Settepani is a surprise find one could easily overlook along busy Malcolm X Boulevard in Harlem. I was walking by on a rainy and chilly Saturday and stumbled upon Settepani, which is exclusively a bakery at other locations, but is a whole cafe with a substantial menu in Harlem. There is a small set of tables and chairs outside for classic sidewalk cafe seating and plenty of two and four topper tables and booths inside. You are met with the pastries up front and I seemed to be in a weak moment. The sight of their reasonably priced tarts at $6 apiece makes the decision very easy: pecan for one and apricot almondine for the second. They will pack them in small cardboard boxes if they have them available so your tarts are not crushed on the way home. They made it home safely intact, despite being at the bottom of my back pack. These tarts have a nice and firm crust and seem pretty durable. The pecan tart is more straightforward, but with a surprise twist. The pecan tart has a top layer covered completely with pecans, which, combined with the thin layer of filling far less than commonly found in pecan pie, improves the pecan to filling ratio and contributes to its nutty pecan flavor. I taste what seems to be maple syrup reduced that may be the glaze and contributes to the flavor and texture of the crust. This pecan tart is for those who prefer something less sweet and more nutty than pecan pie and find pecan pie too full of sweet filling. The apricot almondine tart revealed its almond character before I looked it up on the menu. Visually, it reveals the three apricot halves in a triangle atop the tart. The apricot serves as an introduction to the subtle layer of marzipan underneath. That's when I searched the menu to see if they describe the ingredients of their pastries. The tarts at Settepani are not too sweet and that is a big positive for me. I have found the American style of baking is more reliant on sugar, whereas other parts of the world use fruit or other means to bring out sweetness. Settepani would be a great place to have brunch finished with a pastry and coffee. Nothing seems exhorbantly priced and this pastry intro went very well. The rest of the menu is promising for a return and there's more upside to their rating when I return. 3.9 stars! read more

See all

This spot continues to offer wonderful service and delicious pastries. With spacious outdoor and indoor seating, I saw people meeting socially and using the tables for a good cup of coffee, a pastry and some lovely space to work. A local spot that meets all your needs! read more

Settepani - With a cornetto - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Fine Neighborhood staple. I stop in at least once or twice per season. I often get the risotto, arancini, and/or meatballs. Drinks are always good, plenty of dessert options. Owner/manager is welcoming; server and bar staff seem to turn over frequently. I would miss it if it wasnt here. read more

See all

I live in California but I've always been fond of this place! The location is great! It's perfect for a patio dinner at dusk! But today! I had the pastries! I didn't know that this was one of their THiNGS! One of the best scones I've ever had! So I'll be stopping thru for morning items now!! We also had dinner! They had a beet soup as a special and it was perfect for this rainy fall day! I can truly say, this Italian restaurant has been consistent for over a decade! The service is a bit too casual. So if you aren't use to Harlem service, know your patience is needed here. As many places in Harlem, customer service training by a professional could help. read more

This place is a no go for me... We stoped in during the hotter months cause it looked adorable from the outside. Yes, decore is nice inside but we didn't enjoy our cocktails at all. They seem short staffed. Menu had no vegan options that I saw. Place just seems to be confused with what it wants to be really.... bakery or what ?? I donno, I won't be coming in her again. Vibes were off... Anyways we left as soon as we were done with our drinks. Enjoy read more

Settepani - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

MY ORDER : biscottti (chocolate) And almond cookies. I came inside for an ice latte (coffee beverage) and a snack... they didn't have any plastic togo cups so I had to use the hot coffee large cup(which is fine). Overall the seating is limited because majority of the seating area is for dinner guest only so they have bar stools and benches for "quick bites in and out guest". Overall I'm having a peaceful time at this restaurant before I call it a day. The staff are professional and nice . Great customer service ! I would probably bring my family here for brunch and what not. Please support the locals!!! read more

Settepani - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Settepani has to be one of the worst businesses in Harlem! The service is terrible, the ambiance is nice in the summer, however, that is where the buck stops. I have been to Settepani twice the first time the waiter was very rude and slow (the waiter was busy flirting with the girls at another table). The second time I stopped by for coffee and a pastry this past Sunday... once again bad service! My boyfriend and I arrived at the restaurant early morning there were two people in the restaurant, we went up to the counter to order our coffees and we were told in a angry tone that we would need to sit at a table if we are drinking our coffee there, we went to sit at a table in the dining room and the woman pointed at a table near the front door and said "coffee drinkers sit on this side of the restaurant" we went and had a seat and waited about 15 minutes without anyone coming over to take our order. We got out of our seat and left the restaurant! I will not be returning to Settepani as they do not deserve my business! And based on the reviews here on Yelp it seems like others agree! Thanks for nothing! read more

