Sir nicks is an awesome place. Especially for pizza i am hooked on the supreme pizza. It has so much .it's simply delicious.

Great lasagna Deal. So cheesey and flavorful. Guy at the front is so nice. Pizza options even as a slice are great. Keep in mind the pizza that's there for a slice is double dough versus thin crust which is normal Leo what people order so I feel like the pizza slice to go it's double dough. But for this place the pizza hits it right out of the park and then also they have other things that are great so I wouldn't just look for pizza when I go there. read more

Saw this little pizza spot and figured I'd give it go, they only had the Pepperoni jumbo slice available. Compared to other places, slice is average sized and unfortunately wasn't jumbo. Pizza was definitely sitting there for some time, crust was really lackluster and sauce and cheese felt like it was out an old can. Breaded zucchini was the only saving grace, and the main reason I bumped this up from a two star review. read more

This is one of our go-to favorite local pizza shops to order from for Friday pizza night! The pizza is always hot, fresh, and cooked perfectly. The crust has a nice crunch, the cheese is stretchy and gooey, and the pepperonis always have a little char on them. We typically pick-up and it's always ready on time. read more

Wings were wrong (ordered bonein received nasty boneless) and spaghetti was buried in thick tasteless sauce. The best part of the meal was the garlic bread. read more

Have ordered from them a couple of times. But today I want to give a shout out to the driver Jason who went above and beyond to make sure our order was correct. Kudos to him for handling it so well. One time I randomly order the Greek pizza....so glad I did. So good. And normally not my cup of tea at all! And now I have repeatedly ordered it. Only thing is I wish they would cut the olives in half to be a bit more proportional, and then no olive pits would be left. Tiramisu: They have prepacks from Eli's.... can't complain Philly: not to shabby. Kinda felt like a beef though. Lasagna: honestly surprised. No flavors were over powering. Good thing but then again a down side. Because the cheesieness compensated for all the flavor. read more

See all

Opened on Christmas! Great Christmas spirit! the big pizza is BIG! Pretty good pizza. The fries are really good! Potato skins were not bad as well. Good spot for pizza nothing crazy but it is good! read more

See all

Great pizza and very friendly staff. Calls me by name and always makes me feel special. Veggie on pizza are always crisp and sweet. Moved me away from my 50 year favorite of only mushrooms, sausage and pepperoni. read more

We have been ordering from here at least once a week for years. Now all of a sudden their prices are raised 30%. Manager was really rude when I called back to question ,why did they give me a old menu with old prices. His reply is they have over 250 menus laying around and they need to get rid of them. Well, they lost a good customer here! read more

Amazing pizza! Try the garlic butter with the stuffed Crust cheese pizza! Can't go wrong with it!

I love the people and the pizza here so I wrote a poem ! I love the pizza at Sir Nick's It's really quite a treat It's always hot and tasty Something I love to eat Every slice I've had here Is fresh and never yucky Because it's made with loving care By my good friends Sid and Lucky These two people are very nice And very much in love They truly are extremely blessed By someone from above They're married now And soon they'll have a child I'll come in one day and say "Nice to meet ya " And think about their legacy As they serve me up my pizza !!! read more

Used to be a regular when lived close by. Now it's my go to spot when in town. Great food good service. The sob Texas Pizza is my favorite. The sauce and bacon is amazing. They don't cheap around with toppings very considerate portions in my opinion. Daily specials too!!!! Also the Mexican food is tasty. read more

I've ordered from this place and its great. Pizza is delicious Texas S. O. B. is my favorite. Also they have a wide selection of food Mexican too!! Big slice on the go and there is specials everyday.. I think on weekdays. Customer service is good as well. When I'm in town this is my go to. read more

SAVE YOUR MONEY. I wanted to as soon as I saw the prices but my husband wanted to try a new (to us) pizza place. Ordered a 14" Hawaiian and the dough in the middle was not cooked through. Jalapeño poppers came out of the freezer section, and customer service when faced with an issue is not good. My husband got cheesy crust, which apparently is cheese stuffed crust, so not sure what the stuffed crust on the menu entails, as the website has no pictures or descriptions. When we tried to cut the pie it was difficult, which led to the discovery of the par baked crust. My husband called the shop to inform them and was met with "what do you want me to do about it?", and got no response when he countered with a request for a properly baked pizza. Instead we got a credit to use next time. $35 for ONE PIZZA that wasn't even cooked should be enough to deter anyone from coming here. read more

