The only redeeming thing about this place is that they are open later than any other bagel shops by a couple hours. The main thing is ... these bagels are average. They taste and are the size of bagels you'd get at a Wegmans, or a supermarket. They don't have that very, very lightly crispness on the outside with a flurrier inside. These are dense and as you can see by my pictures, they don't get really thick like the better bagel stores. The price is also pretty crazy. 7 bagels and two containers of cream cheese was almost $40. That's just plain robbery, especially for an average, or below, bagel. I think the pre-packaged cream cheese was around ten bucks per 16 oz. and it tasted like store bought cream cheese with scallions mixed in. It didn't have that kind of sour punch that cream cheese from the city has. The staff was also really flat and seemed gruff. I am sure it was towards the end of their day ... but a little smile or even a 'thanks for your business' would have gone a long way. I def. won't be back here. Nothing beats a NYC bagel but there are places on Long Island that are almost as good. This is not. Even if the bagels were half the price, I likely wouldn't bother with the calories Being closer to the city, I would have expected better than Suffolk County bagels but honestly, Huntington and Hauppague have some real nice spots read more

Stuff A Bagel - Thin, dense bagels. - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

It's breakfast/lunch time. This bagel shop, on Main Street smells like fresh bagels when you walk in. It's clean and there are ample tables that turn over quickly for a seat. A large, large selection of food available that's posted on the walls. The staff is friendly. But here's the issue....if you come in and order what you'd like they pretty consistently charge you higher prices without taking into account the breakfast or lunch deals (i.e. a discounted side salad or drink). There are so many specials and options it's impossible to know if the price is correct and the few times I've come here I have overpaid a few dollars. It's expensive but the bagels and food are really good. read more

See all

Tell ya one thing - I will absolutely never be back. $8.15 ($7.50 plus tax) for two eggs with bacon on a roll? That's obscene. Especially seeing as the menu lists two eggs with bacon & cheese for $7.30 plus tax... so, I'm being charged more for a sandwich with no cheese? Make it make sense. The sandwich also had only two slices of bacon on the entire thing. For these prices? That's gross. I also asked three times while ordering not to cut my sandwich, and of course it was cut. Never again. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

One dozen bagels were $22.00, lacked taste and texture..... Cream Cheese walnut 1/2 pound $8.81, had some maple syrup in it.... cream cheese scallion 1/2 pound $7.83. Keep looking for a bagel store, reminded me of supermarket bagels alot. read more

I am never ordering from Stuff a Bagel ever again! Aside from their horrible customer service and ridiculously high pricing, they have the nerve to add a $3 charge for delivery. This place was SO MUCH BETTER with the old owners. read more

A community staple. Clean. Quick. Efficient. Expansive menu. Everything is top tier. Sometimes I come in for their cream cheese and use for the week. The veggie is my fave. A big time yea for me. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Egg and cheese everything - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Finally a bagel store; nay a business; with fair prices. Bravo for charging a normal amount for delicious items. They provided me with a breakfast that I love and they didn't make me leave feeling guilty about spending a lot more than I should have. For that i will want to return. Thanks guys and good luck to this business in the heart of Farmingdale. read more

Got a dozen to take home and glad I did. First time trying them and I'd get again. They were large and soft like my wife likes - I prefer firmer, but they were very good. Toasted well and made good cheese and lox on a bagel. A young man helped me and was pleasant and polite. read more

This establishment is by far the worst I've ever encountered. Living just 0.2 miles away, I've given them multiple chances due to the convenience, but almost every single time, something is wrong with the order. Usually, we end up dealing with missing items or simply not eating what they got wrong. When we've called to let them know, the response is always a casual "Sorry, would you like to come back and exchange it?" Today, after yet another incorrect order, I was told, "We think we gave you the right sandwich, but in the future, we can open it in front of you to check." The lack of accountability was astonishing. I realized I've been the sucker here, spending around $50 every time for my family of five, only to receive rude service and consistent mistakes. I told them I wouldn't be returning, and their response was a simple, "Okay, thank you." This establishment is not well kept at this point, careless, and completely unprofessional. Save yourself the hassle--there are far better places to spend your money. - F-Dale lifer read more

Stuff A Bagel - Recite for 2 in this instance - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I ordered breakfast items via DoorDash. The bagel and flavored cream cheese was typical but good although the bagel was a little hard. The egg and cheese on a roll sandwich however was awful. The egg was ridiculously small and hardly any cheese. It tasted awful too. Almost as if the egg was fried on a cooktop that needed to be cleaned. read more

I don't want to call this the last resort - that honor goes to G&L although I'd probably starve before eating there again, but certainly not where I look to go when I want a bagel. We'll just call it plan B since it's what typically happens when the bagel cravings arrive but the line at Bagel Hut is out the door. Don't get me wrong, the food isn't awful, but it certainly isn't memorable either. And I'd probably go 3 stars if not for the gruff service and nazi like adherence to the $10 minimum for using a card. Literally was 15 cents shy and told I had to either order something else or pay cash. Walking out on already made bagels didn't seem to phase them. Long story - go around the corner to bagel hut if you can, come here if you must read more

