Had lunch at Sleepy Hallow on Sunday. The potato salad is one of a kind. The ham and cheese hoagie was delicious and served on a fresh roll. My wife said that the lettuce wrap was delicious. We eat here almost every Sunday. Great place. read more

See all

Very clean deli Everything is fresh. My fav is the corned beef special. The employees are very friendly

Sleepy Hollow Delly has been around since the late '50s, this family -owned and -operated deli is known for their famous potato salad. Their extensive menu also offers breakfast items, soups, lettuce bowls, hoagies, grinders, chicken sandwiches, sides (such as buffalo chicken tenders, onion rings, etc.), and other homemade salads (such as coleslaw, macaroni, broccoli, pasta, etc.). We group of us came here for a later lunch, and we ordered: +Mozzarella Stix - came with 5 pieces with a side of marinara sauce; these were larger in size, and the kids enjoyed it +Grilled Cheese with Tomato & Bacon - this was enjoyed and it was stated that the bread and the combination of the tomato and the bacon were delicious +a Turkey Club Hoagie without bacon - super stacked and fresh, this was tasty and a great hoagie +Hot Roast Beef with a side of au jus and horseradish - definitely better with a side of au jus to make it more 'wet' +a pound of Potato Salad - these are housemade often, and these were literally being ordered non-stop; make sure you chill it before eating as it makes a huge difference! It was creamy and had a nice little tang to it Service was friendly, and there were a handful of tables where you can dine-in and enjoy your orders. This place seemed to have been recently renovated as well. There's limited parking in the back in their small lot, but there's also street parking available. Pay with cash so you don't get charged for the CC fee! +potato salad! +great hoagies +friendly service +street parking available read more

See all

Excellent chef lettuce bowl. Ordered potato salad and it is awesome. The lettuce bowl was excellent also. Staff so friendly and polite. The young man behind counter addressed me as Miss. I loved that ma'am sounds so old. Will definitely be back to try other items and more potato salad. read more

Sleepy Hollow has the Best steak egg n cheese breakfast sandwiches. Also solid beer selection

Potato salad is amazing. The hot roast beef either horseradish was excellent as well. I highly recommend.

This hidden gem is worth visiting. The workers are welcoming & show patience to their patrons. The fried mozzarella are great. The Potato Salad is truly the Best as well. read more

Well, as soon as I saw this place, I knew I would have to stop in there soon to try their "famous" potato salad. After seeing rave review after rave review on the Delco Restaurant Review Facebook page, and being a potato salad aficionado, I was so happy to stumble upon it in my travels. I have to say, the potato salad did live up to the hype!!! They use the right potatoes (the waxy ones, not the russets) which are great for potato salad. No eggs, but I really didn't miss them. Other than that, probably just the basics - some mayo, onion, celery, and celery seed. I hear their chicken salad is really good too but I didn't pick any up on this trip. Next time! read more

Sleepy Hollow Delly - Delis Near Me - Springfield, Pennsylvania

Good day to be the cheesesteak guy. Great little place. Unfortunately the cheesesteak was the weak link. Great family run business with Grandma and dad pics on the wall. They support other local business' ie. Fireman donuts. which were good and made by a fireman. Lettuce and Tomato may have ruined this cheesesteak. The meat needed to be on this big bready roll and not on top of the lettuce and Tomato. Overall it was a great experience. read more

See all

Yummy in my tummy soooooo good I love the food and they are vary cool and chill. Also I love the people who work here. Freedy faz bear

Deli meats such as Turkey and roast beef had a bitter taste. Potato salad tasted old and bland! Cannot believe the guarantee promise I read inside about their famous potato salad. Stale bread too and the only thing I liked was the pickle. Tablets making noises and an owner lady appears to yell at her employees in front of the customers all because the lady in front of me wanted to pay for her Kaiser rolls with a card instead of cash. They charge a lousy 4 percent charge with all cards. I don't know how this place exits! Never again. Go to Jems deli up the road. read more

Grotty digs and no A/C, but even so, friendly staff and a family-run jawn. An extensive menu of wraps, salads, hoagies, steaks and fried goodies. The food itself was just OK. I had a wrap and the bacon tasted a wee bit sour. (Odd) Plus it was drowning in ranch dressing. Next time (if there is a next time) I will get less dressing or ask for it on the side. I want to support and love local businesses - and Sleepy Hollow is a neighborhood fave, but for me it was just OK. read more

