Cancel

Open app

Search

Studebaker's Pizza

4.0 (41 reviews)
Closed Closed

Studebaker's Pizza Pizza Restaurant Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like Studebaker's Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Studebaker's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Good pizza! Prices online other photos were old so I just wanted to let others know.

Updated menu with correct prices. The pizza was really good! The marinara sauce was yummy! The bottom crust of the pizza had a bit of a buttery taste that was good too

Austin F.

Dine in is back (hallelujah!) which makes for a great meal before catching the movie next door at Centre Theater. Great pizza, great atmosphere, and the best cheesy breadsticks on the planet. Also, mellow yellow from the fountain is a serious plus!

Small town feel. The pizza smell is awesome as soon as you walk in. Little hot inside considering it was only 80 outside today.
Damon D.

Real small town feel. There was a family here sitting across 2 tables. They don't have large tables and the 2 in the middle may have been occupied. Employees were super friendly and even walks the pizza out to your table. Super small bathrooms, and they were hot. Eating area was warm as well. Bathrooms were worse than eating area as far as being hot. Bathroom was super clean. Parking was to the left side of entrance. Like 30ft away. Food: amazing pizza. The bread of the pizza is so soft, it practically melts. Of the 3 pizzas, not one was bad. The breadsticks we were fighting over. You will not go wrong with a meal here. Stop one and enjoy some fantastic pizza!

HAIR NEXT TO THE PIZZA!!! FOUR OF OUR PIZZAS HAD HAIRS IN, UNDER, AND NEXT TO THE PIZZAS!!! SHUT THIS PLACE DOWN!!

THIS PLACE IS A HEALTH HAZARD! DO NOT EAT HERE! If I could give this place 0 stars, I would. FOUR OF OUR PERSONAL PIZZAS HAD HAIRS OF DIFFERENT SIZES ON THEM!!! And the hair were in different areas--next to the pizza, under the pizza, under a piece of sausage, in the cheese. I only knew about one of the pizzas because the other people in my group did not tell me until later! This was the worst experience I've ever had with getting take-out. The health department should shut this place down!! I should have heeded the red flags: The woman who took our order had terrible customer service; the man making the pizzas did not wear gloves nor did he wear a hair net; all three of the workers looked at us with contempt. Tourists: beware! Montpelier locals: eat frozen pizza or make your own!

Seafood pizza?
Natasha M.

My friends and I were in town for the Bear Lake Trifecta and decided to carb load at Studebaker's. I was not too hungry and initially thought I could only order a medium or large pizza, but I was happy to find out they offered personal sized pizzas. My friends opted for the bbq chicken and sausage & pepperoni. I decided to take the plunge with a Crab Alfredo or something pretty exotic for the region. Well, they did a bang up job of not only delivering on a fast hot pizza with a crispy crust, but also it was loaded with cheese and meat. It was a little overloaded, but more for me! I also tried my friends sausage & pepperoni and it was proportioned out a little better, but the red sauce and crust were top notch. They're conveniently located next to the theatre which makes it a great place for a date or family night.

The pizza that is NOT suppose to have peppers of any kind on it.

We ordered a medium pizza: 1/2 the whole nine yards, but no peppers of any kind, the employee repeated back that no peppers of any kind would be on the pizza. the other half of the pizza was pepperoni and mushrooms. We got home home and guess what was on the pizza? Peppers! Both green and jalapenos see photo! We called the manager and all he could do was defend the idiot who took the order rather then try to make it right with local who helps to keep him going long after the summer tourist leave. Not very nice. Update: The owner contacted me and straightened the situation out. Only fair that I updated my review as well.

Pacific alfredo pizza - chunks of crab smothered in white Alfredo sauce, mozzarella cheese and onions.
Andy B.

Great tasting pizzas. We ordered the Pacific Alfredo and the Meat Eaters pizzas. Both medium.-sized. The portions are big enough for four hungry eaters and the price is cheap for the amount of pizza you get. It was our first time ordering here and glad that we did. Will order again when we travel through this way.

Bogo$6.99
Kelli W.

Good idea to call ahead 208-847-3020. Takes 45 mins to an hour to get your order. We called ahead and dined inside. The pizzas are buy one large, get 2nd large pizza for $6.99 all the time. Great pizza, lots of toppings, and buttery yummy crust!My only complaint was customer service over the phone wasn't very friendly.

Stephen L.

The price is good and the pizza are pretty good... but just good as we are in the middle of nowhere (very few restaurant around). With $6.99, we got medium BBQ Chicken with Bacon pizza. My son loved it, while I felt that the pizza is OK... very cheap to fill-in two adults and a six-year-old. While the "true star" is a-two-star, but in this part of the world, it could be considered 3.5 stars, as literally, we're in the middle of nowhere...

Michael M.

Located next to the great Montpeiler movie theater, Studebaker's had been serving great pizza for a number of years. I travel to the area every couple of years and always try and get pizza here. It's a small, family-owned and ran establishment. Order at the counter, they call your name to pick up when ready. Great prices. I've never been disappointed and highly recommend.

The Italian sub I ordered with no peppers

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Studebaker's Pizza

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Studebaker's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...