Came here for an outing while in town. My friend Sky recommended the restaurant as a place she had wanted to try. We came here and the service was amazing! The staff were all nice, attentive and made some great suggestions on food and drink options. The day we came they were out of some menu items but that didn't stop us from ordering good eats. I had the salmon over mashed potatoes and asparagus. They bring out this delicious bread with oil. I had a margarita and we had a delicious dessert. Will definitely come back again. read more

See all

The food was so delicious, especially the peach mixed salad! I'm not sure if the salad is seasonal but if they still have it on the menu def give it a try!! The NA spritz were also good, but the lemon one (she bites) is very bitter so be mindful of that when ordering. I think the service could have been better and more attentive. We were seated on a small corner table outside and did feel forgotten often even though all the other tables around us got consistent service. But besides that I'd recommend trying this restaurant for a yummy meal with njce ambiance in the heart of Harlem. read more

Settepani - She Bites A Night at the sprItz - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Settepani had been on my daughter's radar as she wanted to treat me for a pre-B'day dinner while she's here from the W. Coast. And since we'd finished with a painting class a short drive away, this Lenox Ave restaurant, turned out ok. After some bouts of rain, the sun came out and decided on outside seating. If you're traumatized by bees like I am, obviously sit away from the flower boxes as these had honeybees hovering. My daughter and I took it upon ourselves to just move to another table. One gentleman (manager?) was extremely friendly and talkative. The other manager seemed mechanical and at that point my kid and I didn't want to rattle the cage too much- but his attitude seriously needs to be checked. Our Crème Fraîche(?) Sour Cream(?)+Salmon+caviar Crostini were crisp, light and absolutely delightful to eat and my Pear Spritzer Mocktail was refreshing. My daughter's Margherita pie had nice taste with a puffy crust- but it was a bit doughy. My Bronzino- with some uncooked/some overcooked wedge potatoes and too-perfectly-laid out zucchini and squash slices had a nice crisp and tasted good. For a brand that's been hanging around as long as they have, my dish was quite honestly, unimaginative. Who knows- despite the ratings being are all over the place, perhaps their pastas are the way to go- but this wasn't the grande dame of Italian food. read more

See all

The lunch menu consisted of three beautifully presented salads with added protein, and our beverage request to include fresh limes was accommodated. Our desert was a shared tiramisu. We loved the relaxed feeling of a colorful Italian restaurant, from tasty bakery display-case offerings, to light bright paintings in front of which we stood to get a photo reminder of our Settepani visit. read more

Cute spot, with nice outdoor seating and good service. We stopped for a little treat and got a dulce de leche mini cake. It was good however a little dry ( however we did come towards the end of the day). The table next to us had some pizza which looked and smelled great haha. Definitely would come back and I am looking forward to trying other things! read more

See all

Great food, mediocre service. I've eaten here half a dozen times over the last few years, and the vegetarian pastas are really yummy. It's always a diverse crowd and seems to be a popular spot for date nights, group dinners for millennial & Gen X women, and occasionally fundraisers/birthdays. On one occasion, I couldn't get a receipt reprint that I really needed, despite emails, calls, and going in person to request it. I gave up after a couple weeks, but I feel like it's pretty standard practice to provide a receipt and I was made to feel like this was a completely unreasonable ask. On another occasion, we arrived on time for our reservation but no table was reserved. There were plenty of seats so we were seated without an issue. One server gave us cups and offered us water but never came back with the water. Another came ten minutes later and offered water, which he did come back with. We were only given one menu for our group of four people. When we requested more menus, we were eventually given exactly one more. Why?! Our server is usually Jean-Claude, and he's a character. Not everyone's cup of tea. He's flirtatious, flattering, and jovial but can come across as dismissive, eg when all but one person has been served and the other entree "will be out soon" for 20min and is dropped off without apology after everyone else has given up on politeness and polished off their dishes. Or when asked whether a cocktail was sweet, he assures it is not sweet, and then it arrives extremely sweet. It's often loud inside, with music that's slightly too loud so people are shouting over it. There are no soft surfaces so sound isn't dampened at all. The strange lighting situation (dim plus blue-hued fairy lights on the ceiling) also takes away from the intention to create a nice sit-down environment. TLDR; after many chances, and an equal number of service misses, I've relegated Settepani to date night takeout. read more

