fault, and I can't tell if he bore any of the cost of the replacement. I spent a lot of money on the original repair, and I guess I'm happy I didn't pay another $1000 for a replacement, but my experience with Suburban was not a happy one.
P.S. When I picked up my car, there was a new gouge in the front door (small scratch down to the metal, no dent) -- it's a small and crowded parking lot. Also, my battery had been disconnected and reconnected, since my radio was asking for its security code. read more