Shout out to the staff at Sleepy Hollow who maintained their professionalism when the delly ran out of potato salad!! Your friendliness and courtesy did not go unnoticed! I will order the potato salad next time to make sure I don't leave empty handed:). It's that good folks! read more

One of these days I had to try this place. I love these kind of places. They remind me of the old Trio's Cold Cuts in Clifton Heights that my family frequented religiously when I was a kid. Opportunity presented itself this past weekend. I judge a lot of deli places based on how well they make a basic sandwich. My benchmark is the good ol Turkey Special with rye bread, Russian dressing, and cole slaw. I tried this with a side of the famous potato salad and an ice cold beer. Now, they use the deli sliced turkey for this sandwich, not sliced turkey from the bone. I suppose I can't hold this against a local place like this. It's not like they can roast turkeys every day. But the bread was soft, the cole slaw was fresh, and I polished it off. But here's where they won the 4th star. That potato salad... It's legit! In an area like Delco where everyone's grandmother has a potato salad recipe, you have to be strong when you claim to be a potato salad master. It was a fine lunch. read more

I want to write this review because of the fact that I really like this Delly because it is a local known business! It is a bit expensive, the problem with this establishment is it is not consistent I love the potato salad when it is on point!Over the past few years I have had to go back and return my salad due to it being sour. I will say when I go back they do not give me a hard time exchanging. I really absolutely love the macaroni salad also, I went yesterday to pick up potato salad and cole slaw for Memorial Day and again NO FLAVOR I guess it was not a good batch but it was really expensive. I just want to give a heads up to maybe taste the salad before you leave. read more

Delicious potato salad! The hoagies are great too! Lots of meat. Don't forget to pick up their business card and get a hole punch for every sandwich purchase, to earn a free one! read more

Delicious!!! So happy its so close to my house. The potato salad is indeed delicious. Wish their broccoli salad came without bacon (vegetarian here) but they've been very kind accommodating my other dietary needs thus far! A little expensive but great otherwise! read more

I always drive by, today I decided to stop in. Typical deli with an assortment of hot and cold sandwiches. They serve breakfast all day. Countertop seating with 4 booths. Take out Beer available. My lunch was very satisfying, will definitely be back again. Like other reviewers said, my wife agrees the potato salad is very good! read more

Stopped here to pick up some of their potato salad that has been well regarded and reviewed. The potato salad aficionado in my family agreed that this potato salad is pretty good for store bought. Service here is fast but somewhat perfunctory. read more

Solid 4 stars...nice part of Springfield/good location/easy to find, AWESOME potato salad, decent menu otherwise, friendly staff. Potato salad-albeit expensive at 4.99 a pound - definitely tasted like my grandmom made it, and just really good. Bought the 5 pounder - perfect to bring to a picnic or luncheon. Solid 4 stars; although the menu did seem a bit overpriced for what it was (beyond the potato salad, which is in a category of its own for me!). Broccoli bites and other similar frozen then fried US Foods/Sysco appetizers averaged 5.99 plus-waaaaay overpriced, IMO. I'll pay for quality, homemade, Grandma-style potato salad at 4.99 a lb., but 5.99 is just too much for frozen, fried crap. Give Sleepy Hollow a try-the potato salad is a MUST ORDER! read more

Sleepy Hollow Delly - Delis Near Me - Springfield, Pennsylvania

Great sandwiches and the potato salad is amazing!! Just had a cheesesteak and it was really good.

They were horrible and mixed up my order. Was a simple order. They "lady" at the front desk was so rude a replied "I do not no" and walked away read more

We are in town visiting family and my cousin got sandwiches from here to go. We split a cheesesteak and an Italian hoagie, and both were great! If I had to choose one over the other I would pick the hoagie. If we ever come back to the area, we would definitely return. read more

A review that focuses on potato salad?? Yup... That's what I'm finna do... (Gonna, for those not up on southern lingo). I'm always on a search for a great hoagie, and this place made its way onto my list of places to try. I ordered an Italian hoagie with oil, vinegar, and hot peppers on the side. The hoagie was good and would satisfy anyone. The LTO is just as important as the meat that goes on it, and it was as fresh as you'd expect. Now on to the potato salad. I usually pass on anyplace touting the "Word Famous" anything... I found myself ordering the potato salad anyway while waiting on my sandwich. I wound up enjoying this more than what I originally came in for. It was simple, yet flavorful. Tasted like there was a little sour cream in it along with celery seed. I have left plenty of potato salad on plates because of how horrible It was. I don't know about the world's best claim. But this place can definitely tell people that they won't find any better, anywhere near by... read more