The new rainbow cookie croissant is definitely worth trying! I have a feeling they are going to get harder and harder to get your hands on. The jam and cream in the middle are so good and makes it an easy to treat to eat. I warmed it in the microwave for a few seconds to make it a little more warm gooey. Would definitely try the cookie version of it read more

Settepani - Rainbow cookie croissant - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

What an experience. I love love enjoying a nice weather in Harlem. The restaurant is located in a quaint corner in, and it feels so dreamy sitting in the outdoor area. It felt like i was transported elsewhere. The sirens sounded peaceful even. Anyways. The food had so much flavor without the overpowering each other. The creamy rosemary sauce really complemented the dish. I had a fantastic time just indulging in the energy. The sunlight always seems this spot directly. After years of walking by, i finally decided to take myself out on a late lunch. I love the curated menu and the cocktails menu is something you won't get anywhere else. This May be my new solo date spot. Magical. Also, it just makes me so happy that is family owned and the staff was so sweet! I need to come back already. read more

See all

This is now my favorite restaurant in Harlem. I fell in love with the gorgeous interior decor with beautiful bouquets of flowers and twinkle lights up above. There was plenty of lovely outdoor seating in front, and since it was a nice day out, we chose outdoor dining. My friend and I shared the Fried Calamari, which was served with tomato sauce. The calamari had a nice crunch, but was a bit chewy for my liking. I don't think it was worth it for $17. For my entree, I ordered the Pistachio Crusted Lamb Chops, which came with roasted artichokes and potatoes. This was absolutely delicious! The lamb chops were encrusted with actual pistachio pieces, and tasted almost candied with a slight crisp. The lamb chops were wonderfully tender, succulent, and well seasoned. The veggies were cooked perfectly and quite flavorful. However, I would have preferred something other than artichoke, which was kind of hard to eat. Since this place is also a bakery, there are many tempting dessert options. My friend and I decided to share one of the small cakes, which were only $12. We went with the sponge cake with caramel frosting. The frosting was velvety smooth, rich, sweet, while the sponge cake was moist. Each delightful bite melted in your mouth! Service was solid. Our waiter was extremely friendly, charming, with a great sense of humor. It was just a little difficult to get the waiters' attention at the end when we wanted our bill. I would love to return to try the Steak with Fries and more of the sweet treats. read more

See all

The restaurant has a very cozy and classy feel. The music is soft and relaxing. The lasagna is a must have! Pineapple mimosa is delicious! The attention is impecable, staff and waitress are very sweet and their Recommendations are on point. read more

Settepani - Creamy lasagna - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I had Spaghetti alle vongole 、the pasta was home made linguine , but I liked spaghetti better ... Food is good, but small potion to me lol They said Their Tiramisu is #2 in the city, it was good, ( but I forgot to take photo) I also had Italian cheese cake, But I don't taste much ricotta cheese, and I don't admit it's Italian cheesecake then read more

See all

2023 Pasta is perfect, bread is high quality, desserts and decor spot on. Clean atmosphere. Inviting. Diverse options. A very pleasant experience. read more

Settepani - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Service was horrendous. It took them 20 minutes just to come to our table to take our drink quarters, then it was another 15 minutes before we got those drinks, and the server didn't even bring them all out. Finally after 30 minutes, all the drinks were there, however the food took well over another hour after ordering before we got it. We also sat outside the restaurant on the other side of their barrier. So essentially we were just on the street in a random table by a bush that was point and pricking us constantly. Their bakery items are pretty bad. Don't get any of those because you will be disappointed. read more

See all

One of my favorite spots to go to in Harlem! Family owned business that has grown with the Harlem community and always the best service! The atmosphere and location are excellent! Whether you come for brunch, happy hour or dinner-it is always a great time had by all! Since it started as a bakery-it is definitely dessert worthy! They also cater if you have a small or large event! read more

Settepani - Happy Hour in Harlem!!! - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This review is from my visit in May. Overall I'd give a 3.5. I really wanted to try the lasagna but it sold out. Went on a Friday night. To s of seating available indoor and outdoor. Great decor. I like the big table in the back with the faux fire place. We'll attended but not crazy crowded. I think the bar tender was also the waiter so there was some delay. What we ordered: Tagiatelle Bolognese Salmon w/Sautéed Spinach Calamari Toscano Burrata Fresca Melanzane Alla Siracusana Sarde A Beccafico I was very happy with the salmon and the calamari. The bolognese could use some more flavor. Drinks were tasty. I wouldn't order the other items again. I'd return to try the pizza and lasagna heard great things about those. read more

