Consistently good. Almost always open. Delicious thin crust NY pizza served as whole pies or by the slice. Excellent grandma pizza too. Fast service. Reasonable prices. Limited assortment of Italian dishes besides pizza. Depressingly run down dining room but some nice outdoor seating. Plenty of free parking. read more

Called ahead for 2 pizzas and mozzarella sticks. Got there after the 25 minutes they told us it would take, and it was completely empty. They told us our food wasn't ready. The guy slicing the pizza was not wearing his mask over his nose. We took our food home and in the mozzarella sticks we found a chicken bone. Will not be returning, we lost our appetite. read more

Slice of Heaven - Mozzarella Sticks with a side of chicken bone - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

We ordered pizza from here. Half chicken parm and half eggplant and one plain. Delicious is all I can say! Generous portions, quick delivery! We will be ordering from them again! read more

I just want to say how amazing Slice of Heaven and the owners are! We were down for the week and my kids would go almost everyday for a slice. On Friday night which is one of the busiest nights probably for the pizzerias as everyone is leaving the next morning. We ordered our pizza and it did not show up. Come to find out the poor delivery driver got into a fender bender. We called and asked about it and the owner was so apologetic and she remade our pizza and delivered it herself! Thank you so much for your amazing service and amazing pizza! read more

We ordered a Stromboli and this is what we received. For $18 I would expect more than bagged mozzarella cheese that doesn't even melt when heated. Very disappointed in the quality. Many other places on the island that use real, Italian ingredients in their cooking. Thank you, next read more

Slice of Heaven - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Pretty good pizza. Foldable crust, thinnish and crispy the way we like it (some may not) cheese and sauce was also very good. Pizza size was average and adequate. Not the north Jersey pizza some are accustomed to, but still a good place for pizza if you are looking for a solid, good tasting pie. FYI, NO free refills on fountain drinks. read more

Slice of Heaven - Large plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Really good slice if you eat it on the premises I ordered 2 slices of regular pizza on two different days. Once, I had them plain. The second time, I asked them to add mushrooms. The mushrooms both here and in another pizza establishment we visited were canned mushrooms. They were fine. I was surprised; where I live, fresh mushrooms are added to pies. The pizza was really good the day I ate it on their porch, right out of the hot oven. It wasn't as good when I drove it home to our rental house. Maybe if I had taken the trouble to heat it up again read more

I think you have the best pizza on the island but your place is disgusting. I would deal with that for great pizza if your sanitation procedures were up to snuff. The guy making my pizza, balding with a beard, was leaning over the pizza board, rubbing his whole face with both his hands. Proceeded to make another pizza. No hand washing. No gloves. Two weeks ago, a middle aged lady with a teenager were just as oblivious that they were making peoples food. BTW, the place is filthy. Clean it up or sell it to somebody that knows how to run a restaurant. read more

Tasty pizza. Not too many places on LBI can serve you Ham & Pineapple on a pizza (Hawaiian), but Slice of Heaven can!! Phoned it in and it was ready when we arrived. Value is strong! read more

I didn't even get my chicken tenders.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was starving. Customer get 5 stars , gave me slice of pizza!

We had a catering order done from here for 24 people. Pizza and trays of entrees were excellent. Communication was great, service was great and food was delivered right on time! Will most certainly use them again. read more

I've been coming to LBI since I was born and slice of heaven is always a staple. Over the 23 years they have varied in quality (naturally). But regardless I love it. Not sure how the rating isn't higher honestly. Even with my high pizza standards, slice of heaven always holds a place in my heart and stomach. The plain pie is stellar and Buffalo as well. Quality chicken and good Buffalo sauce made up for the not fully melted cheese. Overall would recommend this place and always take friends and family when I come down. read more

Slice of Heaven - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Pizza is so bad it didn't even make the LBI short list of best pizza. How does this place stay open. Friends tried it last wknd as last resort when arriving here late. It's just bad. Pizza guy was miserable and there was guy sitting in corner barking orders to poor girls. https://www.newsbreakapp.com/n/0bXlBVBa?pd=09X2uyAd&lang=en_US&s=i16 read more

Slice of Heaven - Old menu now new menue with have the items removed - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

