Went on a Sunday morning and the line was out the door but moved quick! The staff was very nice and patient even with the line. The parking lot is small on the side of the building, noticed many people parking on the street on the side/back. There was a little path to the road. Bagels were very good! Lots of cream cheese on it. The maple walnut cream cheese was very good in the French toast bagel. The bagel sandwich was good as well! read more

See all

Coffee was delicious, my blueberry danish was delicious, and my bacon, egg, cheese bagel was delicious! There was a line almost out the door and we didn't wait longer than a few minutes for our entire order! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Blueberry & Cream Cheese Danish - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Popped in while traveling because I am always looking for a good bagel.... The visual of the bagels is good- nice size and shine. I ordered bacon l, egg and cheese on a poppy - not toasted. Again the visual was great - fried eggs are a plus. I poked the bagel and it felt dense and I was looking forward to that first bite. Bagel - 7, very airy inside and smooshed flat as a pancake as soon as I picked it up. Everything inside - cold! The egg was rubbery, no melting cheese, the bacon was stiff. Disappointed. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bacon egg cheese on a poppy not toasted - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

My favorite bagel place. They make them fresh at this location. And the service is nice and quick. I love the salted bagel toasted with scallions cream cheese. You know it's good when the local people visit it. Enjoy read more

The food, and service is phenomenal! It's a small place with a few tables, but we always get our order to go, so it's fine. The people are kind and helpful. read more

Love the everything bagel - savory exterior and chewy interior. Pairs nicely with their home made cream cheeses - we've tried plain, strawberry cream cheese (my daughter's favorite) and an AMAZING olive cream cheese. They also make really good breakfast sandwiches. I've yet to grab lunch here - but I'm sure it would be good. It's worth noting that the service is friendly and attentive - it's clear they're cool under pressure as the place is generally always busy. read more

Tried the Jersey Turnpike. It was ok. I prefer their BLT or BEC. Service is always fast and friendly!! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Jersey Turnpike on everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Came to this place while on vacation in the summer. It's definitely the spot to go to and very popular. I will say for the few breakfast sandwiches we got, it was pricey but definitely delicious. Stop by if you down in Florida and want a yummy fresh bagel. read more

Always fresh bagels, made on site. Customer service is top notch. Never a bad experience.

I've been craving a good bagel for a while and I found this location this past week. Everyday that I've gone everything has been great! It's always super busy but the service is amazing. I will be returning to this location EVERYTIME I want a bagel. The staff is great & very welcoming. read more

Good place for a bagel can get pretty busy and not alot of seating if you like to dine in.

Friends of ours who had visited before insisted we had to try this locally-owned, NY style bagel shop and bakery. They gave the breakfast here a glowing review, so we came in with some level of expectation. Overall, we were satisfied. The food was quite fairly priced; my bagel sandwich was only $6.50 and plenty filling. My husband and I both thought there could have been a little more flavour to our sandwiches, but they were still tasty. We ate as a group inside the shop, and everyone was uncomfortably warm by the end of our meal, as it was very hot inside the shop-- not terribly surprising since it's a small spot, and the kitchen area frying up food is right there, but it's unusual to walk outside in Florida in September and find it refreshing! We will definitely be back at some point, though. I'd like to try more of their menu out. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Counter area - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Someone mentioned to me about this place. We purchased bialys, knishes, and everything bagel. We are from NYC so we were excited to try it. Knishes were great! Bialys were kind of big and doughy was sad not the same, as back in NY, I ate it anyway with lots of chewing. Bagel was ok. Ambiance was great, service can be improved with a smile and be happy to serve the clients. Someone gave me another location in Punta Gorda that sells bagels and my traditional food. read more

Good place to get a bagel. The Jersey Turnpike is the breakfast sandwich to get. Good selection of bagels

just amazing! new to the area from Chicago, so the food culture has changed a lot! been searching for a good bagel place and THIS is the spot. feels straight out of new york. friendly, hospitality, amazing food! and overall just a amazing vibe read more

Ugh. The driest thing I've ever tried to eat. Absolutely horrendous. Turkey and cheese melt. Former New Yorker and these bagels are just over boiled garbage. Macaroni salad is from a giant pail that's delivered by a food service. Don't waste your time on a $12 bagel "sandwich". Super nice people who work there though! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Turkey and cheese melt -drier than the Sahara Desert and flavorless - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

We stopped into Stuff A Bagel for a pickup order of a dozen bagels and some whitefish salad. They have a deli counter and a few tables. The service was friendly, quick and efficient. The bagels and fish salad were delicious. The bagels stayed fresh for few days. We will definitely go back the next time we are in the area. read more

Well the bagels are fantastic and the portion is not skimpy the only issue I have are the flies and the AC vents YOU MUST CHANGE your filters & REPLACE OR PAINT THE VENTS FLIES REQUIRE A FAN ABOVE THE DOORS I'll update if it changed read more

