Fantastic grandma slice--my favorite pizza in the area. The plain and other specialty slices are also great. Our go-to pizzaria. Their dine-in entrees don't impress as much as the pizza as you can infer from the photos below. But it's truly five-star pizza. read more

See all

As we were driving by, this restaurant caught our eye so we stopped in for dinner. We were sat quickly and presented with a bread and butter basket. Restaurant was clean, full of patrons and on the loud side. For appetizer, my husband ordered the fried shrimp. It was a large serving, served with both tartar and cocktail sauces. There was a nice, crisp breading on the shrimp, but I feel like they were fried just a little too much, as they were fairly dry. As we waited for our entrees, we became aware of the heat in the restaurant. It was extremely hot during a heat wave, and very uncomfortable. To the point, we asked for to-go boxes and our check from the server when she served our entrees. It was too hot to actually enjoy the meal. For dinner, my husband ordered the chicken pinocchio. A generous portion. Smothered in gravy, mushrooms and onions. He said it was delicious. I ordered the appetizer mussels marinara as my Entree. Again, a large portion. The marinara sauce was very good, and there were large slices of garlic throughout, which I enjoyed. Service was good. Unfortunately, it was really just too hot to enjoy the entire experience. read more

See all

Always want to try this restaurant every time we pass by. The restaurant has nice decor and servers are very friendly. Food is good as expected but stuffed mushrooms is not my thing. read more

See all

Have ordered shrimp parmigiana for my dinner today. And this is what I've got. Not that it costs good amount of money, also only 5 shrimps. Moreover they consider it as a dinner plate. Truly disappointing, will never order from here again read more

Spuntino - St. James - Shrimp Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

Amazing food, service & cheap 10/10 experience would come back everyday if I could. My favorite food is there famous garlic knots . read more

Nothing great here ladies and gems It's as average as you can get Not bad (except the stale Pinot noir) and the main dishes as stated not bad but meh read more

See all

Spuntino has always been our go to restaurant for many years. Decent Italian food, good service and pleasant staff, however the last few times we have been there, the service was horrendous. Wait staff is very inattentive. Throughout the meal, it was difficult to get the server's attention for simple things like refilling drinks or asking for condiments. Appetizer dishes were not cleared before dinners were brought over and there was no room for meals plates. The waitress failed to come over and asked if we needed anything the entire time we were there. This last time was a disaster. It seems to be getting worse every time we come. Good service can make or break a dining experience, and unfortunately, this visit missed the mark. Sorry management we won't be coming any time soon until you get on your servers to do better. read more

Spuntino - St. James - Fried zucchini appetizer. Would you pay $14.99 for that? This is not the usual dish we get from Spuntino. This is burned and skimpy. - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

The food is great! When we went it was very quiet. We got a basket of bread once we sat down. I ordered a chicken Caesar salad; there was enough that I brought home my leftovers and got an extra meal out of it. I definitely recommend! read more

Amazing pizza. Amazing food. Amazing staff. Definitely my favorite place on St. James.

This place has THE BEST pizza. Came in a the first few times to grab quick slices and just... wow. Their pizza and bread in general is on point. They figured out the formula and they nail it every time. We recently went to Spuntino's St. James for the full in house dining experience and that was also fabulous - excellent service, friendly staff, very accommodating to any requests we had. We got a table quickly around 6pm but the place started filling up as the night went on. Try the chicken parm (if you don't fill up on the delicious bread first!) or the primavera, great flavors and perfectly cooked chicken. Can't wait to come back! read more

Spuntino - St. James - Chicken Primavera - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

Sputinos has really good food and a nice atmosphere that makes it a fun place to eat. The staff was friendly and the service was quick. I'd definitely go back again and recommend it to other people. Spiny seat read more

See all

Excejjant Great food and experience top food. Will come again. Fabulous time. Yes. read more

I'm never pleased with Long Island pizza. This was a nice thin slice, very crispy, not overly oily, perfect amount of cheese. Just a great slice of regular pizza. read more

