Claims to have proper NY bagels. It's a small place with about 10 tables & lots of takeout. Staff was just a bit surly but not offensive. The bagels were better than I have had in a long time. And, they have Egg & egg everything bagels. No one in FL seems to make them. Enjoyed the kitschy decor. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Egg bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

Food was tasty service was quick, inside is like a New York bagel shop themed. Got the pumpkin spice bagel and the lox bagel sandwich read more

See all

According to my New Yorker friend this is a taste of nostalgia with vibes from the city. My SWFL-born self was content to find a simple bagel spot. Enjoyed a bacon egg and cheese sandwich on a sesame bagel. Bagel quality was fantastic, but the remaining sandwich ingredients were greasy and not up to par with the bagel. I'd go again when in the specific mood, but I wish there was more stuffing in the bagel, especially given the name of the business. read more

Ahhh...takes you back to NYC! Great NY style bagels, great spreads, good iced coffee! The menu is pretty big for a small establishment like this but they kept those orders coming out of the kitchen and keeping their customers happy. I loved the in house made bagel chips - what an awesome way to utilize bagels! While obviously the bagels are the main attraction here don't dismiss the danishes and the turnovers. Sooooo good! read more

See all

Top 5 bagel for me! This is authentic New York and I will be coming back every time I'm in town. They were also pretty quick and the girls working were very nice! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Lox Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese Deluxe on jalapeño cheddar - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

If you're in Southwest Florida and craving a taste of New York, Stuff A Bagel is a must-visit. Walking in, the vibe immediately transports you to the heart of the New York, with the bustling energy and the unmistakable aroma of freshly baked bagels. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, always ready with suggestions. I recently tried the Turkey Reuben on marbled rye and it was delicious. The tanginess from the sauerkraut pairs perfectly with the savory turkey, creating a balance of flavors that's just the right amount of bold without overpowering the taste of the bagel. For those with a sweeter tooth, the French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese is a delight. It has the perfect balance of sweetness, ideal for anyone looking to indulge. But my personal favorite has to be the cream cheese with smoked salmon. Every time I visit, I make sure to grab a container of this flavorful spread. It's simple, yet absolutely delicious, and the smokiness from the salmon makes it the perfect bagel spread. The shop offers an impressive range of sandwiches, making sure there's something for everyone. They even had knishes! Whether you're in the mood for a savory classic or a sweet morning bite, they've got you covered. It's a cozy spot that brings a little taste of New York to the sunny shores of Florida--definitely a place you'll want to return to time and time again. read more

See all

Great little bagel place located on Daniels in Ft. Myers. David was doing a Yelp Elite Review while I just came along for lunch. The staff is very friendly and I had a lovely omelet with ham, veggies and cheese and a sesame seed bagel. It was delish and very filling! I love being able to have breakfast at any meal and stuff a bagel won't disappoint! They have a large menu and David had a Rueben on a pumpernickel bagel. We will return again while in the neighborhood! read more

See all

Such a cute place I wish I knew about sooner! The scallion cream cheese on a cheesy bagel was my favorite! The service was great. Family oriented ambiance. Loved the photos, stickers, and signs on the walls that gave the place culture and character. I will definitely be back, there are so many options to try still! read more

See all

The bagels and sandwiches are great the prices aren't crazy and the portions are big!

For many New Yorkers, bagels may be a taste of New York, but if you walk in Stuff a Bagel, you experience part of New York. The walls are full of memorabilia, from New York Islanders, Yankees, Giants, and Mets. The bagels, wraps or rolls are named after Long Island Expressway, Jersey Turnpike, Southern State, La Guardia and Frank the Tank. The Giambalvo's family established several Stuff A Bagels in Cape Coral and Fort Myers. We normally go to the one located in Daniels Parkway near I-75. My favorite is "Lox Deluxe", lox, cream cheese, onions, tomato, capers on Onion bagel! Sometime, I changed plain cream cheese to scallion or jalapeno. Frank The Tank comes closely second loaded with ham, beacon, sausage, egg and cheese. Wife loves her plain and/or cinnamon raisin bagels with plain cream cheese. They have lunch items from Chicken Salad, Pastrami Melt, Roast Beef to Philly Cheesesteak, etc. Good lunch variety! Well, there are Turnovers, Danish, Muffins, Croissant and cookies to suit your sweet tooth! The staff are motivated, welcoming and friendliest we ever experienced. A great place for breakfast and lunch for eat in or take out! read more

