I've been ordering from The Shirley Sub Shoppe for quite some time and I always order the chicken picatta. Most of the time, it is great, better than most high end restaurants. Why is it that occasionally it is really bad? Isn't there consistency in their recipe? I got it a few weeks ago, and it tasted a bit like the water from the pasta had not been drained. Today, it was dry with little flavor. When they have a great recipe, stick with it! read more

$14 for a roast beef sub and we got grey old smelling beef that gave my son a stomach ache and made him nauseous. I wish I saw it before he ate it. Absolutely gross. Should have never been served. The fact that they would put this beef on a sub makes me question everything there. If they think this beef is acceptable, what other old or expired food will they serve. Will never eat here again. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Old nearly rotten beef - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

The quintessential 3-star place. With most of my 3s, I debate whether it should have been a 4 or a 2. Not this place: 3.0000. Italian Sub: Comes in one size, pretty long, not much meat, and not premium, but can't say it's lacking. Bread nothing special, supermarket quality, but nothing disappointing--other than the long-ish wait for a sub that requires no cooking. Professionally wrapped. Clean tables. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Italian coldcut sub - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

See all

Could agree more with Matt V. Made the mistake of coming here blindly for a quick lunch. Was taken aback by waiting over 10 mins for one sub, seemed like they weren't busy and had plenty of time to yap. Turkey sub, way over priced. 15 is insane in this economy, wasn't nearly full enough. Must've heard tomato when I said mayo. Too. Made a toasted sandwich drier than a fart. Do yourself a favor and pay 9 bucks for one in Ayer. If you know, you know. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Turkey sub - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

Turkey sub, way over priced. Granted it taste great. Sub was paper thin , minimal meat, and minimal vegetables... Won't order again based on size of sub and 15$ price tag read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

Fast delivery, good service and good food. All of your sub staples plus extra! Very basic but comfortable inner space and everyone is very sweet. read more

Just came back to say I had pizza and salad from the other Shirley pizza place and it was terrible. Pizza was lame and the salad was pathetic. I'd rather pay a bit more and get way better food. Shirley Sub Shoppe still had my vote. read more

came 4th of July weekend and came here as they were open. Staff was friendly and patient with us as we scanned their MASSIVE menu. The Stromboli with ham and mushrooms was HUGE and delicious. The chicken Marsala was ok, and the chef salad was large and filling. 4 ate for like $50 it was worth the price overall especially the Stromboli!! read more

I ordered a small calzone from here with light sauce. Instead of putting the sauce in the calzone (like specified in the ingredients) they gave me a cup on the side. I'm not sure if that was done in error or just because I asked for light sauce. Overall it was decent. A little light with the filling but the ingredients were fresh and it was cooked nicely. The dough had a very garlicky and salty flavor, which was fine by me, but if salt isn't your thing then you may want to try something else. read more

I ordered a small Hamburg and ricotta mozzarella cheese pizza cooked well done and it was one of the BEST pizzas that I have ever had! I would give it a 9.1 on a 1-10 scale. The crust was airy chewy and crisp. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Small Ricotta and Hamburg pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

See all

Ordered food there today - there was a dead bug in 1 of the sandwiches *They did credit the CC for the 1 sandwich read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Dead bug on olive - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

i always order an italian with everything toasted...every time i pick it up or have it delivered it's never toasted...i dont think they understand what toasted is..shirley sub used to be the best place around now it's gone down hill... read more

I ordered over the phone, regular order of 4 gyros, 3 fries and a garlic bread and an order of 12 mozz sticks. Except it wasn't 12, it was 12 orders of 12 mozz sticks. They confirmed one order of a large mozz stick since their menu doesnt say small or large just thhe amount They did not tell me how much it costs, when we came in they slid me the signature paper but tried to hide the price. They scammed me straight up Into paying 149 for 12 orders of mozz sticks. They didn't even include the garlic bread. Avoid. There's no excuse, it's obvious this isn't what I wanted imagine what theyll do to you. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Avoid these scammers - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

