We ordered 2 small chicken souvlaki salads (very good), spanakopita (bad) and the lemon soup (tasty, but too much salt). The spanakopita has wet, thick dough. It's supposed to be dry, flaky, and light phyllo dough. The spinach, cheese etc. inside was good, but we've never had dough that bad. At first taste the soup was yummy, but as we went on the salt content took over. That was a shame. Really a 2 1/2 score. read more

Absolutely delicious....every single thing we got was so good. The lemon chicken soup was outstanding. The gyro melt was amazing. Greek salad also great! The owner John was so welcoming and had us taste their homemade Greek yogurt....it was phenomenal. Try this place you won't regret it! read more

Great specials that our recent my phone. The food, gyros are amazing so are the new owners ‼

Came in for lunch and ordered 2 lunch special and an entree. Gyro sandwich was delicious nice portion, spinach pie and Greek salad was delicious. Greek salad plentiful, decent selection of tomatoes, onion, feta loved it. The gyro melt wasn't so good no marinara sauce or pepper and onions. Overall great meals, plentiful and very reasonable. Thank you. Too hungry to take pics. read more

The food is fresh and well prepared. The staff is friendly and professional. This is my go to place where I can take out or have my meal delivered read more

Great food great people. I haven't had anything that wasn't delicious there. Highly recommend if you're in the area.

Came here on a work day for lunch since I haven't had Greek food in over a year. Very friendly workers. Asked for the gyro lunch special and it came out in less than 3 min. It was veterans day so they seemed to be not busy at all. Got takeout and they were accommodating in giving me lots of napkins, white sauce and ketchup. For the food, their fries were on the bland side and the size of there pita bread to lamb meat just wasn't not right. The pita is just not big enough to pack what they put in the gyro. Maybe they were being extra nice and giving me more meat but I wanted more salad. Should have ordered the deconstructed version so I could control the ratio better. I would come back though read more

Simply Greek Express - Mediterranean Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Great food , owner was super nice great service. I definitely recommend and I will be back read more

The food was amazing and fresh. Unlike many Greek Spots on long island. The food was well plated and delivered, this is the only spot me and my Girlfriend go to order Greek Food. the 35-minute drive is always worth it read more

The food is delicious, the service is fast and they try not to make mistakes. The walls have beautiful paintings and the prices are good for the most part. read more

I had to come back after ordering chicken Doner, this time I ordered two chicken lunch bowl. It was delicious , is easy to to order, I'll definitely be back read more

Small,very casual Greek spot with fresh and flavorful food, generous portions and friendly service. We've gone several times and everything has been top notch. Their chicken egg lemon soup, avgolemono, is glorious. The best I've had anywhere. Lemony, vibrant and not a bowl of paste, like I've had elsewhere. Sign up for texts and get great offers too. Definitely in the rotation! read more

Just called times to place a to go order. Put on hold 3 times for 3 minutes. Hung up three times. Drive by. Parking lot was not full, the place did not seem crowded. I guess I'm going to Twisted. read more

Very fresh and authentic Greek food! Nice and friendly service and nice variety of the classics as well as new creations!

Amazing service - the kind of place where the owner/workers are chatting with guests and learning their names. Delicious food and very generous portions! They even brought a delicious complimentary yogurt with pears and it was such a nice touch. read more

We stopped in for some gyros and salad while holiday shopping. The food was delicious, and the portions were so big we had enough for another meal. The owner and staff are so friendly, and they have the most amazing Greek yogurt with imported cherries. I have been disappointed with the other Greek restaurant in Commack. This will be our go to from now on. read more

The inside looks amazing a big upgrade from the old place The new owners are so nice . We started with The roasted red pepper hummus it is delicious and the pita was hot and fresh . The chicken Avoglemeno soup was probably the best I have had. The Prassopita was spectacular My husband had the Greek island salad with Grilled octopus & Calamari the small is plenty for 2 Followed by the Greek yogurt with Cherries. We will definitely be back The owners are so friendly and explain every dish it's hard to choose . read more

The food was delicious, the portions are huge and the server knew the menu very well. Tha owner came over to make sure we were enjoying the food and asked if we needed any thing else . He gave us 2 complimentary desserts bc it was Mother's Day. We were VERY impressed with the food and we will be back! If you are ever in the Commack area, make sure to stop in here! read more

I only have the gyros here but they're nice portions and have ample lettuce and tomatoes too. Their pitas are different than nearby Greek place but much tastier. I highly recommend this place plus their prices are better than competitor nearby. I will continue to go here over my old place. read more

