We stopped in on a Monday evening and had a great experience. Had some friends visiting who adore Aurelio's. I've always been a bit on the fence about the pizza, but it's good enough. Our friends LOVE the pizza so it's a win win. Had the Monday special, $15 cheese pizza and $3 PBRs. What really differentiated this visit is when Tom, the owner stopped by to chat. It wasn't very busy but it was delightful hearing about Tom's experience in running the place. The bar area seems pretty quant. Tom said they have music on Fridays that we'll have to check out. Highly recommend stopping here if you're looking for a great pizza and beer experience. read more

I love Aurelio's and have ordered from a few locations on my visits this summer. Was super disappointed July 4 and again this past Monday, July 13. Since my to go pizza was over done on the 4 th I was sure to mention to the girl handing me my pizza and checked it before but once again it was over done. I showed the cashier but she just stared at me. Since I had a meeting to get to I just left. I decided to write the review after showing my sister the pizza. We grew up in Homewood and love the pizza but this was not up to the Aurelio's standard. I had orders this summer from New Lenox and Palos Heights and both were good. Winfield needs to check there oven temp and timing. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Overdone , almost burnt - Italian Near Me - Winfield, Illinois

We just ordered takeout today, it had been a while since we've had their special sauce. Let's just say the pizza was phenomenal! I miss having an Aurelio's nearby. Very tasty indeed ... we'll be back! read more

Ordered online (ticket #60) a 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 sausage fiesta for carry out. Once home, saw that there was no sausage. When we called (we had to talk and wait on hold) to speak with the third person, "Tom". He offered credit for the missing ingredient ($1.75 on a $30+ pizza) or we could return the pizza and they would make a new one but, of course, that meant 30 minute round trip drive and an hour wait. When we told him this was unacceptable, he offered a $10 credit. At this point we asked his name for a Google review and we would take the credit. Then, most galling, he said if we write a review, he was withdrawing the credit or any compensation for their mistake. We've been patrons of Aurelio's since 1976 at various locations including Villa Park, Geneva, and Addison. This is the first time we've ordered from this location. We'll never do that again not only because the customer service was so poor but, quite frankly, the pizza was not what we expect and normally get from Aurelio's read more

Our daughter and son in law brought over a pizza from this Aurelio's last night. Worst pizza ever and I'm 72 and like pizza. They had to know at Aurelio's what was in the box and that most people don't open the box when they pick up an order. If they only would have known. Stuffed pepperoni --[actually black: seemed like the pizza burned and then they layered on another layer of sauce which also burned. Large black burned areas. You had to peel off. Worse pizza ever!!! read more

Absolutely love Aurelio's pizza! The sauce is the best. Service is always friendly and quick. We visit about every 2 months and are never disappointed. read more

Came here for the Bosco sticks and they were delicious! Not a big fan of the sweeter sauce but my gf likes it so we gave it a try. Big bummers was that they do not have a red sauce that is dairy free. So my daughter had to get bbq sauce on her pizza but she liked it. read more

See all

Last two times I've gone here I've gotten EXTREMELY sick. Only had pizza and salad both times. Pizza tastes different I think it's the cheese. It looked weird like it's barely melted and the crust was like cardboard. Unfortunately for my health I think it's best to stay away. Doesn't taste like it used to. read more

order around 6pm guy on the phone stated order would be ready in a hour. We get there around 7. We get told there is 3 pizzas ahead of us and ours wasn't even in the oven yet. I totally get that your slammed before christmas eve nothing wrong with waiting if you're not ready yet. I drove 25 minutes to get there just to go back because our pizza wouldn't be ready for another hour. A simple call saying you were slammed would've been helpful. When I go in and say something all you guys have to say is you're slammed and oh well. That's horrible customer service! read more

Pizza was great. Italian beef bland. Fries hot. Going back for the pizza. Staff excellent. Nice place. Outside seating great.

Best pizza ever!!! Crispy crust, 2 different cheeses, ots of meat and veggies..very flavorful... read more

Still a very quaint and cozy place to come to. Plenty of parking, there's also outdoor seating. The last couple of times I've come they're very short staffed ,so the wait is a little bit longer than normal, given the workforce this is not anything abnormal. Pricing has increased a little bit but this is also apart of the inflation. The host and server were very polite and gave some good recommendations. The place was very sanitary and plenty of room to pick a spot to see wherever you like. Trying the new stuffed sauce pizza, it is deceiving and very filling! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Trio appetizer - Italian Near Me - Winfield, Illinois

See all

Terrible it's good if you like to eat your pizza with a spoon. Service was horrible they got my order wrong both times I went there. Pizza was soggy they give Aurelio's a bad name read more

Classic Aurelio's, just ask for extra sauce on the bottom if you want extra. I love the sauce and always get extra. Delicious!!!!!

