This was only my second time going to Steak 'n Shake (first time was in Ohio--awful as well), and I think my last time.
This location is right by our home in CoMo (we just moved here), and we stopped in for a bite one night during the week. There were so many things wrong with this place...
1. Right when you walk in, you see 4-6 servers/busboys standing in the back corner, talking and/or doing nothing but try to ignore their tables. It's very unprofessional. I've worked in both the restaurant and fast-food industries and it's never acceptable to see that many people standing around with nothing to do. It was not very busy, maybe 5 tables had parties, but that's still no excuse.
2. Our waitress seemed very ditsy and forgot 3 times to bring the ticket back to the table, though she told us she would every time. She also rang up the receipt before we ordered shakes, even though we told her we wanted them at the beginning of the meal.
3. My boyfriend ordered chicken fingers and fries, no complaints there. I ordered the Portobello and Swiss burger with fries. The waitress did not seem to know what it was, even though it was right there on the menu. She brought me a plain old cheeseburger with fries. The worst part was that I ate all my fries before realizing I got the wrong burger! So I had to wait for her to come back over to the table (she was standing in the corner talking to another server and didn't see me staring at her across the room). When I explained to her that I received a plain cheeseburger instead of a Portobello and Swiss, she again had no clue what I was talking about and looked at me like I had ten heads. I physically had to lift the bun and meat off the burger to show her that it was missing mushrooms and the correct type of cheese. She said she'd bring it back and "have them fix it" for me. Meanwhile, I did't even have fries to occupy me and I was a little annoyed. She came back two minutes later with the EXACT SAME BURGER with a handful of hot mushrooms thrown under the bun (no onions, like the burger is supposed to have, and there was still one slice of plain old American cheese on it). The burger was cold by this point, but I didn't want to make a fuss so I choked it down. I'd like to point out the description of the burger I thought I was ordering: "A Double Steakburger with fresh Portobello mushrooms, seasoned on our fiery hot grill and topped with melted Swiss cheese, caramelized onions and garlic mayo." The burger I received (the second time around) had no Swiss, no onions, and no garlic mayo. I'm not even sure the mushrooms were Portobello! I was severely disappointed.
4. We had to actively call the waitress over when we were done so we could order our shakes (she was ignoring us again). Someone else delivered them so we didn't even have a ticket when we went up to pay. We then stood at the counter for 5+ minutes while someone who was supposed to be working the drive-thru window used the computer. She didn't look at us or even say "Someone will be right with you"... all she did was yell "I need someone up front!" and go back to her station. Our waitress watched us pay and leave and didn't even wave or say anything to us as we headed out, even though I made eye contact with her 3 times.
Overall, the chicken fingers, fries, and shakes were decent, but the service and burger were just awful. We will definitely not be eating here again... McDonald's is so much better. read more