I've gone to Spuntino's numerous times in the past two years. Great place with friendly staff and a varied menu. Portions are HUGE; you honestly could get most appetizers as main courses. The main criticism I have is that a lot of the food is SLATHERED in sauces. It's quite overwhelming and I need to remove 2/3rds. Except for the pasta. Pasta is sauced nicely! All in all a great place I'd recommend to others. But if you're looking for a healthy option -- go elsewhere. read more

Sputino's is located right on 25 A in the quaint hamlet of St. james. One of only two St James roads this is on the busier road. Its a bigger Pizza / Italiam restaurant and had a good number pf people enjoying wine, calamari and lunch in the dining area. We grabbed a vegetable slice loaded with Vegs and flavor. Also used some red Vegs in lieu of tomato sauce. They have a good variety of pizza slices, rolls and also a good looking calzone to stay or go. Would also stop again for a pleasant dining location to enjoy sitting and staying a while with wine etc. Casual but nice here. Friendly welcoming people. read more

Spuntino - St. James - Sputino"s - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

Uninviting and unfriendly atmosphere. God forbid you don't have a reservation you get treated as a second class citizen. Never again.

Two friends and I went there 8/22/2025. Ordered the veal Milanese and it was absolutely buried in arugula, a huge mound. It was like 3 bags worth were dumped on the plate and I had to move it aside to get to the veal, which was ok once I found it. read more

Was so excited to eat here because from outside it looks beautiful. Went on a Sunday evening. Dinning room was not full. Food was ok was nothing great. Won't be back. read more

Had lunch at 2:30 today with 5 other ladies. (Seniors) Some had appetizers from the dinner menu and 3 had a regular meal- which wound up from the dinner menu. All the food was excellent. I had veal francais and didn't need a knife to cut it. They said the mussels and shrimp meals were fantastic. Haven't been back for a long time, but sure to remember how delicious the food was, and the service great. read more

Great Pizzeria, lots of choices and food is consistently good. the service is always good and they go above and beyond to make sure your Experience is great. the ambiance is perfect for a pizzeria. read more

Love everything about this place. The food is great. The service is amazing and friendly. The one time we had an issue the manager made a good by giving us a gift certificate. We come here time and time again read more

The service is professional, helpful, and kind. Servers were being attentive and checking on customers throughout the meal. Food could be a bit hotter. Hard to serve a table of 8 all at once if they don't have enough space to keep food warm. read more

Great pizza and service . Sunday music is great . Best pizza around in saint James

Yesterday we had a family birthday party catered by Spuntinos. One of our family favorites. I have to say everything was just perfect! From the on time delivery to eating every delicious bit of it. We always order more so we can share leftovers to go with family. The food here is more than your average Italian restaurants. It isn't my first time catering from Spuntinos, I have been for years and won't be my last. Highly recommend. Thank You Spuntino's! read more

Finally got to check out Spuntinos for dinner with my family. Went on a Sunday and it wasn't too busy. Service and food were both great! We started off with the Arancini with was great! I thought it was going to be served like a rice ball but was surprised to find it served in a large baking dish. It was delicious and definitely can serve a large amount of people. We were able to take more than half of it home! I had the Chicken Milanese and my husband had the Chicken Scarpariello. Very large portions and again, able to take more than half home with us! The drinks were on point and we will definitely be back! read more

See all

I stumbled upon this place and I'm so glad I did! The food was so fresh and tasted amazing. They have an awesome lunch special with many options. The staff was friendly and welcoming. The mozzarella sticks are unmatched!!! Everything was sooooo good! read more

Spuntino - St. James - Chicken Lunch Special Sandwiches and Gorgonzola Salad - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

Stopped by here after seeing it on the side of the highway home. We were starving and stopped in for some pizza. We were sat immediately as there were only about 2-3 tables or people. They let us bring our dog in which was odd but nice, they also brought him some water. We started with the compliment garlic bread-soso yummy. Got a Caesar salad which was loaded with cheese, good but a little too much for my liking. We also got 2 small pizzas for the table, I would recommend this over one larger one. We got a classic margherita and (I cant remember the name, but it had sausage and peppers). Both were so good. Wouldn't return only because it's out of the way and a random decision that we went here. It's on the better side of mediocre but don't go out of your way, interesting location as well. read more

Went during Pasta night special Good portions and bread service. The price is right a great value. read more

Great pizza, great bar, very nice ambiance. Fresh Peroni on tap. Service is quick & polite.