See all

UPDATE-------- -I genuinely don't know why I keep giving this place a shot. Good pizza, but extremely unprofessional customer service. Received the wrong pizza yday and supposedly spoke to the owner "Lucky"(twice). He guaranteed me a free pizza same order including the right ingredients the next time I called in. Called in the next day was passed to a person named Alfie who handled the situation weirdly and refused to give me the free pizza. Ummm...ok. I have receipts bro that shit was wrong..ON TOP OF IT, my sis is ALLERGIC to one of the items they mistakenly put on the pizza!- yet, nope, still here's Alfie defending the his pizza warrior stance. Basically he's still talking nonsense. Usually I love this place, and the staff/management, but idk if they're under different ownership or what , but the customer service has gone down shit hole. Now apparently the owner is not there and there's no way of contacting him nor rectifying the mistake(WHICH ONCE AGAIN WAS APPROVED BY THE OWNER..how else would I know this dudes name?) yet...I was still treated like a second class citizen(Yet, I've ordered from here a billion times). I was ranting and raving about how good this place was to my sis who visited from Germany yday. Told her how not only the pizza was bomb, but the staff was super awesome-apparently I spoke to soon. I srsly can't stand when restaurants like this change ownership/management or staff and begin to lack integrity. They also skimp on the condiments and never include plates or napkins regardless if you ask nicely in CAPS. Le Sigh. It's annoying. Guess another one bites the dust. *** Images:( 1)Missing toppings underlined in red. correct toppings that I actually ordered/ missing the mushrooms as well(so basically I paid for 3 toppings and got 1.) (2nd) receipt is what they delivered minus the mushrooms. Sis is allergic to green peppers. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - Missing both ingredients. - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

See all

Growing up in the suburbs of Chicago I was absolutely spoiled with how much good pizza there is nearby. Sir Nicks has always been; and most likely will always be, my family's number one spot. Their pizza is just simply the best. I have loved it since I was a kid amd I have introduced it to numerous friends both local and from out of town. Never have I met someone who doesn't genuinely love it! The meat lovers is my family's favorite and we always get the XL so that we have leftovers! read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - 18" Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

See all

After Portillo's got so cheap on their beefs, we started using sir nicks they haven't disappointed yet

try ur best thin crust pizza. i like thick pizza but this place made me fall in love with thin crust again, but it's just cause it's so good here specifically. try it! do not order the ribs. they are steamed and no good. now I have a taste for pizza just typing about it. read more

I ordered the 24" inch all meat pizza. I was able to feed 3 families and it was delicious for a great price. You can't go wrong with this place. The service is also on point. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

Sir Nick's is our family Friday night pizza spot! Good quality pizza and friendly staff! Recommend the hand tossed.

We finally found our favorite spot for pizza delivery. Always great food and speedy delivery. It is definitely our go to!

My mom and I are super pleased with our pizza. Got the Godmother pizza and it was not greasy at all! So PERFECT! Definitely will be coming back. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - Godmother Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

Just ordered two pizzas from here and they were terrible, the cheese one was dry a d the veggie one was burnt, not to mention how expensive they are. The only good thing was the jalapeño poppers. Won't order again! read more

Love this place, service is phenomenal and their food is always hot fresh and delicious! Order here often it's our go to pizza place!

