Tried Shelly Pie for the first time since moving back to the burgh... I wish we would have been here sooner after trying to find a good Sicilian pizza in the area with little success. Shelly makes one FANTASTIC tasting Sicilian pizza!! Next time we are going to load it up with more toppings. We will definitely be back for more! The sauce was great tasting, the dough cooked perfectly, the amount of cheeses and toppings made this absolutely delicious. read more

Group-friendly joint for Italian food. Rumor has it that Shelly brought the recipe for the pizza dough from Vincent's, and although it has the same appetizingly chewy crust, it lacks the lightness of Vinnie's. Although there is "an obscene" amount of toppings on their enormous pizzas, they aren't cheesy/greasy like Mineo's. Even if you don't partake of the pies, if you leave hungry, you didn't do it right. A bowl of delicious Italian wedding soup and a tossed salad suffice to fill you up. I have no idea if Shelly's has a dessert menu, because I've never had enough room in my stomach to ever consider glancing at it, much less seriously contemplate ordering anything off of it. The staff are kept busy when the place is hopping, but they're always nice, so please tip them generously. Prices are eminently reasonable. Thanks, Shelly! read more

Shelly Pie - Bowl of Italian wedding soup - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Friendly staff. Food is usually very good! Not bad for a local joint. Will have leftovers read more

See all

Do you ever just look at a pizza and just KNOW it's gonna be good? Well Shelly's Pie is it. I personally like mine well done, and as you can tell they were not shy with the pepperoni. Highly recommend to anyone in the area. read more

Shelly Pie - Deliciousness - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

So, haven't had Shelly Pie for a few years since I moved away from the area. I remember that it was so much better than Vincent's Pizza; flavorful crust, tasty sauce (the foundation of a great pizza.) Always ordered pepperoni and sausage. Pepperoni was thick sliced and plentiful and sausage was large pieces and delicious. Well that was then and now the crust tasted like basic white bread, the sauce was ok but was skimpy, the pepperoni was thin (Hormel?) and not plentiful or tasty and the sausage was small and bland. Was expecting the awesome pie that was but got something kind of middle of the road. Haven't had Casey's or Pizza Palermo but for the price may have to go with them next time. Oh, also ordered fried zucchini- couple pieces were tasty but rest was soaked in oil. Very unappetizing. read more

Absolutely the best pizza around. Great staff, too. Outstanding steak hoagie. Great family restaurant.

The pizza here is no joke. We decided to order a large pepperoni with extra cheese and sausage. The delivery was great. We didn't have to wait too long. The pizza arrived with the right temperature. However, it was heavy as heck...lol. When we opened the lid, we knew we were in over our heads. The cheese was oozing as we tried to cut and lift a slice. The box lid that resembled the 'soul glo' stain was saturated with cheese grease. Then we realized we couldn't eat the pizza without a fork and knife. I don't mind eating pizza this way if it is Chicago style, but this was just soggy from too much sauce, cheese grease in the center. The pizza itself reminds me of the Vincent pizza park pies. We also ordered wings on the side and they were alright, not crispy though. Overall the pizza was good, however the distribution of the ingredients was a bit off. There were too many ingredients that made it soggy in the center and too much dry outer crust. read more

Shelly Pie - Pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and sausage. - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

One bite , it's a 7.2 everyone knows the rules. $24-26 for a Large with onion & pepperoni. $4 per topping on entire pizza. Not my style of pizza. It's very heavy, very greasy. Not bad for what it is tho; It can use another minute in the oven. I'll be back but wouldn't go out of my way. I'd like to try the small or medium pizza. Both look different in the photos. read more

Shelbys pies are good..the sauce is homemade and just the right amount of dough to keep the customers coming back Great local pizzeria in turtle creek next to the bridge .... And when COVID is over, great place to eat in and enjoy too.... read more

Visited today with my daughter. Based on the outside of the building, I was very surprised with the inside and the way the restaurant was decorated, it looked very nice. I also loved the fact that there is an adequate amount of booths. The bathroom was also very clean. We came about 4 pm for dinner. The place was fairly empty and a server was over promptly after we sat. After looking at the menu i found it to be just a tad more expensive than I had expected. We ordered a large one topping. The pizza was 15 and the topping was 4. The pizza was a decently big size, lots of cheese and thick crusted. The pepperoni was a bit oily but overall okay. It reminded me alot of Vincent's pizza. My only complaint is the server wasn't too great with bringing refills. read more

See all

We had an excellent experience- the food was 10/10 and the service was wonderful. They went above and beyond and the whole staff was incredible with our group of 16. We will definitely be back and highly recommend for anyone looking for great food and a fantastic staff. read more

Best pizza around and made by an awesome hard working woman who embodies the American dream.

