What a great find in the small town of New Meadows! I had heard from a friend that this is his…read morefavorite pizza in the area. For our first time, we had a basic pepperoni/sausage pizza with red sauce. Miss Kitty's didn't disappoint. prices were reasonable, service was friendly and prompt, and the pizza was definitely the best around. I can't wait to try their meatball sandwich, calzones, and other pizza sauces. Well worth the drive from McCall. Thanks Miss Kitty! We will definitely be coming back many times this summer.

Good pizza, clean place and nice people what more could you want. Worth the stop on the way through…read morenew meadows.

We are visiting McCall and looking for a pizza option... there are a few to choose from. I am happy…read morewe picked Hometown Pizza. I've read posts about other items on the menu, this rating is just based on what we ordered - pizza! Pros - great pizza! We order a large cheese and pineapple pizza for 3 kids. A medium 1/2 garden & 1/2 combo for two adults. The garden was delicious (great flavor, fresh, good veggies/ crust proportions of ingredients) -- and no complaints and full bellies for everyone else. - super quick, ordered and it was ready for pick up in under 30. - very reasonably priced $50 for two pizza that fed us and left a few slices for lunch tomorrow. Cons - the website for ordering online was a little clunky, but worked... (not bad enough to knock off a star). - while everyone else liked the crust one kid did not, it was thinner and had a different texture (less "bready") than other pizza places, e.g. Papa John's. (IMO it was good!) The place was packed at 5pm on a Wednesday so that might mean something!

I went here many times. The buffalo chicken pizza is heaven. It makes me mad not to see too many…read morepeople in here. The people behind the counter are really nice and hospitable. The ambiance could be better, but if more people really knew about this spot, it could be a serious hit. I'm backing this up, it's good.

Amazing pizza! I loved how crusty was their pizza! The menu is very simple. The place is very…read moreclean. I Highly recommend trying it!

we've had pizza here twice now. it's a tiny place within tamarack resort, but it's super convenient…read morewhen you don't want to drive back into town for something. they have a pretty good sized menu of different pizzas to try. the other night we got the 4 pigs and the hawaiian. the 4 pigs was the best! it's bacon, canadian ham, sausage, and pepperoni. the toppings are decently generous as well. the hawaiian was canadian bacon and pineapple. if you like that kind of pizza like we do, you will enjoy it! the one thing about this place is the crust is kind of thin. it's like a cracker type thin crust. it's very crusty on the ends, which is probably why they have the name they do. It isn't my favorite kind of pizza crust, but it's still tasty. we got 2 pizzas for $48. it wasn't a deal breaker, especially when we didn't feel like going anywhere or cooking. you can also eat there and they have some beers too. my one gripe? they charge $1 a packet for ranch. and it's salad dressing ranch so it's really vinegary. kind of a bummer. I love ranch on pizza though!

Pizza was very good! Locals eat here. Place is a bit rustic. Coke products. Nice salad bar…read more Small parking area. They do lots of carry out.

Called in order to go. Hot and ready when we got there. Great service. Pizza tasted great!read more

Called and placed an order to-go. Pizza was hot, ready and on time. The Big Growler pizza was…read moreamazing. Inside looked nice and clean, hostess was very nice when picking up the pizza.

If I could leave a half star I would! I live here in town…read moreand I'm not impressed. First, I tried to call my order in and had to drive down and wait. I told the guy the phone was off the hook and that i tried to call nine times, he responded saying he knew because they were getting busy. Then after waiting 25 minutes, I went inside and it still wasn't done. Waiting another 20 minutes. This will be my last pizza here. Ten years ago they were better, not the case now. I'll be calling the Foresters Club from now on!

Yummy food, great beer, and kind service! The restaurant was clean and we were served promptly! All…read moreof the meals and drinks came exactly as we ordered and felt like a fair price!

The service was terrible. She was very rude and then the wait to get our salad containers was very…read morelong. The salad bar was not stocked with fresh vegetables. We were waiting for garlic bread and still had not gotten the bread 30 minutes later. We finally went to talk with her and she then admitted that she forgot about the bread and it burned. There was only one other family in the restaurant that had already been served.

Food was delicious, service was fast and friendly and the ambience was pleasant and peaceful.read more

We went on the earlier side and waited hardly at all for our food. The service was friendly as well…read moreand kept checking on us. My mom got the full serving of the chopped salad and it was massive. We split the spinach artichoke dip and also had leftovers. I got the fettuccine Alfredo and it was delicious. It's definitely good food for the price in my opinion. The space itself is spacious and comfy, with outdoor seating for warmer days. A nice location for if you're staying anywhere downtown. Highly recommend since it has different types of food!

Fabulous hamburger, fries, shakes. Be prepared for a line in summer! They handle gluten free needs…read morewith gf buns.Its worthy!

What a delicious restaurant. Sometimes the line can be quite long, but the freshness and taste of…read morethe food makes it worth it. We have eaten here three or four times and always been 100% satisfied. I would recommend this place to anybody that is visiting McCall and wants a fun place to grab some food. The milkshakes are also very awesome!

Restaurant is in the way back. Chairs and tables very uncomfortable. Pizza tasted and looked like…read moreit came out of a grocery store freezer. There was a lot of discussion in the back about the wrong cheese being put on the pizza. They didn't offer a discount tho. My turkey and cheese sandwich was supposed to have tomatoes but did not. Won't be back.

It was pretty good standard bar food. Came in to late for pizza, beers cold. Not a bad stop. Bar…read moretenders are nice people. Locals are funny here. Bud was 2.50