Phenomenal!! I've been working down the road and ordering out from here for a few months now and EVERYTHING they have to offer is FIRE! Salads are don't right - meat on the side so as not to wilt your lettuce; why don't more places do this?!! Their steak tips are excellent btw, all the sandwiches I've tried have been amazing, same for the pizza, and the wings are fantastic!! Between myself and coworkers we order from here at least a couple times a week and never disappointed. Thanks Shirley's! read more

This place can't seem to get an simple order correct. So if you do order something, plan to get only half of what you order and then have to wait to get the rest. I have encountered some tough places but this one is pretty close to the top. The female receptionist talks trash about you in Spanish while you try to correct an order. Then pretends the phone reception is bad. You order three simple things, and the sub shop blames you for forgetting to give the order to the delivery driver. Now, you have to eat in shifts because they just could not get two items correct. Chicken on a salad, a pizza. So you get a salad with no chicken, a cold sub and no pizza. *boggle* As for the food. Chicken parm sub, over cooked, dry with a teaspoon of sauce. If you want a good mean go across the street and deal with a real pizza shop. I just don't understand why no one seems to care about getting the order correct. They certainly don't care at Shirley sub but do care about taking your money. read more

Could they have spared a little more broccoli on this broccoli and extra cheese pizza? Apparently it's my first and last time going there. Guess they don't value repeat business. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Could they have spared a little more broccoli on this broccoli and extra cheese pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

Joe is the best driver. Food is always hot and fresh. Reasonable prices. Very clean store and nice people.

Customer isn't always right here. ORDERED FOOD AND WAS QUOTED NO MORE THAT AN HOUR AND 15. Food arrived an hour and 45 minutes later The desert ordered was wrong but they promised to credit us free desert next time. Husband opened his chicken finger plate and all the sauces we asked for were missing. His chicken was rubbery and the fries / onion rings he ordered were oily and mushy. We called and they couldntyyydeliver new plates so my husband offered to bring the meals back for a refund and they still refused! The owner must be hurt because this NOT GOOD CUSTOMER SERVICE. Food was not good at ALL!!! read more

Ordered a large Chicken Pesto pizza for take out which I thought was pretty good, though I could have definitely used more pesto. Can't say anything really stood out, but maybe something else on the menu would. I certainly wouldn't rule out coming here again. read more

beautiful interior, friendly staff, delicious food! 10/10, had a great time with my friends read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Buffalo Chicken House Special Chicken Pesto - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

I ordered a large chicken ranch! Wow it was so greasy and salty. Man it was the most disgusting thing I every ate in my life. I even had a stomach ache? Is this a big cheese pizza? Than where is the tomato sauce? It looks like something other than a pizza! read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

Overpriced average pizza, long delivery times. I given this place a bunch of chances because is close to home but every time i get it I regret it. 3 large pizzas almost $60!! Toppings are sparse he is a pepperoni and onion with a couple flakes of onion and a chicken and bacon pizza with a few shreds of chicken read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Pepperoni and onion with no onion - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

See all

It has really sucked over year or 2. I tried again got a pizza pool of grease. Whole center was a wet sponge.

I ordered a pizza tonight, seems they dumped a lot of salt, called,no comment.not be calling soon.

Ordered dinner tonight, my onion rings were over cooked and burnt, hard as a rock.them cooks needs to pay more attention to what there doing.this is the second time. Next time will order from somewhere else. read more

IA rare find for sure. I was not able to leave my hotel, and ordered on line. They said it would be delivered approximately 6:59 PM.. they DID! the Baked stuffed Haddock was spectacular accompanied by a delightful salad and some of the best honey mustard chicken wings I have ever had. Great food at reasonable prices delivered on time... WOW read more

Love their subs, my go to is steak &, cheese with banana peppers extra Mayo &, salt +pepper. Very creamy good chicken broccoli FETTUCCINE. Great Buffalo traditional wings. Always fresh &, warm. Very polite service when I go. read more

Just moved to town and an admitted food snob. Have eaten here 3 times this week pizza was great, burgers where great and dad loved the haddock sandwich. Staff were excellent so far highly recommend. read more

