Square Grouper Bar & Grill was the perfect last stop on our way home from the Keys! I had been searching all over for a great Key lime martini, and this one absolutely exceeded my expectations. It was perfectly balanced--tart, sweet, smooth, and strong without being overpowering. It was exactly what I had been hoping to find. Our bartender, Megan, made the experience even better. She was incredibly sweet, attentive, and genuinely friendly from start to finish. Since my friend was driving and didn't want alcohol, Megan made her a Key lime margarita-style mocktail that was absolutely delicious and so refreshing. It made my friend feel just as included in the experience, which we really appreciated. The service was outstanding from everyone we encountered. From the host who welcomed us to the team serving our food, everyone was warm, kind, and attentive. Our waters were refilled multiple times without us ever having to ask, and we always felt well taken care of. We ordered the buffalo shrimp, which came out hot, fresh, crispy, and packed with flavor. To finish, we shared the Oreo cheesecake, and it was the perfect ending to our meal. Megan checked in on us throughout our visit, making sure we were enjoying everything, and her genuine hospitality really stood out. This was, without a doubt, the best customer service we've experienced anywhere in the Florida Keys. We can't wait to come back the next time we're in Islamorada! read more

our server Ron was awesome !! He knew the menu and He recommended the tile fish bites for an appetizer and led us to all the right entrees! He was very attentive and friendly!! we have been coming to Islamorada for decades and this was our first time ! Food was absolutely amazing !!!! Best meal we have had by far in Islamorada ! we will be back at the end of July and for sure will be eating at Square Grouper and hopefully have Ron as our server ! The atmosphere Is very relaxing! read more

My favorite spot this whole trip! My boyfriend and I are on our first weekend getaway together. We decided our last dinner in town would be here. Our friend Bubba highly recommended it, saying "square grouper slaps." If you know him, you know that is extremely high praise. Let me tell you, square grouper does indeed slap. We were seated on the patio, facing the marina. We got to watch a magical sunset as we literally stuffed ourselves stupid with a variety of insanely yummo seafood. We got the coconut shrimp, portobello fries, scallops, and the tile fish, all per the amazing Ari's recommendations. Did I take any pictures NO I was enjoying a wonderful evening with my yummy man. They were all absolute wins. I've never had coconut shrimp before, and these were absolutely delightful- tender and tropical, which is not a flavor I thought I would enjoy but was happy at that uno reverse. The portobello fries were crisp and juicy?? And meaty from the mushroom?? Idk man a bitch was into it I ate them all. My scallops were divine- they came with this pork belly and sweet potato hash and just pleasured every tastebud with every bite. His tile fish was good, it was crispy and gorg. He ate the whole thing so fast, while commenting in between bites how much he was enjoying it. We also got the key lime pie (mine) and the brownie (his). It was literally my favorite key lime pie of the whole trip, it was so good. We couldn't finish the desserts and took them home, I'm really excited to have them as the best midnight snack of my life. Amazing Ari- you are a gem. Her service was unmatched. She was so happy, informative, and attentive. Her recommendations did not miss. She took phenomenal pictures for us in front of the water that I can one day show our kids and say "look how hot mom and dad were before you guys!" She needs a 200% raise. Thank you for making our last night here so wonderful! read more

I love all the square groupers in the keys. It's been a few years since I've been to the Islamorada location. I feel like this visit was even better than my last time. Of course I know to go early because the wait gets really long. But while you're waiting, you can hang upstairs at the cocktail lounge, which also has a great happy hour. Once our table was called for dinner we went back downstairs and sat inside to enjoy the air-conditioning. My friend ordered the almond encrusted snapper, which was so delicious. I ordered the wahoo special, which was absolutely incredible. I love how it was still rare like sashimi inside. That's the best way to eat fresh wahoo! My dish blew me away. The drinks were great, service fantastic, and wonderful atmosphere. I'll always return back to square grouper it never disappoints! read more

Cool vibe. Seated pretty quickly. Tuna appetizer was excellent, portion size a little small. Grouper sandwich was very good, serving size was a little small. Service was friendly and prompt. Great place , 100% recommend. Key lime pie was very good. Silky smooth, sweet, coulda been a little more tart. Great place! read more

On our way home from Key West, we stopped here for a delicious lunch. We sat outside m. The grouper sandwich was yummy. Hubby had the cashew salad with shrimp. Perfect! The passion fruit iced tea was refreshing. The service was welcoming and efficient. The ingredients were tasty and fresh. The view of the water was lovely. Very enjoyable! Our server, Ron, was the best! read more