This place used to be amazing and overly generous with toppings and portions. But recently it's been nothing but a let down. I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni on the entire thing and mushrooms on half. I specifically told the lady on the phone to put the amount of mushrooms you'd put on the entire pizza but only on half, since we like mushrooms. The woman repeated the order back to me perfectly. I get the pizza home and there's only pepperoni on half and not even enough mushrooms for half a pizza (in terms of generous Shelly pie toppings). Paying for a $30 pizza and not getting what you asked for is frustrating. This isn't the first time a pizza has been sub-par in recent months. They need to get back to what they were known for - mounds of toppings. read more

Shelly Pie - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

The pizza is awesome, it's my favorite in all of Pittsburgh. The portion size is generous and the ingredients are fresh and delicious. I can't recommend them enough. read more

Always our first night dinner when we are in the burgh!!!! Must have a Shelly pie and a Turners tea.

Wow! Found a new favorite tonight. First of all, don't let the tag "medium 8 cut" fool you. Their pizza is BIG. One slice = 2-3 typical pizza slices from a pizza chain. I think I'm in love with their dough. It's soft and pillowy without being soggy. They give you plenty of toppings too! ***Also want to mention that I'm super impressed with their system during COVID-19. They sanitize the pens, maintain a "one person per order inside at a time" rule, and are giving tips to their staff who would normally be working if their dining room was open. Love to see it! Will definitely be back.*** read more

See all

It's a lot. From the awkward location, to the size of the portions it's quite the experience. The service was extremely friendly and the atmosphere was lively upon entering. The pie itself was massive and after returning home dove it. It had decent flavor and the ingredients themselves seemed pretty average, tons of grease made it impossible to eat. It's not good, it's not bad, I'd eat it again, but wouldn't go out of my way. read more

Just picked up and order. Pretzels look and taste like they sat under lights for a week. Beer cheese tastes like ordinary nacho cheese. Pizza wasn't even warm and we only live 10 minutes away. Disappointing as we usually have good things to say. read more

Shelly Pie - Pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Wonderful pizza, even as take-out. Love the stuffed pepper app. It has a spicy kick. Try it to go with the pizza. Thanks Shelley et. all. read more

We had an unexpected but wonderful experience at Shelly Pie in Turtle Creek, PA the day before Thanksgiving. We had originally set out for a quick lunch at a place in North Versailles but the wind storm had knocked out power in the area and businesses were closed, so we headed down Greensburg Pike to see if we could find an open restaurant. When we stopped at the red light in TC, my daughter noticed Shelly Pie and said that her office had recently brought in a bunch of pizzas from there and they were really good. Loaded with toppings. That was all I needed to hear so we pulled in to the lot and headed inside. The restaurant is nicely decorated and we were greeted with a friendly smile. The three of us decided on a large pepperoni pizza in order to have some leftovers. The pie arrived quickly and looked delicious. The toppings were loaded on top and full of flavor in every bite. All three of us agreed that it was the best pizza we've had in quite a while. This isn't your regular local pizza joint, it's much better. The prices are good and the atmosphere engaging. If you like pizza, try Shelly Pie! I know I'll be going back. read more

Shelly Pie - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Every thing is delicious and the staff is amazing, with helpful hints and buddy of all their kindness

This place has great reviews and I wanted to see what the hype was all about! Upon arrival, the parking lot was somewhat difficult to locate. It looks like you can drive into the back of the bank next door to access the lot or there's a one-car driveway on the side of Sally's. We ordered pick-up and the order was ready upon arrival. The cashier who helped me was really funny (wish I remembered his name!) The pizza was wrapped in a brown wrap with a cardboard base, no big bulky boxes. First let me say this pizza was HUGE. The two of us didn't even eat half of it. A small would have been a better option. The taste was okay, not the best pizza but not the worst. The bottom of the pizza was a little soggy, but that may have been due to being a pickup order. All in all, it was good pizza. The crust was thick, doughy and was easily my favorite part. For a three topping pizza it ended up being a little over $24....expensive in my opinion. Maybe next time I'll order a small or try something else on the menu. read more