Place was hoping on an early Friday night. Ordered dinner salad, fried ravioli and cheese pizza. Everything tasted great. Service was fast and employees very attentive to giving refills and making sure everything was ok. read more

We went there after a volleyball game and the waiters were so kind and funny. The food was incredible and i was stuffed after the pizza. Also, the vibe there was great. read more

didn't really care for it , it might be some peoples cup of tea, but not mine , friendly staff and service

Absolutely horrible. I ordered chicken Parmesan. They gave me sliced microwaved chicken breast. No Parmesan, no cheese in the dish at all. And with some weird sweet meat sauce dumped on top. This is an embarrassment to the dish. And this place is obviously not making it. Anytime a restaurant is being that cheap with ingredients it's best to stay away! Literally anywhere would be better. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Winfield, Illinois

Going to Aurileos these days is like watching your new BMW go over a cliff and your mother-in-law is driving. Pizza? Perfection (long wait but perfection) Service? Just keeps getting worse. Having to beg for a to-go box and for the check just shouldn't happen. We've been going for about 4 years. They have outdoor service and that night had a great band. Loved the pizza. Service great. But the last few visits has shown worsening service which is now in the toilet (funny thing because the men's room toilet overflowed onto the floor) So if you love great pizza - and you're really patient and tolerant of poor service, give it a go. Otherwise... read more

Love the outdoor seating especially with the great weather we are having today. The staff is very friendly. This is a great local place to have drinks with friends and some good food. read more

Aurelio's Pizza - German Grapefruit Beer goes well with boneless wings. Yum - Italian Near Me - Winfield, Illinois

I usually go to the one in Addison but on 02/19/20 decided to come to this one because I was in the area. It is very different in terms of ambiance than the one in Addison (which is 1950s theme). Its modern, plain, sparkly clean, bare bones nothing fancy comfy. I asked if they charge for extra sauce. She said no. So my pizza comes with extra sauce criss-crossed on top of the cheese instead of underneath the cheese. I did not like it prepared like that but ate it anyway. It seemed to lack seasoning but was ok. The check came and they charged me for extra sauce. We had a conversation about that because she said there was no extea charge. They did take off the extra charge and were very nice about it. Not overly impressed by the pizza. read more

UPDATE: I came back to give them another shot... And this time they were SPOT ON! I guess they got the kinks out and now taste exactly how Aurelio's should taste! They remembered my extra sauce this time, and I know this because it was swirled all over the top in a pretty - almost kaleidoscope - design. SOOOOO excited to finally have an Aurelio's near my home... even though I will miss our favorite servers at the Lake St. location. read more

What is up with the service? Better training, please! Had to go to the bar to get another drink. Had to keep flagging down the waitress to get anything. Got a horrible chicken parm sandwich and the manager wanted to argue when we sent it back!! Pizza was missing a topping. Had to ask twice to get the check corrected. Horrible experience! Sorry cause I love the pizza. Won't be back to the Winfield location. read more

Worst service I can remember. My wife gets her drink 10 minutes after ordering then I get mine 10 minutes later (twice)!! It's MONDAY night for Christ sake Will NEVER return. We were ignored over and over. Pizza was MEDIOCRE. all I could taste was olive oil YUCK!!! read more

Yum!! I am excited to have an Aurelios by me finally! I grew up on this pizza in Villa Park and fails to disappoint here. A toast to the courageous owners for bestowing pizza greatness to the area! read more

Best Bruschetta ever! I highly recommend. Amazing! And Yelp won't let me post until I write more, which is so stupid! 5 starts for Auriellos, 0 stars for Yelp! Ha! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - Bruschetta to-go! So good! - Italian Near Me - Winfield, Illinois

Dinner anyone. Earlier today I planned on having pizza from aurillios pizza because there was a coupon for 14.00 online. Needless to say it would not work and the restaurant would not accept it even though they knew about it and blamed THEIR marketing firm. Well needless to say I cancelled my order and went to pizzeria demaria in Carol stream for a great dinner. read more

We have always loved Aurelio's, starting back in Homewood. The Aurelio's is Winfield is the closest we have come to the original. We were so disappointed to find out that we were right on the outside of their updated delivery range. After getting turned down a couple times trying to order delivery, I figured it would be worth reaching out through the website to see if there was any way they'd be willing to deliver to us. I received a call from Jon (the new general manager) the next day. I was blown away by the willingness and customer service. He has made sure that our address is accepted within their system - he also some of my other family members that live near us. After that, he told us to ask for Jon if we can and ever have any questions - he even offered his personal cell. It was a great experience, and we plan on ordering a lot more from them. Thanks Jon! read more

We have always liked Aurelio's pizza. But since the mask requirement started I have been inside more than once where employees and what seemed like the restaurant manager just didn't seem to care about wearing masks. Good pizza, but I'll be taking my business elsewhere. read more