Really nice restaurant with good food. I enjoyed the chicken Philly and side salad, especially after adding some mayo and peppers to the Philly. The Mrs loved her grilled chicken sandwich and shoestring fries. The coleslaw was a little different but also good. It's a little on the pricy side, but everything is in the Keys so just accept it. If you're a tea drinker note that there's no regular tea on the menu, just a passion fruit version. Our server was great and super friendly. The inside is mildly upscale for the area, but not fancy; I'm calling it upscale beachy. They have inside and patio seating, with a view that overlooks the marina/boat ramp. read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Grilled chicken sandwich, fries, coleslaw - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Best seafood, best service, beautiful location and decor. Been coming here, we'll to the original on cudjoe for 8 years. Miss the complimentary bread basket with pretzel bread and cranberry bread. They used to have poutine fries too. read more

We were here in April and very much enjoyed the third floor. Next time we will try the first despite all the warning signs access after 6 was not an issue when we were there. Service was excellent! Everyone worked hard to make sure you had everything you needed. Old Fashions were very good. Stone crab claws are enormous and nicely done. Conche chowder was very tasty and pretzel was amazing. read more

See all

This was our third time coming. I came specifically to eat the sesame seared tuna. We also had the fish dip. This place opens at 5 and when we arrived just before 6 we could not get a table or sit at the bar. We sat at a table outside in 93 degrees weather but the fans helped. Adriana V was our waitress and she was very attentive. My hubby ordered the fish dip which was very good. The jalapeños gave it a spicy bite. He also ordered the yellowtail with jasmine rice. He loved it. He said the portion was big enough. For dessert we had the brownie bread pudding à la mode. It was delicious. The only thing that could have made it better would have been to sit inside in the AC. read more

See all

Food was great. My favorite is upstairs in the cocktail lounge where they have the raw bar. (Can't order food from raw bar if you're downstairs) The shrimp cocktail is the most delicious shrimp and comes with the remoulade and cocktail sauce. My fiancé ordered the yellow tail special which was delicious and I ordered the shrimp pasta which was good. We as well ordered the calamari that was delicious. Parking is limited so get there early because you will most likely have to wait (which means you can go upstairs). The service and ambiance were great and I highly recommended this place. read more

Love the place since opened. Service is always great. Good bar. But portions are getting smaller And taste is not the same. The Fish dip was bland and smaller. Mac and cheese super dry and 3 pieces of lobster. Chicken and waffle: waffles tasted great but was thin cracker size and the chicken was tasteless. Seafood stew was terrible, tasteless- tomato purée and cream. Food quality and preparation has definitely dropped. It's the Keys now, mainly corporate... read more

Square Grouper in Islamorada is our family's favorite restaurant. We make the drive from Miami once a month for it. The fish is always fresh and delicious. If you're visiting me in Miami, I'm taking you here plus the staff is always amazing! read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

It's a cool place to eat at since you're in the marina. Other than that, it's a tourist trap in my opinion. They are super busy so service was not great. Of the three things we ate, the only one I could recommend is the appetizer which was the flash fried conch, get extra wasabi and order it at the same time. We waited 10 mins for the server to bring us a side of it. I ordered the lobster tacos and 90% of it was filler with scraps of lobster. Don't waste your money. I did love the sweet potato fries. Been there, done that, wouldn't go back. read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Blackened grouper sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

incredible vibes incredible food incredible service cant wait to come back make sure you go upstairs for a pre dinner drink read more

See all

This was my second time visiting while we were in the Keys!- first trip with family & kids- excellent! 2nd time on a girls trip- excellent servers and really good food! Try the pickle soup if they have it on special! Fresh fish & salads! Great cocktails & of course views! read more

Delicious food, nice ambience and good service. Had the special lunch panko coated tripletail with rice and a salad with their honey mustard dressing which was light and very good. Tripletail is a white mild fish. Glad I went with that! I will be back. read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Panko encrusted tripletail. - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Our waitress Arie walked us through the menu like a dance. Her knowledge of flavors was very impressive for a young lady. The food and drinks were great. read more

Our server Ron was great. Lively place, great food and atmosphere even at an early dinner. Highly recommend read more

We were told to try Square Grouper from a truly knowledgeable source, who also helped us understand what a square grouper is. Who knew? At any rate, we headed to the Sunset Lounge that opens @ 4:20.We had seats at the bar and were frankly blown away by James, the bartender, the service, the food, it was all amazing. We started with the smoked fish dip - so good - the only thing is I wish the crackers were a bit more substantial. The dip was perfect with dry vodka martinis. I had a wedge salad with lardons and fresh shrimp. Yummy! Wayne had tuna tartare - and there wasn't any of it left. We toasted it all down with a lovely rose' and ended a perfect evening with picking up some awesome merch. Sorry we didn't know about it sooner, but a great place for great food, good service and more. read more