Shelly Pie - Medium pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and green peppers - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

We ordered pizza and wings both were terrible. And this place is not cheap. The pizza crust was thin, soft, and soggy in the center. No taste. We ordered toppings that were just slapped on there. The pizza was a mess. The quality of the cheese is poor. The wings were not done. We had to put them in the oven for 25 minutes. Even then, I couldn't enjoy them because I couldn't get past the original taste. We were going to call and complain but why bother? We'll never ever go there again. Save your money. The food is horrible IMO. read more

Love this place! I wish I was closer. The pasta bolognese was perfect. My husband had the pizza and loved it. I liked all the daily specials. Are they posted on the Facebook page? read more

Really high expectations, really thin really flimsy crust, eba (everything but anchovies) but really not everything. Really love pizza but hated it and paid $30 for a medium. Really really sad :( read more

Shelly Pie - Eba pepperoni sausage mushroom onion green pepper - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

The pizza looked and smelled delicious but as soon as we picked it up to take a bite nothing but grease was dripping and there was hair on the pizza. Then the Philly cheesesteak was soggy and it didn't taste good at all. read more

A big pizza place with a huge menu. Very friendly staff, and reasonable prices. Good pizza. The rest of menu is average at best.

I literally just ordered from this place using Uber eats. I ordered an eight cut Sicilian with pepperoni and mushrooms and provolone sticks. I paid two dollars for two toppings yet they only put toppings on four cuts. And what really has me hot is the fact that I paid $6.50 for three provolone sticks. WTAF! This place owes me some money. Never again! read more

Shelly Pie - I paid $6.50 for three provolone sticks. Unacceptable - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

We haven't dined-in at ShellyPie as yet, but we did order dinner for delivery for our dad. The delivery company unfortunately delivered to the incorrect address (which the delivery company did resolve quickly). I can't thank Shelly Pie enough though...the owner Mike and also Lisa were very helpful, professional and courteous about the error. We placed a second order the next day...(it was delivered on time and in excellent condition!) And Shelly Pie was kind enough to add a few little extras to our dads meal delivery, which was greatly appreciated! My dad loved the generous size and excellent taste of the lasagna and meat balls! He also really liked the house dressing on the salad and said the wedding soup was better than homemade! Thank you Shelly Pie for the great meal and excellent customer service! Look forward to dining in at the restaurant in the future:) read more

My husband and I were in the mood for trying pizza somewhere off the beaten path (at least for us), so after a quick search, we were on our way to Shelly Pie in Turtle Creek. Shelly Pie is a sit-down pizza restaurant (though they also serve things other than pizza). It has a warm and welcoming vibe...most of the people there seemed to be locals. It was very clean, bright, and had lots of TVs. Our server couldn't have been nicer and was very attentive. We opted to keep things very basic and ordered provolone sticks for an appetizer and a medium cheese pizza for dinner. The provolone sticks arrived in short order and were delicious....fried to perfection and appropriately gooey. The best part of the sticks was the marinara sauce they were served with....super flavorful! Most dipping sauces are bland and generic, but this actually had chunks of tomato and lots of visible spices. It was so good that we actually ate the rest with a spoon when we ran out of provolone sticks (don't judge). After we were done with our appetizer, it took a REALLY long time for our pizza to come out. I mean....we're talking probably 45 minutes? Our waiter was really apologetic and kept saying...."It should be out soon...how long could it possibly take to make a cheese pizza?!" (Our thoughts exactly!) At one point he even offered to bring us out some bread to nosh on, which we declined since our appetizer had taken the edge off of our hunger, but we appreciated his concern. So the service was great! But hopefully 45 minutes for a cheese pizza is not the norm and we were just there when they were having an off night in the kitchen....because that's definitely too long to wait for something so simple! When our pizza finally arrived, we eagerly dug in and weren't disappointed. The crust was thick and chewy....pretty unique from other Pittsburgh shops. They also go CRAZY on the cheese....it's super gooey and heavy, so you'll definitely want to sop up some of the extra grease with a napkin before digging in (or I guess maybe not, depending on your feelings about grease, haha). Overall, it was a really tasty pizza. My only complaint was that it was a little sparse on the sauce.....their sauce is delicious, and I found myself wishing the pizza had more to balance out the extra cheese and thick crust. However, that was easily solved by asking our waiter for some extra sauce on the side, which he happily brought. And next time I'll ask for the pizza to be extra saucy! Long pizza wait time aside, we were very pleased with the food and service, so even though this isn't exactly around the corner from us, it's certainly worth making the drive again to partake in this deliciously unique pizza! read more

