After eating our burgers from Danny's, I had to pick up ice cream from Custer's. No regrets, my…read morefriends! Unfortunately, I don't remember what I had but I remember there was the word "paws" in the name of the ice cream flavor. Everyone, it was extremely hot when I went and we were in the middle of the heat dome! Anyways, the staff is very friendly and it's an ice cream stand that accepts cash only. The next time I visit Danny's, I'm definitely stopping by for my ice cream cone!

Delicious, rich ice cream and frozen yogurt available plus toppings and I think some regular food…read moretoo, like chicken tenders and fries, burgers, etc. You order from at the counter and just wait until it's ready. Really enjoyed our dessert, and there are wooden benches to sit at which is a nice touch. Keep in mind it's cash only.

One of the best, easy access, accessible parking seasonal ice cream shop. Well run shop with many…read morefriendly employees. Delicious ice cream with great servings. Multiple flavors available in hard and soft serve. Enjoyed by multi generations. Portions commensurate with price. One drawback is no indoor bathroom but they have portapotties. Great for after shopping or going out to eat as they're very close to Middletown off rt17

Twincone never gets old, been coming here for a while. Always have good service. It's just an old…read moreschool ice cream spot. Cant go wrong coming here.

Food is delicious. Menu has both breakfast and lunch items. Great place for brunch. Reasonable…read moreprices. Service is great. Will be back.

Absolutely perfect in every way. We stopped by for breakfast and were immediately made to feel like…read morewe were visiting a family member. The service is top notch, friendly. The staff genuinely care about the customer leaving just a bit happier and satiated than when they had come in. The food is made with love, and just the right amount of seasoning. Coffee is plentiful, strong, and can give any dinner a run for its money. The experience was so good that we came back every morning for our entire stay, which is something we have never done before. Omelettes, waffles, really left a strong impression.

Very clean and neat with plenty of indoor seating ice cream shop. I give a lot of credit to the…read moreworker here, since after I came in for ice cream, all the other customers came in talking on there cell phones rather than actually ordering and she was very patient and polite with them, despite all rude indecisive people walking in making her wait to serve them. This place also out of all ice cream places in Middletown has the largest and best selection for if you dairy ice cream or sorbet. I had cannoli ice cream it was good , but white chocolate raspberry Rocky Mountain ice cream was amazing, definitely never seen before and would recommend easily.

Great Ice cream...but terribly unreliable at being open. They post hours and times, then do not…read moreadhere to them. Face book posts being now open all year, but that is not the case. I have ordered delivery from here several times, only to find out they didn't open that day! Disappointing..

This was kind of an odd-ish experience in an odd-ish kind of place. Monticello seems like it has…read moreseen better days, and definitely has a very unique combination of inhabitants. We ended up here for a post-dinner treat, and it was quite busy. There is little to no room inside the place, so you're constantly trying to squeeze and shuffle around as the whole ordering process is a complete human free-for-all. We ended up with a gentleman who greeted us by saying "this is my first time working in three years!" Well OK then! He managed to get one of us a malted and vanilla twist soft serve on a cone, but the malted didn't really taste like anything other than an unpronounced chocolate flavor. The other one of us got a Snickers sundae that was so massive and just completely overtopped with Snickers pieces and fudge. Like, we're not complaining--all too happy to consume these thousands of calories!--but it was a bit of a wild mess. Kind of a surreal experience, but we're not necessarily mad about it and would probably even come back if we were ever in the area again. Be prepared to wait and to have a furrowed brow if you go.

Recently visited on our vacation and this place was cute and had so many options. The staff which…read morewas two young ladies were very nice and had great customer service. If we were visiting again I would definitely stop by a get another sweet treat.

I'm not a fan of strawberry Jam on my ice cream. I ordered a Sunday with strawberry syrup…read more Strawberry syrup usually is a watery-like substance filled with crushed strawberries. It's not an overly sweetened jam-like substance likened to that you would put in the middle of a sheet-cake. I was very unhappy when my husband brought that home to me. It def ruined it for me! I'll stick with ice cream shop at exit 116 in Wurtsboro next to Teek and Vee's. But they only take cash- so keep that in mind if you choose to go to that one.