I recently got a cheesesteak from Slice of Heaven. This cheesesteak was absolutely amazing. I don't know who made it but I would consider giving them a raise. I ate half for dinner and then half for lunch and the quality both times was amazing. Thank you Slice of Heaven. I will be coming back to get another cheesesteak very soon. read more

Great pizza, fast and delicious! Perfect spot to get a few pies for a crowd. Ordered 8 pizzas for a group dinner, order was done as instructed and on time. Would recommend read more

All the way from California , hoping for some good pizza but sorry they pies were not good. $20 for a large pizza, so much cheese you couldn't tear the slices, asked for well done, it was limp, and honestly no flavor. Pretty bummed considering I spent over $40 for lunch and didn't want to eat more than one slice. Sorry to be negative but hopefully this helps you do better? read more

Worst pizza I've ever had!When I was eating it I felt like I was eating cardboard.The dough is very dry and hard,the cheese is super dry and crusty, and the sauce is just nasty.If you want good pizza dont go here. read more

Highly recommended. Calzones are by favorite. Abundant toppings. Stuffed pizza will satisfy the most voracious appetites. The sauce is excellent. Discount for cash. read more

This place is AMAZING. The owners are so nice and always courteous. The food is great. I've had pizza and sandwiches and they are always delicious and fresh. Expect a line, is WORTH THE WAIT. read more

Remember when Chef Boyardee had a pizza kit for busy moms way back in the Sixties? Probably not. I mean, who wanted to eat a pizza that came in a little box in Aisle 5? That's the kind of memory that needs to be suppressed, much like my recent pizza from Slice of Heaven. First of all, consider changing your name to Slice of Hell. That's how bad was the pie we ordered for delivery. We ordered a spinach/mushroom pizza, fools that we are. We're used to fresh ingredients, so we were fully expecting leaves of spinach and freshly sliced mushrooms. What did we get? Chunks of spinach from the kind of frozen block found in grocery stores. The albino mushrooms came straight from a can. I have never thrown out $25 worth of pizza before. It was so unpalatable that it went straight into the trash can. read more

My family and i just ordered our annual slice of heaven meal from our guy while its our last night here on lbi.. we did 2 pies, 1 plain 1 pepp. And 2 chicken cheesesteaks. How anyone gives this spot less than a 4 or 5 is beyond me. This is by far my favorite spot on the island.. i saw a few bad reviews, and dont quite understand. But, to each their own. Keep up the great work and quality food guys! Thanks again for an awesome night of pizza and sangwiches! See ya next year! read more

See all

The mozzarella sticks and french fries had absolutely zero seasoning. Bland and forgettable. The pizza was about as appealing as a frozen Totino's pizza. The only reason they get even one star is because their crust is decent. read more

DONT Order wings without asking for price. NONE on the board and when my son got home, he said the wings were $26.00 a dozen is that sound right? Price gouging at its best that's for certain. Live next to this place and will never go again just based on principal. Yes, prices have gone up and we travel the US monthly and see it but come on guys! 1. Cheese Pizza 2. 24 wings $76.00 read more

A damn good slice, could use a renovation though but who cares it's a pizza joint. Reasonably priced too

Really enjoyed the pizza from here. I thought it might only be "ok" based on the rating. I like to consider myself a bit of a pizza snob and really enjoyed it here. read more

So this pizza was sooo expensive. I'm from NYC and this was the same price per slice as a giant slice in the city but way smaller. The pizza was fine but not worth $4 a slice. I wish the price of slices was posted somewhere. I didn't notice until after I ordered that the pie prices were posted and a large cheese pizza was $20. That math doesn't add up, I would have gotten more for my money if I had just ordered a pie. Everything on the island is expensive but overall, I was pretty disappointed as I kinda feel like they're trying to pull one over on their customers. read more

This was a very good slice. We walked over here after we saw our favorite joint "O'Malleys" pizza was closed. It's in a strip mall, and has some outdoor seating - which we liked. There area Tons of slice options. The pepperoni was crispy, and the sauce was great. The pasta pizza however was limp. Nice, clean, air conditioned, and a bathroom. Great for us. read more