See all

We have lived in Cape Coral for over four years and we've heard nothing but good things about this place. I finally got around to try it and I can't believe that I've been missing out all these years. It's a super cute take out with very friendly service! I got the asiago cheese bagel with cream cheese on it which I would recommend. The cream cheese was whipped and was absolutely amazing and they don't skimp on it either!! I hear that the everything bagel with cheese and egg is supposed to be great as well. That will be my next venture because I will definitely be back! read more

Stuff A Bagel - a man in a bakery - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

I have been here many times and it never disappoints! The food is always cooked to order and hot, and the service is pretty fast for always having a line out the door. It feels like you're in a New York bagel shop and the staff are on top of it in there. It's a smaller location, but they filter people in and out quick which is nice. My only tip is - make sure to ask for your bagel toasted if you want it that way! They don't ask, you have to tell yourself. I feel like I'm there a few times a month at least - so good! read more

See all

We absolutely love this place and so does everyone else apparently!!! Weekends always have a line(which moves quickly) and the reason is because it's so good! read more

Great NY style bagels . We were in the area visiting and was looking for a bagel place Definitely recommend it.

The bagels were delicious, the people were nice as well. A must try for breakfast or lunch.

Stopped here after a haircut at the Carpenter's Chair next door. I'd never been here so asked them what was most popular. They says the Jersey Turnpike. It's pork, cheese and fried egg on an everything bagel. Only $6! Delicious! They have a great dejection if bagels and sandwiches here. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Jersey Turnpike. - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Just visited this location for the first time. Bagels were very good; coffee not so much. We're happy to welcome stuff a bagel to the old bagel factory location. The only thing keeping them from being successful will b the coffee....very bitter. Hopefully they read their reviews and take it to heart. read more

Great bagels! They are the first local bagels I've had that can compete with northeast bakeries. There are okay bagels that look like what I'm used to but I was so missing the chewy inside. These are perfect with a nice assortment of flavors. read more

One of the few items that was ordered was a BLT and it was very disappointing. 1 slice of tomato and 3 pieces of bacon, not what I expected when ordering a BLT that costs $12. read more

Stuff A Bagel - BLT - lack of - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Great bagels and prices! Biggest con is their phone systems they have for all of their Cape Coral locations. It either goes straight to voicemail or claims it's not a working number every single time. Not ideal for when you are on the go. read more

Food and service both excellent. Stuff A Bagel provide a superior product. I had a bagel with cream cheese and lox very very enjoyable. I also bought a half dozen onion bagels, which were fresh and great tasting very much like a good New York bagel. read more

Used to be my favorite place to go since I left New Jersey, and unfortunately it's not worth it anymore. First told at 10am there are ZERO rolls...which ok, they get very busy. I can understand that. So I continue to order a Jersey Turnpike(pork roll egg and cheese) on a croissant with salt pepper and ketchup. And I get this. 99% egg and 2 very thin slices of pork roll, and no salt pepper and ketchup. I get maximizing profit, but this is a completey different level. It's not worth the drive across town anymore. Save a trip and find something else. read more

Stuff A Bagel - After being told at 10am there are no rolls whatsoever, I pay almost $7 for a pork roll egg and cheese sandwich and get this. Ridiculous - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Recently new to the area! We usually do not do breakfast. However this morning we had stuffed bagel and oh my. The bagel was yummy and they do not slack on the meat! The home fries were even yummy. We will definitely be back I suggest stuff a bagel to any looking for a light breakfast! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Stuff A Bagel, Pine Island Rd., Cape Coral, Fl., Here is my 2 cents on the food and chatter. I was nearby and wanted something different plus sweet. So I got a raspberry danish and a reuben. About 15 bucks The reuben with a small portion of cole slaw and a small danish tasted very good. The problem is everything is SMALL & PRICEY. I think because we are in a OVER PRICED TOURIST AREA they charge too much and the local yodels of floridians let them get away with it. read more

