We don't order out very often but when we do, we don't want to be disappointed like we have in the past. It's nice to know that a place like this is local and a very impressive pizza. But let's talk about garlic bread, garlic bread with pesto sauce, and Cheese. It was excellent haven't had good garlic bread in a little while and this didn't disappoint me. I think the next time I order pizza it will be with garlic and pesto sauce. We also ordered Parmesan sticks and a wonderful pizza with a good crispy crust just the right toppings Sausage on onions with mushrooms. Beautiful pizza. we will definitely come back! read more

Stone Fire Pizza - The best garlic bread with pesto sauce, medium size pizza with just the right toppings and mozzarella sticks - Pizza Near Me - Clearlake, California

See all

The workers here will fight you on what your own name is to be transphobic. Pizza is good is why we go back but picking the pizza up is always a huge bummer. read more

Pizza was absurd got the chicken bacon ranch,With Parmesan bread twists. I definitely recommend so far best pizza spot im clearlake. Was clean and the workers were so nice! read more

See all

I ordered a large Combo pizza last Friday night (10/31/25) so I wouldn't have to cook. I was starving when we finally got home. I have ordered this pizza before from this location, so I was looking forward to scarfing down some slices. The pizza was off... it tasted like something was missing. Flat in flavor. My husband also said the same thing. It tasted old. I can't put my finger on it, but I wouldn't recommend this outlet. When I lived in Hidden Valley, I would often go to Stone Fire Pizza and always enjoyed their pizzas. read more

This is by far my favorite pizza place in Clearlake. The pizza is delicious, the staff is friendly, and the restaurant is always clean. I've never experienced any problems with any of my orders. read more

The taste tried to give my child a slice she said sick... I rather go to the supermarket next door and build a sandwich. read more

Stone Fire Pizza - Ham and jalapeño pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Clearlake, California

Gave me my pizza without my lettuce or tomato on it so they making me a new one but should have made it right the first time. read more

Stone Fire Pizza - Without my tomato or lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Clearlake, California

We were impressed by their pizza! We got combination and meat lovers. We got it fresh out of the oven and everything tasted great, especially the crust. read more

worst pizza ever!! save your money! don't go there! been sick to my stomach all day since i ate there.

First of all, a calzone, jalapeño poppers, and onion rings should not take forty minutes to complete. Other customers were eating in half the time. Yet, the calzone was overcooked and not-so cooked at the same time; the crust was crunchy and greasy gooey. The onion rings and jalapeño poppers were fried okay, but I was also expecting homemade ranch --nope. I must be a glutton for punishment because I'm grabbing a pizza today just to give them a second chance. I'll let you know shortly. read more

Great pizza every time I visit. I would recommend a stop by this business. The staff are always helpful and the location is great if you're in town visiting the Lake. read more

My request fir x sauce was ignored. Pizza was dry. And specifically told the I would like x sause. So beware. Any request will be ignored. Second time. read more

Food is great. The unique style of crust and flavors are wonderful. The atmosphere is great too. There is a small arcade for children and a nice secluded area in the corner for large gatherings. Unfortunately the service is horrible. Not the personalities per se but the sense of urgency is considerably lacking. An online order should not take over an hour and a half to be ready. Order was promised between 7:15 p.m. 7:30 p.m. I am sitting here writing this review at 8:10 p.m. as I'm still waiting for my order. At first they told me 12 minutes. I gave them 15. Came back and they told me 6 minutes. I gave them 15 more minutes. Went to the counter and both pizzas were done but breadsticks were still not done. I'm positive that they didn't even start my order until after I came in to pick it up. As I sat there waiting I watched a gentlemen order at the counter, leave the store and came back 18 mins later with his order ready. I asked the employee behind the counter how that is possible when I've been waiting over an hour. He tried to tell me that he had a phone order. I told him that I heard him order his meal, pay, walked out and returned with his order ready. The employee just apologized and didn't really seem to care about my experience. I have a feeling that online orders are last priority or out right ignored. read more

