Why don't these review sites allow a "0" (zero) rating. DO NOT use Smart Auto Care.
In early 2021, I purchased a used 2012 Land Rover LR4. I spent an additional $4150 for a "Premier" vehicle service contact with Smart Auto Care (SAC). for 60 months, 75k miles with a $100 deductible.
Fast forward ~2 years and the check engine light came on. I took it to a local Land Rover repair facility, one that specializes in Land Rover vehciles. I've been going to this facility for my other Land Rovers for 20 plus years. Reputable and do good work. I use one other facility "in the area" and sometimes the dealership for oil changes of they have a special.
After some checking, it was detemined that the vehicle had a code P0018 relative to camshaft/crankshaft discrepancy. After additonal diagnosis, it was determined that the timing chain is loose and therefore required a set of parts/procedures to be performed, total estimate ~$5200. ~$2000 of which is parts and $3177 of which is labor.
And there's where my nightmare begins.
According to SAC, they use an "average" of local labor rates to come up with an amount that they will pay. That isn't stated anywhere in the policy and so far, they have told me there is no way they can adjust the labor rate. They use the first 4 facilities that come up in a 25 mile radius search using Repairpal and then average those.
They make no disctinction between an oil change corner gas station, or the dealership. They don't care. Not even for a premium vehicle.
So, in the end, I have a $4100+ contract and a $5200 repair bill that will cost me $1700+ out of pocket because they want me to take to some random shop. Yes, they are paying for the parts and part of the labor, but nowhere near the cost of the repair and me having to pay the $100 deductible.
DO NOT BUY a contract from Smart Auto Care unless yu understand this. If you have a local shop or a non specialized or non high end vehicle, it may work for you, but any premium automoble with specialized repair services or needs will NOT be covered because of hte "average labor rate" thing they are doing.
For refercne, dealer rate is $245/hr, my shop is $205/hr and they are willing to pay $120/hr. Timing chain job is rated at 18.4 hrs according to the adjuster, so with the ~$80 difference in labor, it will only cost me ~$1500 plus tax, fees, deductible to get a repair done that IS covered under this contract and I should only have to pay $100.
NOWHERE in the contract does it state that they "use an average" of local repair facilities. I was told I can take to any shop, which I can, but the contract says its at "their sole discretion..." and "..."we will pay UP TO...the published rate"....and they may request that I have the vehicle moved. I just read it that they of course, wouldnt pay over the shops published. I didnt think I had to know that they use some "average" calculation behind the scenes and wont pay the published rate, they will only pay the average rate of shops THEY choose based on their 3rd party software.
They were very clear they are not requestiing I have it moved, only that they have no way to adjust the labor rate. Policy clealry states, "sole discretion" - so they do in fact have the right to pay "up to" the $205/hr at the Land Rover specialized facility, but they will ONLY pay the average of the mom and pop corner stores within 25 miles of ~$121 hr.
TOTAL SCAM. ANYTHING TO NOT HAVE TO PAY.
Update: I called the first 4 shops in the list that SAC provided, and SAC told me that these are the shops they use "to get an average labor rate" and all 4 shops said that they cant or wont work on my vehicle due to capability and or experience.
How is it legal for SCA to provide repair facility labor rate comparisons from shops that CANNOT even do the work.
All I am asking is that they pay the rate f the shop that my vehicle is at, nothgn more. They cant even provide a rate that is 60% of what the shop charges. SO I am stuck with paying 40% because they list shops that have some mysteriously low labor rate but when you call, they cant do the work.
Again, they are scamming people out if their money because when it comes time for them to meet their obligations they have no answer and wont step up.
New Update:
Case was escalated to the "Power Train Manager" of SAC, Gary. He called me this morning and without me saying anything, he agreed to my email proposal of meetng in th emiddle of a the shop wher eits at $205/hr, and the shop that I called frm their list that quoted $160/hr. So they Agreed to $182.50/hr. I will cover the rmeaning remaining $20/hr.
While I don't feel 100% whole in regards to the policy, I ddi offer that compromise, it was accepted and I feel that Gary made it very easy to meet them in the middle so that I am mostly covered and feel like i wasnt completed cheated or have to cover some crazy high repair bill.
Thank you Gary.
For the record, this isn;t the end. The tear dwn has to happen etc. to be cont.... read more