In the spirit of transparency, let me just start by saying that my visit to Stella Jean's actually came a little while back. However, even though I'm only posting this now (before it gets any later), I actually had most of this written out for a while. So why the delay? Because I'm so far in the minority, I figured I would wait until I could come back and see if my first trip was a fluke and/or if it was just the flavors I tried. Sadly, though, while the parking gods usually look favorably upon me, they've forsaken me every time we've tried to come back when we're in town!
On the surface, everything about Stella Jean's is right up my alley - the shop is cuzy and cute, their flavors are unique, and they source their ingredients from a lot of great purveyors, like Valrhona Chocolate and Califia Farms. More importantly, their selection of flavors looked super promising. Alongside their menu mainstays, like Mango Sticky Rice, Strawberry Oat Crumble, and Ube + Pandesal Toffee, they also feature a handful of rotating seasonal offerings which are equal parts unique and interesting. What's more, for anyone that has dietary sensitivities and/or preferences, they always have several options that are vegan, gluten-free, or both.
-- UBE & PANDESAL TOFFEE - Ube, Pandesal (Filipino Sweet Bread), and Toffee
As evidenced by its intensely purple coloring, this had a strong taste of ube to it, which I really liked. The toffee nicely balanced that earthy sort of flavor, but I didn't get much of the pandesal, though, maybe I just missed scooping some.
-- MANGO STICKY RICE - Mango Sorbet, Pandan, and Coconut Milk
Compared to the other flavors we had, this felt crisp and so much lighter. The sorbet was a nice reprieve from how creamy everything else was and I liked how refreshing the mango tasted. Solid.
-- SALTED MAPLE + BANANA BREAD - Maple Syrup, Chocolate Chunk, Banana Bread, Sea Salt, and Coconut Milk
This flavor had me the most excited, but it fell a bit short. While I loved the combination of the chocolate and banana bread, the maple syrup was too much. Not only did it make this too sweet, but it overpowered everything, including the scoop of Apple Butter Crumble.
-- APPLE BUTTER + CRUMBLE - Green Apple, Cinnamon, Nutmeg, Apple Butter, Oat Crumble, Sea Salt, and Coconut Milk
Pretty cool how this felt like eating a scoop of apple pie a la mod in a single scoop. The mix of flavors was pretty classic, but it also felt oddly subtle. That being said, it may have had more to do with the Salted Maple & Banana Bread blending with/overwhelming this one.
Besides how overly sweet a couple of the flavors were, the other thing that dampened our experience was the service. More specifically, the guy who helped scoop our ice cream, as he seemed generally annoyed for some reason. I'm not sure why he would be with us, as we only asked to try a couple of samples each compared to the couple ahead of us who tried three or four per person, but he seemed like he was eager to get us in and out of there ASAP. Also, FWIW, he seemed just as bothered with the couple behind us, so maybe he was just dying to go home.
Between how nearly everyone that's been to Stella Jean's has fallen in love with them and how the Salted Maple + Banana Bread was the only real problematic flavor we tried, I really do think we just got the wrong flavors. Maybe a bit of bad timing as well, considering how all of their current seasonal flavors sound fantastic - Banana Turon Crunch, Guava Cream Cheese, Matcha + Pandan Birthday Cake, and Pineapple Fog. Either way, I feel almost compelled to try to visit Stella Jean's again the next time we're out this way. Just maybe their other location in Costa Mesa instead of this one.
Regrettably, THREE AND A HALF STARS rounded down for now. read more