We like this place, and are actually sitting here now. The food is good, the service use to be as well. Until they get rid of the teenage boys that act like 5 year olds and their buddies hanging out who don't work here, we won't be back. For the owners, it's Wednesday night, 12/10 @ 7:45PM. You need to clean house on your staff. read more

Yummy Pizza Good Service Consistency Pizza Joint Ambiance. Large enough for a small party read more

Pizza is good. But having to pay for water is ludicrous. Had he told me it cost money for the water I would have turned around and walked out without any food. read more

I like the oddball stuff every once in a while so when I saw and Apple Butter Pizza on the menu of one of the better pizza places, I had to try it. Perfect combination of flavors in this Smear of olive oil with red pepper flakes, apple butter, ham, caramelized onions, garnished with basil. Will definitely order that again. read more

Stephens Pizzeria - Apple Butter Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

Waited for 45 minutes and counting for a pizza dine in. Loud teenagers in the back of the kitchen cutting up the entire time. Not a fun time. Update: When I asked about the pizza they had forgotten about us in the dining. When addressed by the waiter. From the kitchen comes a laughing "my fault"and delivered the pizza with a smirk which I did check. Don't get me wrong good pizza but annoying staff. Carter my bad lol read more

Terrible pizza! The crust was burnt, the cheese pizza was already baked ahead of time with other ingredients added on top of the cheese. I would not eat there again. read more

Stephens Pizzeria has really good pizza. It is located at the end of a shopping center. When you enter the restaurant, the counter is immediately in front of you. There are booths on the right side and a tables through a door on the left. You place your order when you enter and find a table. They bring the pizza to your table. The servers were nice but could have been more attentive. The food was really good. I was pleasantly surprised. The crust was just right with a good crunch. The cheese was good, and the tomato sauce was really good. The flavor was really good overall. The ambiance was relaxed and casual. Overall, I rate it an 8/10. I will definitely be back when we are in the are. read more

Stephens Pizzeria - a close up of a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

very disappointed with this cheat meal the pizza was missing toppings and sauce lol slices of dough and the bread sticks were burnt read more

Stephens Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

Friends had us over for dinner and they ordered the Philly cheesesteak pizza and the pesto pizza. It was some of the best pizza we've had in a really long time ever since we've moved out here. I can't wait to eat there again! read more

The ambiance is typical small-town pizza parlor and is always friendly. I've always had pleasant service there. They have delicious pizza. Their Philly cheesesteak pizza is sooooo amazing! Also, their tiramisu is the best I've EVER had! I've heard the owner guards the recipe and I see why. read more

First off, I was torn between giving this place a 3 star to 4 star review. The menu prices online were incorrect to what I was charged after pick up. It was more than what was posted online. The pizza was fantastic and so were the wings but I paid more for less. Normally you get 10 wings for $11 but I received 8. Now that price would be fine if it was still the $9 price that I saw. Pizza was a few dollars more aswell. Total for my pizza and wings was $40. I'll come back but not as much until it's more transparent on how they run the place with pricing. Advice fix it as soon as possible. read more

Good pizza! Love the personal size and extra toppings! The crust is amazing and you can tell it's homemade! So good! read more

Stephens Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

This is the best pizza I had in a very long time. I stopped going to pizza restaurants because I make a better one at home but the pizzas here are amazing. The service is superb, nothing but great things to say about this place. read more

Worst pizza I ever had!!! Couldn't get thru the second slice and had to throw it all away! I'll never go there again.! I've had frozen pizza that was much better. I wish I had done that cause I could have saved some money. read more

Absolutely must visit! This place has the best pizza, subs, and sauces. You must try garlic butter sauce. I eat A LOT of pizza. As a result, I have tried a lot of garlic butter sauce at various pizza places, mostly chain restaurants. The sauce at Stephen's is a garlic herb butter sauce. Oh so creamy and good and not overpowering. I asked for light sauce on my pizza so don't let the picture lead you to believe this pizza was dry. It was not at all and had just the right amount of sauce. Clean restaurant, friendly service and fantastic food. read more

See all

Delicious Pizza! Perfect pick up meal after a busy day! Great staff who work very hard and provided a well prepared meal for our family. Check this place out! Mari M read more

Just wanted to thank the ownership and staff of Stephens Pizzeria for following up and showing they care about all customers. I was able to try out their pizza and have to say it's delicious. Thanks again read more

The dough and sauce are usually what makes a great pizza. The sauce is good but the dough is like a saltine cracker, especially when asked for Brooklyn style thin crust. The salad was fresh and service was good. read more

Stephens Pizzeria - Good flavors but dough is not really a pizza dough. - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

I've visited a few times, the pizza always taste great. The service is good but on multiple occasions our pizza has been delayed due to being burnt, the staff have offered us free dessert every time it happens which is not necessary but nice. It's a great little place to grab food where there's no loud music so you can easily have conversations with whoever you visit with. Definitely worth a try! read more

Ordered food to go. We both got two sandwinches with chips. Order came out in a tied bag so I couldn't check the order. Once I got home, one out of two sandwiches were wrong and forgot both bags of chips. Food tastes fresh but employees need major help. read more

The food here has been excellent every time I've been here. The prices are fair, customer service is equally awesome. Must try!