See all

Excellent bagel and cream cheese assortment. I also had the meat packed breakfast burrito and it was delicious. My girlfriend (born and raised in the Bronx) loves their cream cheese and lox spread. She says the bagels are just like her childhood. read more

Great NY bagels. Friendly staff. Great variety in both bagel and spread flavors. Weekend mornings expect a line but they keep it moving.

The best bagels in town ! The quality of the bagel speaks for itself! So yummy & the staff was so sweet I love this location read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Friendly and quick service on a Monday morning. It was my first time stopping in and I couldn't help myself! I order a breakfast sandwich (served all day), a bagel and cream cheese, and half a dozen to go ! They have done in options here and Wi-Fi or you can take your food to go. I thoroughly enjoyed the jalapeño cheddar bagel. The cheddar and jalapeño flavor really come through AND they are generous with the cream cheese. Def will have it again. I shared the sausage, egg and cheese on an everything bagel and it was very good. Very filling Things to note, come with CASH. They do take credit card but there will be a 3.5% service charge on top. Their half a dozen comes with 7 bagels for $10 which comes to $1.43 a bagel. Single bagel costs $1.50. You save even more by doing their dozen (14 ct). Would be a great pick up if you're hosting breakfast or brunch for a crowd read more

See all

Amazing variety of bagel sandwiches. I specifically recommend the pastrami on everything bagel.

This place can be poppin sometimes but worth the wait!! Small indoor area that can get crowded but they have a few tables. The bagels and cream cheese were amazing!! They had breakfast sandwiches too which looked great. Large selection of various drinks. Would definitely go back here! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Cinnamon raisin bagel with maple walnut cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

We got here on a Saturday morning about 7:30 am. The inside has about 7 tables or so. The staff was friendly. Our sandwiches were delicious. The bagels were a great size, plenty of cream cheese. The potatoes were well seasoned. We will be back! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Brooklyn Queens Expressway (Home fries, 2 Eggs and cheese) - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

We thought we would give it another try after 1 year. The entire experience was very bad! We were there at just after 1 PM and they close at 2 pm. The noise was over the top and could hardly hear the waitress. We were the only 2 people there! They were cleaning floors, putting chairs on tables and shutting down drink coolers. We finally took our food to counter and asked for take out containers. To top it off the Bagels were very hard and dry. I asked for mine to be toasted and it was not. Very bad overall experience and will not be back. read more

As someone who comes from NJ and NY, I was very pleased with the quality of bagels here. There are also so many different kinds of flavors to choose from! My husband loved the jalapeño cheese bagels. I had a very delicious French toast bagel. They were nice and fresh. We also tried some assorted pastries: muffins, a cheese danish, and a chocolate coffee cake. The cheese danish was scrumptious and the muffins were nice and moist. The chocolate coffee cake was super sweet and made for a good treat with different textures. We will certainly be back. The staff was kind and also provided service in a quick and efficient manner. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

As good a bagel as you can get anywhere around here. These are legit bagels, some specials but legit. They have the closest to NY Style Kaiser Rolls too! Run dont walk!!!!! read more

Saw the reviews on yelp, was down in fort myers from Long Island. I've been to stuff a bagel on Long Island. For Florida bagel wise , not my cup of tea. read more

Wow really disappointed to stand here completely ignored the store isn't busy 10:30 am ..... love stuff a bagel sad to see they are losing their customer service and don't care anymore . :( read more

Best bagels in all of FL! I've have okay and decent but this place tastes like I'm walking in NYC! Double toasted everything bagel with cream cheese can't go wrong read more