Nick the manger called me when I asked to have the box taped because of a bad DoorDash delivery. I told him about the delivery driver and he thanked me for the information. These guys have the best pizza in town and now I know they also have the best customer service. read more

First off I want to say that their chicken strips are bomb! Those are a must try! And I think their ranch is house made or a higher end brand so it's delicious as well. Now let's get into some other items. Their pizza reminds me a lot of Round Table's original. I do wish they have a thicker option. I like thick crust and my husband likes it thinner, so it would be nice if both of us can get exactly what we want each time. The toppings are nice on the meat lover's pizza, but everything could be a little more flavorful. If you're Italian like me, do not get their Margarita Pizza or their calzone. There was no ricotta on the calzone, which is like.....super important. There was so much melted shredded cheese on it that the box was soaked in oil. I'm okay with a greasy pizza (OBVI!!), but this was a little overkill. My husband was burping up oil for a long time...so just avoid the calzone all together! The margarita pizza just had shredded mozzarella cheese, diced tomatoes, basil, and lots of garlic. I prefer the sliced mozz...so that was different. Also, garlic doesn't belong on that type of pizza. I ordered garlic on my other item so they may have thought they were "hookin me up" but it just didn't work. Also - I think their garlic they use is the minced garlic from that jar that everybody gets at Costco, WHICH IS FINE FOR A HOME COOK... Other than that, I have had only good experiences with the customer service and every other food item I've ordered here. I will be back for more eventually. It's the only pizza spot near my home. read more

They got my order wrong and charged me extra. I ordered a family meal deal with breadsticks and a soda. When my husband got there she only had 2 pizzas ready for him. She claimed she didn't hear him say family meal deal with breadsticks and a soda. She said it was to late to add breadsticks but she can give us a "free" 2 liter. I paid 50 bucks when it was only supposed to be 43. My husband and I both heard her over the phone say "family meal deal". Pizza wasn't anything special. Didn't taste bad but nothing special. We bought the pizza because we wanted it for the football game. I'm not going back to this place. Make sure you get proof of what you ordered because if you don't they'll give you less and charge you more and then add a free soda. read more

The young blonde female who works here is terrible! Terrible customer service. She will ignore you, and watch TV instead, talk to coworkers. How come it takes about a good 1hr plus to get your pizza, when you order rhey say 30 minutes. 8/10 times when i go to pick up my pizza, they never even started cooking it. Also, 8/10 times my order is completely wrong. Why order if you're employees are just seeming to have a free for all, making whatever they want,, how ever rhey want. From burnt pizzas to undercooked pizzas. Last time we walked out with our pizza, got in the car, opened the pizza realized it was the wrong pizza tried going back into the restaurant the blonde female locked the door (before closing hours) when we called she gave a lame excuse like "oh well we are closed now" I literally could go on, but just save your time money and get food elsewhere. This location is a hot mess. Sounds like retraining is necessary. read more

The pizza is good. I've only been here once and for some reason never think to eat at this restaurant. Some of the customers are on the rougher side. If you want really great pizza, it's in Kelseyville! read more

See all

Great pizza!!!! Always on time and very friendly & fast. Love their pizza and when my family comes to visit we always order from them.

Order a pineapple ham and a combination pizza for the first time the other night the young man on the line was very friendly I appreciate that my husband pick up the pizzas and they were still hot and very delicious we will definitely be ordering from here again read more

Ordered a pizza, got a confirmation to pick up in 35 to 40 mins, got there and no pizza. The place has kids running around stealing paychecks, goofing off, and their floors are dirty. Not hard to have a quality business on a slow night but they managed to screw it up. read more

Not true "stone fired" pizza. I just bought two slices for my lunch break. When they were handed to me they were cold and greasy. I took three bites and threw both slices away. Gas station pizza is better than this place. Don't eat here!!! read more

They messed up our team's very large online order that had been placed a day earlier. Disaster ensued. Pizza is overpriced too.