Shelly Pie - Cheese pizza! - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

I grew up in New Jersey and have eaten TONS of pizza from both NJ and NYC. I have heard people say this area is the mecca of pizza, where good pizza comes from etc. Now although NJ will always hold a special place in my heart...pizza from nj nyc is straight DOO DOO compared to Pittsburgh. I thought i knew what good pizza was, until i moved to Pittsburgh. I went on a small pizza mission when I first moved here trying all the local pizza spots and let me tell you.. Pizza in Pittsburgh blew my pants off. The pizza at Shelley Pie is so big, its like a monster pizza ate all the other weaker pizzas and formed a giant super pizza dripping with a hundred pounds of cheese mad toppings and love. The pizzas here are so gigantic if you tried to lift the pizza it would collapse in the center. I went into a pizza/carb coma after attempting to eat Shelley Pie and it was totes worth it. read more

Shelly Pie - Large Shelley Pie. - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

We have ordered pizza at Shelley Pie for years now, and have always enjoyed the pizza. The last few times the pizza has been inconsistent, and not completely cooked, with the dough raw . Not sure about ordering here in the future. read more

Pizza was outstanding. Great service also. Good for larger groups who want to share

Worse experience ever! Ordered via Grubhub, get to the restaurant to pick it up and find out, they don't start making your order until you get there! Then they messed up the first order, so had to wait for it to be done again! Waited over an hour! Horrible customer service! Very disappointing experience! And then ended being double charged! read more

Went to lunch with a friend I haven't seen in over 20 years. I've always had take out but not inside dining. Pleasant surprise. The menu had numerous Italian favorites, my wife enjoyed an Italian sub that she couldn't finish however she tried it was just too much sub for her and it was delicious. My friend and I ordered a large pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms. A large pie is 12 cut. When the pizza came out there was enough to feed an army. Absolutely wonderful pizza. Fresh, hot, and so delicious. The sauce wasn't overpowering, the cheese was plentiful as was the pepperoni,sausage,and mushroom. It was cooked to perfection and after the first bite I knew I was in heaven. Just an absolute reward to a palate that after not going dining for over 14 months was satisfied with the flavors all brought together. I highly recommend Shelly Pie Restaurant as I highly recommend the food that is expertly prepared. I'd suggest instead of reading this review you go check it out and I'm sure you'll agree. The only downfall is the parking and the entrance. I didn't see any handicap assessable entrance or parking and be prepared to walk the steps to enter. Guarantee if you work up an appetite walking the steps to enter, you'll be very satisfied leaving with a full belly. read more

Nice thick Pizza with huge crust. Service is usually spot on. The only small complaint is the cheese slides off.

Order here at your own risk. We have tried to give them multiple chances, but they are completely unable to get any order even remotely correct. They either do not add multiple items, or they just don't read the order. If you tell them no croutons, they add croutons. If you tell them no gravy on the potatoes, they add potatoes. I would mention the missing items but the list is far too long to waste anymore time. Avoid this place. Just terrible. read more

This place is outstanding !!!!!!! Our new favorite place ! Best pizza ANYWHERE and we've been trying their dinners and apps lately........The Fettucine Alfredo with chicken is delicious and the Eggplant Parm is outstanding........Fried Zucchini was great........this place is just great.......we're telling everyone ! read more

Stopped to get a Shelly Pie for the game. spent $30 something and I got home to see my pie is burnt on the top and the bottom. Usually the pizza is out of this world. Next time I will look at the pie before I leave. That's my suggestion. The pizza chef needs to pay more attention!! read more

If I could give no stars I would. Middle of our pizza was raw. The red sauce on my ravioli was burnt.