From the owner: Great specialty sandwiches and Barbeque brisket, chicken, ribs and more!read more

This is such a cute place from the moment you see it from the parking lot to going inside. The wood…read moreand decor is so welcoming! They have a great menu and the food was super yummy! I enjoyed the frittata with red pepper, spinach and feta! It was super fresh and the dressing was tasty which came with the salad. My friend enjoyed her signature coffee called SugarHouse Latte and breakfast sandwich. Waffles were a tad firm but soften with the syrup. You gotta try the samples in the back! So many flavors! Cinnamon is yum yum! My other friend had their brownie which he enjoyed so much I didn't even have time to take a picture! Definitely check this place out and relax outside!

What an adorable farm to table gem. In a remote location this little gem is definitely going to be…read moreone of my favorite spots. It's a very causal setting with several indoor and outdoor tables. The only downside is that they always seem to be understaffed and the employees are always in the weeds...which can be more a sign. If the times rather than management. This is not a sit down restaurant but order at the counter and pickup. They offer a great assortment of breakfast items that are made to order fresh. I love that they change their menu often which enables you to try different dishes that are in season. This little place is definitely worth the drive.

This is not only my family's favorite ice cream shop of all time... their soups and stews in the…read morewinter are scrumptious! The owner is the sweetest man and we smile when we're on the way over, anticipating an enjoyable visit. Yummy and excellent quality from the food to the people. Love Sticky Fingers forever! So glad we have it close by.

Gave this place 3 stars because the ice cream is good portions are below average and big upcharge…read morefor toppings we ordered 3 large cups one with sprinkles only one with hot fudge and dry walnuts and whipped cream and another with one topping it came out to 37.00 a bit pricey ... don't think we will be returning

I ended up at Bellvale Farms Creamery after accidentally crashing my friend's bachelorette weekend,…read morewhich honestly feels very on brand for me. I had never been here before, so I went in completely blind, but the second I got out of the car, I understood why people come here. First of all: parking on BOTH sides of the street. Say less. Nothing ruins a cute little ice cream trip faster than circling for parking while your will to live slowly leaves your body. Then there's the smell. The scent wafting through the air should honestly be studied because it had me floating toward the building like a cartoon character following a pie cooling on a windowsill. I'm not saying the aroma dragged me in against my will...but I'm also not *not* saying that. Inside, the shop is set up in an "L" shape, and they have the flavors posted both outside AND inside, which I deeply appreciated because nobody needs the chaos of 14 people trying to read one tiny menu while pretending they're ready to order. They let you sample flavors before committing, which is dangerous for someone like me because suddenly I become an ice cream sommelier. I ended up getting Bellvale Bog and Calf Trax and let me tell you: absolutely worth it. 10/10. No notes. And somehow it gets even better once you walk back outside because there are picnic tables with a view that is genuinely stunning. Like, annoyingly picturesque. The kind of view that makes you stop mid-bite and rethink your life choices. For a completely spontaneous stop, this ended up being one of the highlights of the day. I will absolutely be back, and this time intentionally.

I always try to stop here when I'm in Warwick in season. I think my presence has the uncanny…read moreability to call the rain regardless of forecasts. I love that. As everyone runs inside or to their cars, I tend to relish the solitude the showers bring with a delicious cone and a beautiful view. If I lived closer, I would schedule visits on rainy days. I never get the same order twice, but I haven't had anything bad yet. It is a lot of ice cream. I try to go on an empty stomach. The lines can get crazy. Although parking can look like a doozy on busy days, surprisingly people drive as if they have sense once up there. I haven't worried about myself or my car getting hit, which was my concern when I first started visiting and saw what looked like chaos in the parking lot and along the roadway. Service is either normal or exceptional. I've never experienced anything bad nor heard complaints from other customers.

People. It's a gas station. It's right off route 17. The gas pumps are from perhaps 20 maybe 30…read moreyears ago. Cash is $.10 less than credit. Very old-school. In the small convenience store they sell lottery tickets.

Horrible. I live nearby and I try to make my purchases local but I give up on this place. Gave…read morethem many many chances. The problem well is that the gas pumps are often not working and the pay at the pump NEVER is working. Like so many people, I would like to gas up and get back on the road but no they are never working right and they do have an upcharge for paying with credit card. Having to go into the dinky store and wait for the cashier to come up to the register is a pain but more so it is about having kids in the car. I do not leave my kids in the car. Soooo it becomes a nuisance to go in the store just to pay for gas. I have asked them so many times to please fix the pumps and they clearly just do not care at all. I will never go there again.