Pizza is always good!! Every time!! Wings were a little weird but tasted good lol. Even got half and half without being charged for a 4 topping pizza!! Pretty cool!! read more

If your staving and like surprises with your order that you waited over an hour or longer for or if you call to place your order there is a blonde who is so so rude will put you on hold and then after being on hold for 15 mins she disconnects the call, she is very very unprofessional rude to customers Oh yeah this is the place, total flakes along with total rudeness Firestone Pizza read more

Just moved to Clearlake and wanted to find that great pizza place. Everyone said Stone Fire, so I gave it a try. Excellent pizza! Generous toppings, great flavor and that just right crust. I will be back. read more

Terrible food, terrible service. They do the opposite of what you order, burner your food, and take your tips like they deserve it!! Smh buyers beware! read more

Stone Fire Pizza - Terrible food. I said last time I would not come back. I should of never gave them a second chance! I got burned ass food. With a tip! - Pizza Near Me - Clearlake, California

See all

We stopped in tonight to order a pizza and the twisted breadsticks to-go. We ordered at a good time because they became very busy. Everyone was nice, food was good. The wait was a little longer due to new people starting but they offered a complimentary drink while we waited. read more

I have ordered pizza for myself and my kids, I was left to figure out what else To eat because they forgot to make one of the pizza and took over an hour to deliver when I was quoted 50minutes at most. I called to see what they can do but instead they said I can either get a refund or a pizza which means that i would have to wait an additional 30 minutes minimum to for the missing pizza. Very stupid as this was their mistake, not mine or the dasher but theirs. Very disappointed on their response. Oh yeah but kids pizza arrived very cold read more

i called all morning and got nothing but spam messages offering me money or asking me to change phone plans. then i called again at noon and got a "hello....click....." to voicemail. disaster of a place no service no food etc read more

Worst experience ever! Called in an order, paid up front on my card, told 30-40 min. Went in to get order, told no order existed, told we made a call to the wrong place, told our order would take 1.5 hours to make anyhow. Oooops! They found the order, they found the charge, then said they could not refund the money. Husband got cash back. We used to go there all the time, but besides screwing this up they were also NOT WEARING MASKS! This is awful when food is being prepped, and sold. If the owner cares at all, maybe they will change things and reach out. read more

I had to come and update my review. I decided to give this place a second try and was served by Raymond, who gave me and my son a totally opposite experience than the first one we had, really making it up for us. He's the kindest guy ever. He was so nice in so many ways, he deff removed all the bad impression I had at our first visit. read more

Don't expect anything fancy here. Simple pizza diner where you order at the counter and play arcade games/pool and watch TV while you wait. There were 3 other tables being served at the same time and our pizza took very long to arrive. Pizza was not bad. Ok for a stop along the way to the coast. read more

I completed my order for a XL pizza online through Menufy at 6:45 PM. I followed up with a call at 7:00 asking if they had received my order, and they said that they had and it should be ready in a few minutes. So, I headed to the spot and the girl who had answered the phone said there had been a mistake, and that my order was just now going in the oven. I was confused as to how that had happened, but whatever, I shrugged and headed home. I waited at the house for 25 minutes or so and then I called as I was heading out the door to see if it was close to ready. I waited on hold for most of the drive back to Stonefire, but when I finally got someone back on the phone, I was told my order had been made a size too small so it would be another ten minutes or so. I waited for ten minutes in the car and then headed in. After several minutes of waiting in the store, I was told by someone (a manager?) my "your pizza hasn't gone in the oven, my brother says to give you a refund." Well, by this point it was 8:00 and I had a kid who was already up past her bedtime. I exchanged some terse words with the manager and left, wholly let down and disappointed, and still very hungry. This was the worst pizza experience of my entire 34 years of life. Also very few in the kitchen were wearing their masks properly, if at all, including the manager. Maybe it's lucky I didn't get the pizza. read more