This place is run by half wits and people who don't care about customer service. If they make a mistake they blame you. The lady speaks heavy Spanish and is very slow and gets mad. This is why easy orders are always wrong. They ask you three times for a simple thing AND STILL MESS UP and give you an attitude. It is simply not worth it. Owner your place will be run down by these people that's not good customer service here. And I guarantee you've lost customers already for over priced items and fake prices. What a shame .. me and my family will never be ordering here again. They simply do not care STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE read more

Terrible bagel shop The right is an everything bagel, the left is a sesame bagel. The 2 everything nagels we got were literally 30% smaller. Not sure what the benefit of this is but it sucks. The bagels are gummy, just low quality, the tuna tastes old. Just not good. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Not good - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I went in for 2 sandwiches and they were excellent. The bagel were soft and sizeable. The amount of food was substantial. The associate that took my orders was very engaged and careful that I get what I ordered. The decor was simple and clean. I will recommend if your in the area try it and see if I am correct. read more

See all

Great food, service was slow for me but I was noticing it was who I ordered with because the other staff members were quick. I saw people going and coming with bakers dozens, sandwiches and all while I waited for 2 sandwiches. Again my guy slow but others fast. Also good place to hang out and eat if you wanted. read more

What a fantastic find on our visit to the Island this weekend. Fast service, friendly staff, perfect bagels and hot coffee. Enough seating for all their customers and a great array of spreads and menu items. So glad we stopped in! read more

See all

The food is mediocre but passable. The service is not up to par. But the place is acceptable if you want to go coffee and a bagel alone or with a friend. The coffee has room for improvement. read more

When I go to LeChe,which is conveniently across the street from Stuff A Bagel, I always stop there for a snack. I love their chocolate croissant and their bagels. They are still practicing social distancing, they have plexiglass where you place & pickup orders and also their tables at each end have plexiglass and they are also adequately distanced from one another. It is on Main Street Farmingdale NY where there are so many great places to shop, eat or just window shop. I hear that they have great paninis! Next time, I will try a panini. read more

See all

Bagel and sandwhich we had were fine - service good no complaints. However we wont go back- it was filthy! floors dont look like they are ever even swept . The corners and edges of floors black! Tables look like never wiped down. Thats bad enough but the bathrooms were gross!! Makes you wonder what kitchen looks like. read more

I was surprised to read some of the reviews about this shop. It's not close to my home, but I come here each time I photograph an event in the area and have have never been disappointed. While they have a beautiful array of food, I am usually doing a bagel with topping. O.K. So what do I look at to rate "Stuff A Bagel" I walk into a big bright restaurant and have always been greeted with a big smile and hello. Any line has always moved quickly and efficiently. I have always received what I've ordered... quickly. They have a HUGE selection of specialty sandwiches and a nice variety of hot dishes. Not just a bagel place here but a full service deli with very reasonable pricing. My bagels have always been fresh. What do I mean by that? If you've ever had a bagel that's been sitting around all day, you'll know what I mean. I like their coffee bar too. Simply, pay and then take care of whatever you want and there is plenty to choose from. There is plenty of seating and could easily handle the meat eater as well as the vegetarian. I can't tell you about their vegan selections. Thumbs up for "Stuff A Bagel." read more

See all

Bagels good. Cream cheese was a little funky. Came after Saturday am rush. Possibly didn't have a chance to refresh? Terrible customer service + absolutely filthy. read more

Excellent staff, friendly environment, fast service, great food & coffee. Being located in the "downtown" area close to the LIRR makes it very convenient for commuters. Highly recommend this location. read more

Ordered blueberry pancakes they were over sized and not in a good way. One was actually burnt and the others were undercooked. The pancake batter was not cooked all the way through. The bacon was fatty and extra greasy. Very disappointing experience for the money I spent. read more

I just came in for the first time because it was near where I dropped off my dog for grooming. It was a raining cold grey day and i just wanted a cup of coffee. The coffee seemed a bit watered down, but could have been that day. They definitely had unusual breakfast menu items for the holidays. The bagel shop was noticeably not as busy as you would expect on a Sunday morning. I did enjoy sitting on a high chair looking out the street sidev window on a raining day drinking my coffee though. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

They seem to consistently get orders wrong. As of most recently, I just ordered a very simple wrap but they left out lettuce tomato and bacon. read more

First off lemme say that I know this is just a bagel spot and I shouldn't be expecting the world. Second off.... F THAT I get to work and I'm like instead of the Chinese food or pizza lemme try to be more healthy and *thinks long and hard* DING DING! "I'll just get a Chix Caesar wrap from the bagel place I've never been too" I love Chix caesars and I'm all hype I'm doin good on my diet. I call ahead, go pay the chick, head back to my job and the more I walk the more I'm concerned about how light my bag is. SON I open the bag up ready to go to town, I couldn't even go to apartment... The sh*t was shorter than my index finger, I've never in my life seen a wrap this small, I even took a pic for comparison smh. So after I show my coworkers to make sure I'm not buggin (they agreed).. and I accepted that my hunger wouldn't be satisfied, I'm like Ight, maybe what it doesn't pack in size, it packs in flavor... NOPE not even close. Smallest AND worse wrap I've ever had and wasted 8-9 dollars on crap. ..I wouldn't even go back for a plain bagel wit butter. 0 stars read more