See all

One of the best spots for brunch, lunch, or dinner--Square truly has it all. The ambiance is excellent, the food never disappoints, and the service is consistently great whether you're seated at a table or at the bar. I do have my favorite people there, though! Emily is hands down the best bartender for brunch, and Chris is my go-to bartender for dinner--both in the main dining room. They always make the experience even better. The place is usually packed, which says a lot about its consistency in both food and service. Honestly, I don't think I've ever heard anyone complain about this place. It's just that good. read more

See all

My favorite restaurant. Service is impeccable, bar is second to none food is outstanding and consistent every time. This is a destination in the Keys. Landed in Miami, drove 90 miles in traffic to Islamorada and went straight to the Square Grouper. Only way to start a trip. Food is amazing, drinks are expertly prepared and served. Dessert is splendid. The service is friendly and casual. Can't go wrong at this well run establishment. Place is always buzzing with energy and the Sunset Lounge upstairs is a great companion. read more

See all

The Islamorada location opened last year in a beautiful location We had been going to her first location in the lower keys for years. The second floor is limited to individuals over 21 which is nice. They have a nice happy hour I enjoy eating the great variety of Oysters. You can't go wrong with any item we generally stick to small plates In sure you will enjoy the experience The service is also very good young staff full of energy Enjoy The Square Grouper has gotten 1481 reviews in July read more

Absolutely insane. Food is out of this world, we had Grouper in a variety of ways, Tilefish, Seafood Stew, Yellowtail egg rolls and coconut shrimp. The location is great with an awesome view from the second deck. read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Almond crusted Grouper - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Superb restaurant in Islamorada! My family ate here for lunch this past weekend and really enjoyed it. We had a short wait- 10 minutes or so- and when we were seated our table had a great view of the water! Our waiter was able to accommodate us with 2 high chairs for our kids and there was a great kids menu available as well. I ordered the blackened mahi fish tacos with a side of caesar salad- everything was DELICIOUS! My husband had the coconut shrimp and our toddler had the kids grilled shrimp which was a very generous portion. Absolutely recommend to those in the area! read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - fish tacos with caesar side salad - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

This was our third time here but first time for dinner and it did not disappoint. Every staff member we came in contact with was friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. We chose to sit inside but we could see the beautiful dock and ocean through the large windows. We began with the house salad and conch chowder, both good. The fresh fish dishes were absolutely delicious as you can see from the pictures. Definitely recommend this place. They don't take reservations so come early read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Amazing dinner- fresh fish, innovatively prepared; such a nice break from the traditional fried fare you find everywhere. I had scallops served over a bed of sweet potato and pork belly hash. OMG delicious. Five stars. read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Diver scallops over sweet potato and pork belly hash - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Came here for Happy Hour of $2.00 PBE oysters. So fun - bar opened at 4 and restaurant opens at 5:40. we had a glass of wine and a Dozen fresh oysters . Delicious- fast service and packed quickly. Good food happy hour but not wine HH. Would came again! read more

Wonderful ambiance, food and service. So glad we chose to come here for lunch over other spots we considered in the area. The view outdoors was great, and the kids were thrilled to watch the resident manatees. It was a chilly day, but they had heaters out to keep warm. The cocktails list was interesting; not your usual suspects, but I was super excited about the spicy options, especially jalapeño infused vodka.. I love a good kick to a fruity cocktail. The Spicy Peach Martini did not disappoint.. I had two in the time my husband finished one beer; that's how good it was. The beer list was pretty great too. Our kids ordered off the kids menu and the portions were good; the shrimp was a smaller portion than my son would have liked but he filled up on the fries. The grilled cheese was a larger portion and was also delicious. My husband and I each had a Square Grouper sandwich.. couldn't not get that on our first time here. My hubs had it blackened and I had it fried.. both were seasoned to perfection. I had the Caesar salad as a side (very good!) and my hubs had the chips and coleslaw, both of which he liked very much. We were really glad we had lunch here. Our waitress was great, the atmosphere was wonderful, and the food was delicious. 0 complaints, all compliments. read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Kids grilled shrimp and fries - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

VERY expensive and you all ruined my night by placing that cigarette ash tray of a human next to me. Yes I am allergic and ended up vommitting in your bathroom before the drinks were even delivered. So over-rated.....next! read more

Food is absolutely delicious and so fresh! There is usually a big crowd there but it makes sense because the food is amazing. The wait is usually no longer than 5-10 minutes if you have to wait. Overall great experience and would definitely recommend going there again! read more

