Average food. Decent experience. Nothing great but nothing bad. It's a good back up plan but there are better choices for your first pick.

Very good pizza!! Crispy crust and fast service, you've made a family of 5 very happy (and full!) thank you!

A great place to feed the family while on vacation. Super delicious pizza. No leftovers.

TOURISTS BEWARE! I would have gladly given this place a 5 star review after 2 successful orders and deliveries, however, the THIRD TIME WAS NOT A CHARM! The delivery hadn't shown and after 40 minutes, I called. They accused me of speaking nonsense to them; said children were answering the phone (average age of our group is 52...no children) and then called our hotel claiming we were making threatening phone calls and they would report us to the police. (Over a pizza??!!) We were merely trying to get our pizza. Stateside folks, your phone doesn't always work here...im not sure whom they talked to, but it wasn't me or anyone in our party! They refused to give us service. This is honestly the worst I've ever encountered on the rock. I am beyond dumbfounded. We are very frequent visitors and Senor Pizza will never again receive ours read more

Senor Pizza did not disappoint. This was our first time ordering and everything thing was perfect. Had a Pepperoni , mushrooms and black olives large delivered to the Ritz Carlton with in 30 min of order placed. Pizza was delicious NY Style pie!! Yummy in my Tummy . read more

I tried the pizza near my condo, which was smaller and cost more, and it sucked. A couple of days later I tried Senor Pizza based on the good reviews. It was Sooooo much better! I had it delivered and it was still hot. The dough was fresh and didn't taste like the cardboard dough from the other place. The ingredients were also fresh. Suffice it to say, I ate the entire 12" by myself. read more

Being in St Thomas amidst the hurricane recovery; this island needs good reliable pizza. Pros: They answer the phone They deliver Pizzas not bad either Cons: 1 slice is about 1/4 of a large pizza (not exactly a con) Not sure how fresh the produce is read more

Good pizza for the islands. Obviously it's not New York pizza but it's the best in the island. Great staff.

Pleasantly surprised all around! From order to delivery to our resort took only 30 minutes. The pizza was hot and fresh upon delivery and the delivery driver was super friendly! He called when he left the pizza shop so I had adequate time to walk to the front of the resort. We ordered a half pepperoni and half mushroom pizza. There was a lot of garlic in the sauce, but we didn't mind! We found it to be very reasonably priced as well considering the size of the pizza and the cost of everything on the island. We will definitely order from Senor Pizza again on our next trip! read more

Great pizza and quick delivery to Margaritaville! Delivery options are limited here and they delivered with no fee! We ordered pepperoni pizza and cheesy bread. Pizza was great , cheesy bread could have been seasoned more was just ok. read more

For the island very reasonably priced. I had a calzone wife had a salad, quick and very tasty!

Definitely a great choice for a lazy evening by the beach. One of very few places in the east end that delivers. Since we are staying in sapphire beach, we didn't want to spend an extra $20 on transportation to and from red hook. We got the Greek pizza with artichokes. Overall it was very good. Lost of flavor for sure, but it was missing one of the toppings it was supposed to have. Would probably try something different next time. The crust was delicious and it kept its integrity even with all the toppings and the delivery. I also got a Caesar salad. The lettuce and the parmesan were both fresh. The dressing (not sure if it's house made) could be a little more flavorful BUT I give them a lot of props for have a Caesar dressing actually made with anchovies. That's how I like it, and that's the traditional way to make it, but I know a lot of people don't like the anchovy taste. Ordering was easy, staff was very friendly. If we have a desire for pizza again before we head back to DC, we would definitely order again. read more

We tried Senor Pizza while vacationing here and all 6 of us agreed it was the best pizza on the island. The crust was amazing and cooked perfectly and the toppings were loaded with just the right amount of cheese. I would give 5 stars if the ambience was a little more family friendly/comfortable. I felt like I was being interrogated with the lights and the table was sticky and place was filthy. read more

This pizza was so good! We got the supreme And that's a big compliment coming from a New Yorker! Loved it.

