Cancel

Open app

Search

Shennanigans

3.9 (44 reviews)
ModeratePubs, Burgers
Open • 11:00 am - 2:00 AM (Next day)

Shennanigans Photos

SHENNANIGANS ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Live music
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Shennanigans

Recommended Reviews - Shennanigans

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Broccoli bites
Cheree L.

OH MY. This little hidden dive bar is absolutely amazing. The service is awesome, and the people there are oh so friendly. Very welcoming and fun. OH AND THE FOOD IS AMAZING. I ordered the broccoli bites and WOW. 5 stars , so freaken delicious.

Dmitry D.

Nice bar, welcoming, food menu looked good but was too late to try. Tried a new type of Red Bull wasn't bad about the same as original. Would go back.

Bar area.
Josh G.

It's been a minute since I've written a review (okay maybe only a few weeks, but even so). For those interested, my abode location on this lengthy island has shifted from Nassau to Suffolk and so I find myself getting into new food spots and new...Shenanigans (did you see that coming?). This aptly-named little hole-in-the-wall spot was (takeout) dinner for my fiancée, her family, and yours truly about a week or so ago with pleasant results. Shenanigans definitely has that local feel. A kind of business that nobody outside of the area knows, but if you live around these parts, you've been here, had a meal here, or have some kind of story that involves here. I can't say I fall into any of these categories (yet) as the one meal we did have wasn't even in this divey yet welcoming location. I picked up the grub and got that combo of feelings from the booths and high top tables, little gaming screen machines, beer signs, and the whole bar (which takes up most of the space). While waiting, some Led Zeppelin and Hall & Oates played on the digital jukebox (good choices) and the employees were friendly and kept letting me know the food was almost ready (even though it took a little longer than we expected). Most of the customers seemed a little older, but I felt comfortable enough hanging out and could see myself stopping by for Happy Hour at some point down the line. Once the grub had been grabbed, I drove back to open our bounty and found some pretty tasty food. My build-your-own-burger with sautéed mushrooms and onions was solid and the interestingly-cut potato wedges were a perfect side (plus slaw and a pickle). My fiancée also enjoyed her burger and so did her parents. We shared some wings too which were put in a Jack Daniels BBQ sauce. Though they could've used an extra slather, the wings themselves were great. Not too shabby. Overall, I'll say my first experience of Shenanigans was honestly not filled with too much of that word. But hey, that's a good thing in some ways. Though I look forward to getting a chance to find myself in some...you know...here in the future. Glad to get a quality review back on the board at a nice little local spot in my new location.

Pirogies
Melissa V.

We go here frequently, why? It's a nice cozy place to go to. They have been following covid guidelines and make sure you do too. Masks on, sanitizer on the tables, and signs everywhere. It's a small cozy bar and you won't be forgotten. They have different themed nights. Musingo is my personal favorites plus you get gifts too if you win!! Food is always good typical bar food- you can't go wrong. This time we tried their potato leek soup, pirogies, fried shrimp is always a go to, and flank steak with mashed potatoes and vegetables. You just can't go wrong. Always a favorite go to.

Bar Area. My selection
Carlos P C.

So this is a restaurant with a full bar, that accepts credit cards as payment and had it's own parking lot. As you enter you'll notice that they have outdoor seating with a canopy, although they don't allow for smoking. The Bar Area is located in the center of the room with a U-shape to it and the kitchen is located behind it, towards the rear of the building. They offer an ATM, 4 Arcade Games such as Cards and Slots, multiple TV's, TouchTunes, and they play QuickDraw here. Occasionally they'll have live music playing and Trivia Night. There's separate restrooms for men and women. They have a fairly large and diverse menu of food to select from, but the kitchen closes at 9pm. The unique feature to this place is it's wall that are full of hand drawn cartoonish portraits. This place has a fun vibe about it and is worth checking out.

See all

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Shennanigans

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pubs 653 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Old City Public House

Old City Public House

4.0(134 reviews)
0.7 mi
•$$

The food is very good, I have eaten here over a dozen times…read more The owner is friendly and so are most of the staff! However, there's one old bartender that wears glasses that always gives me and my party an attitude when I go in there to the point where I don't want to dine there and stopped recommending it to people! Several different people that I dined here with on multiple occasions have noticed it. The ambience is great when you don't have somebody with a shitty attitude there ruining the experience that I'm paying good money for. I always tip well so I guess she just doesn't like me and scared away one of your longtime patrons. 4/5 food, service overall experience -1 star for nasty/ rude glasses lady

Tried Public House on a friend's recommendation and can't believe I never visited before…read more Although it's your standard American style pub restaurant if you're a fan of French Dip sandwiches this is the place for you. There's a good selection of FD sandwiches along with the usual burger, sandwich and wraps along with a decent selection of appetizers. The sampler appetizer included your standard apps: potato skins, mozzarella sticks, wings & onion rings with sauces was slightly overpriced at $22.50 but still good and could pass as a meal itself. The best choice was the French Dip sandwiches all cooked to perfection and well portioned served with French Fries. Callout to our server Jessica was outstanding. Attentive, friendly and knowledgeable with some excellent sandwich suggestions. Restaurant features a full bar area, dining area with table service and a section of the dining area that can be converted to a private room for special events. Overall a great little pub with attentive, friendly ostaff serving excellent French Dip sandwiches at reasonable prices.

Photos
Old City Public House - Bar area

Bar area

Old City Public House - Zucchini fries

Zucchini fries

Old City Public House

See all

Shennanigans - pubs - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...