Amazing as always!!! The fish dip was the best we ever had!!! Food excellent, service impeccable. Leaving you with my favorite part at lunch here from last month, enjoy!!! read more

Square Grouper - Islamorada - Crabby Mary!!! - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

We had an incredible meal here. Being from Jupiter we wandered if it was affiliated with the one here and it is not. This place is a must go on Islamorada. The food, atmosphere and service were all incredible. Also, it has the best key lime pie in the keys, hands down. read more

Loved everything about this place! We got lucky on parking which was a bonus too. They have a smaller lot, otherwise you could maybe find some street parking. This is definitely the place to be! The location was so cool, right on the canal, with beautiful sunset views, lots of docked boats, and a sweet manatee family. They don't take reservations so we put our name in and then headed to their upstairs bar area for happy hour. They had some pretty good happy hour deals. Drinks were very good as well! A fun spot to hang out until our table was ready. Our table was ready in about 45 minutes. We were lucky and got an outdoor table. They have such a nice outdoor space. The staff was very friendly and attentive. We started off with coconut shrimp which was some of the best I've had. I then had a rice bowl with the catch of the day for dinner. It was the best meal I've had in a long time. Everything was so fresh and flavorful. I can't say enough good things about their food. Our experience was so great we had to come back another night on our vacation. It was that good! Highly reccomend! read more

See all

We drove down from Marathon to check out Square Grouper in Islamorada, and it completely lived up to the hype. Got there around 4:45 on a Saturday and there was already a big line forming, always a good sign. The inside filled up fast, so the four of us grabbed seats at the bar (the outdoor seating looked really nice too, we'd definitely try that next time). We started with cocktails, edamame, and buffalo shrimp, all fresh and flavorful. Then came the mains: I had the blackened wahoo cooked medium rare, it was perfectly done and incredibly fresh, definitely one of the better pieces of fish I've had in the Keys. My girlfriend got the filet mignon sliders which were juicy, tender, and surprisingly filling. My dad ordered the almond-crusted grouper, easily the star dish of the night. Just a perfect balance of flavor and texture. My mom had the seared tuna, also super fresh and really well-prepared. What really stood out was the quality of the seafood, super fresh, well-seasoned, and generous portions all around. We've been coming down to the Keys for over 10 years and places like this are rare. Happy to say we've found a new go-to spot. Highly recommend. read more

See all

This is one of our must-visits when we're down on Purple Island. They offer lunch (which may be new?) and it is fresh and flavorful beyond imagination. We ordered your spiciest bloody Mary's concocted by the lovely bartender Emily who was so knowledgeable and friendly. I ordered the cashew salad with garden greens, red onion, Gorgonzola, maple Dijon mustard and topped with sesame seared ahí tuna and some sesame crackers. This was UNREAL, in addition to my boyfriend's fresh catch of the day, Tilefish with rice and garden salad. We then returned for the highly anticipated happy hour upstairs with a beautiful view starting promptly at 4:20 :D, served great mojitos and even better $2 oysters and $5 stone claw crabs. Despite the madness of trying to find a seat, the bartender was incredibly patient and accommodating. 6 out of 5 stars hands down !! read more

See all

Love the patio (all shade a big plus) and our server Emily was fantastic. Great food, but I do agree with a few other reviews that the fried conch needs less ponzu sauce. Burrata appetizer was more of a salad, but delicious. Coconut shrimp-big and tasty. Fish special with orange buerreblanc was really good, fish tacos, burger and BLT were great too. Winner was the key lime pie (did plain with no berry drizzle). 5th one we've had down here- the filling was a great consistency and tartness with a crunchy graham crust. If we weren't leaving we would hit this one again. read more

Loved this spot! Surrounded by boats and wonderful service, amazing seafood dinners! Take your pick, you can't go wrong, they really know their fish, quite a skill! Even the basic calamari was yummy. Highly reccommend, also check out their other partners on other keys! read more

Ok - let me start by saying that I love seafood. I have tried so many kinds and styles everywhere. I know a good seafood dish from a great one. I had one of the greatest fish dishes I have ever tasted last week at Square Grouper. It was wahoo al pastor which was listed and described as not quite sushi but maybe pan seared just a few seconds. Largely just warmed and seasoned after (maybe) a marinade, it was a joy. Not raw by any means but cooked to exactly the point of being cooked while keeping it moist and tender, it was a perfect fish. There were other things in the table but this one dinner was memorable enough to merit a full blown five star rating from me. Great work, Square Grouper! read more

Great atmosphere, food and service! Recommend for special night out or looking for great food.