Pizza was old. Pasta dish was dry and charged for a full portion after I had to tell them salad pasta slice of pizza $52 really

You can never go wrong with this restaurant! Drinks are good, food is good, always friendly service! The stuffed artichoke is delicious!! Bring back the stuffed peppers!! We loved those! All in all, excellent and we will continue to visit! read more

Delicious! Love their grandma pizza, fresh basil and delicious seasoned tomatoes on top, super flavorful. Their regular pizza is great but after having the grandma pizza, the regular tastes bland. Really their whole menu is phenomenal from their various pies to the dinners you can't go wrong. This is my favorite place in the area. We've also used them for catering and have been very satisfied. can't say it enough, you can't go wrong with anything on their menu. read more

Spuntino - St. James - Grandma pizza, 2 individual slices - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

They had delicious garlic knots and good pizza when we stopped by. A nice local choice for pizza!

"As a native of Nassau County north shore we rarely get to patronize restaurants further out on the Island. So, when a dear family friend suggested "Spuntino's Brick Oven" Restaurant" in St. James we were curious and off we went. What a very nice surprise to find a restaurant with such a warm and inviting atmosphere along with excellent food. James the owner/mgr came over to make sure everything was ok. He showed genuine concern to make sure his patrons were happy. You need to order their baked stuffed artichoke. You'll be glad you did. Amazing!! As an appetizer it easily feeds four. I highly recommend this place and we'll be back!" read more

I love Spuntino! And this St. Janes location is no different. We came here after perusing a few open houses in the area as house hunting makes us hungry! Our waiter Joe was so nice and so friendly. We gobbled up the focaccia from the bread basket in minutes and he kindly brought us a fresh batch straight from the oven. After all, carbs are the way to my heart. The menu here is the same from our usual Dix Hills locale and it's hard for me to stray from my favorite, the penne melanzane. I usually order it with rigatoni but it was just as good with the penne. Our little dude loved the tortellini brood soup, hubs had the broccoli rabe and grilled chicken panini and MIL had the lasagne. All around, everyone loved their meal and the warm ambiance of Spuntino's. We are happy to know that if we end up moving east that one of our favorite restaurants won't be too far away. read more

Spuntino - St. James - Delicious winter drink menu - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

See all

Atmosphere-- LOVELY! This place can be casual or chic. We experienced live music tonight--very, very nice covers! I wish I took more photos to share. Food is delicious! Ordered the pesto russo, arugula and proscuitto 12" pie and mussels in white win sauce (not pictured). Everything was so tasty. I'm definitely coming back! This was my first time here for a date night, it didnt disappoint. Service was great too! Everyone was so friendly and attentive. read more

Spuntino - St. James - Proscuitto and Arugula - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

See all

This was our first time here, we brought my father in law out for dinner, and I must say.... We truly enjoyed everything! Portions were large. The mussels app was amazing! Try it if you have not yet- excellent!! We will be back! Thank you for a wonderful dinner. read more

Spuntino - St. James - Muscles Rockefeller - Pizza Near Me - St. James, New York

Very good place. Service is fast and reliable, The employee who rang us up Sam was very quick and got down to buisness. The food was better than any of the places ive tried, the angel hair was smooth and very enjoyable along with the flavorfull meatballs. The ambiance of this resturant is very beautiful, great energy in this store. read more

We order lunch from here and they never disappoint . Great food and really great lunch special prices . Highly recommmend read more

Sputinos is a nice Italian restaurant serving classic dishes, and offers a variety of specialty pizza pies. This is a family favorite for us in St. James, and has always been reliable. The service is very good, prompt, and inviting. From dinner service, to take out pizza, you can have confidence that the food will be delicious. The prices are decent, but slightly overpriced given the competition, but fair overall. Nice atmosphere, and comfortable seating indoors and out. Definitely worth a try. read more

See all