We had a great experience at señor pizza. the kids loved the cheese and the calzone was my favorite. It was a clean and friendly environment. Will return read more

Worst pizza I've ever attempted to eat. Delivery was quick....However, that could have been because the pizza had been made 7 weeks before we got there. The crust was completely inedible. It was hard, and nearly impossible to bite, and it tasted horrible. I've had every 'type' of pizza out there: NY, Chicago and StL styles, and this was none of those..... Perhaps it was bark or driftwood with sauce and toppings. They also didn't answer the phone for AGES. I should have taken the hint and given up. The owner did respond on another site in which I reviewed his business, telling me I should have called to complain instead of taking the 'low road', and also calling me names. What part of ***not answering the phone*** did he not understand? read more

The employees were great and very accommodating. I had ordered on my way back from Cruz Bay on the ferry, and realized I had forgot something on St John and had to go back - which is a two hour trip with the ferry schedule. They were nice enough to re-make my pies when I returned. The pizza was great, tasty, and ingredients fresh. I'm from NYC and am selective of my sauce and pizza crust (rolling my eyes at you California). The sauce had a really nice tangy sweetness to it, and the crust was great - chewy/crisp in the right places, and held up nice to a lot of toppings. Also ordered a salad which was fresh and delicious. For those concerned with price, I found it completely reasonable given a high convenience, high quality, large portions, and deliciousness. Also, if a few dollars more for a huge delicious pizza gets your swim trunks in a bunch - don't forget you are ON AN ISLAND in the Caribbean. Everything is more expensive to import, maintain, power, and operate. You should be polite and understand how this affects the cost of products. read more

So I'm not sure how many stars to rate this place.. The pizza was reallllly good! We got he Hawaiian and added jalapeños. It was ready in about 10 mins. the guys working there were very friendly! BUT.... We saw nasty roaches crawling around the floor. (Extra protein?) we ate the pizza anyway bc we were really hungry. read more

It seems like this is the only place that delivers on the island. Also, it's important to note that delivery is just to your resort and not to your room so if you are at a resort like Margaritaville, you still have to make your way to the lobby to pick up your pizza. They were out of bread sticks which is what my teen girls really wanted but I thought the pizza was good. They also only take cash and are reluctant to give change so I would be paying attention to how many dollars you have in your wallet before you order.Also, if you're getting a busy signal when you call, that just means they are slammed. I would just keep calling back every minute or so. read more

I had a few good slices of pizza (by Island standards, of course) and my wife got a nice fresh salad. Add a couple of cans of soda (no fountain soda) and we had a nice meal after the beach for about $20 - a true rarity on St. Thomas. BRING CASH - just a FYI - no credit cards. The guys behind the counter were great - and Seinfeld on the tube. Nice! Between 3.5 and 4-stars. read more

Halfway through our trip it's clear that these islands have a captive audience and the restaurants have colluded to offer mediocre food at extremely high prices. Señor Pizza was a refreshing change. The pies are priced very fairly and the atmosphere is clean and has the sort of pizzeria vibe from when I was a kid. The food is universally good. Not a famous pie from NY or Chicago, but better than most places. We've already been twice and have another week left. Highly recommended. read more

Disappointed after reading such great reviews. Ordered pizza with several toppings including feta and bread sticks with extra marinara. Told it would be around 30 minutes. An hour later the delivery guy was calling. No extra marinara. Said he forgot. Didnt offer to make it right. When I got to the room, discovered no feta and the banana peppers were made up of at least half being the tough tops that are not appealing to chew thru. Pizza was okay. But you like to think you can get what you ordered and paid for. read more

Pretty good pizza! Similar to New York style (by that I mean big slices). Prices were decent also. We also had the wings, but there was nothing too special about them. They were ok. They serve pizza by the slice or whole. We got three whole pizzas and they had it ready pretty quick, which was great because we were starving! Not a bad little place. read more

For a pizza place in the USVI, I was shocked by the incredible quality and taste. Worth navigating the touristy location.