See all

Came in on a Sunday, it was quiet and had nice background music. Service was wonderful and the burrata was fantastic. read more

Settepani - Barata - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food was delicious and I'm obsessed with the vibes of our waiter. I was laughing all night and literally wanted to drink the sauce from my bowl of linguini and clams. read more

Settepani is a lovely Italian restaurant in Harlem with delicious food and a very comforting atmosphere. They have a great outdoor seating area and the restaurant itself is very cute. I came on a Sunday and they have a wonderful brunch menu from 12-4 pm. They have a delicious selection of custom cocktails and they also have a great brunch deal with bottomless mimosas for 2 if you're into that We ordered the Pollo Alla Milanese, Parmigiana, Arancine, Prosciuto E Melone, the Pasta Del Giorno (which was a spinach pasta with lamb ragú), Crepe Con Nutella, and the Bombas (donuts filled with ice cream) for dessert Everything was delicious and fresh, and none of the dishes felt too heavy. The family that owns this restaurant is incredibly sweet and friendly and all of the staff are very nice as well. I definitely felt welcome here. Overall it was a lovely experience and I would definitely recommend Settepani to anyone who is looking for a nice dining experience that will leave you feeling warm inside! I will definitely be back. read more

See all

The menu says online there were vegan options and when i asked about it to the server he said some items could be made vegan. Kinda misleading and also the food was mid. read more

The bakery here is a scam. $2.75 per macaroon then charged me $25 for a plastic box of 6? Woman working behind the counter was so unbelievably rude and is just there to scam people. read more

Settepani - $16.50 for the macaroons then $9.50 for the cheap plastic box :) - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious! I've visited before but this recent visit was a better experience all things considered. The outdoor area was very spacious and tables were seated enough far apart. The menu was not too complicated. My party tried the pizzas, lasagna, and I had the salmon with green beans. My dish was cooked well- great seasoning and not dry. We also tried the bombas and they were good! The Nutella and the 2020 redemption were the best ones. They also have adult Capri suns that were tasty. Service was a tad slow but I would still go again! read more

Settepani - Salmon and green beans - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My friends and I were really looking forward to trying this place, but we were sorely disappointed for multiple reasons. I'll elaborate, but the TL:DR is that I would NOT recommend this place for young people, the service was atrocious, and the food was simply not good. I made a reservation for our group at 9:15, and the last member of our party and I arrived around 9:25. Upon entering, we immediately noticed that we were the youngest people in the establishment by 20 years, easily. The two other people in our party who had arrived before us were seated, but they hadn't received the drinks they ordered more than 10 minutes ago. When our waiter finally came to our table, he joked that since we were late, he couldn't serve us. I did not appreciate this comment. Our waiter and the service are my biggest complaint. Our server was obviously flirting with the other women and me at my table even though he was much older than us and we were clearly uncomfortable. In addition to this, he: - didn't ask about food or quality of drinks - said that bread was coming, but it never appeared - never brought the salt and pepper we asked for - didn't clear empty plates or empty glasses in a timely manner The worst part of the night was a direct result of empty plates being left on the table. As another waiter brought our main courses, I lifted up one of my dirty plates to make room on the table. When he put my pasta on the table, he hit my dirty plate, making my sauce-covered fork flip onto my shirt. He asked if I was okay, but didn't say sorry. I noticed that my gnocchi didn't smell appetizing so I wasn't in a rush to eat it, but I also couldn't because I no longer had a clean fork. When I eventually got my fork and tried the gnocchi, it wasn't good at all. I communicated this to the waiter and asked if he could take it back, and he joked that I would have to pay him a thousand dollars. By this point, I am very annoyed and not in the mood, so I don't laugh. He tells me to lighten up and that life is short so I should laugh, which I didn't appreciate at all. Just take back the food, please! I will say that the drinks were generally good and that the meatballs were tasty. I would recommend that this establishment rebrand as a bakery + bar with small plates because no one at my table liked their entree. It was also clear that there was only one waiter for the entire restaurant, which I'm sure impacted our experience. I will never return, and would advise you not to go! read more

Settepani - Here's the gnocchi I took one bite of. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Walked by and took out a lemon tart, which is great! Not too sweet, and the lemon is refreshing. Service was also great! Such a lovely place to visit. read more