(3.75) ~ Good Overall Food & Service. Note: There are about (4) booths inside and a window counter with about (4) individual seats. There's some parking behind the restaurant for eat-ins and (15) minute street parking on the side for Take-out Orders. MENU: ** Potato Salad = (4) very good version of the "classic style" * S'mores Pop-Tart = (3.75) Good * Italian Grinder = (3.5) good * Apple Juice = (3.5) good read more

I'm new in town & this is quickly becoming one of my favorote delis in the area. I can't vouch for anything other than the Italian grinder & potato salad. There is a small lot behind w/ about 4 spaces and some people park on the side. The potato salad really is that good. Most people order out but I usually dine in & they will bring your food to the booth for you. You'll probably pay about $1 more per hoagie than you would somewhere else but I've never felt bad about it. read more

Sleepy Hollow Delly - Italian grinder - Delis Near Me - Springfield, Pennsylvania

My husband and I are new to Delco, but so far we love Sleepy Hollow Delly! They have great hoagies (We have tried several), wraps, and specials. We have never been disappointed with anything we have ordered. Family members have also stopped here on the way to visit us, and have enjoyed their food. They sell six packs for carry out, which is harder to find in PA. This is a great local deli with friendly staff! read more

Sleepy Hollow has the absolute best potato salad you will ever eat. I am at the point where I honestly won't buy it from anywhere but here. Their food is always fresh and good quality, you always know what pure getting when you go here. Super consistent and really friendly staff! read more

You say potato, I say pototo, either way its the best potato salad in the world! Be careful bringing it to a family/ friends barbecue, they will request it every time for the rest of your life...but it will also guarantee an invite back to every bbq :) read more

I'm up and can't sleep because I'm craving their potato salad. Generally I don't even like potato salad like that but Sleepy Hollow's is like crack. I want. I want. I need. read more

Best potato salad on the planet!!! I don't know what the secret is but this potato salad is to die for! Hardy sandwiches, great service! They have a grill so you can get a cheese steak or hamburger. Beer for take-out but it's a little more $$ than other take-out places or bars. Delivery for lunch only. They close at 8 on weeknights, 9 on weekends. Highly recommend! read more

Sleepy Hollow Deli has been in business for 50 years or more. I have been going there for 40 years and it has never let me down. I love their roast beef hoagies but their salads are some of the best in the county. Always clean. Polite staff. Norm and Erin have done a phenomenal job. I highly recommend this place. read more

I celebrate their potato salad. I challenge you to find a better potato salad in the United States of America. The secret? Have gingers peel potatoes in the back room. That's it. read more

Always a place to get potato salad for a party, it's really good. You can call days ahead to place order for parties. Excellent tuna hoagies and sandwiches. Has a few booths to sit and eat. Has a few shelves of everyday needs like soup, etc. left over from when it was more of a corner store. Serves beer. Parking along side and out back. read more

This place never let me down, was a 4 star. It seems over the last few years they have been on a steady decline in my opinion... amongst others. Customer service is now mediocre at best and value seems to be disappointing. Don't get me wrong, taste is always great, I just feel that I can get a lot more for my money. If I'm paying almost $8 for a sandwich, I expect it to be a good size, not something that I would have to eat 2 of (and I'm not a big guy).Hence my pictures of my grilled Reuben wrap... total let down. Hope they improve because they were always a "go to" place. read more

Ok, I went there and got an Italian hoagie the 12' and I have to say it was very good. Very tasty and yes as previous yelpers stated the potato salad is awesome... I have lived in this area and pass this store year after year , this is a cute place inside. They have some tables inside and outside. I will definitely go back and try something else. read more

The potato salad and the sandwiches are great. The roast beef special sandwich is very good. I have not been disappointed with anything I have had. read more

Love this place. Just moved into the area and this place is probably my favorite sandwich spot in town. The Italian grinder is awesome. The potato salad is also really, really good as well. I would like to see the place a little cleaner though. Floors look like they need to be mopped and there's been a few times we go in and the trash is overflowing. Other than that the place is great. Give it a try! read more

5 stars based solely on the potato salad. I'm not sure what the secret is here but it is really just so magically good. I can't say I've ever had anything else from Sleepy Hollow but I can say if you're looking for the best potato salad you've ever had then you absolutely must go to this deli. read more

Fast, friendly, and most important - DELICIOUS! You can also pick up beer here too making it the best place for one stop shopping. Great food selection, you won't be disappointed.! read more