This a review based on a lunchtime take out order. I visited for the first time a couple of days ago and got the meats slice and the fried mozzarella. The pizza slice was pretty good - not horrible but not spectacular either. I would definitely come back one day for a freshly made whole pizza! I really enjoyed the fried mozzarella - the cheese tasted pretty fresh, the breading was good, and the marinara sauce tasted as if it was made in-house. It's a dish that probably would've been better eaten inside, because the heat and condensation from the container sorta softened the breading by the time I made it home. As some other reviews mentioned, the ambiance inside is a little dull. The soda machine was broken, so I'm not sure if drinks are available, but the young guys that were working were pretty friendly. The seating area seemed pretty spacious, though unoccupied. read more

See all

I hate I gotta do this but slice midtown. No sir. Maybe I could've asked them to run my slide through again but it was floppy & not that good. They get 4 stars because they're open late. 5/10 slice read more

Slice Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Tennessee

Fantastic food . Friendly service and the place is very clean . Best pizza around. You will not be disappointed .

We ordered Grandma's Pizza thru Uber eats while we were at Memphis Made Brewery. It was delivered quickly, and I really liked the pizza. I look forward to checking out the place soon. read more

My family and I had lunch there today. The pizza and spaghetti were first rate. Service was excellent. I recommend this place highly. Please give them your business, you won't be sorry. read more

Pizza is good but quality seems to be slowly deeclining...this place is falling apart, their soda machine has been broken for a long time, their floors are dirty despite being the morning and not being busy, their bench has grease stains just needs a wipe down. The eating spot on the window has part of it that is rotting away looks like water damage, the back room is being treated like storage. Nobody is sweeping or mopping, there is a dead cockroach and other misc garbage on the floor. They have a fridge that also seems to be broken, the little cooler they are now keeping drinks is barely cold enough to cool drinks and not well. This place will eventually close unfortunately and soon quality will be bad enough I won't even want to go. read more

I got the Grandmas Pizza, Strumboli, & 2 Cannolis. Everything was amazing! The pizza and strumboli were so flavorful & the cannolis were also delicious. The staff make you feel right at home, providing you with a comfortable & cozy atmosphere to eat some of the best pizza in memphis! read more

See all

So, I have been a loyal customer of the previous establishment in this location for a while. I found Slice when I tried to place an order & the number to the previous business was disconnected. Blessing in disguise. I've order the meat lovers a couple of times now & it is just TASTY & not greasy. You can taste the quality in the meat they use. The sauce isn't too much & compliments the rest of the ingredients. For reference, I love a thin crust & theirs is cooked to perfection. Yes, I personally always order the large because it taste that good & warms up well (hint: put in a skillet to crisp up the crust). BUT, it is also good cold. I will eat their pizza either way. If you are ordering from here, be conscience of the sizes. This isn't like order from those other chain places. When you get a large, that is exactly what you are getting. read more

I like the idea of the Big Box Sampler but the wings really made me rethink my decision of spending $30 on this. I've never had wings with little to no meat on them and being it was one of 2 proteins in the box, it just wasn't worth the price. Food quality and taste is like any other pizza spot. Very underwhelming to say the least read more

See all

Great pizza. I'm a cheese only guy and it didn't disappoint. I highly recommend. Kids loved it too.

I really like this pizza New York style is always great. Some of the sandwiches are real good. I love the spaghetti sandwich when it's done correctly. I love the Italian beef, except it would be better if they would dip it. Overall, I love this restaurant they treated everyone well.. Just those few things I mentioned probably would bring them down a star it started as a five read more

When I tell you beyond disappointed. The pictures look good on social media but let me tell you the taste is not there. Everything is BLAND. Started with Garlic knots which were the best thing. The marinara sauce taste like it's straight out of a can just straight tomato sauce no Italian seasoning no salt etc. Fettuccine Alfredo was the biggest disappointment ever. It had absolutely no flavor. It tasted like they just mixed milk and pasta. The most bland dish I've ever had. Tried to add my own salt and pepper but no helping this. Now the pizza, the vodka slice was decent but again no salt just tastes like they take sauce from a can and throw it on the pizza. The white pizza had no flavor. It was like it was just ricotta only. When I tell you big disappointment I mean it. The pictures looked so amazing and left to go eat somewhere else. 2/10 do not recommend read more

Slice Midtown - pizza, pasta, and salad on a table - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Tennessee

The food was delicious. The drinks and food came out promptly. Services was excellent.: the ambience is a nice chill.

For me, best pizza in midtown. Fresh dough, fresh toppings, lots of mozzarella cheese, great service.

Staff were friendly. They recommended the carbonara, which was really tasty. The pancetta was perfect. It also came with salad and bread. We have been traveling for 10 days so I have had a few house salads recently. Most have been iceberg lettuce with croutons and, if they really assert themselves, some finely shredded cheese. This salad was a delightful surprise! Leaf lettuce, red onion, chopped tomatoes and black olives. The menu had a lot to offer but we are only in town for a day. Give them a try! read more

Really good pizza and sides. If you're looking for something more authentic NY style pizza in midtown, this is the place to go.