Slice of Heaven - BBQ chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Very good pizza, we tried a variety and the margarita was crisp and tasty with a flavorful sauce. The pepperoni pizza was cooked perfectly with just a bit of crisp on the pepperoni and the white veggie was full of veggies. read more

Excellent thin crust pizza but they also make grandma and other styles. Have a small menu of other dishes but they are known for their pizza. Old, divey building, but usually clean. Carry out or eat there inside or out. Park in front or in their lot. Reasonable prices. Usually open late in season. Open all year round but not every day. read more

Delicious food and kind staff! Pizza, salad, and chicken cutlet were great! Even though the food took a while, the staff was nice and offered a free soda for the wait! read more

Slice of Heaven is a got-to-go-to place every time we visit Long Beach Island, at any time of year. The cheesesteak is exceptional and their pizza is as good a board-walk pizza you will find on the island. One of the great things about LBI is that you will not find any chain restaurants on the island. Finding a gem of a place like Slice of Heaven is perfect. If however you are looking for one of the chain restaurants - go back over the bridge.... but you will be missing out. read more

Good service. Bland pizza. The first time I ever added salt to a pizza to give it some flavor.

My daughter really enjoyed the hero she ordered... She said the sauce on the chicken cutlet was great. Were it not for the attitude we experienced with the gentleman who was cleaning the outdoor seating area, this would have been a five-staff recommendation. However, when when the man came out of the establishment, he kept staring at us with this look of disdain. He continued to go in and out shaking his head. My daughter thought this may have been because a couple of us had shakes from the establishment next door. I would understand that; the seating is for their customers, not for the adjacent business. The signs posted outside of the pizza place clearly indicate they don't want "outside" food. However, there were eight of us in our party, and six of the eight had ordered food and were still eating. We weren't using their space, we were joining our party as they enjoyed their meal. read more

Pizza has gotten good and I'd say it has become better than Bay Village Pizza. Will be my choice spot!

Employees, including the one making pizza, wearing masks under their chins. One employee wiped his whole face with his hand. Other reviews say the same and clearly they've taken no steps to fix it. read more

I typical conversation with these people is like "we're out of that, we're out of that also, we're out of that also"... They seem to be out of a lot of stuff. They couldn't even take a pizza order with the toppings correctly. They overcharged us and then tried to feed us some bologna about a hacked menu that we ordered from online. We actually now call the place Slice of Hell. Its a pretty run of the mill overcharging shore town pizza joint. I wouldn't ever go back here, not like they'd have the we wanted to order anyway. read more

Love this place!!! Great pizza and owners are awesome. Anytime there is an issue they are aware of they rectify it right on the spot.

Came here for lunch and got a chicken parm sandwich and it was bomb. Cheap and filling. Quick too because it's prepared earlier so I'll Be back to get this again read more

Slice of Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Three words for you: Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Slice of Heaven? OMG, yes. Wonderfully crunchy, not burnt crust, delicious toppings and sauces. I ordered a couple slices (big slices too). A joy to eat. Cute, friendly staff. Prices are a little high, but I wasn't sorry and I certainly don't have a lot of spare cash. Also, you can't go wrong with a Ben and Jerry's nearby for dessert. Plenty of room inside to eat, some outdoor seating. Its a block or two from the beach, and after a summer of tourists with sandy feet and screaming, salty kids, it gets a little messy. Still worth a trip. My friend from Manhattan comes down to visit me every spring before the tourists hit and we come here for lunch. We always sit outside and I have never had to stand up to let someone out of the restaurant. There are two doors, if I recall. One caveat: don't get a pizza to take home unless you live close by. I am 15/20 minutes away and by the time we got home, the crust wasn't as amazing. Softened up a bit. (Dad wasn't impressed). I, however, love it. Have to come here once or twice a summer, just for that buffalo chicken pizza. :) read more

Spent the weekend in Beach Haven with some of my girlfriends and we were STARVING. We weren't in the mood to fire up the stove and getting pizza delivered seemed like the best idea. It hit the spot. We even went so far as to enjoy slices on the beach. The delivery guy got extremely lost (our rental was a little hard to find) and he was a temp, and rather grumpy. Then again, I'm sure I would be too if I was lost. If you're staying in the Beach Haven/Holgate area, give this place a call. read more