Food came mashed together but when we called they gave us a new order an hour later. read more

SIR Nick's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Carol Stream, Illinois

Let me begin by saying that this is now my go to spot for delivery. From the gentleman Lucky that took my order and got it all right on the money to the delivery driver,the experience was perfect. Moved out to the burbs from downtown and this has been the first time I was completely and utterly satisfied. Pizza was bomb and ordered the pasta combo baked. Heaven!!! Highly recommend read more

Normally love this place but the customer service i had tonight was terrible. They upgraded my fries without asking me so when i asked to make my 3 gyros into combos he said its to late because he made me large fries... didnt offer to fix the situation so i left without drinks.. got home to check my order and had no receipt. Called the owner Lucky, he said i have to ask for a receipt because he doesnt give that to customers... kinda concerning. Taking my business elsewhere. read more

I really like to place. They have a few stores open around the suburbs and I've never known about it until my brother told me that it is a quick place to grab a slice of pizza. They should make more of these places, and not just in big cities or in college towns, but for the average person for the average day. Sick of having to buy a a whole pizza when I just want a slice. So along with pizza, SIR Nick's also sells other stuff, but I've only gotten the pizza slices. It not like amazingly good pizza, but it's pizza. And the price isn't too bad. 1.50 for a slice (though it like a half slice) which means 3 dollars for a full slice. Good for a quick eat when you get sick of your normal fast food. read more

Price is right and food is well above average. Since we started ordering from here, We have had the pizza, beef sandwich, Italian grinder and the wings. All very good. In addition the staff is very friendly and we have had the same delivery person, Ricky, numerous times. He is the most friendly and polite delivery kid you could have. Highly recommended for quality of food and service. read more

Sir nicks is a go to to-go for the Carol stream area. It's not uncommon for them to mess up an order, so make sure you always check before you leave. They have great prices for their pizza with coupons, so it's a great option if you're entertaining for large groups of people without breaking the bank. If you're looking for a cheap slice, it's like a dollar and some change per slice for a quick lunch. Their fries are comparable to portillos fries but not the pricey price tag. It would be nice if they had a few tables, but it's pretty much a to go place with a few bar stools. read more

2 days ago our credit card came up short 16 cents, yes 16 cents and the guy (Lucky) would not accept being 16 cents short. wow. we are moving on to a different place. perhaps the otr sir nicks nearby. i hope it was worth losing a many yeared customer for 16 cents. rob and martha h. read more

Grew up eating this pizza. I know ownership has changed hands a few time but the recipe seems to have stayed similar. Love this pizza. It's pricer compared to the pizza chains but the quality is much higher. This is some of my favorite pizza in the Chicagoland area. read more

Huge menu to choose from, and prices seem pretty fair. This place has been here upwards of 20 to 25 years, so they must be doing something correct. Foot long polish and fries was excellent, and one time I stopped in and even ordered a few tacos from their Mexican menu (no joke), and those were pretty good! Will try again for sure, but the first few times I had food from here it was very good and enough to warrant future tries. read more

Great pizza and great wings and reasonable prices. I recommend this place. I always get thin crust with extra pepperoni.

Very surprised to learn they have raised their prices significantly during the pandemic. Will not be ordering from them again since this was their response to helping the community. How disappointing. read more

The pizza is so good here. Have had it twice and everyone who had it loved it too! Prices are reasonable as well. This will be our go to pizza joint. read more

Very good pizza. The hours are great if you're ever in the need of a late night snack. I appreciate that because sometimes you just need pizza at 9pm to release some stress. Well at least I do . Do yourself a favor and ask for your pizza well done. I have noticed that this ensures a cooked through pizza and crunchy crust. read more

Hello all of you pizza going yelpers I'm ereck and I'm the morning delivery driver for sir nicks. The food is great the people are nice and the prices are reasonable. Lucky is an amazing guy and boss understanding and reasonable we have the best double dough pizza and the thin crust is on point. In house made pizza sauce dough and nothing but the best quality in the food we serve. I look forward to hopefully seeing you at our location or maybe when I bring you and your family dinner. read more

I have never had an issue with this place. They are nice and quick. The pizza is definitely top 3 in this area. They never let my family down. Pizza is always cooked to perfection. Thanks Sir Nick's. read more

There is no shortage of pizza joints in my area but Sir Nick's is one of the best. We order their thin crust pizzas and usually the hot wings. The pizzas are made with good cheese to sauce proportions. You wont find gobs of sauce, which I am not a fan of on their pizzas. Their hot wings are pretty good and occasionally we order their fries which are fantastic. They are also very nice and you can tell they genuinely appreciate your business. read more