I stopped by for the first time after seeing this place on Yelp. The gelato itself wasn't bad and…read morereminded me of the style I saw in Florence, especially the way the gelato was displayed in the covered containers. The experience, however, could have been better. The employee did greet me when I walked in and let me sample a flavor before I made my choice, which I appreciated. However, he seemed to be in a rush, which made the experience feel less welcoming. I came hoping to try the tiramisu flavor because I had seen it on Yelp, but I was told it was only last week's flavor. I understand that flavors change and that they had just received a shipment, so not everything was available yet. I just wish there had been a little more guidance, such as letting first-time customers know where the current flavors are posted (I had to ask if they update them on Instagram). As a first-time customer, it would have been nice if he had asked whether I had visited before or explained how the rotating flavors work, instead of making me feel like I needed to quickly pick a flavor and move on. One other thing I noticed is that there isn't any seating inside. A few tables or chairs would make it a more enjoyable place to sit and enjoy the gelato. Overall, the gelato was good, and I appreciated being greeted and being able to sample a flavor before ordering. With a friendlier, more engaging customer experience and a few small improvements, I'd be more likely to return. *Thank you for your response. I believe there has been a misunderstanding, as the visit you described was not mine. I visited as a first-time customer and purchased two gelatos to go--one for myself and one for my husband. I sampled two flavor before ordering, which I appreciated. I also want to clarify that I never had a father with me, nor was I part of a group sampling every flavor. Because of that, I was surprised to read those comments in response to my review. My review was simply an honest account of my personal experience. I acknowledged the things I appreciated, including the greeting and being able to sample a flavor, while also sharing constructive feedback about feeling rushed and wishing there had been a little more guidance for first-time customers regarding the rotating flavors. I respect that every business receives feedback differently, and I wish you and your business continued success.

After a filling Turkish meal in the Gulfgate area, South Sarasota,we wanted something for dessert…read more We focused on gelato and walked in. The owner could not have been nicer and gave samples to try his offerings. The gelato is rich, creamy and delicious with some alcohol mixed in. I had a combo and loved every spoonful.(wish I could remember my combo) Flavors change periodically.

My favorite ice cream place…read more Waited for one year to visit Florida's best ice cream! My number one recommendation is the banana split. I also love the Cherry Amarena and the salted caramel. If you are a pistacho fan you won't be let down either.

I want to start with thank you for letting me and my friends try on many flavors because we were…read moreindecisive!!! You are so patient and nice!!! I got banana split, hazelnut and tiramisu! And you have to get medium in order to get 3 flavors. They are literally the best flavor combined into one cup!!! Definitely worth coming back!!!!

Authentic creamy flavorful gelato! The owner is very sweet as well…read more Very clean and beautifully decorated. Will be back

I love the decor on here, very Italian chic. I ordered the…read moreFrutti de Bosco & Strawberry Gelato. It was delicious and it was a beautiful day to walk around with a cup of Gelato in your hand. The service was great, very patient.

love this place!! cute and fun atmosphere. lots of great options. matcha drinks are greatread more

The service is rude and they judge you for no reason at all.... And the food tase like dog shit I…read moredon't know if they did my order wrong but the dirt matcha then you first sip it is delicious but then the ice melts a little bit it tase watery like and kinda no flavor at all I highly recommend you not getting it.

Move out the way, Culver. There's a new sheriff in town…read more Whit's Frozen Custard makes the Vanilla and Chocolate custard fresh everyday. They have flavor of the day, which changes. I got the Peanut Butter Custard with chopped Reeces Peanut Butter Cups: absolutely delicious. You can order a Custard cake, their pay on ice cream cake. It's spot on. If you have a sweet tooth, stop by here.

I'm so happy Whit's opened on the Key! We walked in yesterday after the beach and bought a pint of…read morebanana pudding and chocolate marshmallow brownie. The custard is made fresh daily and very delicious! Can't wait to go back and try more. The store was clean and the staff was friendly. There is an outdoor sitting area as well and a small parking lot dedicated for their customers.

Such a wonderful gelato experience! The place is beautiful and very clean! The gelatos are…read moreabsolutely incredible, the mix berries and pistachio flavors completely stole my heart. I love that all the gelatos are vegan, gluten free and dairy free making it a perfect spot for everyone to enjoy a delicious treat without compromising on flavor. The quality, taste and variety of flavors are amazing. I also love that they have other location around the Tampa Bay Area, making it easier to enjoy these delicious gelatos in different places. Definitely a must visit when you're in Anna Maria island. I can't wait to come back and try more flavors.

So, this was not a pleasant experience at all. The person working there is incompetent and…read moredefinitely looked like she wanted to be anywhere but here. First, I asked if we could get samples and she said two per person. That is reasonable. However, the sample size was on the tip of the spoon. Not sure what that achieves. I asked her about the Bacio chocolate boxes on display and if I needed to purchase the whole box, and she said something within the lines of "that's how it usually is" ummmmm the shop has single chocolate pieces for sale, so my question was not entirely unwarranted. Anyways, she put my gelato on the counter and I didn't even realize that it was mine. I had to actually ask. After we grabbed our order, we left, and some of us realized that they did not get a full scoop... Now to the actual flavors, the variety was a bit limited but I have to say that the gelato was delicious. Nonetheless, I did not like the chocolate as it tasted fudgy and I did not get a single hint of the pistachio flavor. I also have to add that she closed the place at around 9:40 pm -20 minutes to closing time. I am saying this noting that the opening time is noted with a red marker on a masking tape, changing the opening time from 2:00 pm to 5:00 pm. This information needs to be updated on the website, since people rely on the internet to get this information. I know someone might say that I should be reviewing the food (that is what the two stars are for), BUT customer service is a part of the experience, especially in a touristy place like Anna Maria. The Gelateria has a lot of potential but the customer service is a genuine loss to the business.

Very misleading. Hours online from multiple sources say 1 pm to 9 pm. When I got there they were…read moreclosed and it said they'd be open at 6 pm. What froyo spot doesn't open until 6 pm?? At least update your hours online.

Frozen Yogurt with a nice creamy smooth feel in the mouth, good natural flavour and an 8 flavour…read moreassortment of vegan, low fat and reduced sugar choices. Kosher as well. All machines were operating and were clean. Tasting samples were available. The Skinny Dip has a nice selection of toppings with perfectly fresh cut fruit, popping bobas, various crumbles and sprinkles. We enjoyed the tart (Excellent!) as well as the Seasalt Caramel Pretzel. Service was very friendly and the small restaurant was very clean. Outside seating as well with parking available. Price was good for an excellent frozen yogurt product. The best we have had in a long time! This review January 2023 Sarasota FL

This is a pretty good frozen yogurt place with many different toppings. I like their original tart…read moreflavor and I don't really go for any toppings but they have a wide variety. During checkout it's asking for hat amount you would like to tip and it's not clear how skip this. Since it was a self-service with everything, not sure who am I tipping at this place.

The selection and variety of their sift serve is excellent. The topping selection is huge…read more This would have received higher stars if not for the following: 1) When paying, their system includes the option for gratuity. This narrative needs to stop and this business is no exception. This is entirely self serve. 2) Two of the five liquid toppings were empty. Either keep them full or take them off the counter. 3) Seats, tables, etc are not kept very clean.