Cute little place for brunch, dinner or some drinks. The best part is the outdoor seating area. If you're expecting an incredible meal - skip it. If you want a good meal, this is a good place. It's more so a cute vibe to relax and enjoy nice conversation -- especially in the summer! read more

Settepani - Steak and eggs. Steak is under the eggs so not too big. $24. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I was taking a walk in my neighborhood and came across this place. They have outdoor and indoor seating which is great. Ambiance is causal but also very welcoming. My server was very friendly and patient with all my questions. I ordered my go to pizza prosciutto and arugula. It was pretty basic, no flavor at all. I added the crushed peppers and that helped. For the price i don't think it's worth it. read more

See all

DOGS! DOGS! DOGS! NYC is being overrun with dogs in eateries. It's come to be accepted at cafes. Now they are in supermarkets and now here. No offense to dog lovers, but be courteous. I used to love eating here but it's pricey. So why would I want to pay for over $100 for a meal with a large dog in the establishment and feeling uncomfortable? Restaurants are free to welcome the pets but I'm also free to eat elsewhere. read more

I love this place. Food is always good. Customer Service is top notch. And the restroom is ALWAYS clean read more

This is my go to restaurant in my neighborhood. The food, staff and ambience is excellent. The staff get to know you after awhile and kind of treat you like family. I always enjoy my visits to this restaurant. It's only a few blocks from where I live and it's always a nice walk (both ways). They do switch up the menu so if you're adventurous this is definitely the place for you. I got attached to one of the their salads and then when it wasn't on the menu I almost melted (it was a pear salad, so tasty and yummy). Overall, it's a great spot for lunch or dinner. read more

Settepani - Tiramisú cake! We celebrated a friends birthday and this is one of her favorite desserts. It was delicious. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food was delicious as alway and the service was great as usual. Ambiance is on point.

The service is horrible, and the food quality is not good And they don't have what they say they have on the menu read more

The outdoor seating here is perfect! It's like just the right amount of sun. I've been here many times before but this was my first time in awhile. Service is always great, and the atmosphere is just so pleasant. I enjoyed the kale salad with shrimp for lunch. Always flavorful and I truly appreciate when the kale has been "massaged" it's the little things. It's dressed with a light balsamic dressing, sliced avocado, thinly sliced red onion and topped with cranberries. Our food came out hot and in less than 10 minutes! This place is perfect for a quick lunch or a lovely dinner. The renovations look great and really give you an great ambiance. read more

Settepani - Kale salad with shrimp - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Going to Harlem is always a nice experience....just like Brooklyn and certain parts of Queens, the sights, sounds and restaurants are amazing! After attending an event at The Schomburg and feeling inspired about hearing/seeing Artist Charles Whites' masterpieces, being hungry and wanting pasta became the focus. Oh Yes, consuming Italian Food (my favorite) for dinner was definitely on the itinerary-lol. Settepani came up after checking places on Yelp. Two train station stops and several blocks later was Settepani on the corner of 120th Street. The "Grateful, Thankful, Blessed" Sign hanging in the front door draws you inside. Settapani has warm and welcoming ambiance. There is currently a Fall festive theme that includes colorful decor( bright + earth tones variations) as well as gorgeous lighting arrangements. Sayings on the wall such as "This World Needs Vision" + "Love Is Golden" adds to their cool aesthetic. The bar area has lovely leaf shaped table placemats and candles on the counter. They also have a mini-lounge area near the front entrance and dinind table on the side and back section. Settapani has a "Bar Bites" Menu and an entree menu. Server Jovani expressed kind greetings and made food recommendations. The Lump Crab Cake ($12) served with fresh salad greens was really good. Delicious Bolognese had firm pasta and tasty meat sauce. He mentioned that the Hot Apple Cider is good and can be made w/ or w/ out liquor. Ordering the standard Hot Apple Cider ($4) proved to be the right choice especiallyon a chilly evening...oh so sweet, smooth and rich! Thanks to both Jovani and Alex for their politeness, attentiveness and for providing great customer service w/ a smile. Settepani staff, the set up of this establishment and the food are all awesome.... read more

See all

I had the pizza and a side order of calamari for lunch with a glass of red wine. My friend had a bowl of salad and corn tagliatelle. She said, "Love it! That was a fun lunch; the corn in my pasta was fresh. Happy you're giving Settepani a shout-out. As for my food, it was very tasty. I couldn't eat it all, so I took have of it home. They had real mozzarella, which is a rarity these days. So milky and creamy. read more

Settepani - First time I've eaten there and to say the least I wasn't disappointed. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York