I've only been down here for a few years. I was told there are no good bagels down here. This place definitely is not good - it was really bad. I had a toasted jalapeño cheddar bagel with cream cheese. It was hard as a rock and lacked flavor. Maybe I should give up on bagels down here. read more

Francesca is absolutely sensational! Quality and taste in what I ordered (French toast bagel sandwich) was on point! Everyone is friendly and happy while working. It is a pleasure seeing young people taking pride in what they do!! May you continue to thrive hugs, Borny read more

service is amazing & the bagels are fantastic :) i love coming here for tasty bagels and everyone is nice

Great stop for some NY bagels. Shop has tons of fun signs and pictures with cases displaying all tubs of cream cheese and baskets of bagels. Our orders were swapped a bit, but overall great bagel sandwiches. Hot and great ratio of cheese, egg and protein- best in the area we have found thus far! read more

See all

Great bagels! Great and efficient service! This place is always packed and the employees handle it so well!

Amazing bagel spot I come here for lunch all the time. Love the pastrami melt and their jalapeño cheddar bagel read more

Stuff A Bagel - Pastrami bagel - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

If you are from the North East, this is the bagel shop you are looking for. Stuff A Bagel, located at 8911 Daniels Parkway, is legit! I was born in Bethpage, Long Island NY, grew up in NJ, and own Fine Folk Pizza right down the road. I am very particular in what I like about certain foods. These guys are killing it with delicious bagels and the team is always welcoming. My go to here is the Jersey Turnpike. Thinly sliced porkroll, egg, cheese, on a toasted everything bagel, with a side of ketchup, and hot sauce. Stop by once and I bet Stuff A Bagel becomes your go to bagel shop also! read more

Friendly staff, warm bagels, just like breakfast should be. Eat in house or take to go. French toast bagel is pure joy and will start your morning off right. Lots of staff. No waiting, catering options, a welcome addition to our Ft Myers community. Check out this place and enjoy a great breakfast experience. read more

See all

Just moved from New York to florida and this was the first bagel place I've tried. They were highly recommended from friends and family who are also from New York. My wife got two different flavored bagels with lox cream cheese and as soon as I took my first bite it reminded me of bagels back home read more

Great little deli. I had the Phili bagel with pepper jack. Great sandwich! I also got the crumble cake and chips. All sandwiches come with choice of potato salad, pasta salad or chips. Deep River chips are hard to turn down. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Taken mid meal. lol so good - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Excellent bagels and the coffee is very good as well. Was looking for a new bagel spot in swfl and this is it 100%!!

Fantastic bagel place. Have been looking for a nyc-like bagel place everywhere from naples to cape coral and we finally found it. The prices are also fantastic and they are extremely fast as well. A smooth streamlined service plus great prices and great food? Cant go wrong coming here at all! read more

Stuff A Bagel - My wife and I came in and had three bagels. I have been looking for nyc like bagels for years. Safe to say we found our new favorite place. - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

See all

amazing New York style bagels made from scratch staff is always so friendly and the service is pretty quick for made to order food. go check them out family owned read more

From the menu, I really wanted to like this place. I mean they have a bagel called the Jersey Turnpike. Yeah well super lack luster with pork roll. There were over done thin pieces of pork roll. A Jersey PEC, should be thick with pork roll. It really felt like F%#k you and not in a good way. The French toast bagel with cream cheese was okay at best. Bagel was overcooked and cream cheese was minimal. Choked down 2 bagels for a review. Where are the clowns? read more

Obsessed. Best bagel shop in town. Bagels are fresh, cream cheese is soft and creamy. And their muffins are amazing. Definitely only place in fort Myers to go get bagels. read more

Just like in NY. Get there early - they sell out. Who would go to Dunkin when this is right behind it! read more

Stuff A Bagel - Deli counter - Bagels Near Me - Fort Myers, Florida

Legitimate NY style bagels (or, as close as you could reasonably expect in Fort Myers). If you know bagels, you will know this place is the real deal as soon as you walk in. Bagels are pretty good, a little "bready". The lox is good too. In NY, this would be about an average neighborhood bagel place. So in this region, that qualifies as elite level. read more