Food was very fresh and delicious. Good portions. Beef gyro were really good. Not too salty or greasy. Lemon potatoes were sweet and delicious. It's nice to have another choice for good Greek food in the neighborhood. read more

I really enjoyed the food here. The owner was very nice and accommodating. I had the chicken souvlaki lunch special that came with a Greek salad and drink. The portion was huge. I went home with leftovers. The interior was inviting. What a nice addition to the Commack restaurant seen. read more

Food was delicious ! So fresh! Truly a gem. Family owned business and they were so kind and helpful answering our questions. We had lamb gyros, chicken gyro platters, Greek salads..so fresh and the dressings were all homemade read more

Simply put, the best Greek food in the area. Food was fresh, properly seasoned Highly recommend it,,take out, or dine in. Bravo!!

Sorry we waited so long to get food here! Though the place is on the small side, we ended up dining in because there was an empty table and, while deciding what to order, we were enjoying a conversation with an owner, John. The Greek salad and souvlakis were delicious! The desert, Ekmek Kataifi, just the way to finish the meal! They have a bigger restaurant, perfect for when our friends or family visit, in Kings Park. And we will go there next. When we left the restaurant, the hub and I high-fived. We totally enjoyed our meals and we had fun! read more

amazing food!!! My favorite!! I dream about this food! Everything is incredible. you have to order the Greek Island salad. I highly recommend this place to everyone read more

Food is great, staff is very friendly. The place is kept very clean and perfect for a casual meal. My new top choice for Greek for sure.

I was worried when souvlaki palace closed down but SGE picked right up where they left off. I love the food and they text weekly deals which are super reasonable. The spanakopita, sweet Thai chili wings, lemon chicken soup, and souvlaki are all my go to's. Best Greek in Commack! read more

This was my first time coming here and I was highly impressed with the quality of their food. Greek salad with chicken gyro and a lamb gyro was better than most of the other spots on Long Island. I will absolutely be back. I was too hungry to snap a picture but will on my next visit LOL read more

Honestly the best, most authentic Greek I've had in a long time! The Avgolemono soup was so lemony and bright with just the right amount of chicken and rice. The chicken on our Greek salad was juicy and grilled to perfection! We are fans for LIFE! Will always stop at this cute spot every time I'm in Commack! read more

7 dollar gyro Wednesdays no chicken only beef and lamb. They are delish as big as a meal. The taziiki sauce is awesome fresh and not nasty like the diners. There is no atmosphere there not a place to eat inside better off taking out. The french fries were good and strangly the Greek salad is now made with mescaline and one grapeleave definatly not great. Great take out gyro Wednesday. That's it. The one in Kings park is worse. The Aegean grill best chicken souvlaki larkfield rd. I think same.owner all 3 not positive read more

Lovely, kind and knowledgeable staff. The Greek salad was delicious and the chicken souvlaki perfectly cooked and seasoned. The gyro (beef&lamb) was flavorful and tender. If you're looking for an authentic Greek meal, this is the place! read more

Authentic Greek food and very friendly service. Loved the dips in the pikilia platter. The Stuffed sole with veggies was delicious as was the Greek salad with chicken. read more

Yummy salads good pricing great gyros fast service and great desserts are the hallmarks of this Greek eatery

Beef souvlaki (meat) tasted old. Upset stomach all night. .............................................................................................................. read more

We order from here pretty regularly. Food is very good. They deliver relatively quick. Food is always hot and fresh. The staff is very friendly. The only thing I would critique about this place is they don't tell you how exorbitantly expensive it is when you want to order an extra sauce, but the sauce is delicious. read more

Tried for the first time. I thought the food was okay. However, the tahini sauce was rancid. It smelled like rotten fish and tasted horrible. That alone ruined my experience. It must have been old and or expired. read more

Delicious fast Greek cuisine, reasonable prices, huge portions! The ambiance is slightly better than a takeout pizza place, but everyone who works there is friendly and eager to please. read more

The people that work here are very very nice!! The food is phenomenal and they do $7 gyros on Wednesdays,the yogurt sauce is delicious!!

Excelente service, delicious chicken panini pesto, super nice gentleman at the front desk, I'm absolutely happy read more

Simply Greek Express - Chicken pesto panini - Mediterranean Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

We used to come to this greek restaurant every single sunday for an early lunch/breakfast when Pete owned it and were so heartbroken when he passed. Tried Simply Greek for the first time this week and can say I was not disappointed! Their salad dressing is the best (just like Pete's)! The portions are HUGE and the food is just sooo good! Will be coming back on a regular basis! read more