Stuff A Bagel - It's a WRAP on ever going back here - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

If I could give zero stars I would ! This place used to be amazing but now new owners it's disgusting. I'm a New Yorker I know what a good bagel should taste like and this is not it . The bagels are like rubber and the store itself is filthy. Find a new place this one will it last ! read more

People always recommend this place on the Farmingale message boards, and after trying it for the first time I wonder if they were paid, or just never venture out past Main Street for something better. I ordered an egg on a bagel for breakfast and an italian wrap for lunch later. The egg sandwich was fine. Not bad, but nothing spectacular either. The reason for this review is the Italian wrap. It was, how do I put this nicely...not good. No lettuce, no tomato, no onion, or any of the usual toppings. Just meat and cheese trapped in a sad little tortilla, no bigger than the size of a Hot Pocket. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Saddest little wrap I've ever seen. - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Delicious bagels were nice and fresh this morning! I love a fresh warm bagel to start the day. The bagel was a bit smaller than some other local shops, but still good. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Egg everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

If you want to play egg sandwich roulette, try this place! I ordered 3 egg sandwiches on rolls, and every single one was wrong, even though I watched them write down and confirmed the order. They forgot to even make one. We got home and realized one was missing, one was covered in mayo, and one was drenched in ketchup even though I specified absolutely no ketchup. We went back, and the girl at the counter completely denied that the order was wrong. Another worker attempted to help us and remade one, but made us give the original bagels back. Ew? And then I assume he just gave her the same bagel because once again we returned home, and it was covered in ketchup. I called, and they argued that the order was correct , and made me text them a picture for proof because I simply asked to be refunded because I was not going back a third time. I was put on hold 3 times and had to explain myself over and over. Lets see if my order is refunded in the 3-4 business days they said it would take, or else I'll simply just report the charge to my bank. Never again, unless I want to be surprised with my order. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Hate to edit a review but since Phil and his wife transferred ownership it's not the same. Bagels taste too yeasty and they have moved away from their base business model. I hope it makes a comeback read more

Rude new owners!! Demand 10 dollar minimum on debit cards Don't care if you spend a lot of money and are steady customer!! And orders for egg sandwiches take way to long !! Get half star for attitude and customer service!!! read more

Overpriced, slow service. The same clerk every morning at open of business seems to not have a clue how to operate the register. Extremely frustrating when this happens days in a row after calling in an order ahead of pickup to minimize wait time in the store on my commute to work. I'm done wasting my time and money at Stuff A Bagel. $13 for bagel with cream cheese and lox with a Snapple? Outrageous. read more

They are worthy of their name. They truly stuff those bagels fr. And all the staff are pleasant asf

Worst egg platter in farmingdale!! Barely any potatoes and they were soggy. I used to order from here a lot but now I remember why I stopped coming here. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

I had the pesto chicken wrap and it sounded like it would taste really delicious. I found out that the pesto sauce tasted nothing but grass. I felt like I was literally chewing my food from the ground. I've never had a sandwich I've been so disgusted with my entire life. The one star is for effort. Do not recommend read more

I recently hosted a bridal brunch for my daughter and decided to have it catered. My husband always gets bagels and cold cuts on Sunday mornings from Stuff A Bagel ~ but we've never had anything catered from there before. I spoke with Amanda on the phone and ordered everything in a matter of minutes. When my husband went to pick up the order it was all packed beautifully and ready to go ! Our guests were so complimentary of the food and presentation ~ and it came with so many goodies including butter and jelly ~ 3 types of cream cheese and even OJ!!! Everyone raved about the French toast bake ! I will definitely be ordering from them again . read more

This place is constantly screwing up my order until I finally had my last straw today. I ordered a sandwich which comes with chicken, mozzarella and red peppers. I triple checked and there is NO TOMATO on the menu board at all. I ordered the sandwich with "no red peppers". The cashier put the order in correctly because my receipt read "no peppers". I went back to my office and ate half my sandwich when suddenly I started feeling sick. I am allergic to tomatoes!!! And for a sandwich that isn't even supposed to come with tomatoes they decided to put them on for no reason. These people have zero sensitivity for allergies and the people who make the sandwiches can CARE LESS about serially injuring someone with their wreckless behavior. Completely unacceptable! Do NOT go there if you have ANY food allergies. They simply do NOT CARE!!! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Is Egg shells a thing to have in sandwiches? Because just about every time I give this place a try I get egg shells in my eggs and it's a significant amount. Next time I order should I say hold the eggs shells? I mean seriously. I haven't gone here for eggs in over a year bc of this and I try to not leave negative reviews but everything seems good about this place except for the eggs. I started going to the Stuff A Bagel in the Massapequa/Amityville shopping center because they are way better. I'm giving 3 stars for the drink selections and to the ones that give great customer service behind the counter. The young lady today was very sweet. But that's about it. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Egg shells - Bagels Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Ordered a fried egg and ham opened it up very little ham on one side none on the other I wish they would give be what I paid for with out customers they would have no business read more