Ordered several pizzas for a corporate lunch. Kindle, the person in charge of catering, met me and helped me with my order. Asked questions like how many people, what type of people (male/female ratio?/ages (younger to older?) dietary needs, etc. She made great suggestions on what types of pizzas to order as well as how they should be cut (square cut works easier for larger parties) She guaranteed delivery on time and it arrived on time, hot, with plenty of plates & utensils. The pizza was delicious and got lots of compliments from our attendees. Will absolutely order again for future meetings. Thank you for great service and food! read more

As a Memphis Native, I've been searching for NY style pizza for the longest. Finally found it and it did not disappoint! Thin and crispy to perfection. As genuine as it comes, definetely check this place out!! read more

Slice Midtown - Cheese Slice Veggie Slice - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Tennessee

Food and service were amazing. The Kimbrough Tower and the Chopped Cheese were delicious

We went on Friday evening to try something new. Take out. Glad we did. Great people. Old style building. Also has tables to dine in. The restaurant itself looks bland but pizza is FRESH. A lot of shoppers from Uber eats and grub hub go there. We ordered pizza slices, the guy taking orders was super friendly giving us updates. Although our pizza was re heated he waiting till cheese was hot and melty. Delicious. The one taking payments on the right side was warm and welcoming. We will return. read more

Slice Midtown - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Tennessee

See all

Great Caesar Salad, pizza was not as expected at all, wouldn't order again. All the toppings we either missing or in the center of the pizza only, no flavor at all. Not what little Italy used to be. read more

Their food is hot or miss. More miss than hit really garlic knots are bomb if you get them cooked thoroughly read more

Slice Midtown - This was not good. Bland. Not even salt and pepper. - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Tennessee

Love the food here! Haven't tasted anything I didn't like here. For our "locked -in staycation" anniversary, hubby and I had a "buffet" of items delivered to share... chicken parm (huge portion), fried zucchini (dip it in their homemade Caesar dressing!), cheese ravioli, white pizza... all yum! read more

Well we apparently live under a rock because when we went to order from Little Italy we found out it was closed. Since we had pizza on our minds we went ahead and ordered from this new owner/business. We ordered online and it was ready when promised. And wow what a nice surprise! The pizza was really good and we also ordered the sampler platter which was a fun way to try all the different appetizers and they were all delicious. We will be back! read more

It's hard to replace a legendary pizza joint, but you gotta know what you're getting into. Menu is the same, but don't expect that classic NY pie you were used to. My order looked underdone but wasn't when I bit in, just not the consistency I was looking for. Maybe they're still experimenting with the dough but they should have worked out those kinks before they opened. Especially considering the shoes they're trying to fill. Go to Aldo's or High Point instead. Update: tried Slices again last night, and am happy to say they've worked out their kinks. The pizza was very good, although I do admit that I popped it in the oven a bit to get a crispier crust. read more

The wait staff is so kind and attentive...we ordered to go and the gentleman at the counter couldn't be more attentive and personable. The margarita pizza is Phenomenal, ingredients so fresh! Highly recommend! read more

Delicious, Delicious, Delicious! I've been there twice and have yet to have a slice of pizza! They have a wonderful variety of dishes! So excited to keep discovering authentic Italian meals. I'm sure it's somebody's mama's recipe they're using because it's really good! If you've not been, do yourself a favor and go. Super nice ppl, clean and love the remodel. Looks kinda like a café. read more

We ordered online for delivery, and the chicken was bone dry. They forgot one of our salads, food honestly was not great. The vodka pasta is completely different from how it used to be, to me it just tasted like plain spaghetti sauce and it was not good at all. The only thing that was good was the pizza, which was the original recipe from little Italy. But other than that, would not order from again. read more

I was the world's biggest Little Italy fan, and while I was super sad to hear they were leaving midtown right after we had moved closer, I was glad to hear that Slice was going to use the same recipes and suppliers. The first time we tried them, we were excited. However, our large pepperoni pizza came...cold, and not from just sitting out, but like the pizza had been made as a cheese pie, sat aside, then with toppings placed on top of it and run back into the oven just for warming. The pepperonis were not cooked through, still having solid fat, and they were not adhered to the pie at all (would literally fall off if you tipped a slice). We figured, no problem, growing pains, we love local businesses and we want to try them again. We have done so, and each time it has been similar--undercooked food, or obvious shortcuts such as these. Our last (probably very last) attempt was this past week. We got a pepperoni pie again, and once again, it was the same exact issue, though slightly less bad (still looked as if they'd been sat on top of a cheese pie, but were more cooked through). We got cheesesticks that had plenty of yummy cheese on top and I was so eager to dive in, but when I bit into it, I found a yeasty, underdone dough, congealed cheese that was still not even melted fully together inside, and an overpowering clump of parsley. I took one bite and the rest of the box went uneaten by the 4 people in the household. I suspect that they are either not leaving the food in the oven long enough or they are cooking at a lower temp. I'd like to say we will give them another chance, but if we do, it will be a long while to give them time to adjust for these issues. They are not cheap, and we were super sad to have to waste so much expensive food (with good quality ingredients to be sure). I think they are trying, but the quality is not there yet. I hope they get there and I'll be the their best customer! read more