Rita's was a quick stop on a recommendation. I'm always a fan of coconut flavored things and I…read moreheard that Rita's coconut cream ice cream was spectacular so I of course had to give it a try. The coconut ice cream icey was creamy like ice cream yet slushy like an icey it was cool refreshing and the coconut flavor was fantastic with tiny little pieces of coconut in it and the price was pretty great too. I'd definitely head back there the next time I'm out here.

From the owner: Best place to get Italian ice and frozen custardread more

Love Stewart's!…read more Whenever I'm in the area, I stop by. If you're on the road, it's a great place to stop if you need gas, snacks, drinks, or ice cream! Their bathroom are always clean. They have an array of snacks and drinks. They also carry other grocery items. They have ice cream, sundaes, and more! I'd recommend stopping here, if you're traveling and need anything for the road.

Stopped in here to get a half gallon of ice cream. They keep the 3 on sale in a freezer by the…read morecounter which is nice. Get in, get ice cream and leave. The Sweet Cherry ice cream is very good.

I'm not a fan of strawberry Jam on my ice cream. I ordered a Sunday with strawberry syrup…read more Strawberry syrup usually is a watery-like substance filled with crushed strawberries. It's not an overly sweetened jam-like substance likened to that you would put in the middle of a sheet-cake. I was very unhappy when my husband brought that home to me. It def ruined it for me! I'll stick with ice cream shop at exit 116 in Wurtsboro next to Teek and Vee's. But they only take cash- so keep that in mind if you choose to go to that one.

From the owner: Great specialty sandwiches and Barbeque brisket, chicken, ribs and more!read more

I can't say enough positive things about Yanni's. We visited this gem while staying at Kartrite,…read moredesperate to avoid the resort's ridiculously overpriced and frankly repulsive food. What a find. The menu had a great selection, everything from sandwiches to gyros, salads and classic sides. We visited twice tried a variety of sandwiches, green salad, and fries. Everything was well cooked, well seasoned and clearly made with care. They also had classic Greek desserts, including a phyllo‑dough pastry soaked in honey with custard and cinnamon (I'm blanking on the name, but it was absolutely delicious). The kids loved getting ice cream for dessert. The staff were friendly and welcoming. It's a pleasure when you are greeted by a staff who is genuinely happy to be there and interacting with guests. We ended up going back two more times during our short stay. I highly recommend this place to anyone local, and especially to anyone looking to escape the horrors of the Kartrite resort food. Our only complaint is that we don't live closer; this would absolutely be our regular go‑to spot if we did!

BYOB :))) A great wine & Liquor store across the street, it just opened, great selection good…read moreprices. THE BEST GREEK I HAVE EVEER HAD! I have traveled around Greece as well. Greek Family run. The menu and prices are amazing. Great variety. Very personal and nice, it feels like your best pair of comfortable shoes. The Greek hospitality is apparent, they offer you a free glass of wine. Seriously just as. I am definitely coming back here but it is now my #1 place for Greek.

This was my 1st visit to this restaurant, and I ordered my food to go. I ordered a bacon blue…read moreburger, chocolate chip and butter pecan cookies, and a savory 'pop tart'. The burger was massive, delicious and cooked medium rare as I'd ordered it. The fries were tasty, too. The cookies though - if you love super soft and rich cookies you will love these! So buttery and warm, and the pecan cookie was loaded with nuts. The owner (or chef?) explained everything is cooked to order - even those yummy cookies. I was very happy with my meal and will return!

If you're vegan this is definitely the place for you to try while in Monticello! The food options…read moreare A1 The service is 10/10 they make sure you are good & took care of as soon as you walk in! The ambiance is a vibe and makes you feel at home.

It's important to have one things if you consider yourself a cafe or coffee shop. Good coffee. They…read morenot have good coffee, it's great as well as the staff that is there. The baked goods smelled like heaven and tasted just as such. But the coffee was the show stealer.

Used to go here all of the time. It's horrible now. Nothing tastes the same. I don't know what they…read moredid but they need to undo it.

Place was clean, delicious and quick. Husband and I were in a rush, sat down immediately, food came…read moreout quick and hot within 20 minutes of ordering. Waitress was attentive and kind, great energy! Will definitely be back!

Great place very friendly atmosphere nice staff. Slightly pricey but with costs today what can…read moreanyone say. Definitely a place to grab a fast bite to eat. Burgers are very tasty.

Solaia was an excellent choice for dinner!…read more For starters, we had a shrimp & mango salad over a bed of arugul. Light, fresh and perfectly balanced with a touch of sweetness from the mango. We followed with seared sea scallops with a creamy white wine sauce. The slight acidity of the wine and rich buttery sauce paired perfectly to complement the sweet scallops. For my entree, I had a broiled branzino with grilled vegetables. The branzino was lightly seasoned and perfectly cooked, moist and flaky! We finished our dinner with classic tiramisu. Rich and creamy! Can't wait to go back for another meal!

I am in Monticello NY for that Kartrite Water Park spot on Thanksgiving day and I had a party of 11…read morewithout any reservations for dinner. This restaurant saved my rear end by letting me know, at 530 pm when I called, that it would accommodate my party by 6 pm. What. A. Gem! I had to shake the owner's hand in gratitude, and, of course, leave a fatter tip. Food was excellent! Every plate seemed to have been thoughtfully put together, with flavor profiles, texture, and temperature just right. Interior ambiance can be quite dark, and those with weaker eyes are encouraged to use a cell phone flashlight to read the menu. The space for our party of 11 felt comfortable and exclusive! We had a lovely Thanksgiving dinner and are grateful to the owner along with the team for taking such great care of us. I hope to be back soon.

Miss Monticello is a classic American diner located in Monticello. It's on the main drag and loved…read moreby the locals. I'm just the tourist that stumbled on this town. Our server, Millie, was friendly and attentive. She welcomed and treated us like family. The menu was extensive. Base on Millie's recommendation, I got the gyro. It was good and not over sauced with tzatziki.

I had an excellent lunch and experience at this diner. My server was quick to help and actually…read morebrought the Daily board, which was quite large, over so I can see it. I ordered a Greek salad wrap, which was perfect. Full of large chunks of feta and olives, and everything else contained in a Greek salad. They even served it with coleslaw, which was delicious, a pickle, french fries perfectly fried and not greasy, and a dolma. Great service and great food. A nice friendly environment.