Stuff A Bagel - small over priced - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Not worth a second trip for me. The bagels were decent for this area but not a great bagel. Had the "nothing to write home about" nova on bagel with light onion and capers. The onion was chopped in hunks instead of thin rings, the cream cheese is whipped and very fluffy and oozes out of bagel, I prefer mine not whipped or just a slight whip. ( I understand a business using that to save money) I also thought it was strange that even though I was dinning in, it was wrapped in paper and put in a bag. I sat down and proceeded with my mediocre coffee to put cream and sugar... they had fake stuff in a dispenser but I'm a "real cream" kind of coffee drinker. The tiny cream cups in a bucket I peeled one by one trying to get my desired taste and I noticed... curdling I expect it to happen, it's hot...but that's why you try and avoid that with ice or some sort of refrigeration..a insulated chilled pitcher of half and half would have been nice. I get they don't want to clean the pitcher, but...love is in the details when it comes to a kitchen IMO. I was given a new cup and offered milk, (not half n half like I wanted) from the kitchen, I agreed as I didn't want the fake stuff, so they poured it in the cup from the back room and brought it to me...not light enough but, I took it, they were busy and seemed a little disorganized. I did notice that no one came to remove the basket of creamer cups, I guess it's like a box of chocolates...some are good, some not so much, maybe you get lucky. On my way there I called ahead and ordered a 1/2 lb of tuna salad and two pumpernickel bagels to take home. I love real good deli tuna... this was not that. It was a darker tuna fish and had a very fishy smell. I noticed they had "white fish" salad on the menu board, tuna? Idk...I did not inquire. The place is small, and feels neglected. About four tables that people were continually using and leaving and next group grabs, not a single table was wiped down nor was the coffee station checked, I was there about an hour. The staff seemed distracted but very friendly and polite. I live in punta gorda and usually would drive down to The Bagel Factory several times a month, they had fantastic bagels (although they were cooked at the ft myers bagel factory) related by name only as I understand. They also had a very clean and inviting sit down area with excellent flavored and unflavored coffee urns to serve yourself and cream dispensers. They served their items in boxes that could be used as plates or to go, and you got chips and a pickle with the food, and their tuna was top notch; Totally different experience... they have gone out of business (owner retired) and I am in search of another great coffee/bagel/lox/tuna spot. Hard to find in this area. I tried stuff a bagel...which is an even further trek for me but I had hope. Ft myers at the other bagel factory is where I know they have great bagels, but was told their other things were all the choice of owner, so I will have to try and see how they are, stay tuned. The reason I did not go directly to other bagel factory was distance, the cape is closer, but I am looking for an excuse to go to Ft Myers. In the mean time, stuff a bagel is ok for grab n go decent to meh bagel only, better than store bought for sure. read more

Good bagels. Great for breakfast or lunch! Egg salad looked yummy. Want to try it next time. Great displays of homemade cream cheese options. read more

When I tell you, if there's one thing I'm picky about, it's a bagel joint. I'm notorious for the quick walk-in walk-out if the vibes aren't there.... But I walked in to Stuff A Bagel and I'm glad I stayed, you know it's legit when there's Seinfeld on the television, the NYT on the counter, a chatty older gentleman at a table with a tall cup of hot coffee and gold pinky ring on. We ordered a lox deluxe on onion and a pastrami on everything, y'know what else we got? YOO-HOO IN THE CAN (another staple sign of legitimacy) and a pound of rainbow cookies (which are impossible to find half decent in SW Florida) everything we ordered was divine, the pastrami was beautiful and mouthwatering, the bagel tops shiny and just an absolute treat. We'll be back soon! read more

Fresh good bagels with great cream cheese options. Classic bagel shop plus they do a variety of sandwiches for breakfast and lunch. Stopped by around 10 am and it was packed! Only waited maybe 5 mins to get my bagel. Only slightly disappointed that my bagel wasn't warm (even though I asked for it toasted) it was still good. If your in the area looking for a bagel this is an easy quick option. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Onion bagel with plain cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

The bagels are so delicious. Bagel with corn beef and pastrami and Egg and cheese on a Bagel sandwich is hot and tasty. Stuff a Bagels has soft fresh tasty bagels. read more

I was born and bred in northern NJ and these bagels honestly taste like grocery store bagels. They also gave me thin sliced deli ham and called it Pork Roll. Uh...no thank you. At least half the employees (including the cashier) were unmasked--at the height of the pandemic. Will definitely not be back. read more

Food : $$$$ I've been going to Stuff A Bagel for 18 + years and the bagels are the best we have in the area. Recently, I visited one morning for a ham/egg/cheese bagel (no drink) and was charged a little more than $8; I believe ~8.50 out the door. Unless the recipe has changed this is a single egg, one thinly sliced piece of ham and single piece of cheese. I know the costs of food are going up; however, the sandwich really doesn't justify the cost of it. Cape Coral is not really a destination paradise; however, for the sandwich I received I feel I'm being changed what I would pay in an airport, at a vacation island area or maybe Disney World. So, why I'm I writing this email about a place that I obviously like? With my family of 4, all getting the same thing it would cost ~$35 with tax and credit card transaction fee. The prices online are very much different then on the wall today; I would suggest the owner take down the online menu until it is updated. Regarding the star rating, the food is okay for the area but not worth the price being charged. Therefore 2-stars rating. The service has always been average. The build is located in a stipe plaza near Winn-Dixie and ACE hardware, with around seven, 2 to 4 seat tables. read more

Quality service in a very friendly and welcoming environment. The food is great and the people are the best. We accidentally ordered our bagels and forgot to get them toasted, we asked for two more and the quickly made them on the house. Highly recommend read more

Stuff A Bagel - Sesame seed bagel with chive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida