Pickleman&#x27;s Gourmet Cafe

Sure, Shakespeare's pizza is a vibe and a local institution, but glad we didn't wait because the…read morepizza is super mid actually quite not good. Cardboardy crust, sauce tastes like tomato paste and cheese is stodgy. Wow. Expected way more.

I have been here twice now while visiting Columbia, and I still don't totally understand the hype…read more It is clearly a local staple, and the location right downtown definitely helps draw a crowd. The atmosphere has that nostalgic college-town charm with loud energy and a laid back vibe, which is fun if that is what you are looking for. But when it comes to the actual pizza, it just does not stand out. It tastes about the same as a frozen pizza you would cook at home, which feels especially ironic since they literally sell their own frozen pizzas up front. Nothing was bad, it just wasn't memorable either. The cider I had was flat and some of the worst I had. If you want to check a "Columbia landmark" off your list or grab a bite in the middle of the action, it works for that. But for truly great pizza, there are better options in town. It's a good drunk college spot... that's it!

The window

The Masterpiece Pizza

See all

Crush from the fountain

Pizza Tree

4.2(133 reviews)

0.1 mi

YUM. I love a place where I can choose a couple slices & have a variety of flavors. The mac &…read morecheese slice was good but slightly dry in my opinion. I absolutely loved the Steven Cheese slice- the pesto was the perfect touch. I liked that the crust wasn't too hard & held toppings very well. We went to the window & had our food in very little time. Prices aren't bad but it'll add up if you just get slices instead of a whole pizza.

Pizza Tree is hands down the best pizza in Columbia. They offer a daily rotating menu with a…read morevariety of individual slices, so there's always something new to try. There's no seating area, so it's strictly takeout. While the prices are a bit on the higher side, it's worth the splurge every now and then. My favorites are the mac and cheese pizza and the margherita--both are excellent. The jalapeño slice, however, was a bit of a letdown.

Ranch Hands - House Zauce. Buttered Onions. Ground Sirloin. Peppered Bacon. White Cheddar Cheese. Shredded Mozzarella.

See all

Instant Classic - A Classic Pepperoni Pizza. Topped with Pickled Red Onions. Fresh Basil. 4 Ranch included on the side.

Pappo’s Pizzeria and Pub

4.1(80 reviews)

3.1 mi

Great pizza, reminded me of an old pizza pub. Our waitress was very efficient and attentive, and it…read morewas very good pizza. We will go back!

The place was really clean, it wasn't as spacious as I'd hoped though. They service was good, and…read moreefficient. The food wasn't bad, could've had more taste to it but overall it was good.

Chicken Club Sub

See all

Chicken Club Sub

Endwell Taverna

4.4(42 reviews)

0.2 mi

This place is a gem! The vibe is cool but not stuffy. The menu is small but has a good variety and…read moreall are phenomenally curated. They were also kind toward my food allergies! The bartenders were friendly and very skilled (upon observation), not just "jack & coke"s. After recently moving from Houston, I've been struggling to find quality food spots, this did not disappoint. I will definitely be back!

My sister took me here for dinner while I was visiting her from out of town. The pasta was quite…read moregood and filling. Also enjoyed the bottle of red wine we ordered. Service was great!

Margherita pizza

See all

Tony's Pizza Palace

3.9(69 reviews)

0.4 mi

Omg my cousin who lives in Columbia suggested lets go back to Tony's because she like the Gyro's…read more Now I've had a lot Gyro and the meat is sliced thin not chunks. Just Horrible. I took my leftover home and try to cut the meat up and I came to the conclusion no help!

Loved my pizza and the old school feeling of the place…read more They treat you like family I loved the wings and the gyro that I took home for the next day

Gyro meat chunked not sliced....poor presentation; where r the tomatoes? No steak fries

See all

Wise Guys Pizza

3.6(83 reviews)

0.3 mi

This is 100% my favorite pizza place in Columbia. Idk what they do here, but the stuffed pizza is…read morebomb. So much sauce which I LOVE. And the crust is so doughy and tastes so fresh. Even the regular deep dish pizza is amazing. - Stuffed pepperoni pizza (5/5): This pizza is heaven. Seriously, everyone must try this. So perfectly delicious. So much sauce, and so much flavor. - Deep dish pizza (4.5/5): Also amazing. The crust has the perfect crispiness. And the simple sausage and mushroom, with not too much going on. So simple and so good.

The stuffed pizza is like true Chicago style pizza and is honestly delicious. Loved it and will…read morereturn soon

Cinnamon sticks

See all

Gumby's Pizza

3.2(87 reviews)

0.1 mi

Gumby's Pizza - Columbia, MO…read more I was working in Columbia last week when a few coworkers suggested we stop by Gumby's Pizza for lunch. Located downtown near the Mizzou campus, Gumby's is a well-known local spot that's popular with students and residents alike. As with most downtown areas, parking can be a bit of a challenge, so plan accordingly. At first glance, the restaurant looks small from the outside, but once you step inside, you'll find it surprisingly spacious. When you walk in, you're greeted by specials posted throughout the entrance area. We arrived right around noon and, to our surprise, we were the only group dining at that time. Orders are placed at the counter, where we were helped by a woman who was absolutely fantastic--friendly, patient, and accommodating, especially considering that several people in our group were visiting for the first time. After ordering, you can choose to sit at a booth, high-top table, or at the bar. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with TVs throughout, a music machine, and even a pool table for entertainment. Since I'm currently following a fasting diet and skip breakfast and lunch, I ordered my meal to go so I could enjoy it for dinner. Having had plenty of pizza the night before at Shakespeare's, I decided to switch things up. I went with a pound of boneless wings--half buffalo, half mango habanero--and added a side of beef toasted ravioli. One of our local coworkers also ordered the XL cheese bread for the table, and I can confidently say, based on both this visit and past experiences, it's easily in my top three for cheese bread anywhere. Everyone in our group was happy with their food, from the pizzas to the other menu items. Overall, Gumby's is a spot I'll continue to visit whenever I'm in Columbia. Great service, solid food, and a laid-back vibe make it a go-to for a casual meal downtown.

I have to agree with, Rylee. Drunk and Sober me would rate this pizza totally different. Drunk…read morewould be a good solid 4+ and sober me would say it's just an average 3. However, I totally did enjoy my small sausage and jalapeno pizza after a night of bar hopping in COMO. I ordered at the counter and took my deliciousness back to my hotel room to enjoy. The counterperson was friendly and professional. There were several of us ordering and waiting for carry-out. She totally kept the line moving and even offered glasses of water for us to enjoy while waiting. My wait was actually a very short time. The set-up behind the counter was easy to view, so I got to watch them make my pizza. When mine came out of the oven, I knew it was mine. There were plenty of topping and the mozzarella cheese was well melted and even had a golden color to it. Is Gumby's the "best" pizza? No, but it is head and shoulders above a national chain pizzeria that is just a few doors down. So, I recommend them over Papa.

Pizza Box

Small Sausage & Jalapeño

See all

The Italian Village

3.7(60 reviews)

1.4 mi

It's been a hot minute since I have reviewed one of my COMO fave pizza places…read moreSince my office moved, it has not been convenient to order from here...but last night I got a MEAT - XL - hand-tossed Same great ingredients as what I recalled getting Same great flavor This place may not be much to look at from the outside, but their ovens do a great job on their pizzas! Solid 4-star again from me

We stopped in to pick up a Meats Pizza, they were busy. The restaurant is to go only and has no…read moreseating. When I opened the door I thought I walked into the kitchen. Just a small corner with a register and refrigerator with drinks for sale. The pizza looked great, the toppings and crust were golden brown. The bottom of the pizza was wet and soggy but still good. The cheese was perfect with the sweet sauce. Overall we were very happy with the taste and quality of this pizza.

Menu

Cheese Pizza

See all

Menu

Arris' Pizza

3.5(55 reviews)

2.8 mi

Arris' does Greek style pizza extremely well. Their sauce is very sweet and tasteful, and the crust…read moreis a perfect mix of airy and soft. I ordered a meat lovers pizza which was perfect and my girlfriend and I shared some fantastic toasted ravs, a Missouri staple. I balk a little at the price, but the service was unbeatable and the food was delicious!

Unexpected excellence in Columbia, Missouri. My daughter said greek/Italian/pizza and we were…read moreskeptical. But the food and service are excellent! They offer gluten free pizza crust and were very accommodating to my special order. Highly recommend giving this place a try! The spanikopita appetizer was a fave along with the staple T Ravs.

Hercules

Cheese pizza!

See all

Grecian Panini and sweet potato fries!

Shakespeare's Pizza - West

3.7(74 reviews)

3.3 mi

Bring your own (vegan) cheese and they will use it on an amazing vegetarian pizza like the one I…read morescored yesterday. Thank you, Shakespeare's! The free stickers are cool as well.

Amazing pizza place to bring your kids!…read more There is a section with steps for kids to walk on and look through the window. Then above it is a hole where workers throw pieces of dough through for the kids to catch and later play with! Such a genius idea because it keeps the kids and adults entertained. Inside vibe of this place is awesome with an Italian man statue that the babies pointed out. There is a bar deep inside the restaurant almost a little hidden which has TVs. There is also a small section with a driving game, and two claw machine games where all kids gravitated towards. Pizza was good, they offer multiple sizes and flexible toppings. Serve your own soda/beverages. Red pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese offered as well. They also give towels. Wish the crust had more crunch or fluff but it was right in between I highly recommend eating here!