Pizza is the best in town!!!!! Cheese stick are awesome! Employees are very nice! Go get your pizza today~ you won't regret it! read more

The pizza was great, plenty of cheese and toppings!! Your order on line or at the walk up counter. Get your own drinks, paper plates and plastic silverware. The ambiance is what you expect with paper plates and plastic silverware. Not fancy. We had pepperoni and mushrooms and the other half was ham and green peppers. read more

The food is excellent, the pizza is flavorful, and the crust is just thick enough. The service was definitely subpar. The girl at the counter blankly stared at me when I asked her a question, and the "kids" in the back were yelling about personal topics and being rowdy and loud. I had to take my pizza to go because it took 30 min after my family had already eaten. This pizzeria is great, but the owner ought to know his/her staff is poor quality. Very little customer service. A stressful experience to say the least because I had to ask 2 times after 20 minutes (when we were the only customers except for one takeout order). A shame that good food is met with poor staff quality. read more

Pizza is hot, fresh and delicious! Oh I'm so glad they are open for dine in. The cheesy bread sticks are so yummy, don't even need any ranch sauce with them. Hubs and I shared a 14 inch pizza with jalapeños, pepperoni and pineapple. Fabulous! read more

Stephens Pizzeria - Garlic & Cheese Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

See all

Sometimes a good pie. I guess depends on who is working. Just got an extra large margharita and asked for well done crust. It came pretty much raw dough in the middle. I really hate when that happens and it seems it does most of the time. read more

Well the 1st time I went there I had an Italian sub that was high quality and delicious...I gave them 5 stars and couldn't wait to get back, the next time I got the same thing..it was ok but not near as good. Then I tried a pizza..not bad but not great. So the last time I went I got a calzone...limp and full of sauce..pretty sure calzones don't come with sauce in it..it's on the side. It was not good at all. Got to be consistent guys. Went from a 5 star to a 2 star in 4 tries. Don't know if I will be back.. read more

I recommended and share the location with all my family and friends. I think they got a the best Pizza around. Stephens Pizza it's a place for enjoy a good time. thank you guys for your hard work. This is my experience and I hope everyone have a good time. read more

Really good cheese on these pizzas. Never expected to find such a quality place in Tennessee.

Really good pizza. Good price for quality! It's a small location so it's easy to miss but you'll be happy you tried! Delicious, toppings cooked to perfection. Chef's kiss! read more

My dining partner and I ran over here during a lunch break. It's at the end of an industrial looking strip mall, but their sign is readily visible. You won't have any trouble finding it. There even is enough parking. It is small inside, with only four booths and two small tables near the counter. They have expanded to the side though, and doubled the seating capacity. Only the two small tables experience any traffic, so you mostly don't need to worry about people walking by while you're eating. It's set up very well. Also, their inspection score was a 99, and it certainly looked clean inside. I tried their Italian chicken Philly cheese hoagie. Although it was a little smaller than I expected, it was certainly fresh, with a good amount of chicken. I didn't really detect much Italian spice on the chicken as there was a lot of sauce included. It wasn't too messy but I think it overpowered the seasoning on the chicken. I was full when finished, so the sandwich is more filling than it initially looked. My dining partner tried the two slice pizza special. It included three toppings and a drink. The crust was good and the toppings were fresh. The slices were large and made for a good lunch. The staff is friendly and you can see your food being prepared. I will certainly be back to try more from their menu. read more

Great Pizza and service!!! Very good value. Cheese bread was great too!!! Didn't try dessert.

Great pizza. Just wish they delivered to my area. Since they don't, we've eaten in and carried out leftovers.

First time eating there and it did not disappoint! Jerk chicken pizza was excellent! We also got the Hawaiian pizza and it was just as good. Best pizza in the area. Highly recommend. read more

Excellent pizza! Also loved their meatballs. Would highly recommend this place for good pizza.

Love this hometown's pizza. Excellent crust, delicious garlic sauce. They get it right every time.

Amazing spot for delicious pizza! I ordered the Pesto Chicken Pizza and I highly recommend it. Get the Garlic Butter Sauce to dip your crust in. You also must try their homemade Tiramisu! The staff was also super friendly and the restaurant is small but clean and cozy. read more

Stephens Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Gray, Tennessee

Today was my first time here and I'm so pleased! My boyfriend and I ordered a carry out meal, a 16" Xtra large pizza with mushrooms and spinach. When we arrived they told us they had made it a bit too well done, so they had placed another pizza in the oven for us. It only took a few moments more of waiting. Most places would've just boxed up a burnt pizza and carried on their day, they noticed their mistake and corrected it beforehand. I'm so pleased with the service here! They were so kind and fast on their feet. The pizza was definitely worth the wait, as well! It was fresh and delicious!! Definitely recommend this place if you haven't been! read more

Used to be the best pizza in the area. I would go here at least once a week. Now they don't care. Don't waste your money on toppings, they don't add them. You'll get a cheese pizza with what looks like a few toppings accidentally dropped on. I got a large chicken and extra mushroom pie, opened it up (in the store) and counted 6 mushrooms and obviously no chicken. The cashier said the toppings were under the cheese. Got home and immediately learned there was nothing under the cheese. $28 for a cheese pizza. read more

Friendly service. Good pizza close to home. Our go to for takeout pizza. Cook time is fast and toppings are good for taste and quantity.