This is absolutely the best (Ok maybe second best) pizza I've ever had. I get a variety of veggies on mine- and it is amazing every time. We drive from all the way on the other side of the island for this. The wings are awesome too. Friendly, and personable staff. Makes the experience superb. The only downside is that they don't deliver all the way to us in E. Mafolie, which is a bummer because we do not always want to take our baby for the long trip there. Either way, amazing pizza. read more

Our last night on the island and we just wanted to stay in so we ordered pizza. It is awesome pizza that arrived hot and within 40 minutes as promised. Thanks Senor Pizza for making our last dinner/breakfast delicious. See you next time read more

Pros: big portions. Cons: pizza is comparable to Chuck E Cheese Specifically, the dough is bland, the sauce tastes like a thousand cheap sauces I have tasted before, and the cheese was rubbery. Not a fan. read more

Great pizza!!! Did not expect this from a place in the island, but man, they really knocked it out of the park. Everyone is really friendly and they get their pizza out pretty quickly. The crust is the perfect mix of crispy and chewy. Recommend going with their spicy marinara sauce, as it gives everything just a little bit of extra kick. We got the meat lovers and both my wife and I swear that they have the best sausage that we've ever tasted. And on a pizza nonetheless... The downside is that the prices are a little higher than you would find on the mainland, but it's well worth it. read more

Not bad but not the best. Might as well get Dominos. Probably tastes the same and you'll save money

You get what you pay for at this place. Pizzas are better than Pizza Hut. Drinks get expensive quickly. $1 for cans. $2 for bottles. However, compared to everywhere else they're okay. Pizzas are prices okay. $17 for cheese plus $2 per topping. They only take cash. They were out of all their chicken products including chicken wings. But it's quick and easy and cheap (comparative to everything else) so we ended up ordering from there twice. Oh they deliver also for added continence. read more

Great pizza, reasonable price, friendly staff. Highly recommend this place. Had a funny dvd playing inside and porch outside overlooks main street of Red Hook. Cool spot to eat and people watch. Meat lovers pizza is great!! read more

Pros: Location - Right off the main drag in Redhook. Easy to spot. Toppings - Quality ingredients. I bought two pies to go & the pizza was still piping hot & tasty after the 20 min ride back to the boat. Delivery - Available Game room - Pool table, flat screen TVs & one armed bandits. Cons: Crust - A tad burnt & not very tasty Price - $41 for two pies Payment options - Only cash Overall good & I'd recommend buying by the slice. Grab a pop from the cooler & dig in. -Jay read more

Fast delivery and driver wore a mask. We had delivered to Margaritaville. Pizza variety is good. We enjoyed the Summer Pizza with white sauce the most. We also enjoyed the Supreme. Thin crust pizzas. I only give them 4 stars because the pizza was a little dry and had a large gap of crust with no toppings about 2 or 3 inches around the pizza. read more

Hands down the easiest pizza place I've ever ordered from! They politely and promptly answered the phone and the DELIVERED to our resort. Perfect after spending the day traveling to USVI. The delivery took less than 45 min on a Saturday night which I think is great! We ordered a Hawaiian pizza + cheese bread. Toppings were fantastic and the pizza overall was very good. Cheese bread was really good! Can't beat the amazing service and good pizza. read more

I was not expecting to find great pizza in Saint Thomas.. I was wrong. Delivered right to our hotel at Secret Harbour late at night and knocked it out of the park. Absolutely delicious. read more

Good eats! Pizza nice and fresh lots of flavor. Wings had a nice kick not to spicy. Garlic cheese bread real good. Delivered to resort im staying in. #Waybetterthentheresortfood #flavor read more

Solid, friendly, quick, and good value. Wanted a quick meal after a day at St. John. Will go back.

Took a couple of slices To Go to the beach. It had cooled off but was still very tasty. At $3, it was the same price as a slice of pizza in the states! Lots of reasonably priced To Go drinks options as well! read more

We ordered this for delivery after a long day of drinking on the beach. Delivery was quick but that's about where the positive ends. We ordered a cheese pizza with bread sticks... and holy garlic, and not like good garlic, more burnt bitter garlic. It got the job done as we needed something delivered but i did not keep any leftovers and probably would not order again. read more

The pizza was affordable. The crust was amazing and the whole thing was finished in 5 minutes:) I could have eaten there the whole 7 days of our vacation. Salads were large and fresh. Fast service too. Drinks were in cans or bottles from the coolers. I would have like a large glass of iced tea, but the food more than made up for it. The wings were tasty and spicy too. read more