This is my 2nd time here and I must say,so far it's the best pizza in the area (need to try other locations to compare). There arent that many to begin with, but the area and atmosphere is very calm and nice. Slices are of decent size and a good amount of toppings. Never experienced eating inside, only take out and it's been tasty both times. read more

We needed a late night joint after a long drive and ran into Stone Fire Pizza. The pictures in this Yelp review are spot on which inspired my order of a large Stonefire Combo and Hawaiian. It's got good flavor and great crust, a little something for both my boyfriend and I to enjoy. Pizza tasted good cold from the refrigerator the next day, and the day after we ended up going back for more. This time we went with a large Pepperoni pizza, which the reheated leftovers of it hit the spot! I could have lived without the dinner salad (lots of cheese, not a lot of lettuce and a super small portion), and was totally bummed that they didn't have delivery in Clearlake. Other than that, pretty good pizza and the boyfriend raves about it. Can't say much about dining in, but definitely can give them props for our pick up orders. The order taker nailed the spelling of my name and they were willing to take phone orders 15 minutes before they closed. Will Stone Fire Pizza be memorable in comparison to our other favorite pizza places? Probably not. However, is it memorable to Clearlake? Yes. Would I recommend? Definitely yes. read more

I have never been there. But my so called friends took my credit card & bought $60.00 worth of pizza. ( then $30)I think the staff must be really careless . I'm a women & the let a 280 pound guy buy whatever he wanted. This to me sounds like bad management & careless peeps.. It makes u think.. Do they wash their hands.. Or just looking for that next dollar... Not trustworthy! read more

We took the family here tonight looking for a decent pizza place. Upon entering the restaurant we noticed a strange smell. It was hard to place not sure if it was from the food from sewer or from cigarettes outside but somewhat off-putting. We decided to order a couple pizzas. We got an extra large cheese and sausage and a medium cheese and pepperoni. Overall the restaurant was fairly clean, although the booth next to us had not yet been bussed, and our booth, while appearing clean at first, turned out to need some cleaning. The busboy was very friendly though and washed it up very quickly for us although he forgot to dry it. The food arrived fairly quickly, and the staff was extremely friendly. I was a little surprised they did not offer free refills on all sizes of fountain drinks, but they did offer a refill on the large. When the pizza arrived, it was placed on the table with no means of serving it other than to use your hands. Normally this might be OK, but they used pizza risers and generally when a restaurant uses pizza risers you expect them to have a pizza server as well. The pizza itself was somewhat less than average. It was extremely cheesy which normally is fine, but there was simply no flavor at all, at least not to the sausage. I decided to try some of the pepperoni as well just in case there was an issue with the sausage pizza alone. That was not the case, the pepperoni pizza it was also rather bland. All six of us agreed that the pizza was fairly flavorless although it did have a nice crust and had a lot of cheese. The sauce was not very flavorful nor was the meet. Still, overall the place was ok. The people are very friendly. The prices were not outrageous and we did eat most of the pizza. We might even consider coming back again in the future, but hopefully they will do something to the recipe to improve the taste. read more

The previous less than 5 star reviews must be the owners of the other failing pizza places in town. This place is great. It is clean, well lit, and actually feels like a nice place to be not like a thrown out movie set. The pizza is excellent. While not artisan, it is very good; and it has always been CONSISTENT, which I think goes a long way anywhere. Great beers on tap, great games on the TVs, Touchtunes Jukebox, friendly staff, OK prices but the rest makes up for it. This is THE pizza place to go in Clearlake, you should only go somewhere else if this one is closed. read more

Friendly, hard-working crew. Tasty, filling pizza. Garlic bread also a plus. Usually a wait for the food but worth it. Sometimes there are screaming kids. read more