Best place ever. I have been ordering at this sub Shoppe for a while now. The staff is polite, the food is great, and the place is clean. I have order a bbq chicken pizza once, and it is hard to find a place that does a really good bbq chicken pizza. Once I order a veggie pizza for a vegetarian friend and I am not fan of veggie pizzas, but I loved that one. All the veggies are fresh, and you can see it and taste. The best veggie pizza ever, literally. I'm totally fan of the chicken picatta pasta. They food quality are like a 5 stars restaurant. I am really impressed of this little sub shoppe, and I will continue ordering with them for a long time, I'm sure read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

I support the Shirley Sub Shoppe!! Great food and delivered well within the time they said it would be. And I especially love that I can order and pay online and even add the tip as well. I stink at math. lol So doing the tip as well makes it a whole lot easier and I definitely support the delivery drivers. They are the ones on the front lines delivering all over. Stay safe & healthy & keep making that great food!! read more

We usually eat at Village but we've given this place a shot a few times... We've always been super disappointed. Their subs are pretty decent, salads are fine if just veggies, but the pizza is really bad. They are VERY skimpy with their ingredients, so it's like eating a thin piece of cardboard with enough toppings to reasonably cover about two slices instead of a whole pizza. If you want a pizza or calzone, go to Village... Totally different league. Only thing really decent seems to be the subs. read more

Just ordered a bacon cheeseburger from them the other day. WOW... that thing was cooked to perfection! Juicy, tender, and beyond satisfying! I tried their pizza, it was okay... nothing to rave about, though it might've been overshadowed by that burger that I had... man... that was such a great burger... read more

Great local alternative to the other sandwich places in town. They have enough different items on their menu to make them an easy choice. They deliver which is a nice feature that other shops don't offer. That, right there, is why I always use them when I'm at work and need some good food delivered. Their Potato Skin pizza is absolutely amazing. Recommend that one to anyone. read more

The Shirley supreme pizza, fish and chips, Alfredo pasta with shrimp, and much more... Delicious, fresh and priced properly. I highly recommend this place and have become a regular patron. read more

A lot of these reviews are reviews for the old owners service/food. The new management has been nothing, but great. One time they did put ketchup on my girlfriends turkey sub, so she didn't eat it. Besides that we have had a great experience and the food has been tasty every visit. I highly recommend the Buffalo chicken gourmet pizza w/ a side of blue cheese. 50% of my 1 cheat meal a week is from Shirley Sub Shoppe. That right there will tell you that it is delicious. I wouldn't waste my cheat meal on anything other than mouth watering deliciousness. Thumbs up! read more

Typical lunch spot was closed today so figured why not give this place a shot?! Ordered an Italian sub and it took 25 minutes to get it ordered and made. The guy taking orders wasn't too bothered that I was just standing there for 10 minutes waiting to place my order. Finally got my sandwich that was supposed to have mayo and no onions. Instead, I got an abundance of onion and no mayo. And a hair. But it gets two stars because the bread was not stale, so that's a plus. Probably won't be going back. read more

Shirley Sub Shoppe - So much onion! - Pizza Near Me - Shirley, Massachusetts

We ordered subs from here-they would have been just average-however the delivery driver was smoking and texting while driving. I believe that even the delivery drivers should reflect the establishment, and if smoking and texting while driving reflects this business-then I will never go back to this place. read more

This little shop is the best pizza in town. Always curious. Always accurate. Always quick.

This is my go to lunch spot. So far I got a hamburger sub and tuna melt. When you get the subs, they tend to give you a hefty amount of ingredients. I'm planning on getting their pizza next to compare to another pizza spot down the road. Unlike the other pizza spot, this place has friendly staff. They have plenty of seats inside with a TV but a small parking lot (not really a big deal). As of right now I'm only giving three stars because it's a traditional pizza shop and trying to find something that pops from the others. Maybe I'll order a pizza today from them to see how their sauce is like to other shops. So until the next review. read more

See all

This restaurant is really clean and nice . The food was excellent and the cashier very pleasant . Lagaña and salad was very good Clean bathroom nice atmosphere . I would highly recommend to anyone visiting like me or who lives inter area. They have nice silverware to serve you your food as well. Best luck for them read more