I grew up on this pizza and enjoy visiting the Homewood, IL location. This place is spectacular in terms of the decor and the bar area is going to be a great place to spend some time with friends & family. Saturday and Sunday football games will be great there. Lastly - the pizza was spectacular and in perfect keeping with the high standards of the original Homewood location. Well done all! read more

Aurelio's Pizza - A very cool bar area! - Italian Near Me - Winfield, Illinois

Ok if you don't like their sweet pizza sauce ( I don't) here is an idea suggested by my helpful server Sean... Go with light sauce and I added my idea of baking it with crushed red pepper. It worked. It is a very nice thin crust pizza with my favorite ingredients of sausage, mushroom, onion and garlic. Since this new location (they renovated and expanded the old Jake's pizza) in Winfield is within walking distance I'll be back. read more

This is our family's favorite. Love Aurelio's pizza. This location is as close to the original Homewood as any. It also has a great dinning area and bar for watching games, etc. Delivery is always timely and accurate as well. read more

The food is very good - just like the Aurelio's my wife and I grew up eating. Prices are reasonable for what you get. And this new location is beautiful -- much more "upscale" than I expected. There are some quirks though, and they are still having some startup/growing pains: -No lunch hours? Really? What gives? Can't you at least open for lunch on weekends? -No delivery? Really? You are a pizza place! -I trust that someday you will get my carryout order right, and perhaps charge me what you quoted me over the phone. Or if you are going to quote me the wrong price, try sometime to charge me LESS than you told me you would, rather than always charging me more. I am willing to tolerate all that for the great food and experience...for a time. Glad to have Aurelio's in Winfield. read more

Ordered a fiesta sausage- $34.00 and change to pick it up. My phone and the receipt said I called at 4.52 pm to order. I was given a half-hour window so I walked in at 5:20. the box barely felt as if anything was in it and it wasn't even warm. It was so dry I could barely taste any sauce and it looked like it was pizza left over from someone who canceled their order or from the day before. Horrible. Wish I would have taken a photo. More than likely, I won't be back. I've been eating Aurelio's for years very disappointed. read more

We just threw away 3/4's of the worst tasting pizza ever and finished our Sunday dinner with cold sandwiches from the fridge.. The cheese seemed to smell and taste really odd or almost chemical like and that's about as politely as I can put it.. This was our second time eating here and the first time seemed really good? Change in ingredients? read more

A bit of a pizza snob, I love great deep dish, and enjoy tasty thin crust. Their crust isn't super thin, its tasty not too filling. Something worked really well. The spicy/sweet/strong sauce blended with great flavor on the 6-ingredient pizza and surprised how it burst with flavor. Our waiter/do-everything Jim was over the top helpful & considerate and added to the meal. New fave in the area! read more

First off, this place is VERY inconsistent. One visit the pizza has awesome thin crust with excellent sauce. The next visit will have spongy crust and overly sweet sauce. It keeps going back and forth and has become a gamble to visit when you have a specific taste in mind. It's very bad, I'll give them that. When it's good, there are hardly any leftovers. Their pizza crust makes this place unique. I think they put a Parmesan or some kind of hard cheese near the outer ring. It gives each piece a satisfying and savory end. Sauce and toppings tend to vary. Sometimes it's perfectly cooked, sometimes it's not. I think their main chefs have different styles. Neither is bad and I think one is the best pizza in town. The other is okay, nothing to write home about. I'd like if I could request the same thing every time. I'd say this is better than the Jason's pizza it replaced. The inside is nice and would be good for bringing a family to. read more

This is by far my favorite pizza place to go! The pizza has been perfect every time. The sauce is what makes you keep craving this! All the ingredients are fresh and top quality including their special blend of cheese. They do have a good size menu for someone who doesn't want pizza...but if I'm going there I'm getting pizza!! One tip, join the "Joe sent me" app. You can build up points for different $ amounts off up to $10. For every dollar spent you get 1 point. This pizza does get expensive so this will help out. Also, this location does deliver as long as it's within a 10 minute drive. read more

Ordered four ingredient large thin with extra sauce. It cost $40!!! But that might've been okay (still crazy though) if pizza was good. I always loved Aurelio's in OBT and of course Homewood. This pizza not only didn't have extra sauce, IT HAD VIRTUALLY NO SAUCE! I'm eating leftover slice as I type this, there is no sauce!! Aurelio's is all about the sauce! An absolute waste of $40! Take the drive to Al's in Warrenville for real pizza, but be prepared to order well ahead of time because they are that busy and they are that good! Shame on Aurelio's. read more

Stuffed spinach pizza? Oh. My. God. Had some friends who wanted pizza in Winfield last night and someone suggested this place. That was quite an amazing piece of pizza! Perfecto! My friend did say when he went to pick it up he found himself in a gps dead zone and got lost somehow, but I would recommend that should this happen... you persevere! You'll be glad you did. read more